How WWE Should SAVE Women's Wrestling

The market leader is once again failing to lead the market, and the situation is getting critical.

By Michael Hamflett /

WWE

It feels important to kick this off by bringing up how this article couldn't fit "...In The North American Mainstream" into the character limit.

Advertisement

Women's wrestling could always be healthier, but a peer beyond the global market leader and its nearest challenger brand finds things in a better state than on USA, TBS, Fox and TNT.

For a company that only launched in 2010 and has also had to navigate through several years of pandemic-enforced restrictions, Stardom has continued to thrive rather than merely survive. The likes of Io Shirai (Iyo Sky) and Kairi Hoko (Kairi Sane/KAIRI) were two of the first legacy players for the organisation, seeking and finding enormous success within the typically myopic WWE system, while the likes of Mayu Iwatani, Tam Nakano, Utami Hayashishita, Gulia and others have drawn critical praise and repeatedly penetrated the supposedly niche bubble Joshi exists in with consistent high ratings for their major matches over the last decade.

Advertisement

In roughly the same time period (with the same setbacks and with several of the same names), Tokyo Joshi Pro-Wrestling has earned similar acclaim with the likes of Yuka Sakazki and Maki Itoh both also making waves in a limited capacity for AEW. Elsewhere, Wave, Ice Ribbon and other Japanese independents help fostered and nurtured talents such as Kana (Asuka), Hikaru Shida, Emi Sakura before they broke out in North America and beyond.

These are promotions and performers in rude health, proving beyond any reasonable doubt that women's wrestling can and does draw by all traditional and contemporary metrics. Previously, box office/ratings decline was one of the self-fulfilling reasons promoters gave for why women historically suffered the wrath of a booker's indifference, but why - if so much data suggests otherwise - is that negligence still happening in both WWE and AEW?

Advertisement

CONT'D...

WWE.com

Breaking over a million viewers for its overrun and scoring the highest rating in three years, the number for the September 12th 2023 edition of NXT was an eye-opener for many that either don't keep up with the show or have long assumed that well promoted, well booked and well presented women's wrestling isn't reflected in the Nielsens.

Advertisement

Weeks before the headline clash between then-Champion Tiffany Stratton and challenger Becky Lynch, Stratton had accidentally-on-purpose errantly named 'The Man' as a former titleholder. Through shrewd use of social media - this was destined to get picked up and immediately corrected - Lynch became entangled in a web while Stratton blew off the "mistake".

The tension had been established, and was doubled down on during the last stages of Lynch's feud with Trish Stratus. Stratton even appeared on Raw and at Payback scouting 'Big Time Becks', eventually drawing her further towards Tuesday nights. After Stratton defeated TV opponent Kiana James on September 5th, Lynch appeared on the TitanTron to call her out, and the two fought a week later.

Advertisement

This was NXT, with some WWE main roster thrown in, delivering something of a surprise development in a surprise hit of a story with an unsurprising elevation of Stratton coming out the other side. But it would be generous to call it complex, or an example of the company making extra effort beyond the norm or even the bare minimum of what males get.

It was short but perfectly formed, which is great until you remember that major companies will typically ensure the former before even worrying about the latter.

Advertisement

Minor ones, though?

CONT'D...

Advertisement
IMPACT Wrestling

The question isn't asked as much anymore, but is NXT a developmental brand or a third one?

Advertisement

Triple H has gleefully labelled it as both per the yarn he's spinning at the time, but the topic was a hotter one when there was still a ratings "war" to consider. Yet, there are those that never considered the black-and-gold/2.0 show a third brand, and as far as women's wrestling is concerned, some of those fans still don't. That's because those fans watch Impact Wrestling...

For several years now, Impact Wrestling has been a steady away version of itself. Perhaps the most steady away in its complex 22-year history, in fact. No longer aiming to be a distant (and that understates it) Number Two promotion in North America, nor even really worried about if the wider audience even wants a Number Three, Impact Wrestling has figured out that there are enough people that watch, enjoy and accept Impact Wrestling for exactly what it is. And as part of the show settling down enough to satisfy its core base and flirt with the odd casuals/TNA nostalgia addicts, Impact has preserved the integrity of the Knockouts Division.

Advertisement

The name should feel dated - it was established to be (literally) punchier than "Divas" once upon time - but legacy and lineage has elevated it, and the tenure implies and often reflects how much work was done back when it was neither popular nor objectively easy to do.

Years and years pass by with a division that promotes consistently good-to-great action, a level of parity that outright ensures that time will be given to female matches and feuds over anything the men are doing based on the quality of the action and drama. There will doubtless be some cynical motivation underneath during particularly barren spells for the divisions in WWE and AEW, but perhaps thats on the two biggest players not to leave so much space open for that in the first place.

Advertisement

Never in recent memory was this more apparent than during the latter stages of Jade Cargill's TBS Championship run. A run which is now over, reportedly alongside with her AEW one. She's potentially crossing the divide.

How did this happen?!

Advertisement

CONT'D...

AEW

AEW didn't go entirely wrong with Jade Cargill, but the resumé wasn't perfect, and merely analysing a 63-2 record and near-two year reign as a champion wilfully ignores the bigger picture.

Advertisement

Few wrestlers felt as "money" in look alone more so than Cargill when she debuted, and though there were inconsistencies in her work, they were excusable when presented with the total package. She was substantially better than some of the lower tier wrestlers the industry has provided a stage for over the year, and she was 50 times the star of some of the more famous ones. Unfortunately for her - and now seemingly AEW - she was the right person and the right time in the wrong place.

AEW's Women's Division has never been more passing concern for those booking the show, and even on the few occasions its simply taken the attention due to not being given enough, underwhelming follow-ups present incredible moments as flights of fancy. After four years, it's easier to name the wrestlers who haven't tried to elevate everything bell-to-bell, such is the obvious desire of everybody up and down the roster from Britt Baker to Billie Starkz to go out there and steal the show.

Advertisement

It so rarely happens though, because the women are so rarely given the tools or time. Cargill needed so few tools to get over that she didn't require time. If her work stagnated, it was only because the creative investment in her character did too. Match graphics were simply enough, as was going a criminal amount of time without a single storyline because waiting (for months) for Kris Statlander returning from injury apparently justified it.

Common consensus suggests a mooted move to WWE would address a lot of the issues and further maximise her incredible upside. Common consensus probably isn't wrong either, but it might not be diving deep enough into the details.

Advertisement

CONT'D...

WWE.com

Who, in WWE's women's division is being well booked at the moment?

Advertisement

Iyo Sky's a paper champion, booked into a background position despite cashing in a briefcase as ostensible babyface. Her next challenger Asuka is more wacky than dangerous, and has never felt more like a first loser than a next winner. Sky's backed by Bayley, who feels like she's accepted never returning to the summit. Admirable trait, but she's getting beaten like a drum for her selflessness. Charlotte Flair's a babyface on television, which is half the problem. The other half is how she only turns up the quality on massive stages, which accounts for approximately five shows in any calendar year.

On Monday Night Raw, Rhea Ripley has ran roughshod over a series of challengers because it suits her character and she's the only star being protected at present, but the undercard is a state as a result. The Tag Team Title “curse” has become yet another self-fulfilling prophecy, and although Nia Jax’s return will absolutely present a unique boost to the division, history tells us the risk and reward are remarkably close together when she’s on top.

Advertisement

The change, as much of a necessity as it is, feels a long way from taking place. Evolution 2018 feels more than five years ago, and even then much of that was promoted in an attempt to deflect from the ugliest elements of WWE’s deal with the Saudi Arabian Sports Authority. And the business side of the organisation has yet again changed forever.

CONT’D…

Advertisement
NYSE

There was a lot to absolutely loathe about the images of Vince McMahon, Dana White, Nick Khan et al celebrating the merger of WWE and UFC under the TKO brand on September 12th, not least that of the 15 people on the podium, just three were women. It got worse in the post-script too; a banner unveiling talents from both sides attempted to present male and female talents as equals for both brands, but it was a case of more haste, less speed. The poster included former WWE Superstar - and current Impact Knockouts Champion! - Trinity, TAFKA Naomi.

Advertisement

A slip, obviously, but was it Freudian one from an organisation with chequered past and an uncertain new future? Men have historically held just about all of the power and still do, so for the billionth time in human existence and capitalism's ugly history, it's up to women to force men to help other women, or nothing is going to get done.

No singular signing to any roster would be as powerful as bringing more in at executive and/or administrative levels within the process, but maybe an organisation mostly just as gross as WWE in the form of UFC can actually drive the change.

Advertisement

When Ronda Rousey was breaking out, Vince McMahon was calling women’s MMA “barbaric”. The disgraced old billionaire always liked being slightly behind the curve than in front, but this was proof that he’d fallen too far at the expense of his finances. TKO will only follow the money, so it’ll take the next Rousey in the Octagon or Lynch in the ring to convince them to plough ahead.

It remains to be seen if Jade Cargill, Nia Jax or anybody else already signed or a future signing could be the next great hope. But WWE is the place to find out - we are back in the worst case scenario, and they are back as the best of a bad bunch.

Advertisement