Dave Meltzer Awards 2 AEW Matches *****+ | AEW Double Or Nothing 2025 Star Ratings

By Andy H Murray / May 30, 2025

Dave Meltzer has awarded two AEW Double or Nothing 2025 matches *****+ scores in his latest round of star ratings.

As published in the 2 June edition of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, Meltzer scored Double or Nothing's Anarchy in the Arena match ***** and the main event - Will Ospreay vs. 'Hangman' Adam Page - *****½.

AEW has now hosted seven matches rated at ***** or above in 2025.

Double or Nothing was a strong night for star ratings, with only two matches falling below the **** score typically considered "great."

Meltzer's full star ratings for AEW Double or Nothing 2025 were as follows:

Buy In - Anna Jay & Harley Cameron vs. Megan Bayne & Penelope Ford: N/R

Buy In - AR Fox, Bandido & Los Titanes del Aire (Hologram & Komander) vs. CRU (Action Andretti & Lio Rush) & RPG VICE (Rocky Romero & Trent Beretta): ****1/4

Non-Title Owen Hart Foundation 2025 Women's Tournament Final - Match Mercedes Mone vs. Jamie Hayter: ****½

FTR (Cash Wheeler & Dax Harwood) vs. Daniel Garcia & Nigel McGuinness: ****½

Stretcher Match - Mark Briscoe vs. Ricochet: ****½

AEW World Tag Team Title Match - The Hurt Syndicate (Bobby Lashley & Shelton Benjamin) (c) vs. The Sons Of Texas (Dustin Rhodes & Sammy Guevara): ***½

AEW Continental Title Match - Kazuchika Okada (c) vs. Mike Bailey: ****½

AEW Women's World Title Match - Toni Storm (c) vs. Mina Shirakawa: ****

Anarchy In The Arena Match - Kenny Omega, Swerve Strickland, The Opps (Katsuyori Shibata, Powerhouse Hobbs & Samoa Joe) & Willow Nightingale vs. Death Riders (Claudio Castagnoli, Jon Moxley, Marina Shafir & Wheeler Yuta) & The Young Bucks (Matthew Jackson & Nicholas Jackson): *****

The Don Callis Family (Josh Alexander, Konosuke Takeshita & Kyle Fletcher) vs. Paragon (Adam Cole, Kyle O'Reilly & Roderick Strong): ***3/4

Owen Hart Foundation 2025 Men's Tournament Final Match - 'Hangman' Adam Page vs. Will Ospreay: *****½