20 Worst Doctor Who Episodes Ever

Modern Doctor Who has clocked up 187 episodes, and let's just say not all of them were good.

By Mark Donaldson /

Since 2005, Doctor Who has clocked up 187 episodes, with wildly varying degrees of quality.

Advertisement

Sitting down to watch each new episode can be a stressful experience, with everyone willing it to be the best episode ever, something to assuage any niggling worries about the show getting cancelled. That expectation can often lead to kneejerk reactions decrying episodes as the "worst thing ever."

However, quite often, a deep breath and a rewatch a few years down the line can open your eyes to the strengths of something you previously branded a turkey. Or, your eyes are opened to what a bad Doctor Who episode was trying to do, which only makes matters worse.

There can be many reasons why a Doctor Who episode doesn't work. Whether it's a big idea that's realized poorly, an unwieldy and confusing script, embarassing performances, or dodgy monsters. From the Ninth Doctor in 2005 to the Fifteenth Doctor in 2024, each of the following bad Doctor Who episodes contains at least one of those elements.

But which is the worst of the worst?

20. Empire Of Death

Russell T Davies' series finales have always been hit or miss. The Parting of the Ways and Doomsday were excellent, but Last of the Time Lords and Journey's End were a bit all over the place.

Advertisement

So there's almost something nostalgic about Empire of Death, RTD's first season finale since 2008, being the very worst one he's ever written.

Structurally, it's a mess. We witness all of UNIT dying in the opening minutes, so we never for a moment think anyone is truly dead. And then there's all that business with finding a spoon to power a TV so the Doctor, Mel, and Ruby can sit down and watch Pyramids of Mars. And let's not get started on Ruby's mother again.

It's more like a bunch of scenes hastily strung together than a coherent episode of Doctor Who.

19. The Wedding Of River Song

From The Big Bang to The Doctor Falls, Steven Moffat finales are generally stunning character studies that put everyone through the emotional wringer while the universe falls apart.

Advertisement

The opening minutes of The Wedding of River Song – where the barriers between past, present, and future have broken down – sets the Series 6 finale up to be just that. And yet, it can't quite stick the landing.

The marriage of the Doctor and River bringing reality back together again doesn't make a lick of sense, and the Doctor using the Teselecta to avoid his execution is such an obvious resolution that you wonder what everyone was worrying about in the first place.

Worse still, there's so much strange and random stuff happening throughout that it's tough to connect with the episode emotionally, as we're whisked from giant chess boards to pyramids and pulled between the past and the present constantly.

The potential was clearly there, but it doesn't quite gel.

18. Planet Of The Dead

There was a lot riding on Planet of the Dead as the first of 2009's David Tennant specials.

Advertisement

But even divorced from that hype, it's an uninspiring bit of Doctor Who that feels like an excuse for everyone to go on holiday to Dubai.

The Dubai locations are supposed to justify the "special" nature of Planet of the Dead, but they're just repetitive sand dunes. The UK-based quarry from The Waters of Mars looks more like an alien landscape than this episode does.

The CGI stingrays don't feel tangible either and the fly aliens are laughably bad. It all just feels like RTD and co-writer Gareth Roberts took the rest of the day off after typing "London bus in an alien desert".

17. The Long Game

The Long Game stands out as the worst of Christopher Eccleston's consistent run of strong stories.

Advertisement

A Doctor Who story about rolling news and the hidden agendas of the media was ideal for the show's new 20th century era. But the main issue is that Adam's boring subplot doesn't really dovetail with the machinations of Simon Pegg's Editor and his slimy boss.

Adam tapping into the computer systems gave the Jagrafess knowledge of the TARDIS, but how much more dramatic would it be if this unsuitable Doctor Who companion was seduced to the dark side by the Editor?

The Doctor also doesn't get to do a whole lot throughout this story, and the whole thing feels like a rough early draft. The Long Game definitely needed to sharpen its edges.

16. Space Babies

Whatever the truth of the concerns about Doctor Who's ratings on Disney+, Space Babies can't have helped matters. Quite why Russell T Davies launched his bold new era of Doctor Who from inside a manky old space station staffed by talking babies is anyone's guess.

Advertisement

It's got "mid-season filler" written all over it, and yet it was chosen to launch a reduced season of Doctor Who. If Space Babies had been episode seven in a ten-episode season, we'd perhaps all look on it a bit more favourably.

But compare this to some of our recent series openers – The Halloween Apocalypse or Spyfall or The Pilot. Against those, Space Babies feels incredibly regressive, which isn't a great look for Doctor Who's Disney+ era.

15. The Caretaker

Is "What if the Doctor was a janitor?" a great pitch for a Doctor Who story? No. Does it at least have a memorable alien threat? Again, no. Does it at least have a likeable cast of human characters for our alien janitor to interact with?

Advertisement

Depends on your views on Danny Pink and Courtney... so also, no?

There are definitely some fun moments, but the crucial issue with The Caretaker is that it doesn't know what it wants the Doctor and Clara's relationship to be. Is he a jealous suitor or a disapproving father figure?

Weirdly, Capaldi is given both to play, which only adds to The Caretaker's muddled tone.

14. New Earth

New Earth makes sense as David Tennant's first series opener. Keep it fun and snappy, and bring back the Face of Boe and Cassandra to further emphasize that this is just Christopher Eccleston with a new face.

Advertisement

But why on Gallifrey did it have to be so bad?

There's a dark satire about privatised healthcare in New Earth, but for some reason it's reduced to a subplot in a campy body-swap comedy that's stretched to breaking point.

Yes, Billie Piper and David Tennant are very funny playing Cassandra, but that doesn't mean you have to dedicate the rest of the episode to alternating between their performances.

Ultimately, nobody watching New Earth is having as much fun as Russell T Davies was clearly having writing it.

13. The Rings Of Akhaten

The Rings of Akhaten is a decent enough 'first trip in the TARDIS' story, but it completely falls apart with the resolution.

Advertisement

Any Doctor Who episode that requires the Doctor to somehow sacrifice themselves that isn't a finale or regeneration story is already unlikely to work.

Nobody believes that the Doctor is actually in any jeopardy because someone else will come along and fix it, or the Doctor will do something clever at the last minute.

Which is presumably why writer Neil Cross just shrugs his shoulders and has Clara turn up to save the day with a leaf... because sentimental value? It's a shame, because Cross does some great world-building in Akhaten's first 20 minutes, only to fumble the conclusion.

12. The Woman Who Lived

The Woman Who Lived is one of the most lacklustre, uninspiring Doctor Who stories of all time. So much so that it's kind of hard to class it as one of the worst, because it's hard to summon up any strength of feeling about it whatsoever.

Advertisement

Maisie Williams doesn't have the range to portray the centuries of sorrow experienced by Me, and therefore comes across less like a lonely god and more like a stroppy teenager.

Rufus Hound does his best to provide the comic relief, and Capaldi responds well to this. However, Williams' performance is so flat, and the threat (a literal Lion King) is so unthreatening that it ends up as a damp squib of an episode.

Which would be fine, if it wasn't also an integral part of the ongoing series arc. Oh dear.

11. The Tsuranga Conundrum

The Tsuranga Conundrum is a lot of fun, but like many of Chris Chibnall's Doctor Who stories, it's a bit too busy for any of the supporting characters to make their presence felt.

Advertisement

The Pting is an interesting creation, a creature of instinct and appetite that is immune to the Doctor's usual moralising and diplomacy. And if it was just the Doctor, the fam, and Roy Kent trying to eject the Pting, The Tsuranga Conundrum would've been miles better.

Instead, we get Graham and Ryan helping a man give birth, an awkward android love affair, and a "heroic" sacrifice that lacks impact. And none of it is particularly memorable.

10. Closing Time

Cybermen... in a department store!

Advertisement

That's a concept that feels like it could be enormous fun, if given the budget and scale to fulfill its potential. Instead, it's reduced to being a stray plot thread in a lacklustre sequel to The Lodger.

Closing Time is a perfect example of the unnecessary sequel. The Doctor checking in on Craig would maybe work as a small scene in an End of Time-style final tour, but this isn't that.

It also effectively repeats the climax of The God Complex, with the Eleventh Doctor lamenting how he always puts his friends in danger.

Closing Time should've picked a lane. As it stands it's a frustrating mish-mash of a fun Cyberman story and a sequel to a beloved episode that satisfies no-one.

9. The Lie Of The Land

The Monk Trilogy in Peter Capaldi's final series feels like it robs us of three cracking standalone adventures for the Doctor, Nardole, and Bill. Especially as its conclusion, The Lie of the Land, completely undermines the whole story.

Advertisement

Because it's happening in the middle of a series, there's no scale to the Monks' invasion of Earth. It's a few streets, a handful of extras, and Peter Capaldi gurning out of a TV set. With such a lack of bombast, it's hard to care about any of the episode's bizarre flourishes.

From the Doctor tricking his companion into putting a bullet in him, to the overused and uninspired "love conquers all" resolution, The Lie of the Land was a deeply unsatisfying finale to a muddled three-part Doctor Who story.

8. Journey To The Centre Of The TARDIS

Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS was Steven Moffat's attempt to make up for the mistakes made by The Invasion of Time.

Advertisement

But crucially, he and the episode's writer Steve Thompson forgot that while it may have revealed the inside of the TARDIS to be a Victorian hospital (for some reason), The Invasion of Time at least had a compelling story.

Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS has no such story, and is a fairly vapid tale of some alien scrap merchant brothers.

Instead of being a compelling piece of drama, the episode feels like a paper thin premise for a TARDIS escape room or VR simulation, without any interactivity or engagement for its audience. A missed opportunity if ever there was one.

7. Orphan 55

Orphan 55 is bad, but it's not as bad as fans make out. It's got great monsters, and the idea of an irradiated Earth being turned into a luxury resort is a sharper satirical idea than people give it credit for. Also, Jodie and the cast are having fun, which helps a lot.

Advertisement

However, it's stuffed full of supporting characters that range from the forgettable to the weird, and the downright annoying. You're supposed to care about Vilma and BENNI!!!! but she's so tooth-grindingly annoying that you find yourself on the side of the Dregs.

And then there's Jodie Whittaker's speech to camera about saving the planet, which is a classic example of a vital message being delivered in the most clunky and patronising manner possible.

6. The Curse Of The Black Spot

The Curse of the Black Spot is a mess. Missing pirates, a woefully miscast Hugh Bonneville, and a "scientific" explanation for the Siren that seems more magical than anything in folk tales.

Advertisement

The biggest issue is the ending, in which Rory Williams dies... again. If The Curse of the Black Spot had gone out when intended (in the second half of the series), then it might've had more of an impact.

Especially after A Good Man Goes To War and Let's Kill Hitler – Amy fighting to save Rory's life would've landed much better after we'd already seen her lose her daughter.

But a handful of episodes after she already brought him back to life in the Series 5 finale, and we're all looking at our watches.

5. In The Forest Of The Night

In the Forest of the Night has a strong image at its core, with the urban sprawl of London covered under sheets of greenery. But that's all it has going for it.

Advertisement

From a cast predominantly made of child actors to the fact that nobody expects Earth to be obliterated three weeks before the finale, In the Forest of the Night is a clanger of a Doctor Who story.

And oh boy, that resolution. Okay so, the trees save us, they shield us from the devastating solar flares, and ask for nothing in return. And then, instead of suggesting that we learn from this on-the-nose message about the dangers of deforestation, the Doctor glibly tells Clara everyone will forget all about it?

So yes, as Doctor Who eco-parables go, In the Forest of the Night IS worse than Orphan 55. And don't get us started on that girl hiding in a hedge at the end.

4. The Battle Of Ranskoor Av Kolos

The main thing that separates Russell T Davies and Chris Chibnall as Doctor Who showrunners is that when a Chibnall first draft goes before cameras, he has the good grace to apologise.

Advertisement

RTD on the other hand boasts to Alan Yentob about how his first drafts are final drafts, thereby explaining all the issues with Empire of Death.

The Battle of Ranskoor Av Kolos is not offensively bad – well, besides the bit where the Doctor doesn't chastise the religious extremists for destroying five innocent planets – it's just really really dull.

The conflict between Graham and the Doctor over what to do with Tim Shaw could have really lifted this above its dreary plot, but unfortunately, Chibnall never had enough time to sharpen it into impactful drama.

3. Nightmare In Silver

Nightmare in Silver is a garish fairytale with a cast of irritating supporting "quirky" characters, and some stroppy kids. To make matters worse, it also features a terrible upgrade for the Cybermen.

Advertisement

These sleek and speedy Iron Men are nowhere near as cool as Nightmare in Silver thinks they are, and ultimately that's the biggest failure of the episode.

Which you could forgive, if it had likeable characters and a strong Matt Smith performance instead of having, you know, Matt Smith's two worst performances in his entire run.

God bless Jenna Coleman for trying her best to upgrade such a narratively defunct script with the episode's only charismatic performance.

2. Legend Of The Sea Devils

With the recent announcement that The War Between the Land and the Sea will repeat the same old story of Sea Devils versus humanity, you have to hand it to Legend of the Sea Devils for trying something different.

Advertisement

A big swashbuckling pirate adventure with Sea Devils could – nay, should – have been perfect Easter bank holiday fare. Instead, it was a confusing, choppy mess of an episode that is among the most inept hours of Doctor Who ever made.

The transition from the practical effects to the CGI is shockingly bad, particularly the Sea Devil leaping onto its ship. And the story's resolution is muddled and confused, to the point that it's genuinely difficult to understand what the hell is actually happening.

Still, John Bishop dressed as a pirate was a good laugh.

1. Fear Her

Fear Her is the worst Doctor Who episode of the modern era, largely because it takes a decent concept and completely and utterly fumbles the execution.

Advertisement

This is Doctor Who at its most CBBC-level childishness, which wouldn't be as big a problem if it didn't also have some of the darkest subject matter of any episode in the entire 60 year history of the show. This is a Doctor Who episode about domestic abuse, that isn't given an ounce of gravitas.

Instead we get David Tennant eating marmalade from the jar, laughable whisper-acting, and the skin-crawlingly irritating "fingers on lips" scene, with direction as flat as one of Chloe Webber's drawings.

Advertisement