Madden NFL 23 Review: 3 Ups & 7 Downs

Did EA pay fitting tribute to NFL great John Madden, or did they fumble the ball?

By Jamie Kennedy /

EA Sports

NFL great John Madden passed away aged 85 on 28 December 2021.

Advertisement

Immediately, tributes flooded in from all corners of the sporting world for one of pro football's best characters. Simultaneously, EA's braintrust began thinking of ways they could tie the Super Bowl XI champion's legacy in with their annual franchise - pretty much everybody knew then that John would grace the game's cover.

He did, and EA even included a few other trinkets designed to pay homage to the man their series is named after. The question is whether or not Madden 23 actually went far enough with the love, or if it tweaked gameplay enough towards simulation that the man himself would look down proudly on a project he was once very hands on with.

Advertisement

Madden 23 isn't the best football game ever, to say the least. However, EA did tinker with some on-field elements that make passing, running, returning and more a refined experience. Sadly, the usual 12-month cycle isn't nearly enough for developers to overhaul Madden the way it sorely needs.

Here's all the good and bad from this year's entry.

Advertisement

Downs...

7. The Presentation

EA Sports

Presentation should be one of Madden's biggest strengths.

Advertisement

Tune into any real-world NFL broadcast and you'll be treated to swooping camera shots, spectacular overhead views, bustling activity on the sidelines and some of the most passionate sporting fans on the planet. Very little of that is actually replicated in-game, which is a real shame.

Commentary from Brandon Gaudin and Charles Davis is seriously tired. You'll hear the same lines and phrases you did years ago, and some of them fail to match up with what just happened post-snap. Their creaking banter, as well as crowds who look like they'd rather be anywhere else, don't help Madden 23 at all.

Advertisement

The series of canned animations that happen with coaches, coordinators and teammates also struggles to elevate the atmosphere. Honestly, EA may as well have put cardboard cutouts on the sidelines/in the stands, and hit mute on the Gaudin/Davis combo.

Oh for a Madden-esque "BOOM!".

Advertisement

6. MUT

EA Sports

This will always be a 'Down' for yours truly, largely because he has a real problem with EA's approach towards borderline gambling in Ultimate Team. It sucks in FIFA and NHL, but Madden arguably takes things further by beating you over the head with relentless MUT pop-ups in other menus.

Advertisement

It's beyond tedious.

Also, new 'Field Passes' don't seem to work as intended on release. Maybe EA will patch that, because glitches and bugs mean it's sometimes impossible to find out what you've just unlocked (or why you bothered trying in the first place). As usual, everything is geared towards spending even more money on packs.

Advertisement

Ultimate Team is a crass, money-grabbing concept for sure, but there is some fun to be had if you've got supreme patience. Unfortunately, that patience is rarely rewarded with the same treasures somebody who willingly drops extra cash to get ahead gets.

Pay. To. Win.

Advertisement

5. Face Of The Franchise

EA Sports

EA finally moved on from a rookie year in 'Face Of The Franchise'. Now, your character is five years deep into a once-promising NFL career, but has one last season to prove his worth and secure a new contract. Is that an excellent hook? Absolutely, but the on-rails nature of FOTF holds it back from achieving true greatness.

Advertisement

Being brutally honest, the devs might want to think about scrapping their restrictive, Netflix-worthy 'TV movie' storylines and look towards NBA 2K for inspiration; 2K's product can be cheesy too, but it offers a freedom that Madden just hasn't been able to match since kicking things off in 'Longshot'.

There's another glaring problem that hampers the mode's fun factor too. Being able to play in different positions is a nice touch, but choosing cornerback is torturous. Your star will rarely be involved in snaps, and that makes it harder to hit individual goals or milestones (think playing as a goalkeeper in FIFA's old 'Be A Pro' mode).

Advertisement

Hollow might be the best word to sum this feature up.

4. Franchise Mode Still Lags

EA Sports

Is there fun to be found in Franchise? Yes, there is. New free agency rushes add some drama, and it is cool that EA took the time to add in unique characteristics which determine why players want to join certain teams. Of course, the game's algorithms can't cope with those demands, so that'll need patched.

Advertisement

This fan looked on in awe as baffling departures happened all around him almost instantly. Certain star players decided they no longer wanted to stay put at a club because it didn't match their pre-set desires - that's...strange, because those demands surely shouldn't clash with the team they're already signed to.

EA must start delivering more with Franchise generally. Sure, everyone knows their focus is on MUT, but this is the same experience year-on-year with only incremental changes that don't really heighten the idea of gunning for glory in the Super Bowl. The Playoffs should be way more lively, for example.

Advertisement

NBA 2K23's 'Eras' idea is set to leave competitors in the dust, and it kinda exposes how clunky Madden's career suite is by now. There's so much more EA could be doing to make coaching or GM'ing a franchise more appealing.

3. Coverage/Blocking Is Still Balls

EA Sports

Madden 23's 'FieldSENSE' improvements do work for things like passing and running (more on those later), but defensive plays remain a chore. AI teammates just do not block running lanes, and that can lead to constant blown coverages which you wouldn't see at an elite NFL level in real-life.

Advertisement

Worse, there's no way to fix this.

Similarly, your offensive line does a poor job of protecting QBs or shielding your own runners. This means there's way less time than there should be to pick a pass, and that's true even when you're playing as some of Madden's best units. Everyone sorta runs around in circles bumping into one another like they've never played football before.

Advertisement

'FieldSENSE' was supposed to eliminate overly-scripted animation cycles for tackling and make collisions more lifelike. That's true maybe 40% of the time. The other 60%? That's spent shouting at cornerbacks who weirdly get sucked into the middle of the pack rather than cutting off routes.

2. John Madden’s Tribute Isn’t Nearly Enough

EA Sports

Right, it's important to mention that the 'Legacy Game' Madden 23 opens up with is lovely. Seeing the old Oakland Coliseum fully rendered is a treat, and it's hard to blast EA for including some sort of tribute to Coach Madden in this year's game, but...

Advertisement

...they should've gone further.

The great man's death should've been an excuse to overhaul the experience more than EA did. If anything, cutting out arcade-like features and focusing on a no-frills football sim would've made sense. Instead, they've slapped on a quick fantasy revisit and called it a day.

Advertisement

Madden's presence is felt in this 'Legacy Game' and on the menus, but that's really it. The title doesn't go deep enough down the rabbit hole into John's legacy (oddly enough), or properly explain why he's so cherished in the first place.

Also, being able to play Super Bowl XI would've been ace. Just saying.

Advertisement

1. Madden Needs An Overhaul

EA Sports

EA deserves credit for making a concerted effort to focus on actual gameplay improvements rather than peripheral distractions like 'The Yard' or 'Superstar KO' this year. That's appreciated, but the game's fundamentals are still lagging behind what's expected on modern hardware.

Advertisement

Players still bump into one another like glitched out messes, or half-finished animations rinse and repeat to make some plays unrealistic. The entire package needs an overhaul, but that's probably not going to happen whilst modes like MUT are money-making monsters.

EA has a monopoly on the NFL license too, so they know they can offer incremental updates here or there without actually rebuilding Madden from the ground up like it needs to be. If only they had some competition - that'd force the team's hand and give them a wakeup call.

Advertisement

Maybe someday, eh?

Ups...

3. Punt Returns Are Improved

EA Sports

All of the 'Ups' are gameplay related, which is nice to report.

Advertisement

Firstly, you might find some success on punt returns. Previously, getting anywhere beyond the 20-25 yard line was borderline impossible on higher difficulties. Now, likely thanks in part to looser tackling animations, there's way more variety in returns (both for you and the AI teams).

Touchdowns are still rare in these instances, as they should be, but they're a real punch-the-air moment when you score one. Kudos to EA for getting the balance right here. They've somehow managed to make you believe that getting over midfield on a return is achievable with the right runner.

Advertisement

Obviously, this is something to look out for when you're the one punting. CPU teams will torch your tacklers like never before, so make sure to switch control from punter to somebody else on the squad unless you don't care about opposition sides starting their latest possession on your 30 yard line.

2. The New Passing Game

EA Sports

Here's the biggest compliment one can give Madden 23's new passing system: Try it and you'll have a hard time reverting to Madden 22's old style. The new power bar isn't the game-changer here. No, that aiming reticule and the fact you can actually throw balls over the shoulders of receivers as they switch directions on a route is.

Advertisement

This skill-based system genuinely gives you more control over the success rate of throws. A QBs base throwing stats aren't the only thing you have to think about anymore - Tom Brady, for example, can still f*ck things up if your aim is all over the place. Ball placement and paying attention to receiver routes is critical.

Prepare for greater insight into how top-tier quarterbacks read the field than ever before. EA's new passing game is a joy once you figure it out. Perhaps the only gripe here is that they could fix ball trajectory - everything feels just a bit too low. Hail Mary's are fine, at least.

Advertisement

This is a step forward for the series.

1. It’s The Best Madden This Gen

EA Sports

Your tolerance for this entry will vary, so be warned.

Advertisement

Is Madden 23 a great game? No, and the number of 'Downs' compared to 'Ups' illustrates that. Regardless, this year's on-field improvements do mean it's the best version of Madden you can currently get on PS5 and Xbox Series X. Sure, that should be tempered by the fact it's largely the same game as Madden 22, but yes.

Put it this way: Lapsed fans who haven't picked up one of these titles for years could be pleasantly surprised by the gameplay adjustments. Going back to that old passing system is also tough once you've sampled how intuitive skill-based throws are here. Toss an interception and it's on you, buddy!

Advertisement

Expecting complete rebuilds from annual sports franchises is probs rather silly. That means Madden 22's returning crowd will scoff at the relatively tiny changes. By comparison, somebody who hasn't bought one of these games for five years may find a lot to like.

What do you think of Madden 23 so far? For more gaming, check out Madden 23: 10 Things You NEED To Know Before Buying and FIFA 23 Beta: 10 Hands-On First Impressions You Need To Know!

Advertisement