15 Most Controversial DC Retcons Of All Time

By Bryant Lucas /

4. Sue Dibny€™s Rape

Once upon a time Ralph and Sue Dibny were the hallmark of wholesomeness within the DC Universe. They were a couple madly in love and forever devoted to one another. Nothing could shake their rock solid relationship, and then Brad Meltzer had to take a huge dump all over it. In 2004, DC released a major crossover called Identity Crisis where it was retconed that back in the day Doctor Light raped the Elongated Man€™s wife, Sue Dibny. When the Justice League found out, the lobotomized Doctor Light and mind wiped Batman, who objected to Doctor Light€™s punishment. This whole story pretty much ruined the DC Silver Age, casting a long shadow across DC€™s greatest heroes. First and foremost, having a character raped in a story is often a sign of bad writing. Sue Dibny, who was also murdered in Identity Crisis, had no agency and was simply a plot device to usher in a darker, grittier DC Universe, where heroes don€™t always act like heroes.