Ranking WWE's First Ever NXT Class - From Worst To Best
24. Danny Burch
Danny Burch did well to survive not just the dark days of the pre-NXT developmental system, but some lean years on the black and gold brand and a stint in the perpetually miserable NXT UK.
A surprise package in the company's 2017 UK Tournament after being hidden away in jobber matches as Martin Stone, Burch was paired with Oney Lorcan after the two beat the respect into each other on television. As bruiser babyfaces, the pair dramatically over-delivered on measured expectations, entering in some choice efforts against The Undisputed Era.
Notching an NXT Tag Team Title run following a 2020 heel turn alongside Pat McAfee, Burch was eventually released in 2021 but picked right back up on the independents. On balance and in comparison to many of his peers from the UK scene, his entire run within the system has to be considered something an overachievement.
23. Summer Rae
Considering the era and the relatively low bar set for women at the time, Summer Rae over-achieved within WWE.
Never a standout amongst some of the other women known for stronger matches, she got over by force of a magnetic personality, and maximised her minutes on both NXT and the main roster. A popular babyface and easy-to-hate heel, Rae was best remembered for her roles in the BFFs alongside Sasha Banks and Charlotte Flair on the black-and-gold brand, and then again alongside Rusev opposite Dolph Ziggler and Lana in that ill-fated love square.
A hit on Total Divas - itself a massive hit in its original run - Rae even created enough lore with Natalya on the show that her Royal Rumble 2022 cameo was one of the lone highlights of the match. She stormed the ring with something to prove, fighting with the Hart Dungeon graduate with so much vigour that you were left wondering which one actually had the Calgary pedigree.
22. Erick Rowan
Erick Rowan only improved during his time within WWE, which isn't as common as one might think considering how that's the very point of time within the system.
The Wyatt Family got over huge on NXT, and while Husky Harris' reinvention as Bray was at the centre of all of it, Rowan and Luke Harper were integral to the success of the presentation. Winning gold on the brand was validation, but more of that should have appeared on Raw and SmackDown that what the wider audience eventually saw.
After a corny and shlocky introduction to proceedings in 2013, various splits and restarts doomed the act, and Rowan with it. A renewed Bludgeon Brothers run alongside Luke Harper wasn't enough to save Rowan from being caught up in some absurd WWE comedy in late-2019/early2020 when he debuted a mystery burlap-covered box (!) that had a giant spider in it (!!) until babyface Drew McIntyre pulverised it with a hammer (!!!)
His release in April 2020 was so criminal that it should have had charges brought against it.
21. Aiden English
Aiden English was done dirty by WWE's creative disinterest when a pairing with Rusev was ripped apart about a year after he'd contributed massively to getting the Rusev Day bit over as one of the biggest things in the company.
A seven year run between 2012-2019 from Florida Championship Wrestling through NXT and onto Raw and SmackDown probably should have ended happier for the Vaudvillain and former NXT Tag Team Champion, but the half-baked conclusion to his relationship with Rusev spoke to how his main roster character was handled in general.
Spotting the way the wind was blowing in the bleak midwinter of WWE's undercard, English took a chance at breaking into the announce booth. Unfortunately, a second career as a 205 Live commentator was also cut short when he was part of the company's 2020 releases, but the gambit proved worth it in the long run - he's since parlayed that into a prosperous run as an announcer for Impact Wrestling/TNA.
20. Kassius Ohno
A late arrival in Florida Championship Wrestling before the wholesale move to NXT, Kassius Ohno brought what was then a dreaded "indie darling" tag to WWE in 2012, but became a highlight of the early black-and-gold broadcasts.
Before making it on to Raw or SmackDown though, he was somewhat surprisingly released from the system entirely. He later explained that concerns had been raised over his conditioning, and that he failed to heed a 30-day warning to turn his situation around. Eventually, he must have just done that because he was back on the show in 2017.
The second time around, the run looked and felt different, with Ohno providing as much of a service as a fabled wrestling mind and fan as he did in major television programmes. He was a total popper on NXT UK (and wow did that show need it) before his 2020 release.
19. Emma
Emma was one half of what was at the time arguably the best WWE women's match of all time when she narrowly lost to Paige at NXT Arrival in March 2014.
While she wasn't entirely defined by the contest in the aftermath, it absolutely raised hopes and expectations for her. Her gimmick - a happy go lucky, clumsy (and slightly stupid) babyface - was immensely popular inside the supportive walls of Full Sail University, but when the WWE main roster didn't have the patience or creative energy to actually get it over gradually, the bubble literally and figuratively burst.
Once a supposed work-rate favourite, she was suddenly more of a gems-and-rarities type, popping in for lowkey classics such as her TakeOver: London battle with Asuka before unexpectedly getting released in 2017 after a shambolic failed repackaging as Emmalina. A 2022-2023 comeback didn't go much better, but she's never really struggled for work in the industry, such is her ability to shore up an ailing division with a relatively steady hand.
18. Mike Dalton
Mike Dalton was considered something of a wrestler's wrestler from his earliest days within WWE, and as usual that tag is as much a blessing as a curse under the purview of the market leader.
One of the early NXT call-ups to suffer shockingly lazy mismanagement on the main roster, Tyler Breeze nonetheless remained part of the system in the years hence thanks to his beloved unit with Fandango. After about a year as the best things on SmackDown in 2017, injuries robbed them of prime main roster years before a 2019 return to the black and gold brand. That lasted until 2021, when both were released.
Rewarded for his skills and fundamentals later rather than sooner, Breeze was eventually brought back as a Performance Center coach, alongside working independent dates here and there with an approximation of the gimmick that gave him his biggest successes.
17. Byron Saxton
Byron Saxton will celebrate two decades with WWE in 2027, having first worked for Florida Championship Wrestling all the way back in 2007. Though he got comfortable in the Tampa training facility, his introduction to WWE's brightest lights was in the worst possible setting.
Cursed by his place on the talent show version of NXT, Saxton was theoretically as doomed as all the rest but eventually found his way into a regular role by getting into broadcasting.
Cutting an affable figure even in the face of abuse from the likes of Corey Graves, John Bradshaw Layfield and Jerry Lawler over the years, Saxton's perpetually nice demeanour stood in direct opposition to WWE in general.
Pivoting to a full-time career behind the desk, he's been a permanent member of the WWE broadcast team since the mid-2010s, having taken numerous other commentary roles since wrestling his hung up the boots for good in 2012.
16. Colin Cassady
Big Cass experienced a number of ups and downs personally and professionally before working taking an indies and Impact Wrestling route through to AEW, where he scored tag gold with Ricky Starks. It was something he never managed with Enzo Amore during their fondly-remembered run.
New Age Outlaws for a workrate generation, Enzo and Cass exemplified the range on offer during Triple H's NXT golden era. Perfect opening act wrestlers, the call-and-response mic work and decent hot tag formula matches made for a perfect blend underneath whatever cutting edge action might have been set for the remainder of the show. An iron-clad bond with the audience was forged, making their doomed runs at tag gold as intoxicating as they were futile.
They briefly burned bright on WWE's main roster, but ended up burning out almost as quickly. Enzo was gone by January 2018 and Cass' release followed soon afterwards, resulting in the aforementioned tumult and turnaround,
15. Judas Devlin
The somewhat unremarkable Judas Devlin gimmick couldn't be further apart from the persona that eventually brought the former developmental prospect to the fore in 2019.
His FCW/NXT stint between 2012 and 2013 didn't reveal a glimpse of the meteoric rise he'd experience in a mainstream national promotion, with most matches ending in defeat against the likes of Sawyer Fulton, Mike Dalton and Derrick Batemen. His black-and-gold was made extinct with a house show loss, further emphasising how little ground he'd been able to game within the WWE system.
It'd take seven more years across independents across the world and a drastic gimmick upgrade to help him reach his most prosperous destination.
As Luchasaurus and later Killswitch, he rocked the wrestling world in a cameo at All Elite Wrestling's inaugural Double Or Nothing pay-per-view, and has been a prominent and distinguishing feature of AEW ever since.