Why WWE's Ratings Desperation Is A GOOD Thing
The Magic Numbers.
"THEY ARE FIGHTING OVER SHAMPOO" was the fan sign that famously stole focus during the total snoozer between Edge and Booker T at the critically-condemned WrestleMania X8. It spoke louder than Booker himself in the Japanese hair care commercial he failed to snag away from the future 'Rated-R Superstar'. It was voluminous (unlike the former Five-Time WCW Champion's locks, evidently) in it's toxicity. It was inspired in its simplicity. It was everything the storyline wasn't, and was comfortably the most entertaining element of the payoff as a result.
Should deferrence be offered to this angle because it's nearly two decades old? Ordinarily, such sh*te would develop a certain charm through the passage of time, but this week's edition of Raw was a pained reminder that in WWE, time - unlike Scott Dawson and Dash Wilder - stands totally f*cking still.
Was this latest embarrassing chapter in The Revival's insipid main roster story in fact their own endorsement for "Usoy Hot", because they didn't look as pleased with it as Edge did with his own commercial? Of course it b*stard wasn't - at least he got a WrestleMania match out of his embarrassment. Dash and Dawson were banished on the pre-show doghouse before the latter took the punishment literally by dragging his a*se across the ring on Raw.
The segment was the nadir of the flagship's own latest lowest ebb - a stinker of a Raw that will post a rating reflective of the creative catastrophe on display, even if Vince McMahon and Roman Reigns' joint presence remotely (and, artificially) inflate the figure. The former NXT Tag Team Champions were at long last headliners alright - but how long can these lead stories be fuelled by fervent fume?
Is Vince McMahon still in tune with his audience, or did he stumble and fall on Twitter and land headfirst in his own notifications as liked by Triple H? Does he bother to read the aimless-but-able output on WWE.com, or scroll below the line to test the pulse of his self-styled "Universe"? None of the above, obviously. In between workouts and one hour's sleep, he's got no time for bothering to check what any portion of his audience wants, when his entire fortune has been built up simply telling them or actively working in spite of it.
Why, then, have his most recent appearances frequently steered towards the contrarian chaos of a comments section?
Before WrestleMania, he willingly threw himself under a company-branded bus to get Charlotte Flair in main events and take Kofi Kingston out of them. On the second SmackDown Live after the 'Show Of Shows', he laughably lauded Elias as the biggest acquisition in the show's history as a red herring tease for Roman Reigns. There's light relief lurking below the darkness of this booking pattern - the daft old f*cker knows what he is. He knows he's out of touch, operating on a level below even levelheaded expectations of his most ardent supporters.
Or at least, the Mr McMahon gimmick does. He'd have to, in order to still have the grapefruits to call himself "brilliant" in the middle of the ring on Monday's horrendous edition of the show. Vince McMahon's been wanting to kill the character for years, so said Bruce Prichard before he got his job back. Might this be The Chairman's latest attempt to put a bullet in the evil billionaire's brain?
The (second) death of Mr McMahon isn't the "GOOD" thing the title of this article speaks to by the way. WWE persists with its own kind of macabre as it is, making heavy use of Baron Corbin as current warden of the Banter Era without needing the gallows humour of the demise of a septuagenarian, but if this whole arc isn't the tycoon booking his own breakdown, then what's this all really been about?
Knowing is half the battle, so the old saying goes. Mr McMahon knowing he's losing the battle against his own mind allows for these objectively bad decisions to occur in contrast to that notion of democracy posited by the rest of his family on the December 18th 2018 Raw before all of them apart from Triple H turned heel again.
But then, was that sliver of optimism ultimately as blind and short term as WWE's own creative strategy anyway? Read that date again; December 18th was six months ago - a lifetime in WWE, and long enough for McMahon to forget the segment ever happened because god forbid somebody rock up to work with a storyboard or timeline to stick to.
Let this not be end of all optimism. The future doesn't look bright, but wrestling history has taught us so often of the dawn that follows darkness, eventually.
Away from The Revival's plight, McMahon's pathetic efforts to explain away the slow death of the latest roster split and the Universal Champion falling to the Deep Six in a laborious 18:56, a particularly putrid Raw also featured Sami Zayn getting thrown in the bin by Braun Strowman in a fate not too dissimilar from the one that befell his bestie Kevin Owens one year earlier.
Is Braun Vince's guy or what? One week, he's this massive muscular monster humiliating smaller folk exactly as the boss would love to do himself if he had twenty less years on the clock. The rest, he's relegated to Battle Royal wins and banter programmes. He's not an avatar for McMahon himself, but the product itself. Nothing matters until it does, then it doesn't again. This Raw also offered two major rematches as hooks to stick around even though the aforementioned McMahon December address promised to do away with the treadmill effect this had on all your faves.
AJ Styles and Seth Rollins' Money In The Bank meeting will be that gimmick's acid test, but neither Braun nor anybody else is pitched up on Raw to challenge Rollins because this machine is crushing the "momentum" it forcibly thrusts upon the poor men and women every week. This is 1984 before the old heads realised Hulk Hogan probably was going to transform the industry. 1995 before The Ringmaster became Stone Cold Steve Austin.
This is the darkness, but - as WrestleMania weekend all-too-literally proved - WWE are so monied that they can afford to blind their loyalest audiences with the lights and get away with it.
Your writer noted that money was the REAL Reason Vince McMahon ironically didn't want to start sharing his wealth, because money is still the driver now that it was then. The missing piece of the creative puzzle has been in how little the dollars have been impacted by the output.
It was in 2018 that WWE first posted figures that placed a higher percentage of earnings in corporate deal columns than customer takings ones. This cruel turning point came as they turned blind eyes to Saudi Arabian insanity for all the money that made, and signed eye-watering TV deals that were immediately used as the stick to beat the product with.
Fox - long considered some of the biggest heels in news media - may be the babyfaces wrestling fans needed all along. The bulk of the cash needs to be earned, and SmackDown's current figures won't come close to satisfactory based on current indications. WWE worked against wrestlers to put the brand over as the draw, but television viewers and ticket-purchasers alike have lost faith in the three letters. It's time for stars again - and many more than just the Brock Lesnars and Ronda Rouseys that are almost certain to only do numbers the odd weeks they're actually there, rather than in the barren months they're not.
After years of hand-wringing and temple-massaging from incredibly patient punters, McMahon's original motivations may insist upon his mismanaged organisation getting its f*cking sh*t together for the good of its future. It's as crucial as shaking off the ghosts of its glorious past.
The Revival were filmed shaving their backs a week before their trunks were coated in mysterious miasma by the other best tag team on the roster, so, at very least, they are categorically not fighting over shampoo. This long, spiralling period - first birthed in 2002 - has now literally reached the skin and bones beyond whatever meat once still remained from The Attitude Era. Like its own inception in 1996, financial motivations put food back on the table. Here's to Fox growing rapidly impatient with SmackDown Live's p*sspoor numbers, and the new feast that awaits.