Gotham Season 5: 4 Ups & 1 Down From 'Pena Dura'
That ending though.
Contains spoilers from Gotham Season 5, Episode 5.
Whether you love it or hate it, there's no denying that Gotham has been anything but predictable. The hit Fox series might have been hit and miss in the past but, since the final season commenced, it's been near enough unmissable, and that doesn't change with the latest instalment, Pena Dura.
After last week's episode, Ruin, revealed Ed Nygma to be the person responsible for the heinous attack on Haven, Pena Dura sees the former crime scene investigator struggle to come to terms with his actions. Knowing full well that he's being controlled by another party, however, Ed makes it his mission to figure out what really happened to him the night the bridges blew.
Nymga isn't the only one having problems, as Bruce struggles to comprehend how Selina can be so calm about having executed Jeremiah Valeska. Speaking of the laughing maniac, there are some great twists and turns in regards to the psychopath's own narrative - all of which lead the instalment to a spectacular conclusion.
It's not a perfect instalment by any means, but a few caveats aside, there really is a lot to love about Pena Dura, and if the closing moments are anything to go by, the best is yet to come for the Fox series.
Ups...
4. Ed's Blackouts Revealed
Throughout the final season thus far, Ed Nygma has been plagued with worry over his blackouts. Unable to cope with the mystery of it all, the green-suited man decides to get some answers this week and, while the execution of said answers are a little problematic (more on that later), it's safe to say that viewers will be satisfied to have an ending to this seemingly never-ending tale.
It hasn't been all bad, as there have been plenty of enjoyable moments throughout Ed's quest for answers (the Batman Forever Easter Egg in the previous instalment, for one), but considering the series is somewhat tight for time, this storyline has carried on far too long.
This final season will contain only 12 episodes — five of which have already aired. Surely, the writers could've wrapped it up a bit quicker than that? Mind you, at this stage, let's just be thankful that we know who the perpetrator is, and that the storyline can finally get a move on.
3. Selina's Downfall
Selina has never been one to abide by the rules, but she's never killed someone. Until now, that is. After stabbing Jeremiah in the previous episode, she's hailed as a hero by many of the city's residents - including Barbara Kean. It's all pretty celebratory - until Bruce reveals his true feelings on the matter.
While some of Gotham's character development has been a bit too quick and hasty in the past, the writers have played Selina's arc out really well. Their iteration of the comic book character has never been opposed to breaking a few rules, but she's always been more good than bad, which differs greatly from the version we know from the comics.
Using Ivy's root cure as a way of allowing the character's dark side to come out is a great move on the writers' part, as it doesn't come across as a contrived personality change, but rather a believable one.
With it being Gotham's final season and all, it's possible that Selina will never be cured, as this dark side will likely separate her from Bruce's light, putting them on opposite sides of the law.
2. Nygma and Penguin's Relationship
With Gotham's ending in sight, it's nice to reminisce about all the things that made the show so great in the first place. One of these things, which we saw shades of again in Pena Dura, was Oswald's odd relationship with Nygma.
The characters shared a wonderful companionship during the third season, with Penguin even admitting that his feelings for Ed were a little more than platonic. The two characters lit up the screen together on numerous occasions, and actors Cory Michael Smith and Robin Lord Taylor's chemistry made the friendship all the more believable.
Having the two characters reunite at this late stage in the game is another stroke of genius on the writers' part, and it was no doubt very hard for viewers not to well up as the two foes came together one last time. The dialogue is tremedous here - as is the subtext.
1. Jeremiah's Twisted Plan
After months of anticipation - not to mention fears that we might not even see his plan come to light due to Gotham being in danger of cancellation - fans were understandably upset when Jeremiah was murdered by Selina in last week's episode, after an all-too-brief appearance.
Thankfully, it was all just smoke and mirrors on the antagonist's part. Turns out that he wanted Selina and Bruce to believe he was dead, as he has something much bigger planned - something that his two nemeses cannot know about yet.
You'd think the biggest takeaway from the concluding moments would be that Jeremiah is very much alive and well, but - in typical Gotham fashion - this isn't the case, as there's another twist. While we're not sure on the ins and outs of it all just yet, we're given a glimpse at the mad man's master plan for Bruce - and it seemingly involves Thomas and Martha Wayne - or people that look like them, at least.
It's a sick game Jeremiah is playing, but that's what makes it so damn brilliant. The Gotham writers sure know how to up the ante, that's sure. It's a shame that the series is on a break next week, but this conclusion is likely all the incentive viewers need to keep watching.
Downs...
1.The Problematic Resolution Of Ed's Mystery
As note earlier, it's a bit of a relief to finally have a resolution to the mystery of 'Who Messed With Ed's Mind?'. However, that's not to say said resolution was executed well, because it was a bit sloppy.
The problems aren't only resigned to the discovery of who's responsible either, as issues also arise during Ed's quest for clues. At one stage, the question-loving villain is kidnapped, tormented and electrocuted by a woman wanting revenge on behalf of her dog that was killed in Haven (for real). Sure, the scene had a bit of comedy value, but it ended up being completely pointless, and came off as nothing more than a plot device designed to drag the narrative out for a few extra minutes.
You could argue that the electrocution was necessary in Ed remembering that Oswald featured in the procedure which made alterations to his brain, but surely that could've been accomplished via another way? Another blow to the head would've sufficed - perhaps by Oswald during their altercation, or from Gordon when he attempted to arrest Nygma.
However, the problems only get worse. After it's revealed that Hugo Strange is the madman behind Ed's memory loss, the crazed doctor decides to performs more brain surgery on Ed.
The surgery was presented as a quick and minor procedure, demonstrated through the fact that the GCPD were on their way to Strange's hideout before he'd performed the procedure, and yet they arrived after it had been completed. Surely brain surgery would take a lot longer?
Moreover, Strange performed the procedure without removing any of Nygma's hair, and after putting him back together, there's not so much as a blood stain - or a loose hair - to be had. Also, apart from an initial groan, Ed seems to feel no pain after the op - and is able to get to his feet immediately. It might be Gotham we're talking about, but some degree of believability is required.
What did you make of Pena Dura? Tell us in the comment section below.