10 Biggest Comics Controversies Of 2017

It's been hectic year for comics hot topics...

Rorschach Doomsday Clock
DC Comics

Like many entertainment industries, the comics one is not without its internal conflicts and slap-fights. Sometimes, these stories of harassment, bickering and worse, make it outside for the whole world to gawk over.

2017 saw a fair few of these, and in fact some of the biggest and most heated discussions around comics in some time, as with social media these controversies burst out into the public discussion much more frequently.

That is saying nothing of controversial comics and content in the medium itself, of which there are a few notable entries of course, from some of comics' biggest publishers.

Maybe you missed some (in which case, how)? Maybe you want a refresher? Or a chance to say 's**t, that was this year too?!'

Well, here are some of the most heated and controversial moments to rock comics in 2017.

10. G.I. Joe #7

GI Joe Cover
IDW

A minor furore was kicked up by a certain segment of fans over a homoerotic variant cover to this issue.

G.I.Joe #7 from IDW Publishing featured a variant cover from Wuvable Oaf's Ed Luce, which included the Dreadnoks in a somewhat compromising position. The cover art is homoerotic, which is something both nice to see in a traditionally masculine property and amusing for a property which, strictly speaking, has had more than a bit of queer fun poked at the concept over the years.

The cover was fun and different, but as you sadly may imagine, caused a stir among a certain segment of comics and G.I. Joe fandom, and saw many using it to add onto the already swirling criticisms of series writer Aubrey Sitterson.

Much of this was co-opted by a distinct group of anti-diversity fans who model a lot of their tactics after GamerGate. Unfortunately, their continual harassment may have won them a victory in the end, as Sitterson departed the project but a few short months ago.


9. DC New Age Of Heroes

New Age of DC Heroes Batman Superman
DC Comics

A fairly small one that is on the rise now, but it has been noted that the upcoming DC New Age of Heroes that follows event Dark Knights: Metal is a bit of a sausagefest.

When DC first announced the upcoming New Age of Heroes, with their Master Class of artists, it was originally noted how the 'class' were all men. Consisting of artists that the publisher considered the top-tier A-list talent on their books, it was a glaring notion that this selection missed a fairly obvious element of diversity.

Going into the growing New Age of Heroes announcements, and especially after a second wave of titles were announced, it continues to be the case that no women are involved in the project, at least out of the named and marketed creators.

It's unusual, as it is not as though DC is lacking in female creators that could have been included: notably Gail Simone and Amanda Conner could have been part of it, just off the top of our heads.

Of course, it could be that DC will make more announcements in the months to come that may include some actual female creators, but for now it's looking a bit of a boys club.


8. Marvel's Legacy Variants

Marvel Legacy
Marvel Comics

As part of a line-wide refresh after the end of their controversial Secret Empire event, Marvel launched Marvel Legacy, which was set to include a wave of lenticular covers upon its release (because that's the thing you do with comics these days it seems).

However, these covers caused quite a stir with retailers. Variants, as a marketing technique, often rely on retailers ordering specific numbers of an issue in order to qualify for the variant cover fans will seek out. The sticking point here, however, was that Marvel requested retailers to order upwards of an extra 100% (or even 200%), of their regular orders of an issue to get the lenticular covers.

To say such numbers are prohibitive is putting it mildly.

Naturally, many retailers began to voice their concerns, and some even refused to stock the lenticular covers in protest.

Obviously, this was definitely not the kind of talk Marvel wanted surrounding their refresh, certainly not, after a year of troubling image and PR issues for the publisher.


7. Doomsday Clock

Doomsday Clock 1 Watchmen Rorschach
DC Comics

You might think this is a huge controversy - and maybe it should be - but it just didn't blow up as big as some other events this year, even though it maybe should have.

It's plain that Doomsday Clock was one of the most talked about comic projects of the whole year, and for the most part that discussion has been positive. Even those concerned at the notion of a sequel to the classic Watchmen comic ultimately circled around the discussion of whether Watchmen 'needs' a sequel.

However, one element of the comic's publication is particularly troubling: the fact that it is yet another example of DC using the Watchmen concept and characters against the original creators wishes.

Without going into great detail, Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons' work on Watchmen was originally agreed to on a contract that would revert the rights to the characters back to the creators around a year after the last printing of the title. The problem, however, is that DC has never ended printing of Watchmen.

Moore has always been against the continued use, and while Gibbons has been more open in the past, he only found out about Doomsday Clock plans at NYCC, from a comics news site.

In the end, Doomsday Clock does also stand as an example of the creators rights or wishes being ignored, and it is a dark shadow on what could be a huge project.


6. Howard Chaykin's Divided States Of Hysteria

Divided States of Hysteria
Image Comics

This series caused controversy twice in pretty quick succession earlier this year.

Howard Chaykin's creator owned work, The Divided States of Hysteria, was published by Image Comics and immediately caused a stir.

Containing yet another example of a trans character facing extreme sexual violence, something which Chaykin has a history of including in his work too, Image saw a great deal of online backlash for the fact that such content had been wrapped in one of their Pride Month variants. Many took issue with the fact that this damaging media trope of trans representation had the audacity to be wrapped within a cover purporting to show Image's commitment to LGBTQ rights and history.

However, Image stood its ground and behind Chaykin, using Chaykin's own essay on the comic (that was printed within the first issue anyway) as a statement on the backlash, and stating that they do not believe in censorship.

However, mere weeks later, Chaykin and the comic became a hot topic of conversation again, as solicits showed the then future cover for the series' third issue, which featured a person of colour lynched and castrated in the street with a racial slur daubed over his body.

This time, the backlash was louder than ever, and ultimately saw Image releasing what it called a 'joint' apology between themselves and Chaykin and the decision to change the cover.

However, in an interview with a site days later, Chaykin revealed that he was not part of this apology, and in fact felt he had nothing to apologise for at all, and suggested that the critics, fans and fellow creators speaking out were being shrill alarmists and more, ultimately offending a swathe of people.


5. IDW Publishing Listen To Angry Trolls

GI Joe Strike Force
IDW

IDW Publishing cancelled G.I. Joe spin-off Scarlett's Strike Force, claiming low sales before the final order cut-off date. But many have called B.S. on this excuse.

As mentioned earlier, G. I. Joe writer Aubrey Sitterson, who was also announced as the writer of this spin off title, came under fire from a segment of G.I. Joe and comics fandom that had taken a hardline, far-right stance on the creator and his push for adding diversity to the franchise.

When Sitterson made comments after September 11th this year that some found controversial, regarding a difference between genuine and false remembrance and respect for loss, this anti-diversity crowd leaped on it as an excuse to demand the writer's head on a platter from IDW Publishing, threatening boycotts.

After a few months, during which time IDW Publishing barely promoted the project outside of it's announcement, the publisher announced that they were cancelling the series after the third issue, leaving it in a considerable cliffhanger according to the writer, due to what it claimed were poor sales.

However, the final order cut off hadn't even been reached yet for retailers, and the first issue hadn't even hit shelves, so Image's reasoning sounds almost disingenuous. Added to this, in an interview with Bleeding Cool, Sitterson went into how he'd been effectively kept from talking about the situation or the books by IDW Publishing. At time of writing, Sitterson has no other titles planned with IDW.

To many, it looks as though IDW Publishing caved to a small, but highly vocal, segment of fandom that regularly employs serial harassment, exploitative hyperbole and vitriol via social media and YouTube videos.


4. C.B. Cebulski Pretended To Be Japanese

Wolverine Akira Yoshida
Marvel Comics

The new Marvel Editor-in-Chief started his first day in the position by sparking a new controversy for the beleaguered publisher.

Marvel somewhat surprised everyone when it announced the departure of Axel Alonso and his replacement C.B. Cebulski, a long time employee of the company. However, the surprises kept coming, with a revelation on Cebulski's very first day in the new role.

The truth came out about a rumour that had been circling the EIC for some time: in the early-2000s, Cebulski used a pseudonym in order to write for Marvel, while also working as an editor at the publisher. Now, while that may seem a little dodgy, especially given Marvel's rules at the time against editors writing books, that wasn't the most controversial part of it.

The pseudonym wasn't just a name, but a whole identity created... an identity named Akira Yoshida.

As you may note, Cebulski is not Japanese at all, however the Yoshida identity was sold as a Japanese writer of manga and Western comics, as a prime example of Marvel's commitment to diversity, and had even had editors claiming to have met him in person (who it would turn out was another Japanese man entirely who they had misidentified, somehow, as 'Yoshida').

While Cebulski is a lover of all things Japanese and Asian, and has lived there for a great deal of time, and even speaks Japanese fluently, he is not himself Japanese, and many saw his pretending to be tantamount to appropriation.

Moreover, Marvel knew about it months back, had reprimanded behind the scenes, but still ultimately raised him to Editor in Chief.


3. Marvel Suggest Diversity Was The Cause Of Poor Sales

Marvel Now 2016
Marvel Comics

Marvel's VP of Sales, David Gabriel, caused a stir when it was revealed from a meeting with the retailers that the publisher seemed to put the blame on declining sales on the introduction of a raft of diverse characters.

At a Retailers Summit reported on by ICv2, Gabriel stated:

“What we heard was that people didn’t want any more diversity. They didn’t want female characters out there. That’s what we heard, whether we believe that or not.”

While he did go on to elaborate as to whether they should believe that, many took that as to mean Marvel saw the fall in sales as being down to the greater inclusion of female and diverse characters.

Naturally, such a conclusion would be drastically reductive given other factors such as fan event fatigue, exploitative variant cover incentives and maybe even looking at other elements of the content of their publications.

Many took issue with such a statement, and it painted Marvel in a poor light, given the controversies yet to come.


2. Secret Empire

Captain America Hydra Secret Empire
Marvel Comics

Marvel's major event of 2017 was a hive of controversy for events both within the comic and surrounding it.

Secret Empire told the story of Captain America, now revealed as a secret Hydra spy the whole time, making his move and conquering America for a group that many see as the Nazis of the Marvel Universe.

Marvel of course didn't want people to see that, trying to argue that Hydra were not Nazis and that Captain America as such wasn't either. However, on taking control of the US, Steve Rogers is seen to institute reeducation centres, book burning, increased surveillance, bombing attacks within the nation's borders and even internment camps.

The fan outcry to this plot line, recasting a hero created by Jewish men as, yes, a Nazi, was loud, ranging from sensible, concerned criticisms all the way to death threats to the story creator, Nick Spencer, who responded to all kinds of criticisms with the same attitude.

Marvel came under constant fire with each issue and element of the story that became revealed, just as imagery from the comic was co-opted by the alt-right and neo-Nazis within the real world America, who now felt that Captain America was theirs.

Ultimately, Secret Empire may have sold well in comics, but it didn't do so well in good will with critics and fans.


1. Eddie Berganza

Eddie Berganza DC
DC

After almost a decade of knowledge of his actions, DC finally let the controversial editor go after allegations of sexual misconduct made mainstream news as part of a wave of public scrutiny directed towards the entertainment industry.

Eddie Berganza spent many years at DC as an editor and Group Editor, in charge of overseeing one of the publisher's most iconic characters, the forebear of all superhero comics, Superman himself. However, it had been an element of common knowledge within the industry that Berganza was another thing too: an alleged sexual harasser.

Finally, after continuing in employment with DC for so long despite complaints made within the publisher, and even seeing himself promoted over time, Berganza's alleged misconduct was exposed by Buzzfeed, in the midst of the wave of sexual harassment revelations sweeping through the wider entertainment industry.

Now receiving mainstream attention, it caused DC to take greater action than it ever had before, initially suspending Berganza before ultimately letting him go entirely.

For many, it was a move that had taken far too long to come, and for some, too little, too late. Ultimately, it was something DC should have corrected a long time ago.


Contributor
Contributor

Joe is a comic book writer out of South Wales, writing LGBTQ+ superhero series The Pride and also co-writing Welsh horror comedy series, Stiffs. He's also a comics reporter and reviewer who works with Bleeding Cool and now WhatCulture too. So he makes comics and talks about comics, but there's more to him too. Somewhere.