1 Up & 6 Downs From AEW Rampage (Aug 26)
CM Punk speaks; Tony Khan doesn't fix All Out; Rampage feels lifeless.
Honestly, this fan didn't expect to boot up another week of AEW Rampage and find more 'Downs' than last week's pitiful effort. Some readers may look at the counts and wonder how anyone can find six negatives from a one hour wrestling program, but the little things matter.
AEW isn't doing them very well at the moment, at least not on Fridays.
Tony Khan's latest episode dumped on a faction before then trying to paint them as a big deal for a throwaway pay-per-view match. The boss also penned yet another random title shot for somebody who doesn't deserve it, and put two bouts back-to-back that were practically identical in their presentation.
Elsewhere, a pointless tag situation summed up the messy, directionless vibe that Rampage has these days. Then, in the main event, fans looked around quizzically as the ROH World Title bout fizzled out rather than racing towards a hot conclusion.
It shouldn't fill anyone with pleasure that one really had to scrape to find any positives at all. AEW has a major pay-per-view next weekend, but the product doesn't reflect that. Not even one tiny bit.
Downs...
6. House Of Blah
You can't defend The Dark Order getting a 'surprise roll-up' win over House Of Black. Who cares about Miro's interference giving them an out? Malakai Black's crew were made to look like idiots here, and there's no justifiable excuse for why they continue to struggle against teams much lower on the food chain than them.
Brody King was challenging for the AEW World Title a short time ago, and now he can't even outmuscle 10? Come on now. This is a sad state of affairs for the group - they huff and puff against lesser teams whilst commentary pretends that nothing of the sort is happening and hypes them up.
Also, who has interest in seeing Dark Order or Best Friends (a match that'll happen next week) in the Trios Title tournament final against either The Elite or United Empire? It's gonna be Kenny Omega and The Young Bucks anyway, and they're not jobbing to either babyface threesome.
Rampage's opener was another that did HOB no favours.
5. Rankings, Tony?!
Giving Wardlow a squash match fine was fine. Fans welcomed the Ohio native home with open arms, and everyone revelled in the chance to watch him powerbomb the t*ts off some poor sap en route to another win. Giving Ryan Nemeth a TNT Title shot for no reason...wasn't fine.
What in the name of Dolph Ziggler was that all about?
Nemeth has never won a singles match on Dynamite, Rampage or AEW pay-per-view. He hasn't exactly been racking up victory after victory on YouTube shows like Dark either, so the question must be asked: Tony Khan, where the heck did you pull this championship clash from?
Wardlow's belt didn't need to be on the line here. If anything, this didn't even need to be a match. Ryan could've come out to rag on Cleveland before the TNT Champ emerged to shut him up and have a staredown with Jay Lethal, Chris Sabin and pals.
4. Back-To-Back Squashes
The fact AEW booked back-to-back squashes says it all.
There was next-to-no difference between Wardlow hammering Nemeth and Powerhouse Hobbs smashing Ashton Day. So, this writer is left with no option but to question the smarts of booking two identikit squashes in subsequent segments on such a short program. What is this? Wrestling Challenge from 1991?
Wardlow and Hobbs even performed similar foot/knee on chest finishes right at the end of their respective triumphs too. This was really the best they could come up with for both guys on the show? To that point, who knows why All Elite feels the need to have QT Marshall and The Factory poke-nose their way into Hobbs' feud with Ricky Starks.
Perhaps that's a separate whine, but it's worth talking about. QT and chums smacking Ricky in the mouth with a gold watch as Powerhouse looks on pleased makes little sense. Shouldn't Hobbs, who believes he carried Starks for the longest time, be doing the smacking himself?
3. The Point Of All This?
Ruby Soho is going nowhere in AEW.
It was super-random that she was teaming up with Ortiz in the first place (he's also lost in the shuffle), and then the pair went and lost to Sammy Guevara and Tay Melo. Yes, the latter duo are great together loved-up, obnoxious heels, but this whole exercise came out looking pointless.
Soho, who had her forearm jammed in a car door by Melo previously, didn't get a lick of revenge. Meanwhile, Chris Jericho accidentally harpooned his own match stipulation by pointing out that Ortiz' hair was starting to grow back in "after I shaved it off".
Yeah, that really showed him eh?
Interference from Angelo Parker and Anna Jay was a little too frantic to mean much too, and it's a worrying sign that AEW is starting to get rather lazy with some of these finishes. Y'know, just saying - this is a company that once prided itself on being different to WWE's more formulaic approach.
2. An Odd Finish
Dustin Rhodes is an industry treasure who deserves all the respect in the world, but he's not a great fit for main event ROH World Title matches in 2022. Well, at least not when the build is one week long and doesn't even come into play during the match itself. Where was the old stager story mid-match here?
He and Claudio Castagnoli worked a basic TV bout.
Whilst the match was hardly bad, it didn't need to happen. Also, that leapfrog low blow spot sucked the air out of the crowd before a sudden uppercut scored the win for Claudio. Was that deliberate? Unintentional? Either way, it failed to hit home with the fans. They all just sort of stood around looking miffed.
Keep in mind what this was: A RING OF HONOR WORLD TITLE MATCH. People are right to expect better from Castagnoli's title defences than this. The competitive technical showcase he worked with Konosuke Takeshita at Battle Of The Belts III worked. This did not.
1. The Overall Messy Vibe
This guy said it last week, and it's worth repeating. AEW is kinda all over the place right now - All Out is next weekend, but there's no main event set in stone yet. On TV, random wrestlers are getting shoved into random title matches without any rhyme or reason, then the announcers are crowing about bullsh*t title rankings in the very next segment.
So many workers on the roster seem rudderless/like they've got no sense of direction, and a fair few would probably be better off trying their luck in WWE. That might sound ridiculously harsh, but it's so bloody frustrating to watch Tony Khan continue to do nothing with folks like Ruby Soho when the entire wrestling community claimed she'd soar to new heights upon becoming All Elite.
That hasn't happened. She's been here for almost a year!
It's all rather concerning, to tell the truth. The sooner this gets sorted out, the better, because AEW is capable of being awesome when the roster is motivated, hungry and determined to put on a good product. Be worried for All Out. Be very worried.
Up...
1. CM Punk’s Exclusive Comments
Full transparency is important, and so is being honest. It was rather challenging to find any positives to take away from this week's Rampage whatsoever, but one short 30-second segment stood out for all the right reasons. It was one of those fly-on-the-wall moments that made fans feel like they were seeing something they weren't supposed to.
CM Punk was shown being helped back to the locker room after his bruising encounter with Jon Moxley from Wednesday's Dynamite. Then, in a neat touch, AEW kept the cameras rolling so Rampage had a killer exclusive. Punk's foot is mangled, and the once-defiant ex-champ can't hide it.
Bring on the intrigue.
Yes, it's still very annoying that All Out is next weekend and doesn't have a settled headliner, but this is a potentially-fun piece of spin off narrative. What does the future hold for Punk in AEW? Is he physically able to perform at a high level anymore? These are questions that should tick over for a while yet without the need for immediate answers, and that's a good thing.
What did you think of this weeks AEW Rampage? For more content, check out 10 Ways Triple H Has Transformed WWE In Just One Month and Madden NFL 23 Review: 3 Ups & 7 Downs!