1 Up & 5 Downs From AEW Rampage (Aug 19)

Jade Cargill goes Triple H and Tony Khan REALLY needs to rethink AEW Rampage.

Dustin Rhodes Claudio Castagnoli
AEW

Spoiler: AEW Rampage wasn't very good.

It's a bit painful to say that, because All Elite's third hour has provided bucketloads of entertainment since it launched just over one year ago. If nothing else, wrestling fans know they're going to see some fine matches when they tune into Tony Khan's programming, but...not on Friday night.

Vince McMahon has apparently traded booking WWE Raw and SmackDown for Rampage - AEW put on no less than five bouts in a one-hour show, which was at least two too many. Further problems developed when one realised that Dustin Rhodes is the new number one contender for the ROH World Championship in 2022, and that Khan rubbished his own rankings yet again.

Honestly, WWE eats a ton of sh*t from people for being all over the place at times, so it's only fair AEW gets the same treatment. Tony must sit down and properly evaluate what he hopes to achieve with Rampage, because the quality has become alarmingly erratic in recent times.

The fact there's only one positive to take away from this week's show says it all.


Downs...

5. They Gave THIS Hype?

Zack Clayton Hook
AEW

So, to recap, AEW wasted air time on last week's Rampage by setting up Hook vs. Zack Clayton. The reality TV man boldly predicted that he'd win the FTW Title during a follow-up promo on Friday, then he passed out in a submission hold just 30 seconds later.

Woohoo?

Hook should've progressed beyond these rudimentary squashes by now, to be honest. There are bigger things on the horizon for him, at least; Jericho Appreciation Society members Matt Menard and Angelo Parker cut a promo on him post-match. Still, in the short-term, the situation with Clayton was pointless.

Fans barely even reacted to Zack's promo, so it's not like Hook choking him out played before some big pop either. This is the kind of thing people might expect to see on Dark or Dark: Elevation, but it wasn't a great fit for Rampage.

Taz's boy should be past this stuff.


4. “Stand By Match Up”

Julia Hart Buddy Matthews
AEW

Excalibur then revealed that Buddy Matthews and Serpentico were waiting in the wings on the off-chance that Hook vs. Zack Clayton didn't last long. What? Wow, way to make the House Of Black member (in particular) look like he just sits around in catering waiting for the call.

Then, to top it all off, Buddy's match lasted 90 seconds.

OK, if Vince McMahon didn't replace Tony Khan in the booker's chair for this week's Rampage, one has to ask another question. Did Vince Russo take the gig instead? This is exactly the kind of mind-numbing silliness he would've put on WCW Nitro back when that show's name was mud.

Literally calling Matthews vs. Serpentico a "stand by match up" was stupid, and the fact it then flashed by in an instant is borderline laughable. Not even Miro rushing out to brawl with Buddy could save this segment from the 'Downs' section, sadly.


3. Rankings? What Rankings?

Dustin Rhodes Claudio Castagnoli
AEW

Right, here's hoping Dustin Rhodes vs. Claudio Castagnoli is a surprise package on next week's Rampage. As nice as it is that AEW wants to stand by Dustin though, something else is true: Rhodes probably shouldn't be challenging for the ROH World Title in 2022. That's quite the decision by Tony!

This isn't even part of some drawn-out retirement story, or something like that. Dustin vs. Claudio will be a routine, exhibition-style title defence for Castagnoli. It's the kind of bout that'll earn some positive tweets then be forgotten about in a fortnight.

Great. How about those famous AEW rankings, eh?!

Claudio also bungled his promo a little by making it sound like he wanted to issue an open challenge for the same night. There were audible groans when he revealed that he was actually talking about wrestling next week, which is never good for a credible babyface.

This all feels rather rushed.


2. Hmm

Best Friends AEW
AEW

This writer knows he'll catch some flak for shooting this one down, but he doesn't really care. Why? Well, there's just nothing awesome about 10-minute indy show specials in major promotions, and that's what Best Friends vs. Trustbusters was in this week's main event spot.

It didn't deserve to headline Rampage.

Some people might've enjoyed another six-man, but it felt off to this fan. He's still not convinced that AEW's product can sustain another set of titles either, especially when that means more psychology-light six-man tags on shows like Dynamite and Rampage. Can AEW give it a break with the multi-mans already?

Granted, the final few minutes of this one did pick the pace up, but it was too late. Exactly nobody outside Orange Cassidy comes across as a star in this group, and even he's struggling to remain relevant on a busy undercard.

Meh.


1. This Was Pointless

Keith Lee Swerve Strickland Private Party
AEW

F*cking hell, man - this was pointless.

Swerve Strickland and Keith Lee made a mockery of Private Party during their promo last week. The reigning AEW Tag-Team Champs openly questioned why they're even wrestling the team in the first place. Then, come bell time, Swerve and Lee slapped Party around like lowly jobbers.

The match was an absolute waste of air time (score another match for that category), being brutally honest, and it had several sloppy moments. Excalibur claiming it was some back-and-forth epic was eye-rolling too. Everyone watching has eyes, masked man!

It's free TV, sure, but one expects more from AEW Tag Title matches than this. Private Party kicking out of a few moves and then shaking hands with the champs post-loss doesn't cut it. Again, if WWE were booking Keith Lee this poorly, then everyone would be having a conniption fit, and rightly so.


Up...

1. Maximising Their Minutes

Penelope Ford Athena
AEW

Only one 'Up' this week.

Athena and Penelope Ford didn't have a lot of time to work with, and AEW gave them the dreaded picture-in-picture treatment, but both women worked hard and squeezed a lot in. It'd be sweet to see them go rematch style with a few more minutes too, because there's obvious chemistry there.

This lonely positive slips into the 'Ups' on hard graft alone. Ford deserves way more than she gets (All Elite can't be blamed for her injury layoff, to be fair), so hopefully she'll become a major presence on programming going forwards. Then, there was that post-match stuff involving Jade Cargill and her 'Baddies'.

Cargill smashed up Athena's wings with a sledgehammer, then cracked her babyface challenger in the ribs and posed with the TBS Title. Everything about the match/segment was solid and told a good story. Nobody can argue with that.

What did you think of this week's AEW Rampage? For more like this, check out 10 Wrestlers WWE Shouldn't Rehire and 3 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Rampage (Aug 12)!


In this post: 
AEW Rampage
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.