Gotham: 11 Key Things We Know So Far

Na, na, na, na, na, na... Gordon?

The announcement of a Batman TV show as first met with excitement - THE CAPED CRUSADER ON OUR SCREENS EVERY WEEK? AND WITH NARY AN OUNCE OF CAMP? - and then bemusement - Wait, Batman's not in it? - and has since sort of wobbled back and forth between the two like a DC-branded Weeble, with every bit of casting and plot news pored over in the way only we nerds can. It certainly an intriguing premise, and considering how popular DC series have been when adapted for TV (besides the shockingly long-running Smallville, the recent success of Arrow has also prompted a Flash show to enter development), it could be pretty darn good. For the most part Gotham is still an unknown quantity, but here's what we do know so far. With some...minor speculation. I told you, I'm a nerd. And I'm sure you are too.

11. It's Not A Batman Show

Which is probably the most important thing we've learned so far. Whilst the titular city is synonymous with the Caped Crusader, we're not going to be seeing him in this show. It's Gotham pre-Batman, which means no spandex, secret underground lair or signals of any kind. It also means that the show is going to be a much more grounded take on the setting, even more so than Christopher Nolan's celebrated Dark Knight trilogy. Those films tried to make superheroes and villains work in a real world setting. From the looks of it, this series aims to make Gotham into a real world setting. Of course, there was still plenty going on in there before Batman donned his cowl and started to punch evil-doers in the face before driving away in a souped-up sportscar. In fact, it's the reason he started doing the whole cowl/punch/drive routine in the first place. We haven't really ever gotten a good look at what the crime-infested streets of Gotham were like before Bats started to clear it up; how did organised crime infiltrate the Gotham City Police, and who was trying to stop it? What sort of bad stuff was going down before there were Penguins and Catwomen and nutters in clown make-up conducting most of it? Well, maybe we'll find out!

10. Although Bruce Wayne's In It

Well, I say Batman's not in it. He sort of is. David Mazouz will be playing a young Bruce Wayne, and the scuttlebut is the first episode of Gotham will revolve around (spoiler alert!) the murder of his parents. From the looks of things he'll be sticking around afterwards, as the "serious and soulful" orphan looks to Detective James Gordon and the Wayne family butler, Alfred Pennyworth, for guidance and protection for all the aforementioned awfulness of the city he grows up in. Again it's not something we've seen much of before, save for the occasional flashback scene in films and comics - usually the one where Kid Bruce accidentally stumbles upon the structurally-worrying catacombs beneath Wayne Manor that later become the Batcave - so there could be something interesting in here. No doubt the writers will put in enough lame meta-jokes about the kid's superheroic future, but it'll be cool to see the seeds of The Man Who Would Be Bats being planted early on. Mazouz looks to be a cut above your average child actor, too, with an enviable CV of film and TV work, including a lead role in the Kiefer Sutherland series Touch. Which got cancelled, but that probably wasn't his fault. He is only a kid, after all.

9. And Alfred (As A Badass)

Speaking of Alfred Pennyworth, the casting of the gruff, tough Sean Pertwee in a role that has previously been essayed by the likes of Michael Caine and Michael Gough as a stereotypically well-mannered English gentleman has definitely turned heads. Where previous Alfreds have been utterly butlery, for lack of a better word, Pertwee's version of the character is reportedly a former MI6 agent who still knows how to handle himself. Now this is something that we have seen before: in Grant Morrison's recent virtuoso run of Batman comic books and his controversial appearance in the recent animated series Beware The Batman, where he appeared in promo materials dual wielding pistols with a bodybuilder's physique rippling beneath his three-piece suit and bowler hat. Pertwee's character doesn't appear to be going that far, but we will be getting a hard-bitten version of the Wayne family butler who's believable as a resident of the crime-ridden Gotham.

8. It's Jim Gordon's Show

This is probably the most important point, so sorry for burying the lede a little. Probably the most reassuring piece of news we got about Gotham was that, in putting aside Batman's story for now, the show would be focussing on Commissioner James Gordon in his earlier, Detective days. Not only that but Gordon is going to be played by Ben McKenzie, best known as Ryan from The OC (which is experience enough in my book, since anybody who's experienced multiple Chrismukkahs is more than ready to deal with anything Gotham City can throw at him). Maybe more relevant, however, is McKenzie's recent starring role in cop drama Southland, for which he won plenty of critical acclaim. He could be just the right guy to show us what Jim Gordon was like when he first arrived in Gotham City, before he'd worked his way up to Commissioner. And before he'd grown a moustache. Gordon has long been one of the most engaging supporting characters in the Batman universe, with noted thespian Gary Oldman taking the part in the Nolan films and his being a big part of the 90s animated series and iconic comic book storylines like No Man's Land, The Killing Joke and Year One.

7. With Some Great Source Material

In fact Year One may have a big role to play in how Gotham turns out. Ben McKenzie recently tweeted out a photo of the reading material he has to get through as he gets into the role of Detective Jim Gordon. Not only did it include Frank Miller and David Mazzucchelli's classic story of both Batman and Gordon's first year trying to clean up the streets of Gotham, but McKenzie has also been way through collected editions of The Long Halloween, Dark Victory, Earth One and the massively underrated Gotham Central series. This is mighty reassuring. Gotham may be charting new ground in a lot of places, but it's also got a wealth of source material to draw from, and from the looks of it they're cherry picking some of the best. Besides Year One, the Jeph Loeb/Tim Sale double-bill of The Long Halloween and Dark Victory are a couple of the best stories to include Gotham's non-costumed crime fighters and criminals alike, and Earth One is an alternate-reality take on the familiar Batman story that the Gotham City Police Department play a large part in. Gotham Central, meanwhile, is something of a lost gem; created by Michael Lark, Ed Brubaker and Greg Rucka (the latter of whom started off his career a crime writer), the series chronicles the work done in supervillain-strewn Gotham by street-level cops in the GCPD, in stark comparison to the high-flying adventures of the Batman Family. It was like The Shield or Homicide: Life on the Streets set in the DC Universe, and if Gotham turns out anything like that? It could be something very special.

6. There's Some Familiar Villains, Too

That said, whilst Gotham may be keeping its feet firmly on the ground, that doesn't mean we won't be completely deprived of supervillainy. Just that the villains in question won't have reached the "super" part yet. Along with getting a peek at the formative years of Jim Gordon and Bruce Wayne, seeing how they became the iconic characters we know and love, we can look forward to younger - but not necessarily more innocent - depictions of The Penguin, Catwoman and The Riddler. In this case, Oswald Cobblepot is a minion to one of the crime families in Gotham, and has yet to adopt either his nickname or his flock of rocket-launcher wielding arctic animals; Selina Kyle is a streetwise teenage orphan (which is probably better than her appearance in Year One); and Edward Nygma, most intriguingly, is a forensic scientist who works within the GCPD, but does have a particular way of speaking...

5. And Some New Ones

Along with a new spin on some of Batman's rogues gallery in their early years, Gotham also promises some memorable original baddies. In fact, the main villain of the show - and the one whom all the others work under - will be the original creation Fish Mooney, played by Jada Pinkett Smith. From the sounds of it she'll be making up for her ridiculous name by being a total badass; Mooney is a nightclub owner and gang boss in Gotham with "street smarts and almost extra-sensory abilities" ("almost" being the important word, I guess?) Not only does Mooney have the young Penguin working for her, but she'll also have help from her second-in-command, Butch Gilzean - hired to distract from her own silly name - played by Drew Powell, who you might remember from every TV show ever (including Southland!). Smith is quite a get for the show and it'll be cool to see how she makes this entirely new character her own, especially when she's being set up as Jim Gordon's arch rival.

4. It's In Good Hands

In these days of Breaking Bad, Mad Men and the like, the showrunner of a TV series is almost as big a deal to the general public as the cast. Luckily Gotham has managed to land itself a pretty good one in the form of Bruno Heller, an industry veteran who has recently helmed the likes of HBO's Rome - a forerunner of the channel's bigger-budgeted shows - and the Mentalist, which means something very different in the US to the UK. Both those could be reassuring signs; after all, the Mentalist is a police procedural with a psychological edge, and if Gotham is known for anything, it's for being stuffed full of psychos. The political scheming and classical drama of Rome could find its own spin in this series, too, as Fox president Kevin Reilly described the show as an "operatic soap that has a slightly larger-than-life quality". That might just be because of the supervillains, though.

3. Although The Leaked Script Kinda Sucked

There is this, though: a lot of what we've learned about Gotham so far has come not only from official statements but also the leaking of an early draft of the show's pilot script. We learned about the relationship between Gordon and his partner, grizzled detective Harvey Bullock (whom Donal Logue is perfectly cast to play), who introduces him to the ways of the GCPD. We learned that the show's first mystery will be who shot Bruce Wayne's parents? We also learned that the show seems pretty obsessed with dropping in references to Batman, despite resolutely insisting it's not a Batman show; that Jim Gordon seems blissfully unaware of what a cesspit Gotham is prior to joining the police, despite having grown up there; that Poison Ivy might also be introduced during the show's run; and that the dialogue runs the gamut from cheesy 40s slang (I have no idea what "skell huggers" are and am afraid to search on Urban Dictionary) to Dick Van Dyke cockney (which hopefully won't be reflected in Sean Pertwee's performances as Alfred).

2. But That Can Change

Of course it should be worth noting that this was, according to the leak, a "Second Network Draft" - and therefore, not a final draft. The Gotham pilot that was leaked is not going to be the Gotham pilot that will air; not only will it have been rewritten a bunch of times since, but it'll have been rewritten once all the casting was locked down, will be rewritten on the set, and will be rewritten in the editing room. Lines will change through improvisation, characterisation will change through performances. Plus, y'know, most pilots aren't perfect. They have the unenviable task of setting up the characters, world, and central hook of a show in an hour of television, whilst also telling a complete story that's enjoyable to watch, rather than just a metric tonne of exposition. There's plenty to love even in the leaked script, besides: Gordon and Bullock's relationship is a little more relaxed than in previous depictions, some of the less obvious nods to Batman lore are fun, and it really does read like a police drama set in Gotham City. Which is awesome!

1. It's A Different View Of Gotham

We've seen Gotham City onscreen plenty of times over the years. In the 90s animated series it was a stylised metropolis (not Metropolis), in the Nolan films it was Chicago, and in the Adam West show...well, it didn't really stand out against everything else that was going on amongst the Bat-Usi. The point is, we've seen Gotham a lot, but we've only ever really seen it through Batman's eyes, and through Batman's very limited mission ie to eradicate crime. And it's a very specific sort of crime; sure, we might see Bats string up some muggers or burglars every once in a while, but he's mainly concerned with all the supervillains wandering around. One of the things people were most skeptical of when Gotham was announced is whether anybody cares about a pre-Caped Crusader, pre-rogue's gallery Gotham City. And my answer to that would be...well, yes! This show has the chance to stand out from the crowd of crime series on TV at the moment (and always, actually) by featuring larger-than-life characters that we know a little, but could do with being fleshed out a little; it does what Marvel have been doing for the past few years - and DC has desperately been trying to ape - by finding a new and suitable genre to fit its properties into; it covers a side of the Batman mythos, which are 75 years old this year by the way, which hasn't been covered. We can see how Gotham got into such a state that it needed a hero. We see how Commissioner Gordon got to where he is today. We get The Penguin before he got fat. I'm pretty excited, you guys.

In this post: 
Gotham
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/