Every NXT TakeOver Main Event In History: Ranked
6. Johnny Gargano Vs. Adam Cole - Takeover: Toronto 2019
This one was truly breathtaking, a ‘2-Out-of-3-Falls- Match’ that was a Three Stages of Hell in disguise, it was forty-six minutes of pure carnage. The whole match itself was worthy of all of the stars in Dave Meltzer’s back pocket, as each of the falls hit to a similarly high level.
The first fall was a textbook standard singles match that harked back to their two previous encounters. The second, a weapon filled extravaganza that went throughout the arena, giving each fan a taste of the action. Finally, the third fall was a ten times better version than the ‘Ambrose Asylum’ weapon weaved steel cage that preceded this bout by three years.
While the kick outs became excessive by the end, and the finish was a little too dangerous for the sake of looking dangerous, it didn’t matter. It was all too badass for anybody to care. When all is said and done, wrestling fans will look back at this one as the cherry on the top of one of the greatest trilogies that NXT has ever seen.
5. Adrian Neville Vs. Sami Zayn - Takeover: R Evolution
Sometimes, the originals are just better and boy, is this one the best of an era that fans sometimes forget was a golden period for NXT.
The match was drama personified as Sami Zayn put his NXT career on the line against a dominant champion, whose morals were slowly unravelling with desperation to keep his prized possession.
Zayn at Full Sail is very much similar to CM Punk anywhere in Chicago, with the crowd exploding into thunderous anytime he landed a strike. Corey Graves put it perfectly in that it was "As much as this match is Sami Zayn vs. Adrian Neville, it is Sami Zayn vs. himself." As Zayn was fighting an uphill battle from the start, needing to stay focused in order to not be distracted by Neville’s ever-growing heelish antics. By the end of the contest, Neville was a full-on bad guy after harking back to THAT fatal four-way by pulling the ref into the fray, preventing Zayn from hitting his finisher. However, when Zayn was finally able to keep Neville down the feeling was electric.
A rapturous standing ovation followed from both the crowd and the locker room, which only made Kevin Owens following betrayal even more devastating. This was NXT at its finest and should truly stand the test of time as one of the brand’s greatest matches.
4. Johnny Gargano Vs. Adam Cole - Takeover: XXV
Round 2 for Gargano and Cole and it was almost as good as their New York bout, but it just fell short, barely. However, that is in no way suggesting that this was a bad bout it’s quite the opposite. AEW’s Double or Nothing event had taken place a week prior and NXT needed to respond and respond hard, Cole and Gargano did just that and then some.
Both men have insane chemistry and it shows every time they share a ring with their back-and-forth action flowing so smoothly. For every move, there was a counter, for every stiff strike, there was an even stiffer return. Cole and Gargano both looked every bit of the seasoned veterans that they are, with Gargano’s babyface fire on full throttle, complemented perfectly by Cole’s desperate heel schtick. In a simple story told so well, it was may the best man win, and on the night, Cole was the better man and was rewarded so with the gold.
Thank God that this wasn’t Gargano’s NXT swansong as thankfully, he stuck around and was able to continue producing classics such as this.
3. Johnny Gargano Vs. Andrade 'Cien' Almas - Takeover: Philadelphia
It can be argued that this match marks the spot in history when NXT really started to take off. It was already amazing, but this is when the five-star making machine kicked into high gear and it felt like every second match became a Match of the Year candidate.
For just over thirty minutes, neither man slowed down once, constantly working at top speed, keeping the crowd on the edge of their seat thinking the finish would come at any second. Not only was it NXT’s reinvigoration, but it was the beginning of a career renaissance for Almas, proving once and for all that he could be a top guy anywhere in the world with his high-flying prowess and crisp chain wrestling ability. Gargano was as classy as ever, making you believe with every late kick out that he was never going to die and take the title home.
Having the Ciampa return happen after the match was a godsend, as a clean win made Almas look even stronger in the process. Overall, not only did Gargano help create a new megastar in Almas, plus help kickstart a new era of momentum in NXT, but he and Ciampa had successfully written another chapter in their never-ending story. Bravo all around.
2. Johnny Gargano Vs. Tommaso Ciampa - Takeover: New Orleans
As said previously in this article many times, original is often the best, and that is certainly the case with the Gargano Vs. Ciampa saga. While they continued to build their feud over time and increase the level of violence with every match, it's their very first Takeover encounter that set the tone for them all laid the perfect foundation for them to build upon. It was the culmination of a years-long story that led to this point.
If Gargano lost, he was gone and Ciampa would forever reign supreme over NXT with an iron fist. Despite these dramatic implications, you got the feeling that Gargano didn’t even care and rightly so, all he wanted to do was hurt his brother turned enemy.
Despite the Unsanctioned stipulation, the two didn’t even need weapons, all they needed was pure wrestling. It flowed perfectly, from the back-and-forth contest to the sickening sound of Ciampa’s back hitting the exposed concrete, to the final scene of Gargano wrenching back Ciampa’s neck with that symbolic crutch, everything was just superb.
If you appreciate a good wrestling story, you seriously need to go and revisit this one, you could certainly watch it ten times over and never get bored. DIY certainly know how to do it right.
1. Johnny Gargano Vs. Adam Cole - Takeover: New York
The fact that Johnny Gargano has appeared on this list a total of nine times is a testament to how much confidence NXT rightly has in ‘Mr Takeover’ to continually put him on last. However, it is an even bigger testament to the man’s talent levels that six of those nine falls within the top ten. He truly is one of the modern greats.
That aside, he was once more at his babyface best when he stood across the ring from Adam Cole, fighting over the vacant NXT Title in front of a red-hot Brooklyn crowd. These two just know how to wrestle each other, stunning the wrestling world with three outstanding mini-matches with each of the three falls. It was like a roller coaster, with the action going up and down, side to side and all over the place in all the best ways. Athletic sequences, innovative counters and dramatic storytelling are just some of the ways to describe this almost indescribable contest.
The moment when Gargano got the win and finally lifted the title after such a long run of playing second fiddle was the most intensely cathartic in wrestling since Daniel Bryan’s WrestleMania XXX triumph. It was almost cinematic in its brilliance and hence goes down as the best NXT Takeover main event in history. For now….