The Dark Knight has a lot of secrets his handlers at DC would rather stay buried. He's kind of a jerk, he's had his ups and downs, and he's pretty much a wholesale rip-off of another pulp character from the thirties. In fact the only other character in comics who might have him beat for embarrassing skeletons in the closet may just be his sidekick. Robin The Boy Wonder, Batman's erstwhile sidekick, has been around for nearly as long as his mentor and has managed to accumulate his own admirable collection of awful clandestine milestones. Right now the weird history of the prototypical sidekick is being delved into with the Robin Rises storyline, where Batman tries to figure out what the deal is with his clone son Damian, previously presumed dead but now somehow not? And what's going on with Dick Grayson, the original Boy Wonder, who also appears to be dead? Comixology have currently got a Robin 101 sale going on to help get you up to speed with the character's history, but even with all that, you won't be getting the full story. What are the parts of Robin that remain unexplored (oo-er)? What are the aspects of the Boy Wonder which have been left back in the mists of time, abandoned like an injured soldier dragging the rest of the squad down? Why did anybody think it was appropriate for a kid sidekick to flounce around in hot pants and green booties? We will go over all this and more amongst our ten things DC wants you to forget about Robin.
10. His Movie Incarnations
The Boy Wonder has a tricky relationship with the big screen. Burt Ward's sidekick from the campy sixties TV show is about as good as we've gotten with movie Robins so far, with the other two proper depictions leaving a little to be desired. Chris O'Donnell had the distinct misfortune of playing Batman's second-in-command for his war on crime for the Joel Schumacher films, which took the gothic weirdness of Tim Burton's first two Dark Knight flicks and turned them into a cringy pop art mess of wildly contrasting tones. And bat nipples, which have become a cultural meme all their own, separate from the cinematic abominations which sired them. In Batman Forever and Batman & Robin Dick Grayson appears as a grown up, which on the one hand makes his adoption by Bruce Wayne less weird (not got a thing for training kids up to be vigilantes) and also a lot weirder (why does an adult need to be adopted). Also he uses martial arts to sort out the laundry, which is really stupid. The only thing worse than that would be if you'd promised not to introduce Robin in your films, only to do so with a twist ending about a character's real name which is really, really stupid. It's also what Christopher Nolan did with the reveal that Detective John Blake, played by Joseph Gordon Levitt in the Dark Knight Rises, was actually called Robin. Neither version has really informed the comic book character. Which is good, because it would be hella creepy if Damian Wayne's nipples were visible through his costume. In fact we would be surprised if we saw Robin in a film again for a while, however, which might change things; he was noticeably absent from the Burton films, and thus didn't appear in the comics for a spell. He doesn't look to be part of Superman V Batman: Dawn Of Justice, either, which would suit the current absence of a sidekick in the Batman books.
9. The Existence Of Stephanie Brown
Poor old Stephanie Brown. For our money she was victim of one of the most tragic deaths in the history of DC Comics, and yet so many people don't even know who she is - let alone that she was once a Robin. Stephanie debuted in 1992 as an amateur crime-fighter called Spoiler, daughter of B-list Batman bad guy the Cluemaster who went out of her way to muck up her dad's villainous plans. Hence the name! Spoiler, see? He was in prison for most her childhood and came out claiming to be reformed, only for her to stumble across his evil activities and furiously put a stop to them. That's some strong crime fighting motivations right there. No being orphaned by a mugger, but we can't all be so lucky. After that storyline wrapped up Stephanie was kept on as a supporting cast member in the Robin solo book, where she was an on-again, off-again love interest for the Tim Drake incarnation of the Boy Wonder. She even had a pregnancy scare one time which was...interesting. Anyway, despite that she soon became a fan favourite, to the point that slotting her into the Batman sidekick role once Tim abandoned it made perfect sense. To everyone apart from DC, anyway. Stephanie was made Robin for all of two issues before being killed off in the controversial War Games storyline. People were pretty peeved she had lasted for such a short time in the role, and were even more furious when Batman didn't honour her with a costume in the Bat Cave, in the same way he did with past Robins Jason Todd and Dick Grayson. They nearly forgot to put her on that Comixology list and all. Stephanie has since been resurrected but her brief period as the Boy Wonder has been totally expunged from history. Which sucks.
8. And Tim Drake, For That Matter
Tim Drake hasn't fared all that much better either, to be honest. The third official Robin took over after a period where Bruce Wayne simply didn't have a ward, grief-stricken after the death of second sidekick Jason Todd and deciding that maybe child soldiers weren't the answer to Gotham City's crime problem. He got won back around to the idea when the precocious Tim turned up, a whip-smart kid who had been in the audience when Dick Grayson's trapeze artist parents were killed and whose knowledge of the Flying Graysons lead to him figuring out Batman and Robin's secret identities. When he was a nine-year-old. Yeah, Tim Drake is pretty cool. Where Jason Todd had been roundly rejected by readers, Tim Drake was welcomed with open arms, his connection to Dick and his detecting proficiency helping things considerably. He stayed in the role for a good twenty years, he was so good at it, only adapting his codename into the cool-sounding Red Robin - which also saddled him an awful costume - following the deaths of his dad, BFF Superboy and disappearance of Bruce Wayne. He needed a little time off, understandably, but the assumption is he'd return at some point. Instead Bruce's long lost kid Damian turned up and became the new Boy Wonder, with Tim keeping the Red Robin title. Except then the New 52 happened and everything got kinda confusing. DC's huge continuity reboot wiped away a load of their 70+ year history, but it's still not totally clear what is still considered "canon" and what isn't. One of the things we are sure about is that, in the condensed history of this relaunched Batman, he's only had time for a couple of sidekicks - and Tim Drake ain't one of them. Hence he's always been Red Robin, for some reason, effectively removing a couple of decades of ace Robin stories starring him.
7. A Death In The Family
Still, that's nothing compared to what Jason Todd had to go through. We've danced around it a little but the second Robin was the most divisive, and ultimately, the most tragic. When Dick Grayson graduated from the role of sidekick to Nightwing, masked vigilante in his own right, somebody else needed to step up to the plate. When he was first introduced young Jason wasn't much more than an off-brand Dick Grayson, with the same cheerful demeanour and slavish devotion to Batman's arbitrary rules for crime fighting...except with ginger hair. Which he soon dyed black, cementing his place as the second Robin in the eyes of the readers. Then Crisis Of Infinite Earths happened and, like so many of DC's company-wide events since, it completely messed things up. After the multiverse had been destroyed and put back together Jason Todd was reintroduced as an entirely different kind of character: cocky, annoying, mouthy, insubordinate. Yeah, he wasn't very popular compared to his predecessor. So unpopular, in fact, that when DC put together a call-in poll for fans to decide whether or not he got murdered by The Joker in an upcoming storyline called A Death In The Family. A title which rather precluded the point of having a vote, but readers nonetheless chose to have the second Robin killed off ASAFP. For a long while he remained one of the few comic book characters not to rise from the dead...right up until some more universal mumbo jumbo happened in Infinite Crisis and he was brought back as the annoyed adult anti-hero the Red Hood, a violent vigilante at odds with his former mentor once more. Thanks to the New 52 time compression thing his time as Robin was shortened and rarely referred to in favour of him just being a crazy anti-hero.
6. Those Old Costumes
Let's look at this objectively: a middle-aged rich guy adopts a succession of orphaned children and, amongst other things, dresses them up in a series of terrible costumes. Sounds pretty weird, right? That's exactly what Batman has done with all of the Robins, starting as he meant to go on with Dick Grayson by handing over an outfit that included a big yellow cape, a red top, a domino mask, then some bright green gloves, booties and scaly hot pants. Not only is that a fashion disaster in itself - who on Earth though those colours would go together? This is how things were in the days before Gok Wan - but also it's a 12-year-old running around in his underwear. Which is very much Not Okay. Thankfully things have gotten better since then. Except Jason Todd also wore the same costume, which meant that even in the seventies and eighties DC editorial thought that it was an acceptable costume for a kid to wear. It doesn't really make any sense as an outfit for a crimefighter to wear, either, especially when Batman's whole deal is that he operates from the shadows, jumping out of the darkness and frightening thugs as much as incapacitating them with punches, kicks and novelty boomerangs. Bright red, green and yellow isn't the stealthiest of colour schemes. Since then the outfit has had something of an overhaul. Tim Drake's Robin actually got to wear a full set of tights, and the yellow was much less emphasised. Where Dick and Jason had the fighting skills Tim hewed closer to Batman's detective skills, so the shades of his costume were a little duller, all the better to sneak around in. Then his time as Robin was retconned, and Damian got that costume instead, and now he's dead, so basically there's no evidence of those terrible get-ups in the current comic books. Also, we doubt that domino mask would conceal your identity from ANYONE.
5. Batman Is Kinda Creepy
Not that the clothes he dresses the Robins up in is the only part of his behaviour towards them that is a little suspect. In fact we're hard pressed to identify an aspect of Batman's obsession with scooping up orphans and forcing them to be his best mates (he's totally Michael Scott in that respect) that isn't deeply odd, and yet it continues apace, 75 years into the character's history. On a basic level, we're not sure while Child Services is still allowing Bruce Wayne take away these kids whenever he pleases - especially when a worrying amount of them end up dying. Or sustaining serious injuries on a regular basis, at least. Yes, yes, technically he's the "ward" of the various Robins, but y'know. Potato, tomato. There's a whole lot of other things too, however. We can see why Batman instantly gravitates towards exceptional children with tragedy in their pasts, because that's exactly what he is. He sees something of himself in all of the Robins, to the point that his projections make him into something of a pushy stage parent, living vicariously through Dick, Jason, Tim and Damian by training them up to become the same lethal, genius superhero detectives that he is. And you thought you had it tough when your parents forced you to stay in and revise for your GCSEs. Bruce Wayne is working out some of his many, many issues pertaining to his lost parents and his own lost childhood, in a dodgy sort of Michael Jackson fashion. Not only does DC not want fans to acknowledge how weird all of this is but nobody within the stories themselves bat an eyelid either. Alfred thinks it's cool, Dick's fine with seeing others take his place, and Commissioner Gordon hasn't once questioned why this flying rodent vigilante is always hanging around with kids. What's up with that?
4. Okay, The Gay Stuff
We've been dancing around this one, too, because it's really been done to death at this point. Yes, it is weird that Batman always hangs around with kids that are like him. Yes, it's especially weird when he dresses them up in skin-tight clothes and hot pants. Yes, we did just compare him to Michael Jackson. Jokes about a romantic relationship between the Caped Crusader and his underage male partner have been made since time immemorial, despite the fact that they're decidedly un-PC and a lot creepier than any perceived subtext within the comics themselves. That said, whilst we're still making jokes about it to this day, there was a time when the implication of impropriety between the two superheroes was taken a lot more seriously. The origin of these serious business allegations was one Fredric Wertham, MD, a complete hack and total quack who nonetheless boasted a vendetta against the then-new fad for superhero comics and the credentials for a large portion of the US to take his opinions on them seriously. Wertham wrote a whole book on the way that this four-colour menace was warping the brains of the nation's children, with the explicitly violent and sexual comics produced by publishers like EC coming under fire. 1954's Seduction Of The Innocent fingered an even more insidious comic book as the principal culprit for the perceived rise in juvenile delinquency, mind. It was the unconventional relationship between Batman and Robin that Wertham suggested would turn young boys into raging homosexuals, picking up on the "hidden messages" in their adventures. The book was so popular that DC radically changed the way the characters were handled, introducing female love interests Batwoman and Batgirl for the characters. So you're unlikely to see any modern examples of the "secret" gay romance between the Dark Knight and the Boy Wonder, but you will still see Batwoman and Batgirl, so...yay?
3. Other Weird Sex Things
Worryingly, those aren't the only examples of sexual impropriety happening in a Batman comic. His young sidekicks have a habit of getting involved in actual dodgy relationships that appear on the page, and not just within the twisted mind of a failed child psychologist looking for things that aren't there. Weirdly they usually involved Dick Grayson, too, which might be because of his hilarious phallic first name and is rather at odds with his original appearance. As an actual child. Wearing green hot pants. Look, we really can't emphasise enough how weird the green hot pants are, all right? The biggest - and worst - example of this came in the pages of Nightwing #93-95, where the former Robin has an, ahem, interesting encounter with fellow vigilante Tarantula. In fact Dick decides to follow in the footsteps of his former mentor, taking all the lessons he learned under the tutelage of Batman and applying them to Tarantula, the new kid on the block he needs a few pointers when it comes to crime fighting. Eager to impress him, she goes off to take down bad guy Copperhead all by herself, only to get the crap beaten out of her. Which is the moment she falls in love with Nightwing. Unfortunately for her, he doesn't feel the same way, and her feelings are never reciprocated. That is until the end of the story arc where, after getting his own ass handed to him and laying bruised and battered in the middle of the street, Tarantul decides to take advantage of the incapacitated object of her affection by shagging him there and then. Totally non-consensually. The story was so controversial that it was instantly retconned, and nobody ever spoke of it again. Except everybody who read it, realised it was totally messed up, and still tell people of it to this day.
2. Batman Was Robin Once
We're still running hot and cold on that new Gotham TV show that's soon to debut on Fox. The idea of a Batman prequel, chronicling what the city's police department were up to prior to them shifting most of their workload onto the shoulders of a mentally deranged billionaire, is kinda intriguing. Seeing how Jim Gordon climbed through the ranks to the position of Commissioner - and grew that sweet moustache - is certainly something we'd like to see more of, after enjoying the little tease of it in Frank Miller and David Mazzucchelli's iconic Year One comic book miniseries. What we're less enthused about is how big a part Bruce Wayne seems to be playing in the series. Obviously he's going to be in it a bit, since it's a Batman show and all, but how much do you really want to see of the Dark Knight as a whiny, annoying sprog? Wouldn't that ruin the character a little? Where, there is a precedent for it, in the form of the 2000 storyline Sins Of Youth. This Young Justice crossover event saw old, obscure character (soon getting a revival, actually) Klarion The Witch Boy casting a spell that made all of the universe's adults become kids, and kids into adults. Which meant that Bruce Wayne got turned into a kid, and Tim Drake an adult. Which meant that, for a little while anyway, Bruce Wayne was Robin. That's a rather peculiar turn of events. The actual build up to this big change is too complicated/stupid for us to go into here, but rest assured it made for some strange moments, as Bruce still asserted dominance over his ward and yet was technically his sidekick. It all got ironed out rather sharpish but we still got treated to one issue of Batboy and Robin which, so far as we can tell, has never been collected or republished.
1. Plus One Day One Will Replace Him
He may have lived to reach the grand old age of 75, but even Bruce Wayne knows that he won't live forever. He even realises that he can't quite do his job properly at the height of his powers, briefly franchising out his superhero identity to vigilantes around the world in the Batman Incorporated storyline. Before we got there, however, there have been a handful of storylines involving who will take up the cowl when he finally does shuffle off of his mortal coil. There was a whole storyline called Battle For The Cowl, in fact, where various factions fought to take control of his title, and it's pretty telling that the majority of those seeking to take his place (when Bruce Wayne was missing, presumed dead, actually sent back in time to the prehistoric era) were former Robins. In the end it was Dick Grayson, his original sidekick that became the new Batman. He didn't do half bad, either, bringing his natural grace and fluidity in combat, detective training from his mentor and his own much more sunny attitude to the role. Tim Drake actually did a pretty good job - under the circumstances - during the Sins Of Youth storyline, too, and although he's keen we're not sure how well Jason Todd would do if he ever took over as the Caped Crusader. One of the possible futures we saw for Gotham City in the comic books was that Damian Wayne may one take over the Bat-Mantle, as seen in a flashforward storyline around the time of that cowl battle thing. In what we can probably accurately describe as a dystopia, the future of Gotham City doesn't seem all that better than the present. Just bigger and shinier. We're not sure if this is canon, what with Damian currently being deceased and all (plus the introduction of Terry McGinnis, the Batman Of The Future from the animated series, into the DC comic book continuity), but this part of Grant Morrison's epic Dark Knight run seems to provide conclusive proof this Robin will one day become Batman. Except now he's dead, Dick Grayson is off being a spy and nobody knows he's alive, Jason Todd is a lunatic, Tim Drake has become Teen Titan Red Robin and seems to have a lower opinion of his mentor recently, Stephanie Brown is Batgirl...despite all the evidence to the contrary, and these examples of times his sidekicks did replace him, recently it seems like DC are insisting Bruce Wayne will remain the one, true Batman forever more. Even when he's farting around with a zimmer frame.