WWE TLC 2020: Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best

A (mostly) strong showing for WWE's final 2020 event.

By Jack Pooley /

It's fair to say that WWE's December PPVs tend to invite low expectations - the holidays are just around the corner, and the talent are tired and looking forward to a brief break.

Advertisement

But with WWE's recent record-low Raw ratings, there was at least hope that WWE might come out swinging hard for the final show of 2020, and to be completely fair, this year's TLC show delivered above and beyond most reasonable expectations.

It was a decent card on paper albeit not one for fans to get hugely excited about, yet save for the ridiculous shambles of a main event, the show generally ranged from watchable to great.

The two TLC matches alone made the night worthwhile, there were some interesting title changes, and... an unconscious man got his entire body set on fire. How's that for adult content?

This isn't an event fans will be talking about for years and years, but it certainly overdelivered on the sensibly low standards most of us all have for WWE PPVs this time of the year...

7. Firefly Inferno Match: "The Fiend" Bray Wyatt Vs. Randy Orton

Result: Orton sets The Fiend on fire to win the match (12:00).

Advertisement

Rating: Nobody was expecting a great match from this, and it certainly wasn't, but it at least delivered a suitably loony spectacle for better or worse.

There's an obvious, unavoidable awkwardness to this match type that always makes it come off more than a little goofy, and that's really only exacerbated without a live audience, so they were smart to keep this pretty short.

Would it have been more entertaining as a cinematic match? Probably, but the sheer weirdness of watching an Inferno match in an empty arena surely speaks for itself.

To The Fiend's credit, he took those initial flames like a champ, and where else are you ever going to see a flaming RKO?

A bad match by any objective standard, but also mildly amusing schlock that committed harder to the insane danger of the gimmick than possibly any other Inferno-style match.

If you can't laugh at the demented absurdity of a Bray Wyatt mannequin getting set on fire to close out a WWE PPV, are you even a wrestling fan? 4/10

6. WWE Women's Tag Team Titles: Nia Jax & Shayna Baszler (c) Vs. Asuka & Charlotte Flair

Result: Charlotte takes Shayna out with Natural Selection to capture the titles (10:05).

Advertisement

Rating: As easy as it is to be mad about Lana missing out on the title win here, especially to only be replaced by Charlotte, Asuka becoming a double champion makes it forgivable enough.

Having Shayna eat the pin was pretty disappointing though for obvious reasons, and it's tough to get too excited about a thrown together tag team starting a reign that we all know won't last.

Still, the layout was pretty smart, keeping Nia's time in the ring short and letting Shayna do her thing.

It'll be understandably divisive among fans, though, who wanted it to deliver something else entirely and can't even feign excitement about Charlotte winning a title on her first night back. 5/10

5. Big E, Daniel Bryan, Chad Gable & Otis Vs. King Corbin, Sami Zayn, Cesaro & Shinsuke Nakamura

Result: Big E puts Sami away with the Big Ending for the win (8:35).

Advertisement

Rating: Beyond the inevitable "why are all these guys on the kickoff show?" complaints, this was a relatively fun match, even if it sadly didn't give most of the men a chance to do too much due to its brief length.

After a slightly sluggish start it quite sensibly devolved into a more frantic demolition derby, though ended just as it was gaining momentum.

This was just entertaining enough not to feel like a waste of everyone involved - especially during the exchange between Gable and Cesaro - but clearly needed more time to ensure everyone got their licks in.

Ultimately it's too harmless and inoffensive to get that bent out of shape about, though. 6/10

4. WWE SmackDown Women's Title: Sasha Banks (c) Vs. Carmella

Result: Banks makes Carmella tap to the Bank Statement to retain the strap (12:10).

Advertisement

Rating: Though everybody knew where this was going, Carmella gave one of her best in-ring performances ever here, coming off totally credible as a genuine threat against Sasha and showing how thoroughly she's improved over the years.

This was perfect for what it needed to be - fast-paced and not outstaying its welcome while making both competitors look strong.

It was always Banks' match to lose, but Carmella came off as hungry and tenacious, and at least we didn't get a cynical, lazy squash match. Ultimately, the real win here was that it probably gave some of Carmella's critics a moment for pause. 7/10

3. WWE Raw Tag Team Titles: The New Day (c) Vs. The Hurt Business

Result: Cedric kills Kofi with the Lumbar Check to win The Hurt Business the titles (10:00).

Advertisement

Rating: This was a whole lot of fun - Cedric continues to prove himself a major star in the making, and how can you not love Shelton capturing his first WWE tag team gold in 17 years?

It definitely could've gone a little longer and probably been all the better for it, but as a piece of storytelling and especially as a further evolution of Cedric's character, it absolutely killed.

It was fun, smartly laid out, and the right team won. If the two teams worked on their chemistry they're probably capable of a true classic in the future. 7/10

2. WWE Title - TLC Match: Drew McIntyre (c) Vs. AJ Styles Vs. The Miz

Result: Drew grabs the title to retain (27:05).

Advertisement

Rating: This was a terrific opener - a savage brawl between Drew and AJ which couldn't even be derailed by the totally unnecessary addition of The Miz.

Miz looked like an absolute geek with his botched cash-in, and it just confirms how devalued the men's Money in the Bank has become in recent years, but a Drew retain was most certainly the best outcome overall.

For the bulk this was brutal as hell, brilliantly tense, and absolutely earned its epic runtime while playing most of the TLC match hits fans enjoy. AJ bumped like hell throughout and came out looking just as strong as Drew.

Talk about setting a high bar for the rest of the night from the jump. 8/10

1. WWE Universal Title - TLC Match: Roman Reigns (c) Vs. Kevin Owens

Result: Roman grabs the title to retain (24:45).

Advertisement

Rating: This was a glorious car crash from first moment to last, which is exactly what it needed to be.

Even if you take away the unrelenting brutality of the match these two work so well together, to say nothing of the generally fantastic in-ring storytelling.

It bears repeating that WWE is spinning gold with Roman's run right now by booking him so expertly as a monster heel. Fingers crossed they stay the course for the foreseeable future.

To the same token Owens was the perfect underdog here, and the match was laid out so well to make an Owens victory seem like a genuine possibility.

This was one of the strongest TLC matches in recent years because it ticked all of the boxes - violence, drama, and smart character work. 8/10

Advertisement