10 Terrible Doctor Who Ideas That Nearly Happened

Doctor Who can do anything, but there are times when it definitely shouldn't.

Tom Baker Meglos Fourth Doctor
BBC Studios

Doctor Who has been going for over 60 years at this point, and the constant churn for story ideas has meant that all manner of good and bad ideas have been tossed aside. And as Doctor Who fans, we often love to ponder these might-have-beens.

What if Sarah Jane Smith had returned for Tom Baker's final season? How would Hugh Grant's Ninth Doctor have tackled the Slitheen? How would Christopher Eccleston have interacted with Matt Smith and David Tennant?

The mind boggles with the possibilities of some of Doctor Who's greatest missed opportunities. However, the mind then recoils at the mention of some of the terrible ideas that almost made it into televised Doctor Who.

An unmade Doctor Who episode where Sarah Jane was murdered by aliens? No thank you. A Christmas special in which JK Rowling's imagination comes to life? Absolutely not.

Thankfully, saner heads often prevail, and such terrible ideas are consigned to niche Doctor Who Magazine features, or WhoCulture lists!

On that note, let's dig into the cream of the crop of Doctor Who's worst unused ideas.

10. The Young Doctor Adventures

Doctor Who The Timeless Child
BBC Studios

Keen to cash in on Doctor Who's overnight success in 2005, the BBC tapped Russell T Davies for spinoff ideas.

One concept that was pitched to RTD was a CBBC show that would focus on the Doctor's childhood on Gallifrey. For obvious reasons, Davies declined to pursue the idea further, and developed The Sarah Jane Adventures instead.

It was the right call, as a series of The Young Doctor Adventures would've risked destroying any sense of mystery surrounding the character. For starters, how could you develop a whole show around the Doctor's childhood and not reveal their birth name?

Sure, the Doctor's Theta Sigma nickname from The Armageddon Factor would provide a decent workaround, but then what would their parents call them? What would those parents be like?

And then what would the stories be like? Would we have young versions of the Doctor and the Master running rings around their tutors at the Academy, and having food fights in the canteen?

It sounds like what the BBC really wanted was Harry Potter with timey-wimeyness and TARDISes instead of spells and Quidditch. Thankfully, Russell nipped this one in the bud.


9. Tom Baker In The TV Movie

Tom Baker Fourth Doctor Leaning
BBC

One of Philip Segal's biggest stipulations for the 1996 TV Movie was that he maintained continuity with the previous 33 years. To that end, he cast Sylvester McCoy as the Seventh Doctor for the regeneration into Paul McGann's Eighth Doctor.

While that itself was arguably a bad idea for a relaunch of the show, it made far more sense than one change suggested by one of the executive producers.

Jo Wright, who represented the BBC's interests on the project, was keen to move away from the apparently negative public perception of the Sylvester McCoy era. Wright believed that Tom Baker would be a bigger draw as a past Doctor to hand over the torch to McGann.

That might've been true – not least because Baker was the best-known Doctor in the USA at the time – but it would've been utterly disastrous for Doctor Who continuity if an older Tom Baker had been gunned down in San Francisco. Would that negate the entire 1980s period of Doctor Who? What would that even mean?!

Sylvester McCoy was absolutely the right choice for the TV Movie, and given Baker's reluctance to work on things like The Five Doctors, there's no telling whether he'd have agreed to return anyway.


8. The Toclafane Being Behind The Time War

Doctor Who Toclafane
BBC Studios

When the Terry Nation Estate quibbled over the use of the Daleks in the 2005 revival, Russell T Davies and Robert Shearman had to come up with new antagonists for Series 1, just in case.

Contrary to popular belief, Shearman didn't just Tipp-Ex over DALEK and write CYBERMAN – RTD created another monster for use in that first Dalek episode, which briefly had the jokey working title of "Absence of the Daleks".

Called "Spheres", these monsters were essentially an early version of the Toclafane from the Series 3 finale. This means that a race of evolved future humans inside metal balls would've been revealed as the terrifying enemy that laid waste to the Time Lords, the Nestenes, and the Gelth.

Thankfully, the Nation Estate buckled and we got the Daleks, as it should have been from the start. It's hard to imagine the Toclafane having anywhere near the iconic power of a Dalek, and as Last of the Time Lords proved, they don't really work on their own. They need a character like the Master to use them as a private army.

Still, colourful skittle balls in Series 5 would've been quite something.


7. Nelvana's Animated Series

Doctor Who animated series Nelvana
Nelvana

Of the various independent production companies wanting to take on the Doctor Who licence in the early 1990s, Nelvana got quite far in devising a concept. The Canada-based animation studio developed a Doctor Who cartoon that would've sat neatly alongside the likes of The Real Ghostbusters or Captain Planet on Saturday mornings.

Nelvana's animated Doctor Who series was a complete reimagining of the show, which turned the Doctor into a sort of crusader-for-hire, working at the behest of the Time Lords.

The series retained iconic characters like the Master, the Cybermen, the Daleks, and good old K9. However, the dialogue in the scripts and treatments doesn't feel like Doctor Who at all. For example, at one point, the Doctor tells K9 to "cease that infernal barking".

Meanwhile, the Master was to be half-man, half-cyborg, with a robot bird sidekick and looks modelled after Sean Connery. Alright then.

The project was eventually shut down by the BBC, which was probably for the best. Although it's slightly sad that “Doctor Who’s Time Stick Weapon” wasn't the big Christmas toy in 1993.


6. The Return Of Meglos

Tom Baker Meglos Fourth Doctor
BBC Studios

Remember in The Lodger how there was a nefarious alien menace that was tied to an abandoned Silence ship? Writer Gareth Roberts originally had another idea for the episode's villain: he wanted to bring back shape-shifting cactus monster Meglos, who would masquerade as the Doctor and Craig's neighbour, Mrs. Meglos.

So that's a cactus monster, in an episode with James Corden. Talk about annoying pricks.

On one level, Meglos would work quite well as a villain in The Lodger. He could easily assume the forms of the people luring unsuspecting civilians into the Doctor and Craig's building.

But while the return of Meglos amused Steven Moffat, he nixed the idea because, after the Vinvocci and Bannakaffalatta, Doctor Who didn't need any more spiky-faced creatures. Not only that, but an alien posing as a kindly old lady was basically the plot of Amy's Choice, which would've aired a few weeks prior.

Instead, Moffat suggested that the threat should be a malfunctioning time machine, something he would return to again in his era. It was a much better idea, as the sad voices on the other end of the intercom were a far more chilling threat than a cactus would've been.


5. Rose Tyler: Earth Defence

Doctor Who Rose Tyler
BBC

One of Russell T Davies' worst ideas was to develop a Rose Tyler spinoff series that would've aired on BBC One after the end of Doctor Who Series 2.

In a 2006 interview with Doctor Who Magazine, Davies said that the entire show – given the working title Rose Tyler: Earth Defence – had been commissioned by the BBC, and had even been budgeted.

The next stage would've been to secure Billie Piper's involvement, but it was then that RTD began to have second thoughts. While he watched the filming of the final scene between the Doctor and Rose in Doomsday, he realised what a terrible idea it would be to go ahead with the spinoff show.

Discussing his reasoning with DWM, Davies said:

"It spoils Doctor Who if we can see Rose... if we see as a concrete fact that her life continues to be as exciting without the Doctor."

Cancelling Earth Defence was definitely the right decision for Doctor Who, especially as Freema Agyeman had a hard enough time following Billie Piper without the former companion also having her own TV show!


4. Mark Gatiss' Doctor Who Revival

Doctor Who Mark Gatiss
BBC

When Russell T Davies brought back Doctor Who in 2005, it was zippy, vibrant, and modern. The faster pace was a breath of fresh air that reinvigorated Doctor Who for a new generation, while staying true to the show's core ethos.

However, things could have been much different.

In the early 2000s, future new series writers Mark Gatiss and Gareth Roberts, along with future Doctor Who Magazine editor Clayton Hickman, were devising their own Doctor Who reboot.

Instead of introducing the young energetic Doctor blowing up a central London department store, their pilot introduced a sixty-something Doctor working in an antique shop in a sleepy village. And instead of 13 episodes at 45 minutes, Gatiss wanted to do seven three-part serials, totalling 21 episodes!

Gatiss, Roberts, and Hickman acknowledged that they were too meek in their Doctor Who pitch, highlighting ways to save money rather than sell an exciting adventure series.

It's likely that if this version of Doctor Who had got off the ground then it would've been a fun little curio like the TV Movie. But it feels highly unlikely it would've spawned 19 years of telly.


3. Killing Off The Brigadier

Doctor Who Battlefield Seventh Doctor Brigadier
BBC Studios

Writer Ben Aaronovitch originally intended to kill off Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart in the 1989 serial Battlefield, before realising that he couldn't bring himself to do it. It's just as well, as it's hard to imagine a story that would've had the sufficient magnitude to kill off the Doctor's oldest friend.

Battlefield is a lot better than people give it credit for, and it would make a degree of thematic sense to end the Brigadier's story there. It's a story about old soldiers, and the never-ending cycles of war and violence.

However, it's also poorly directed, meaning that the darkness of the subject matter largely gets lost in the sunny scenery and slapstick battle sequences. Against that backdrop, the death of the Brigadier would've been an insult.

Aaronovitch's inability to kill the Brig meant that we never had to endure the sharp tonal gearshift from Arthurian knights trampolining over explosions, to the Doctor losing his oldest friend. Instead, the Brig went out as he always should have: peacefully.

Who knows if his corpse would've still been turned into a Cyberman. But this is terrible ideas that nearly happened, not definitely happened. So let's move on.


2. The Doctor's Rose Experiment

Doctor Who Ninth Doctor Rose
BBC Studios

Though Boom Town feels like it was always part of the Series 1 plan, it was actually a late replacement for an unusual story by Shameless creator Paul Abbott.

Abbott worked on his outline for a few weeks, which revolved around the idea that Rose had been created by the Doctor as an experiment to find the perfect companion.

First of all... what on Earth. Second of all, quite how this would’ve even worked in the context of the rest of the series is anyone’s guess. That's a pretty huge shift in the Doctor-Rose dynamic, and by that point, there were still two episodes left – not to mention Rose's return in Series 2.

It was all for nought in the end though – Abbott had to abandon the project due to other commitments, and Russell T Davies wrote Boom Town in its place.

The Ninth Doctor had a lot of darkness in him coming off the Time War, but going so far as to reveal that he bred a companion in some twisted experiment feels like a step too far.

Also, it’s bloody weird!


1. Steven Taylor Returns... AS A COW?!

Steven Taylor Doctor Who Panda Hifi The Chase
BBC

If you're ever in Cardiff very late at night and your heart is in the right place, you can sometimes hear a giant Welshman hooting in Tetleys-fuelled delight as he comes up with another insane Doctor Who concept.

This is the noise that Russell T Davies makes when he comes up with ideas like "Captain Jack is the Face of Boe" and "Sue Tech".

Thankfully, not all of Russell's late-night brainwaves have made it into the show. One particular plan to bring back Peter Purves in The Giggle was so ridiculous that it rightly received a lot of flack from David Tennant and Phil Collinson.

During the Video Commentary for The Giggle, RTD outlined his abandoned plans for a character called The Ruminant... which was a giant cow. So far, so Russell T Davies, but the giant cow would later whip off his mask like something out of Scooby-Doo, to reveal that he was none other than First Doctor companion Steven Taylor, returning to help the Doctor fight the Toymaker.

Even in an episode as insane as The Giggle, The Ruminant is clearly a step too far. Thankfully we got Steven and Vicki's Tales of the TARDIS episode instead, which was much better. Not a giant cow in sight!


Watch Next


In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Citizen of the Universe, Film Programmer, Writer, Podcaster, Doctor Who fan and a gentleman to boot. As passionate about Chinese social-realist epics as I am about dumb popcorn movies.