WWE Payback 2023: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True

Triple H wouldn't do this at WWE Payback, would he? Actually...would he?!

By Jamie Kennedy /

Being brutally honest, Payback feels like the kind of PLE the creative team doesn't want. Build for some matches has been lukewarm at best, and there's just an undeniable secondary vibe to the whole thing. However, it is fair to say that not every show can be WrestleMania. 'B' level PPVs are gonna happen.

Advertisement

Right, that's more than enough 'look on the bright side' nonsense. This article deals with the absolute worst of the worst that could happen in Pittsburgh this coming Saturday. It's the sort of booking that'd make Payback more ECW December To Dismember 2006 than WrestleMania X-Seven.

Wrestlers treading water (one even going backwards), aspiring stars looking like borderline enhancement talent on a grand stage, WWE booking split stories for the sake of it, unwanted title changes and a cheap return crowd pop for the local market that destroys a modern era must have - it's all here.

Be warned, you're going to pull funny faces reading some of this. Will all of it occur? No, of course not (fingers crossed, at least!), but several of these nightmares could come true over the weekend.

Start. Getting. Scared.

10. Raquel Rodriguez Looks Like A Jobber

Rhea Ripley's combined televised Women's World Title defences since winning at WrestleMania have amounted to just 21 minutes and 6 seconds. Those matches? Zelina Vega at Backlash and Natalya twice at Night Of Champions and on Raw respectively.

Advertisement

She's a wrecking machine Mickey from the Rocky movies would be proud of, basically, but that doesn't inspire hope for Saturday's bout vs. Raquel Rodriguez. It'd be totally crap if Raquel (who matches up well physically with Ripley) was thrown in the same camp as "underdogs" the Judgment Day brute has destroyed since winning the belt.

That'd be unnecessary, and it wouldn't even add anything to Payback's card.

WWE shouldn't get into a nasty habit of presenting Rhea as Goldberg circa 1998. She's far too skilled a worker for that sort of thing. Occasional squash matches are perfectly fine, but not against somebody the promotion still has high hopes for like Rodriguez. It's really important she looks competitive.

9. Austin Theory Goes Backwards

Whilst there have been definite shoots of recovery here or there, poor Austin Theory's obvious potential has been tailspinning out of control since he won Money In The Bank last year. Triple H doesn't seem nearly as high on him as Vince McMahon did, and now he's belt-less.

Advertisement

This is Theory's shot at meaningful change - going backwards and becoming United States Champion all over again would be rinse and repeat booking. He can't afford anymore of that treading water stuff at this stage. Rey Mysterio must hold onto that US gold and then creative can find something else for Austin to gun for.

This guy's pitch? Start presenting him a little closer to how he acts in real life. The man's actually really humble and loves wrestling, so it'd be cool to see him get a babyface run someday. Something has to give though, 'cause doing a 180 makes no sense at all.

None.

8. And Santos Escobar Is Responsible

Double whammy alert.

Advertisement

How sh*t would it be if Austin Theory became United States Champ again and Santos Escobar turned on Rey for the sake of it? Something doesn't feel right when Santos is gladly stepping aside so his mentor can scoop up all the glory and headlines. WWE would typically start a resentment story here.

Maybe that's the plan, which is fine. However, they shouldn't rush through it! Turning Escobar at Payback would be too hasty, and it'd burn through weeks (if not months) of storytelling on TV in just a few short PLE minutes. Besides, that LWO merch is probably still raking in the cash.

Mysterio is defo a temp placeholder for the US division rather than a long-term solution, but that doesn't mean for one second the writers need to scramble on Saturday. They 100% can't go backwards to Theory, and they must not trick themselves into thinking a Santos heel turn is needed.

7. Cody Rhodes Says Nothing Of Note

Cody Rhodes is typically very good at turning nothing promo segments into watchable moments. He successfully navigated some tricky spots on his own during that feud vs. Brock Lesnar, and the man knows how to manoeuvre his way through a skeleton script. He'll bloody have to at Payback.

Advertisement

WWE announcing that Cody will be on Grayson Waller's chat show bit, then scheduling that for a PLE, means people expect something pretty tasty here. It'd be rubbish if Waller trolled Rhodes, took a finish and that was that. Nah, there has to be some form of major announcement from Cody, and the whole thing should be short too.

If not, then why even book it for Payback in the first place? Pittsburgh will be raising eyebrows if this is something WWE could've kept back for Raw 48 hours later. Or, worse, they'll be booing the segment if it amounts to absolutely nothing.

Hmm. Fingers crossed, eh?

6. Trish Stratus Dumps Zoey Stark

This fan believes Lita will return to action at Payback and get some erm...payback on Trish Stratus for wrecking her Women's Tag Title run with Becky Lynch earlier in the year. That'd be logical, because it'd extend the Trish vs. Becky feud without requiring another singles match, and it'd give WWE a bumper tag match to promote elsewhere.

Advertisement

Alternatively, Lita could be absent, Lynch could beat Trish, and then the legend could dump Zoey Stark as her protege. Don't forget this article is all about the worst possible outcomes that could happen on WWE's next PLE! This, should it happen, would be a stinking misuse of talent.

Yuck.

Zoey has been thriving alongside Stratus, and she'd only suffer/get lost in the lower-card glut if she ventured out onto her own without some more seasoning. Sadly, there's a little voice back at the back of some fan minds that says this could be a possibility.

5. WWE Fudges LA Knight’s Rise

Alt subheading: "The Miz Beats LA Knight".

Advertisement

Look, Miz (as his entrance theme says) is awesome. His dress-up promo on Raw was TV gold, and he'll embrace the challenge of elevating somebody on behalf of management. He's selfless, over and damn good at his job. Let's hope creative doesn't ruin everything by backing the wrong horse.

Basically, Knight has to come out on top. He won that Battle Royal back at SummerSlam, and has made the most of everything thrown his way. Hell, LA even managed to further his storyline whilst remaining classy when paying tribute to Bray Wyatt on last week's episode of SmackDown, and that cannot have been easy.

Miz winning does nothing for WWE. People adore Knight, and they want to see him do well ASAP. This isn't the time for some slow burn 'does he have what it takes?!' narrative. Give LA wins, and give him them now. The Miz will be fine even if he loses every single match for the rest of 2023.

4. There’s An Unnecessary Bloodline Segment

Some folks wish The Bloodline drama was over. The chap writing this article isn't one of them, but he does appreciate that the story needs a breather for the first time in a long time. Jey Uso walked out on WWE, Jimmy Uso's own future is cloudy, and Roman Reigns is still the main man.

Advertisement

Let it breathe.

The worst thing Triple H could do is shove Paul Heyman out there in front of the Payback crowd to talk about everything that's been going on. That's what WWE's wonderfully-produced video packages are for. Don't use valuable PLE minutes to go over things fans already know.

Heyman getting chatty when he has nobody else to bounce off of would be lame. So, mind you, would Solo Sikoa being there to stand around looking menacing. Then, if Jey didn't show face, peeps watching the show would only be disappointed and question why it was even put on there at all.

3. Nakamura’s Challenge Falls Flat

This, unfortunately, will always be a worry.

Advertisement

WWE has been heating up then cooling Shinsuke Nakamura down for years now, but it says everything about how much respect wrestling fans have for the man that he's a fun challenger for Seth Rollins in 2023. Will that extend to a red hot atmosphere come bell time in PA?

That's a pertinent question, because few really think Nakamura is taking the World Heavyweight belt from Seth on Saturday night. Rollins being almost guaranteed to win will dampen excitement for this match then. Perhaps that's just the price WWE has to pay on these 'B' tier pay-per-views.

Creative blatantly fancies getting more than one PLE out of this rivalry, so they'd be sitting backstage head in hands if Pittsburgh's fanbase sat on its hands throughout the first chapter. It's really important that Shinsuke is greeted as a genuine threat to Rollins. Otherwise, this might be wrap on his World Title shots in WWE.

2. An Unwanted Tag Title Change

Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn have defended their Undisputed Tag-Team Titles five times on TV/PLE since winning them amidst much fanfare back at WrestleMania 39. The tag division hasn't quite exploded like many thought it would with them at the helm, but they're still super-over and everyone knows the match with Judgment Day at Payback will soar in-ring.

Advertisement

Finn Bálor and Damian Priest winning would suck though.

Oh yes, it's true. Judgment Day has carried a ton of Raw shows this year, but WWE don't need to awkwardly patch up Finn and Damian's fractured friendship by booking them to dethrone Sami and Kev. In fact, that'd be a mistake, and one that'd squash the chances of a fresh team getting the rub by taking those belts later on.

Priest is heading out of JD eventually. He has the MITB briefcase, a singles push in-waiting, and defo doesn't need some short tag title reign for the hell of it. Keep those straps exactly where they are.

1. Kurt Angle Ruins GUNTHER’s Reign?!

No need to rub your eyes. Shake your fist at the thought of this instead.

Advertisement

Payback is in Pittsburgh, and Chad Gable has long been compared to ‘Olympic Hero’ Kurt Angle. This surely won’t happen, but what a nightmare it is to think about WWE ending GUNTHER’s long Intercontinental Title reign right before he tops Honky Tonk Man’s record. Honestly, that sounds rotten.

The Imperium leader will be on 449 days come Payback, and Honky’s record is 454 days. Christ almighty, seeing him stare at the lights and give up that record-breaking distinction would be one of the worst swerves in modern wrestling history. A nice moment for Chad, sure, but no.

Angle is a fan of Gable though, and WWE might reason that having him there in PA makes sense. It's also worth pointing out that they haven't scheduled another Gable vs. GUNTHER bout for Payback just yet. There's still time. Start chewing those fingernails.

What other nightmares could come true at WWE Payback 2023? For more like this, check out 10 WCW Moments So Bad They’ll STILL Blow Your Mind and 10 New Directions For AEW After All In 2023!

Advertisement