10 Horror TV Shows You Must Never Pause

These moments are often horrifying for all the wrong reasons.

By Jack Pooley /

It's fair to say that horror, perhaps more than any other genre of media, benefits from what isn't shown to viewers, of hiding terrifying threats in the shadows and crucially not making the production's visual effects limitations clear.

Advertisement

There's a lot to be said for restraint, for only periodically showing the terror, because with the nature of digital media these days, it's all too easy for audiences to hit the pause button and take a long, lingering look at an effect that doesn't stand up to prolonged scrutiny.

These 10 horror TV shows, each with their own devoted fanbases and many of them acclaimed classics, dared to offer up moments that you absolutely shouldn't pause, from unconvincing CGI to atrociously obvious body doubles, and yes, an Easter egg hunt so terrifying you really shouldn't bother.

TV production is hard with the time and financial constraints compared to film, but even so, most of these moments shouldn't be paused because they're just so easily torn down with the press of a single button.

Experience them in the moment and then move on rather than stripping all of their mystique away with a mere freeze-frame...

10. Terrible CGI EVERYWHERE - The Walking Dead

Despite being one of the most popular TV shows of the last decade-plus, with episodes being budgeted at several million dollars each, it's shocking just how persistently terrible The Walking Dead's visual effects are.

Advertisement

Hell, there are enough hideous CGI blunders in the show that we even wrote a list on it, with by far the most infamous VFX gaffe being an embarrassingly low-fi digital deer that showed up in the series' seventh season.

This is just one of several instances of egregiously poor CGI throughout the show: there's the digital CDC building explosion, Michonne (Danai Gurira) walking past burning mattresses that were created in post, and the awful green screen shot of Rick standing in front of a landfill, not to mention the general overabundance of unconvincing CGI blood throughout.

Basically, never pause anything in this show to get a better look, because there's a good chance it'll just reveal how shamelessly AMC cut corners in order to save a little money. Yikes.

9. The Leviathans - Supernatural

For the standards of a CW show, Supernatural boasts relatively solid production values, but there's no escaping how absolutely horrid - and not in the intended way - the Leviathans look.

Advertisement

The man-eating shapeshifters typically reveal their true nature when their human faces transform into a gaping maw of jagged teeth complete with a forked tongue.

It's a terrifying idea in theory, but the VFX are so uniformly cheap that they end up resembling goofy B-movie villains rather than cosmic nightmare fuel.

It's easy to believe that these effects are the result of interns at the effects house being given a Friday afternoon to motion-track a low-fi 3D animation onto an actor's face. Worse still, they all looked terrible even a decade ago when these episodes originally aired.

Any small measure of fear the Leviathans still hold in your heart will surely evaporate if you dare to pause any of their so-called "money shots."

8. Mike's Hairy-Legged Stunt Double - Stranger Things

Stranger Things is undeniably one of the most popular shows currently on the air, and while you might be tempted to hit the pause button in order to savour the series' outstanding production design and lavish VFX, be careful where you decide to freeze-frame.

Advertisement

One of the show's most-cited criticisms throughout its third and fourth seasons has been the distractingly accelerated ages of its main cast members - basically an unavoidable consequence of the show's lengthy production and, of course, the pandemic further slowing shooting.

But even with the cast visibly growing up across seasons, the show's crew were a little optimistic in assuming that fans wouldn't notice the very obviously adult stunt doubles subbing in for the young protagonists.

In season three's final episode, "The Battle of Starcourt," a Mind Flayer-possessed Billy (Dacre Montgomery) attacks the Hawkins gang, throwing Mike (Finn Wolfhard) into a wall and causing him to fall to the floor in pain.

As noticed by Redditor Maj0rThreat on /r/MovieMistakes, though, for a fleeting shot it's hilariously obvious we're not looking at Finn Wolfhard.

Mike's legs have suddenly sprouted a wealth of hair you'd expect from a grown adult male, not someone who was just 16 years of age during shooting, and certainly not Wolfhard, whose legs are clearly shown to be relatively hairless whenever he's wearing shorts.

It doesn't break the show by any means, but it is an amusing reminder of the challenges of working with a predominantly young ensemble cast.

7. The Terrible Fake Dog Prop - Bates Motel

Here's a moment that should be absolutely heartbreaking, and yet if you pay remotely close attention it becomes completely impossible to take seriously.

Advertisement

In the seventh episode of Bates Motel's first season, Norman (Freddie Highmore) befriends a stray dog, Juno, and after calling out to it across the road, the dog is struck and killed by a truck as it attempts to cross the road.

Horrible and devastating, right? Except if you keep an eye on poor Juno at the moment of impact, it's very clearly a cheap dog doll, given that its body simple tumbles stiffly underneath the truck rather than, well, squishing like you'd expect from a flesh-and-blood animal.

It shouldn't be funny, but the obviousness of the prop, even when out of focus as it's hit, totally obliterates the emotional intent of the scene.

And in a feat of accidental irony, Norman then has the dead dog stuffed, so the late canine now has all the rigidity of the fake dog used to achieve her demise on screen. Classic.

6. Harrison's Adult Stunt Double - Dexter

Many Dexter fans had basically lost all hope for the series as it entered its miserable eighth season, and of the many terrible moments fans care not to remember, there's the ridiculous treadmill accident that befell Dexter's (Michael C. Hall) young son Harrison (Jadon Wells) a few episodes from the end.

Advertisement

While Hannah (Yvonne Strahovski) is babysitting Harrison, he decides to toy around with a treadmill and, predictably, ends up tripping and smashing his chin.

It's a silly scene in of itself, albeit one made so, so much worse by the fact that Harrison's fall is very clearly carried out by a fully grown adult trying and failing to resemble a small, injured child.

There are two shots in particular where the deception is hilariously obvious, that we're looking at a stuntman several times larger than actor Jadon Wells, the man seemingly wearing a blonde mop of a wig in a feckless attempt to sell the illusion.

It's hardly the worst thing in season eight - and certainly not the most infuriating - but an absolute embarrassment from a show that's generally so slickly produced.

5. The Unsettlingly Terrible Effects - Twin Peaks: The Return

Twin Peaks: The Return is one of the most unforgettable TV series of the last decade - a long-awaited follow-up to the legendary series that's as baffling as it is brilliant.

Advertisement

One of the series' more divisive aspects remains its visual effects, which range from utterly mesmerising - namely episode eight's stunning nuclear explosion - to absolutely hideous.

While some of Lynch's fans continue to argue that the low-poly, poorly textured effects were intentional, it's much easier to believe that Lynch simply lacked the budget to execute all of his ideas at a high level of fidelity, and decided to save the big-bucks VFX work for that pivotal nuke episode.

So many of the effects wouldn't look amiss in grotty VHS tapes and chintzy video games from literally decade ago, and while the visual ideas are certainly interesting, sometimes the results are so offputtingly garish as to make The Return a genuine eyesore.

Again, there are those who maintain that this was entirely purposeful by Lynch, to subvert our very expectations of "prestige TV" with a nauseating aesthetic, but either way you're probably better off not scrutinising them too much for fear of seeing just how rudimentary and ugly they truly are.

4. The Hidden Ghosts - The Haunting Of Hill House & Bly Manor

And now for something that isn't a horrible VFX gaffe or unconvincing stunt double.

Advertisement

Mike Flanagan's sister horror series The Haunting of Hill House and The Haunting of Bly Manor were notable for many reasons, not least that Flanagan made the decision to sneakily include ghostly figures throughout each series.

Fans and critics found literally dozens of ghosts cleverly concealed in plain sight throughout almost every episode of each show.

Some are hidden within negative space that the viewer's eye wouldn't naturally draw towards, while others are disguised as general household objects, and there are even those only easily visible if you crank the brightness settings on your TV.

As much as it might seem like a fun game to try and catch 'em all, Pokémon-style, for your psyche's sake it's probably best not to, because some of them are sure to give grown adults vivid nightmares.

3. Anna's Unhinged Jaw - V (2009)

The 2009 reboot of legendary 1980s sci-fi horror miniseries V received wildly mixed reviews across its two-season run, with one of the key complaints being its distractingly low budget, defined by cheap sets and low-rent visual effects which failed to live up to the original show.

Advertisement

This was most palpably felt during the reboot series' attempt to recreate the iconic scene from the '80s show, where villainous alien queen Diana (Jane Badler) unhinges her jaw and eats a live rat.

The original prosthetic effect certainly didn't look great, and there was clearly a ripe opportunity here to massively improve upon it with contemporary VFX, and yet when Diana's daughter Anna (Morena Baccarin) chows down on some squirming vermin it somehow looks even worse.

Rather than using a practical prosthetic, Anna's unhinged jaw and widely extended mouth were achieved digitally, which make sense, except that it looks like ABC spent $5 on an After Effects plug-in to pull it off.

More comical than disturbing, the shot of Anna dropping the terrified animal into her gaping maw looks like something out of a bad '90s FMV video game, rather than a scene from a TV show that aired on a major network barely a decade ago.

TV shows are famously produced on tight deadlines with limited VFX budgets, but come on - people can literally produce more convincing effects on their home computers these days.

2. Peter's Transformation - Hemlock Grove

Alright, this one might ruffle some feathers.

Advertisement

Hemlock Grove does admittedly deserve a measure of credit for combining CGI with practical effects for the physical transformations of werewolf Peter Rumancek (Landon Liboiron), yet it's also painfully clear watching these scenes that Netflix was a little tight with their VFX purse-strings.

The idea behind Peter's transformation, of his wolf form tearing out of his human body, is really quite fantastic, but the execution is far more middling due to CGI that felt poorly dated back when it originally aired almost a decade ago.

The biggest issues are the hilariously bad motion-tracking of CGI yellow eyes over actor Landon Liboiron's actual eyes, atrocious looking digital werewolf fingernails protruding from his human fingers, and embarrassingly low-poly tears on his back as the transformation continues.

The money shot, of the werewolf face bursting through Peter's own, looks pretty great, but everything else is hugely on the rough side, and doesn't at all hold up to the scrutiny of a freeze-frame.

1. Another Terrible CGI Deer - American Horror Story: Apocalypse

Proving that The Walking Dead didn't solely corner the market on awful CGI deer, American Horror Story: Apocalypse offered up its own shockingly naff digital doe in the season's fifth episode, "Boy Wonder."

Advertisement

Near the start of the episode, Mallory (Billie Lourd) uses her extensive powers to not only heal a dead deer's wounds but also restore its youth. It's a swell idea but a complex effect for even a well-minted TV show to pull off, and so it's not terribly surprising that they bungled it.

The morphing effect from the adult to youthful deer looks, to be kind, like something out of a PS2 game, and doesn't hold up to even the most casual degree of challenge.

The effect was widely mocked by fans when the episode first aired back in 2018, roughly 18 months after The Walking Dead first introduced audiences to the deeply offputting horrors of a CGI deer.

Advertisement