How Blind Arrogance Killed Wrestling's Coolest Cult Promotion

Where did it all go wrong for the National Wrestling Alliance?

By Andrew Pollard /

Before the COVID-19 pandemic, the National Wrestling Alliance was as hot as it had been in decades. Under the stewardship of Billy Corgan, the NWA and its weekly Powerrr offering became destination viewing for wrestling fans both old and new.

Advertisement

Coming in at a brisk hour, Powerrr was a fun, entertaining, easily to digest slice of wrestling television. With the nostalgia of a studio setting, characters who were expertly defined, and in-ring action that never overstayed its welcome, the NWA had suddenly become cool again. After years in the wilderness, the one-time industry leader was in full resurgence mode.

While that pre-pandemic NWA was never going to be a serious challenger to WWE or the burgeoning AEW, it provided a hugely enjoyable alternative with a great mix of upcoming talents and seasoned veterans. Unfortunately, the NWA seen today is a hollow shell of its former self, and we're at a point where Billy Corgan is very much steering a sinking ship that's taking on more water by the month.

Upon looking at the current NWA landscape, there are several reasons why the promotion is struggling. With a sprinkling of a history lesson included, too, we take a look at how the NWA went from must-watch to entirely skippable.

Given how your writer was forever full of praise for the NWA for the longest time - including penning 10 Reasons Why You NEED To Be Watching NWA Powerrr back in 2019 - there's no pleasure here in detailing the company's downward spiral.

8. The Previous Iteration

The National Wrestling Alliance as we know it right now, is a very different beast and model to the NWA of decades prior.

Advertisement

While 2022 finds an NWA that's very much a standard wrestling promotion, those three letters previously represented a governing body that consisted of several promotions. Said governing body's board of directors was made up of the heads of the various territories housed under that NWA banner, and these promotors would get together to trade talent and, just as importantly, vote on who was the best person at any given time to represent the wider National Wrestling Alliance as the roaming NWA Worlds Heavyweight Champion.

The roots of the NWA date back to 1948, where Iowa's Pinkie George, Midwest Wrestling Association's Al Haft, Minneapolis Boxing and Wrestling Club's Tony Stecher, Harry Light Wrestling Office's Harry Light, Heart of America's Orville Brown and St. Louis Wrestling Club's Sam Muchnick came together to form the organisation.

As the decades went by, notable promotions such as Championship Wrestling from Florida, Stampede Wrestling, Jim Crockett Promotions, World Class, World Championship Wrestling, and even the World Wrestling Federation all became members of the NWA, with the organisation being the dominant force in the industry.

Of course, Vince McMahon Jr. was quick to pit himself up against the NWA once he took control of the then-WWF in 1982, with McMahon severing ties with the NWA by the following year. Rather than being happy to work under a model where each territory respected the other and trod on no toes, Vince wanted the WWF to be on TV all across the US and beyond - which in turn angered those who worked under the traditions of the long-standing NWA structure and its rules.

7. The Original Fall Of The NWA

What made the NWA's resurgence so special in 2019, was the fact that those letters had meant so little for the longest period of time.

Advertisement

From being the industry's standard bearer, the National Wrestling Alliance name became utterly worthless by the time of the mid '90s. Truth be told, the writing was on the wall as soon as Vince McMahon's ruthless aggression began to run rampant in 1982.

While the NWA - driven by Jim Crockett Promotions - put on the first Starrcade in 1983, McMahon set about putting on his own supershow spectacle that would be bigger, brasher and brighter than anything the combined might of the NWA could deliver. Of course, those Vince plans led to WrestleMania in 1985, and the rest is history.

One of the most significant strikes McMahon made against the NWA, was purchasing Georgia Championship Wrestling. A famed member of the NWA, GCW's sale allowed WWF to take over the promotion's spot on TBS; a spot that GCW had held for 12 years. While ratings for WWF on TBS tanked, that did lead to McMahon selling that timeslot to Jim Crockett Promotions for $1 million... and that fee played a major part in helping fund the first WrestleMania.

The introduction of the Survivor Series PPV was another nail in the coffin on the NWA, with McMahon boldly running that show on the same night of Starrcade '87. Threatening PPV providers that they wouldn't be allowed WrestleMania IV if they offered Starrcade, Vince's competitive drive saw Survivor Series' buyrate be more than double that of its NWA counterpart.

From there, the WWF ran the first Royal Rumble PPV on the same night as NWA's Bunkhouse Stampede, and an attempt from the National Wrestling Alliance to counter WrestleMania IV with the first Clash of the Champions did nothing to put a chink in McMahon's armour.

This battle forced JCP into financial ruin, which led to Ted Turner purchasing the promotion through TBS and renaming it to World Championship Wrestling. Unfortunately, by 1993, WCW was a strong enough entity to stand on its own feet, and thus the organisation withdrew from the NWA.

6. The Wilderness Years

With the World Wrestling Federation having become the market leader as the '80s rolled into the '90s, and with World Championship Wrestling now an entity capable of challenging the WWF's dominance, the '90s was a decade where the NWA's fall from grace hit an all-time low.

Advertisement

As part of WCW's withdrawal from the NWA, the NWA Worlds Heavyweight Championship was vacated by Ric Flair in September '93, and that title would remain unoccupied until the following August when Shane Douglas won a tournament to crown a new NWA Worlds Champ. Of course, that title win was infamous for how Douglas threw down the NWA Title and lambasted the history of those letters, instead opting to present himself as the ECW World Champion as that burgeoning promotion moved to distance itself from the NWA and transition from Eastern Championship Wrestling to Extreme Championship Wrestling.

For the rest of the '90s, the NWA's titles and branding were briefly incorporated into WWF programming as part of a half-assed invasion, and the NWA letters floundered in obscurity until they were ushered into Jerry and Jeff Jarrett's new NWA: TNA in 2002 - with the promotion utilising the classic NWA belts as part of its top singles and tag gold.

That agreement between the NWA and TNA came to a halt in 2007, and the NWA name and titles were floated through various promotions - such as Championship Wrestling from Hollywood, NWA Pro West, and NWA Georgia - for the next decade.

Not to discredit the NWA Worlds Champions of the time, but the wilderness years - with the NWA: TNA sandwiched in the middle - with names like Gary Steele, Mike Rapada, Brent Albright and even Adam Pearce and Colt Cabana holding the Ten Pounds of Gold, were a far cry away from having powerhouse names like Harley Race, Ric Flair, Dusty Rhodes, Terry Funk and Jack Brisco at the top of the NWA mountain.

5. The Resurrection Of The NWA

As mentioned earlier, it was in 2017 when Billy Corgan purchased the National Wrestling Alliance. Prior to that, the rights to the NWA had been with R. Bruce Tharpe since 2012, with Tharpe having acquired the organisation as part of a settlement for an insurance fraud case.

Advertisement

Under Corgan, the NWA would end up becoming destination viewing for a certain section of wrestling fans. While the Smashing Pumpkins' frontman initially utilised the NWA - much like Tharpe before him - as a licensing tool, where other promotions were able to use the NWA letters and titles, Billy completely changed the game in 2019.

It was '19 when Billy Corgan's National Wrestling Alliance launched its own weekly television series, NWA Powerrr. Pulling on the heartstrings of those with fond memories of the classic studio wrestling format, Powerrr was a glorious hour of action that was doused in nostalgia but had a slew of fantastic present-day talents to showcase.

Before the arrival of Powerrr, the NWA had a brief alliance with IMPACT Wrestling before then striking up a working relationship with Ring of Honor. And it was during this time that Cody Rhodes toppled Nick Aldis at All In to become the NWA Worlds Heavyweight Champion.

The American Nightmare would drop that prize back to Aldis a month later at the NWA 70th Anniversary Show, and it was the Brit who would lead the charge when the NWA began putting out weekly content with the first episode of Powerrr on 8 October 2019.

4. The Jewel In The Crown

The very first episode of NWA Powerrr saw NWA Worlds Heavyweight Champion Nick Aldis fend off the challenge of Tim Storm, the ridiculously loveable veteran babyface who Aldis had defeated in 2017 to embark on his first run with the Ten Pounds of Gold.

Advertisement

While he'd had some success in TNA - at one point holding the promotion's top prize - the Nick Aldis seen in the NWA at this point was one vastly different to what had been seen before from the Englishman. The National Treasure had always shown promise in TNA, and for those who'd not been keeping up with the career of the former Magnus, he was an entirely different beast under the NWA banner.

Having defeated Cody Rhodes to commence his second reign as the NWA Worlds Heavyweight Champion, this Nick Aldis oozed star power and carried himself as the utter embodiment of the classic World Champion of yesteryear. Character-wise, Aldis had a sprinkling of Nick Bockwinkle, a splash of Ric Flair, and a smidge of Harley Race to his persona. In-ring, the Norfolk native was extremely capable and could bring the best out of anyone he stepped between the ropes with.

Throughout the initial Powerrr run and beyond, Nick Aldis was the jewel in the crown for the National Wrestling Alliance, and having such a credible World Champion was pivotal to the success and favour achieved by the NWA upon its 'proper' relaunch.

3. The Fantastic Ensemble

Sure, Nick Aldis was atop the mountain of the NWA when Powerrr debuted, but there were so many other amazing cogs helping to turn the promotion's wheels.

Advertisement

With Powerrr's second episode, audiences were introduced to the extensive charisma of a certain Ricky Starks. Elsewhere, seasoned pros like Eli Drake, James Storm, Colt Cabana, Ken Anderson and Eddie Kingston devoured scenery with their words. Then there was the hugely captivating presence of names such as Thunder Rosa and Kamille as the brilliant Allysin Kay took centre-stage as the NWA Women's Champion.

Away from those talents, there were stars such as Tim Storm, Aron Stevens, the Question Mark, Thom Latimer, Da Pope, Trevor Murdoch and later Zicky Dice as others who forever made for engaging wrestling television.

Some may well say that Nick Aldis carried the NWA on his back for a spell - and there is plenty of truth in that - but the National Treasure had a phenomenal supporting cast of players assisting him in making NWA Powerrr such a go-to part of many a wrestling fans' weekly viewing habits.

2. Problems Of The Pandemic

It's likely fair to say that no significant wrestling promotion suffered as much during the pandemic as the NWA.

Advertisement

While WWE was able to adapt to its Thunderdome Era, AEW had Daily's Place to utilise, and promotions such as IMPACT Wrestling, Ring of Honor and New Japan Pro-Wrestling eventually opted to perform in crowd-less buildings, Billy Corgan's National Wrestling Alliance went on a complete hiatus from in-ring action.

Prior to the pandemic, the NWA was as hot as it had been for decades. Granted, there was no danger of the organisation matching the heady heights of the likes of WWE and AEW, but there was so much goodwill towards Corgan's company at that point. The weekly Powerrr shows had long become a highlight of the wrestling week, and fans were eager to tune in for the next hour-long slice of a brisk, entertaining product that had such brilliant, firmly established characters amongst its ensemble.

Once the world went to the dogs as COVID-19 came to the fore, the NWA didn't run any sort of wrestling show for nearly nine months. To run a studio wrestling product without any studio audience meant that it wasn't financially viable for the NWA to continue through those dark days. Not just that, but this time also saw plentiful major names walk away from the promotion in order to find work elsewhere, with Ricky Starks, Eddie Kingston, Eli Drake, Colt Cabana and Thunder Rosa just a handful of those who departed the NWA.

As Billy Corgan himself has stated in various interviews - such as this one with Stephanie Chase - he considered not bringing the NWA back from its enforced hiatus, so unsure was he about whether the promotion could get back to its pre-pandemic heights.

1. Billy Corgan's Creative Vision

As the owner of the National Wrestling Alliance, Billy Corgan is ultimately the one who calls the shots for the promotion. Unfortunately, Corgan has made some mighty questionable calls in recent months, with the NWA product becoming unwatchable to some wrestling fans.

Advertisement

Since Dave Lagana left his executive role with the NWA after being implicated in the #SpeakingOut movement, the general presentation of the NWA and its stars has been extremely off. Lagana rightfully had to leave his post at Corgan's side, but nobody has been brought into the fold to match the vision and direction that Lagana had for the NWA.

Of course, the mass exodus of talent hasn't helped the NWA, but part of what made the product so great pre-pandemic was its knack of introducing relatively unheard of names and turning them into stars you wanted to see on a weekly basis. And that's not to say that the NWA doesn't have some great talents amongst its ranks still - Colby Corino, Trevor Murdoch, Matt Cardona, Allysin Kay, Kamille, Jennacide, Natalie Markova, Hawx Aerie, and JTG amongst those who bring plenty to the table - but the booking and story arcs at play from Corgan of late have served to turn off many who had championed the NWA across these past few years.

It's not just fans who have been left baffled by the NWA's creative direction, for two-time NWA Worlds Heavyweight Champion Nick Aldis - for so long the focal point of the company - is departing the organisation when his contract's up at the turn of the year, with the National Treasure having butted heads with Corgan over his plans for the NWA.

Bizarrely, Billy last month lambasted those questioning him, instructing people to "don't watch the NWA" if they are unhappy with Corgan's creative. Being pig-headed enough to not listen to fanbase feedback is an extremely Vince McMahon approach. The only difference being, McMahon was running a multi-billion dollar company with huge sponsorship deals in place as he raked in record-setting profits. For a promotion as small as the NWA, every viewer counts, every PPV buy counts, and listening to your audience should always be absolutely key.

Instead, Billy Corgan - unlike near-enough every wrestling fan - wants to see Tyrus as his top champion and the person leading the promotion. Until Corgan becomes more receptive to the opinions of others, the NWA is sadly going to lose more and more fans with each passing week.

Billy Corgan helped to once again make the NWA great, but it's Billy Corgan right now who is making the NWA entirely skippable in a wrestling world that offers so many belter alternatives.

Advertisement