10 New Year 2018 Resolutions Marvel Comics Should Make

New Year. New Marvel.

By Ewan Paterson /

Marvel Comics/Mark Brooks

You don't have to search far and wide to see that Marvel, for all their critical success, had a fairly infamous 2017. PR disaster after PR disaster eclipsed any comparative buzz that was making its way through the publisher's books, granting the impression that the year - already set to go down as one of the worst of our time - was unkind to the House of Ideas.

Advertisement

Secret Empires, creator controversies, retailer animosity, fan backlash - there were several of each to name this year alone. That's not good, especially not for a company like Marvel which, until recently, was largely bossing things when it came to just about every medium out there. DC have managed to pull ahead quite spectacularly just by f---ing up less than the competition, to speak nothing of the considerable quality the publisher boasts week in, week out.

But 2018 is a new year, and to repeat an old cliché, a 'New Marvel' can follow it. Marvel Legacy isn't dead yet, and while the year has already gotten off to a cracking start with yet another controversy, this time curtesy of the 'Create Your Own' initiative, things can still be turned around.

Advertisement

Sure, they'll have a few more resolutions than most, but if change is coming, 2018 could be the year Marvel bounce back.

10. Out With The Variants, In With Something Else

Marvel Comics

Variant covers are, for the most part, a neat little bonus. They add extra value to certain collections, give fans a chance to opt for another, well, cover, and shine a spotlight on certain artists. The problem for Marvel last year, however, was that they kind of overshadowed the books themselves, so much so that - prior to the release of Marvel Legacy - certain retailers opted to boycott the event altogether, owed to the company's insistence that they order even more comics to guarantee stores would get the variants themselves.

Advertisement

It was yet another controversy that Marvel could've avoided, but the strangest thing about Legacy's launch (apart from the fact the publisher managed to actually spoil their own reveal in an online preview), was that it felt out of touch. Fans just aren't that fussed on variant covers, and would much rather Marvel focussed on what's actually in their comics rather than what lies on the surface.

Legacy could've been Marvel's answer to DC Rebirth, but instead, the publisher opted to make variants the focus in the months leading up to its release. It's totally needless, and while variants continue to populate store shelves everywhere, they should be considered a bonus, rather than the crux of the entire platform itself.

Advertisement

It's not guaranteed that Marvel will force another rebrand of their comics going forward, but given the lukewarm reaction to the Legacy brand itself, don't be surprised if Marvel Now! redux makes an appearance.

9. Acknowledge Event Fatigue

Marvel Comics

Further to Marvel's fascination with Variants, it's equally true that fans aren't so keen on event comics, certainly not, when a new one comes around every year.

Advertisement

The 'event' this year was Secret Empire, Nick Spencer's story of a Nazified Steve Rogers creating and enforcing a totalitarian will on the world. That reveal (of Cap having been an Agent of Hydra), could be considered 2016's biggest hangover, and it certainly didn't help Marvel sell readers on the concept of another year of events, crossovers, tie-ins and the rest.

Since Civil War, Marvel have had an event in every year, going so far as to option and then produce a sequel to said event in 2016. DC have largely been the same, but a shift to self-contained narratives and smaller crossovers has typified their efforts in recent years, and it's worked - largely - to their benefit.

Advertisement

2018 should be the year Marvel wind back on their commitment to annualised event books. If they're looking to trap the same lightning DC did with Rebirth, it'd be wise to do so.

8. Stop Stumbling (And Creating) PR Disasters

Marvel Comics

With each month that passed us by last year, it often felt as though Marvel had a new controversy waiting in the wings.

Advertisement

Whether it be former Editor in Chief Axel Alonso downplaying the integral and amazing role the medium's artists have to play in selling books, or new EIC C. B. Cebulski offering a belated apology having defrauded the company years earlier by pretending to be a Japanese creator, nothing has gone according to plan for Marvel. Just this month, the terms and conditions for the new 'Create your Own' platform were dragged for stipulating that creators refrain from depicting 'alternate lifestyle advocacies', 'social issues' and other 'controversial topics', a fact made worse by the fact that Marvel had only just cancelled two of their main comics featuring LGBT* leads.

It's beyond tone-deaf, and emblematic of Marvel's apparent unwillingness to tackle the zeitgeist head on when it matters most. Given the publisher's roots, it's frankly embarrassing, and beyond frustrating for fans desperate to rekindle their interest in a universe that, for the last year at least, has failed to live up to its own legacy. Y'know, the one founded on Steve Rogers socking Adolf square on the jaw.

Advertisement

Marvel simply have to do better this year, and while the untimely cancellations of books like Hawkeye, America and Iceman have already ensured they've gotten off to a torrid start, there's still time to make amends.

7. Analyse The Real Reasons For Declining Sales

Marvel Comics

Ah, that old chestnut again.

Advertisement

Sales figures and the comics industry continue to vex as much as they do perplex, with articles every year prophesying the decline of the industry based on these very figures. 2017 was a tad different in that respect, as it wasn't only journalists and academics who commented on declining sales, but Marvel themselves too. The problem, however, was that the comments weren't really all that valuable at all, with David Gabriel having remarked in April that burgeoning efforts to diversify the Marvel Universe were somehow responsible for pushing readers away.

Apart from the fact that, y'know, he was wrong, it was yet another moment that defined Marvel's very inglorious 2017. Event fatigue, the price of books, and other such issues do, however, make the medium less accessible, and until Marvel alert to that fact, it'll be the same story this year as it was the last.

Advertisement

The industry needs a strong Marvel, but if things continue the way they are, we could be left with a very different landscape to the one we've had though all ages, Modern through to Bronze.

6. Stop Making Trade Collecting Difficult

Marvel Comics

Although the direct market illustrates that the bulk of the medium's readers buy comics on a weekly basis, reading as and when an issue releases, there's also a bunch of readers out there who wait for collected editions too. A typical trade paperback (or trade, for short), tends to encompass six-to-twelve issues from a given book's run, but there are also hardcovers, deluxe editions and omnibuses to contend with as well.

Advertisement

For the most part, both Marvel and DC have massively improved on their trade game. Classics are quick to return to print in some form, and the waiting time between an arc finishing and a TPB releasing has been cut drastically short. There's still some confusion though, and while Marvel were a tad late to the graphic novel scene, there's really no reason why they should be making things difficult in the new year.

With so many reboots around, things can get a little hectic for new readers. To cite an oft used example, if one were to approach Mark Waid's run on Daredevil (and you all really should), they'd have to contend with multiple 'first volumes' of the series, a problem exacerbated by the TPB format, omnibuses, and the fact the series was sandwiched in between two reboots in 'All-New, All Different Marvel' and 'Marvel Now!'.

Advertisement

Not so easy, right? Well, now Marvel are introducing Marvel Premiere Graphic Novel (not to be confused with Marvel Premier, or Marvel Premium), which will encompass digital comics launching on print for the first time for no other reason than to confuse us all even more.

Trades are the gateway into the medium for many fans. Make that hurdle easier to jump, and the industry will be stronger for it.

Advertisement

5. Be More Receptive To Criticism

Marvel Comics/Alex Ross

One of the defining features of comics discourse this last year was the apparent unwillingness on Marvel's behalf to accept and react to criticism, irrespective of its source.

Advertisement

This is a problem, because while yes, there are a vocal minority of fans out there who don't deserve the time of day at all, there are valid and important voices in the medium that deserve to be listened to. When Marvel are faced with criticism regarding their depiction of LGBT* characters, for instance, or even the relative lack of diversity on the page and off it within the company, the initial reaction from Marvel's influencers shouldn't be one of contempt or dismissal. Yet, for the better part of 2017, that's just what the reaction felt like, from Secret Empire, all the way up to the most recent set of comic cancellations.

It doesn't make for a healthy atmosphere at all, and Marvel would do well to alert to that fact and treat concerns from marginalised readers seriously, particularly when they themselves are also the target of abuse from an old-guard that's mobilised heavily across social media over the course of the last six months.

Advertisement

Platforms like Twitter have never really been conducive to meaningful conversation, but a wiser use of social media, combined with a concerted effort to listen to genuine fan concern, would make the milieu a considerably less toxic place to be in.

4. Make Marvel A Place Worth Staying For

By Gage Skidmore from Peoria, AZ, United States of America (Brian Michael Bendis) [CC BY-SA 2.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0)], via Wikimedia Commons

Brian Bendis' switch from Marvel to DC earlier this year was nothing short of incredible, and a move that pretty much no one saw coming. While we now know the writer packed his bags on account of his love for Superman, his departure was only the latest in a long line of big-name creators swapping the House of Ideas for something different.

Advertisement

Ed Brubaker, Rick Remender, Kelly Sue DeConnick and Matt Fraction are but some of the names that have left Marvel in recent years, and while the publisher still has a boat load of talented individuals in their ranks (and will no doubt have even more in the years to come), it should be a concern.

Of course, the superhero genre isn't for everyone, and it's only natural that these creators - incredibly talented that they are - would look for new challenges and creative outlets at some point. It's a natural part of the business, but this year, more than others, should be the year that Marvel makes everyone jealous. Give creators the license to do what they want, and make the creative process an enjoyable one for all concerned.

Advertisement

That, and stop cancelling everyone's favourite books. That'd be great.

3. Stop Spoiling Comics Before They've Released

Marvel Comics

While this resolution could go for DC as much as it could for Marvel, it is the latter who suffered the most from spoiling their comics in the press.

Advertisement

In the weeks leading up to the release of Marvel Legacy, the House of Mouse had been drumming up anticipation for a 'big' return. Someone, we were told, would come back from the dead with the 'heart and soul' of the Marvel Universe. What surprise there was to be had, however, was robbed when Marvel debuted the reveal to media outlets a whole day before the comic's release.

This followed on from when Secret Empire's ending was publicised in the New York Times shortly before its concluding release, so two of Marvel's most anticipated comics made their way online before fans actually had a chance to pick them up.

Advertisement

It's obvious that it's done to drum up hype, but all it ends up doing is disappoint readers who were patiently waiting for the actual comic to release. As a tactic to combat leaks, it does little, and probably makes things worse, actually. The spoilers for Legacy #1 were everywhere the day preceding its release, and while that book had more surprises to give, spoiling Logan's return was totally avoidable.

2. Bring Back The Fantastic Four

Marvel Comics

Chip Zdarksy and Jim Cheung's Marvel Two-in-One could very well be the gateway to realising the return of Marvel's first family, but, at the moment, fans are still waiting on that Fantastic return.

Advertisement

A consequence of Disney and Fox's feud over the on-screen rights to the FF, Reed, Sue, Johnny and Ben have absented the comics spotlight in recent years, but things could be set to change this year. Disney have just negotiated a mammoth takeover of 21st Century Fox and, irrespective of the many many worries that entails, it looks as though it's opened up a return for the Four on both the big and small screens.

Reuniting Johnny and Ben with Reed and Sue could've been the plan all along, but it would feel like a remarkable anticlimax if we weren't to get that reunion now, with the politics that stipulated the Four be placed in comics limbo having been made redundant by recent developments.

Advertisement

Only time will tell if Two-in-One paves the way for a Zdarksy and Cheung FF book, but if it does, then this year will already be a considerable improvement over the last. At least for Marvel.

1. Support Comics So They Can Develop An Audience

Marvel Comics/Marguerite Sauvage

By far the most frustrating thing about Marvel's year was how many fan-favourite books they ended up cancelling. Black Panther and the Crew only got two issues in before it was marked for cancellation, and both America and Hawkeye were cancelled a little over a year since their initial debuts. Irrespective of your thoughts on those titles, it's evident that Marvel aren't doing enough to support their own comics.

Advertisement

Marketing, at times, feels like an afterthought, and some books get no time at all to develop a following before they're pulled off shelves. Arguing that fans aren't doing enough to support them either (as has been the case recently), feels remarkably tactless, especially when - as previously mentioned - not all fans are able to support books right off the bat, instead preferring to wait for trades to release later in the year.

Marvel have the biggest potential audience for a comics publisher out there, and yet we're still waiting for them to capitalise on it fully. Comics aren't advertised on TV, film, or anywhere else (in fact it's the reverse, bizarrely, where TV shows and films are advertised in comics), and we've even seen creators themselves pick up the slack in the absence of real support.

Advertisement

Something has to change this year, and it's the kind of change that will only come with a concerted effort from top to bottom, at every level of the industry.

Do you have any resolutions in mind for Marvel? Be sure to let us know in the comments below!

Advertisement