Ranking WWE's First Ever NXT Class - From Worst To Best

14. CJ Parker

As Juice Robinson, the former CJ Parker has been rewarded for his brave choice to walk away from NXT in 2015. 

Advertisement

Going through the New Japan dojo brought out a tougher side to the otherwise fun-loving Robinson, fleshing him out as an awesome all-rounder. He made a genuine mark in NJPW across several G1 Climax tournaments and IWGP United States title reigns, revealing a route more wrestlers probably should have gambled on while feeling as trapped as he did.

As things started to go a little stale in New Japan, Robinson made it back to the North American mainstream via wrestling's newest challenger brand. Ahead of Jay White also arriving, Juice brought Bullet Club to All Elite Wrestling. 

A total patter machine in between decent-to-very good matches revitalised the brand as a strong comedy act, widening its scope enough to welcome in The Gunns as new members in the process. 

13. Paige

The first ever NXT Women's Champion and youngest ever WWE Divas Champion was an instant hit having left the UK scene for US soil, building on a career longer than was legal before joined up with the market leader in 2012. Arriving with reps and getting even more via Florida Championship Wrestling through to the NXT rebrand, when the time came for the black-and-gold brand to get its first female titleholder, she was the perfect choice.

Advertisement

'The Anti-Diva' was a telling nickname for the time, with the persona seemingly as much about Triple H attempting to distinguish his female wrestlers from the state of play on the main roster. This was as much show as tell in 2014 when Paige and Emma used the elevated stage of an "Arrival" Network special to contest one of the best WWE women's matches ever up to that point.

Paige was fast-tracked from there to a Raw and SmackDown run with more mixed results. Personal and professional priorities clashed, and a brutally unlucky injury record resulted in a bumpy four year stint coming to an end with an early retirement in 2018. After a swing as an authority figure and manager, she ended up leaving the company, but surprisingly turned up in All Elite Wrestling in 2022. Another so-so run did at least generate one enormously cathartic home nation victory in front of the company's biggest ever crowd at Wembley Stadium, kicking off a brief reign as AEW Women's Champion.

It's not been the easiest of roads, but she paved enough of it herself to at least get the chance to make the journey. 

12. Corey Graves

The former 'Saviour Of Misbehaviour' broke down when announcing his retirement from in-ring action in December 2014, but has gone from strength to strength as an announcer ever since.

Advertisement

After a decade on the independent scene, Graves was ring and gimmick-ready in Florida Championship Wrestling. Working television tapings from the off, he fought just about everybody on this list and from the existing generation of top stars in a stacked schedule between 2012 and his 2014 retirement. 

The work was decent, the misanthropic gimmick was good to go, but nobody expected him to transition to commentary as smoothly as he ended up doing. A partnership with Tom Phillips on NXT was an instant hit, and he tapped into something upon getting the call-up to Raw in 2016 because he's been a feature on Mondays and Fridays ever since. 

While not the voice of WWE, he's a massive one all the same, juggling play-by-play with colour commentary across both shows and Premium Live Events. 

11. Luke Harper

Jon Huber's late-2020 passing rocked all of wrestling, speaking to what a beloved figure he was amongst all colleagues across the industry. 

Advertisement

Having already amassed immense respect amongst his peers before landing in WWE in 2012, he was a natural fit for a Wyatt Family gimmick the defined the bulk of his time with the market leader. 

Of note in those early days, he worked his very first match in FCW as Brodie Lee before adopting the Harper moniker, and worked only his third match in the WWE system against Dean Ambrose - the man he'd later headline Double Or Nothing 2020 against with the AEW World Heavyweight Championship on the line. 

Regrettably, several half-baked attempts to push both Harper and the Wyatts stalled his career until he was finally able to get his release in 2019. 

Upon signing for AEW in 2020, he was an immediate hit. As an audience, we'd collectively only just started to see the full extent of his raft of skills - a final run as TNT Champion Brodie Lee saved a cursed Dark Order gimmick and remains his wonderful lasting legacy.

10. Alexander Rusev

Miro has found mixed fortunes in All Elite Wrestling since joining the challenger brand in 2020, but even his relative peaks in AEW humbled the missed opportunities during his original WWE run.  He shouldn't have ever needed to go there to break a wrestling glass ceiling.

Advertisement

Regardless of its lightweight origins or just how much the gimmick needed the Aiden English's mic work to help it along, Rusev Day absolutely was a moment that WWE should have done much, much more with. And midcard titles don't count - they certainly didn't then so they shouldn't in retrospect. 

That Vince McMahon thought it was just the fans mocking the 'Bulgarian Brute' explains away a lot of what happened to it, particularly considering how dated (but effective) the presentation of the character was during Rusev's earliest days. 'The Redeemer' gimmick AEW briefly had success with is everything WWE had and threw away until he inevitably re-signs. 

9. Baron Corbin

'The Lone Wolf' has stuck at it to become a a pauper, a King, a Constable and just about anything else asked of him during an unlikely 10-year WWE run that shows no sign of slowing.

Advertisement

His NXT breakthrough came as result of squash match push so effective that Full Sail fans counted the seconds as he dominated, but Raw and SmackDown runs following his call-up were blighted with the sorts of personas that would and have felled others. Not Corbin. For years criticised as somebody that couldn’t perform to the level of his contemporaries, he has instead outlasted almost everybody in his class. 

Having survived the best and worst the WWE system had to offer, he then returned to NXT for a run against Ilja Dragunov and alongside Bron Breakker that ultimately became his most creatively fruitful stint yet.He's not amazing at much, but he's good at enough and has mastered the type of heat his bosses and opponents clearly love. And based on his social media, he makes the most of his time off living his best life. He might not top this list, but he tops his own.

8. Xavier Woods

The New Day man hit big when he joined up with Kofi Kingston and Big E in 2014, but it was good karma for a performer who is constantly name-dropped by others as a multi-talented megastar always looking to help his colleagues on the way up.

Advertisement

The success of his UpUpDownDown side project speaks to that, along with an illustrious and Hall Of Fame-bound career that shows no signs of slowing down. Woods is as timeless as The New Day act itself - for all the wrestlers that have spent five years as weekly television regulars that feels like 10, the three have managed to put that motion in reverse. A group that formed in 2014 with a dead-on-arrival gimmick exist in a decade later as a company cornerstone. 

All of them deserve equal credit, but both Kingston and E have gone on record as crediting Woods with being the driver of what made the group so beloved. There aren’t enough stories like Woods’, in truth. Hard work rewarded, ideas and creativity nourished, speed bumps kept to a minimum - the wrestling utopia occupied by so few.

7. Bray Wyatt

When a performer passes away there’s an understandable tendency to brush aside the lows to focus on the highs in tributes, but with the late Bray Wyatt this was an altogether trickier process.

Advertisement

Not that much of the fault lay at the feet of the ‘Eater Of Worlds’ of course. WWE failed his character, his endeavour and his vision on more than one occasion, and one only need look at the NXT launch of the persona to show how smoothly things could have gone for the gimmick. Husky Harris was gone for good when Wyatt landed, and no matter how warped the various incarnations of the persona became on the main roster, the foundations laid in his black-and-gold run ensured that all of his biggest moments would forever be preserved in amber.

His legacy will only be enhanced as the years pass, too. A WWE Champion, a headliner, a storyline driver and a monstrous merch-mover, his efforts made him a beloved figure amongst his base, and the Fiend aesthetic alone secured him a spot as one of the most visually striking characters ever crafted.

6. Charlotte

At various points the most over and under-pushed woman in WWE, Charlotte Flair's had just about every version of the experience one can have spending a decade there - including being considered the Roman Reigns of the women's division on account of how hated she often was even as a babyface. 

Advertisement

Blame bad booking over bad wrestling, especially for large parts of a career loaded with contemporary in-ring classics. As a member of the Four Horsewomen, Flair contested classics with Becky Lynch, Sasha Banks and Bayley as well as an era-defining bout with Natalya that launched her as the NXT Women's Champion. On the main roster, her big match pedigree was rarely called into question. An Evolution Last Woman Standing match with Becky Lynch was perhaps WWE's best single offering of the year, and if it wasn't, it was challenged by Flair stepping in as a last minute substitute to face Ronda Rousey at Survivor Series a month later. 

As recent as WrestleMania 39, she was still proving herself as a massive main-stage performer. Her Women's Title loss to Rhea Ripley was violent chaos befitting of the pair's similarities in style and size, and a much-needed reminder of what she could offer after a few uneven displays in the months before. 

5. Sasha Banks

Perhaps the best women's wrestler in North American history, Sasha Banks left WWE in 2022 with the matches, the moments and the objective measures to make a very good case for it.

Advertisement

Having spent just shy of 10 full years in the system, she was somebody that bought into the company's methods knowing that she could ensure the feeling would be mutual. Some seminal performances in NXT in 2014 and 2015 earnestly spearheaded a revolution even if WWE's monetising of it made it look stage-managed. A TakeOver: Brooklym match with career rival/partner and real life best friend Bayley was perhaps the company's best of the entire 2010s, and without doubt ground zero for everything about to happen for women across the rosters at that time. 

Having stood up for her character when exiting in 2022, a 2023 sojourn to NJPW and Stardom paved the way for an AEW debut in 2024. 'The Boss' is now 'The CEO', and though she's already openly discussed another WWE run down the line, it stands to be exhilarating seeing her coming in at the very top rather than having to trudge through a broken organisation's sludge. 

Advertisement