The REAL Reason For WWE's Recent NXT Call Ups

What does the arrival of Ricochet and co. to Raw mean for NXT?

By Benjamin Richardson /

WWE

During Monday Night Raw's show-opening promo, proud proxy father Triple H announced that a quartet of his finest NXT sprogs would be alighting on that very night's episode of the show. His freshly debuting yellow-and-gold progeny would include the brand's two top champions, Tommaso Ciampa and Johnny Gargano, as well as 'developmental' standouts Ricochet and Aleister Black.

Advertisement

Hunter, a quiver on his lip, ran down the names suddenly shorn from his pet project for pastures poorer, whilst Michael Cole on commentary provided the briefest precis on their Performance Center performances.

As the night progressed, each of the four new men starred in victorious showcases of their talents. Dual-gold-holders Ciampa and Gargano dispatched Raw's top-tag-dogs The Revival, Aleister Black laboured to a win over Elias, and pinball wizard Ricochet dispatched Lio Rush and Bobby Lashley alongside Finn Bálor. In purely statistical terms, it was a very promising start for the as-yet unconfirmed call-ups.

Advertisement

When the dust settled, it wasn't entirely clear whether the NXT incursion was a one-off showcase to inspire fresh interest immediately after Elimination Chamber, or if they were making a permanent migration from Full Sail.

Tuesday night hinted in favour of the former, as the four-pointed star of stars defied the nominal brand split to feature once more on SmackDown. Again, a tick in the 'W' column was forthcoming for the lot of them.

Advertisement

For a firm answer, we had to consult the oracle. As ever, Dave Meltzer of The Wrestler Observer had the answers, confirming on an episode of Wrestling Observer Radio that the NXT standouts are here to stay. According to the veteran journalist, the decision was entirely reactionary; increasingly troubled by the seemingly unstoppable ratings slide, Vince McMahon arbitrarily decided that he wanted more outstanding workers on the show.

The quickest way to do that was lean on a favour from his son-in-law, requesting Triple H to cherry-pick his four greatest guys for a sudden battlefield promotion.

Advertisement

Amidst the process, the Chairman failed to recognise that perhaps it's what he does with said great talent once they make the step up which is responsible for the never-ending ratings slide. As he apparently identified when outlying his grand scheme, the chaps already at his disposal on the main roster were damaged too badly to be built back into stars.

This is what happens when you create a business out of self-licking ice creams.

Advertisement

[Con't. P1/3]

WWE

There's absolutely nothing to suggest the pattern will break with the latest crop. During the first of the Monday night neophytes' matches, Michael Cole told us that Ricochet, a former NXT North American Champion who wowed crowds with a Meltzer-rated five star match on his debut in New Orleans last year, "first broke out" during the Super Bowl's Halftime Heat. It was a depressing reminder that everything these men had ever accomplished on NXT would now be rendered irrelevant, parachuted onto the 'big boy' product from a plane of ignorance.

Advertisement

In other words, Vince McMahon has taken absolutely no interest in any of their careers up to this point, and is expecting magic in an instant, despite being continually baffled by the failure of previous NXT call-ups systematically dismantled by the main roster rot.

Almost immediately Triple H's inevitable fears were nearly proved correct, when his in-law tried to insist that insta-face Ricochet square off against brand new Intercontinental Champion Finn Bálor. With a single stroke of a pen, the boss wanted to a) give away a dream match as an opening TV encounter and b) defeat the newcomer straight away. This was Vince's big idea to have his new top talent improve ratings; make them look like chumps on night one.

Advertisement

Why are all the existing talent so irrecoverably damaged, again?

At the last moment, a pleading NXT honcho had the plans reversed so they weren't completely idiotic. It rather makes you think that a similar situation occurred during the last round of desperate NXT call-ups, with Triple H lying to the boss about his strongest hand, as the likes of Lacey Evans and EC3 made the grade and meanwhile his personal purview was kept in tact.

Advertisement

Heck, you partially get the impression Hunter's secreting Buddy Murphy on 205 Live lest he follow a similar pattern of ruination. Up to now, he's succeeded in hiding his favourite toys under the bed every time he's been forced to play nice with the clumsy next door neighbour's kid.

[Con't. P2/3]

Advertisement
WWE

Such a confused, scattershot plan of action has resulted in a confused, scattershot landscape. We now have a scenario where NXT's top championships are in limbo, with the latest suggestion being that the newbies will simply perform across all three brands. Does spreading them extremely thin - whilst totally blurring their intended role - help in any way whatsoever?

Advertisement

Probably not. Which might be why WWE also subtly dropped that a "Special Announcement" will be made on NXT in the coming week. Continuity and canon may be irrelevant to the company's writers, but talent can't be in two places at once, and neither, realistically, can championships. This may be a means to removing the gold from around their waist.

Either way, the "gold and black brand" has been left damaged by the sudden raid. Elevating NXT's championships to the main roster will diminish their prestige when they're inevitably presented as a secondary, or more likely, tertiary titles, floating across super-show pre-shows. Simply stripping the holders of the straps once they've made it to the ostensible 'big time' likewise instructs that there's no point getting invested in Full Sail if it's liable to have its reset button pressed on the whims of a capricious overlord.

Advertisement

The real reason for the recent NXT call ups doesn't relate to some grand plan, a company-changing long-term direction that'll benefit both fans and the talent in question. It's simply because the Titan ship's rudder sank so long ago, they no longer know whether they're going hither of thither.

Why have Tommaso Ciampa and co. made it to Raw? Why not. They've tried everything else.

Advertisement