10 Disappointing Wrestling Reveals That Let EVERYBODY Down

Which reveals turned guaranteed pops into disappointed boos?

By Iain Taylor /

There's nothing quite like a great reveal in wrestling.

Advertisement

We still get goosebumps remembering the thunderous pop that greeted The Rock when he returned as WrestleMania XXVII's host, and the revelation that Hulk Hogan was the nWo's third man turned WCW from also-rans into serious threats to WWE's crown.

A good wrestling reveal is what happens when the hype balloon, having been puffed up for weeks or months on end, explodes in a roar of sound and fury, signifying greatness. A bad reveal, on the other hand, is what happens when the hype balloon doesn't so much explode as deflate limply, and the audience reaction is less "sound and fury", more "shrug and sigh".

Naturally, it's the latter type of reveal this article will be taking a look at.

Oh, and before we begin - "It's...it's Christian" will not be appearing on this list. Christian's return to WWE programming was a welcome sight for wrestling fans (even if it did happen on WWE's ill-fated ECW revival), and his arrival deserved a damn sight more excitement than that engendered by Todd Grisham's notoriouly apathetic announcement.

10. Christian Arrives In AEW

Christian's arrival in AEW, however, was a genuine disappointment.

Advertisement

Once again, Christian found his arrival stymied by forces outside his control. Except in this case it wasn't atrocious announcing that ensured the beleagured wrestler stumbled out of the starting gates - rather, it was unrealistic expectations brought about by the AEW hype machine.

To give the necessary context, AEW had recently made waves by luring Paul Wight, a.k.a. The Big Show, away from the WWE. This pilfering of a hugely recognisable talent felt like a big statement from Tony Khan’s company, but it was immediately overshadowed by Wight promising he would introduce another big name at AEW's upcoming pay-per-view.

This immediately sent the wrestling world buzzing. After all, if Paul Wight's AEW debut was mere prelude to this mysterious newcomer's arrival, then the latter had to be a bigger name, right? As such, when Christian - a great wrestler, but definitely a less well-known figure than the man brought in to announce him - came through the curtain, it was hard not to feel disappointed.

Again, this wasn't Christian's fault. If AEW hadn't made such a song and dance about their new mystery signing, Christian would have generated a huge buzz when he stepped through the curtain. Good thing AEW never made that mistake again! (Spoiler warning: they definitely made that mistake again).

9. Hornswoggle Is The Anonymous GM

RAW's year-long Anonymous General Manager saga was, like many an idea in McMahonland, a good concept marred by terrible execution - up to and including the reveal of the man behind the curtain (or under the ring, as it turned out).

Advertisement

RAW's Anonymous General Manager dictated the programming of WWE's flagship show for over a year and, while the idea of a mysterious entity running the brand was an intriguing one, the intrigue soon gave way to irritation. The GM's tendency to flip-flop between heel and face week to week - and sometimes hour to hour - meant discerning his/her identity became an exercise in frustration, which made the angle moribund long before it reached its conclusion.

As such, when the GM was outed as Hornswoggle the fan reaction was... well, Hornswoggle himself put it best on an episode of the sadly-discontinued WWE Countdown when he declared "And the crowd goes mild".

Indeed, when Hornswoggle was dragged out from his hiding place under the ring, fan reaction could best be described as "polite ambivalence". The Anonymous GM schtick had been on life support long before the storyline reached its conclusion, and Hornswoggle was not the big-name reveal needed to resusciate the dying angle.

8. Satnam Singh Sends The Crowd Home Shrugging

Pro Wrestling 101 dictates that, if you turn off the lights, you'd better have a known superstar waiting in the ring when they come back on. As such, when the arena went dark on the 13th April edition of AEW Dynamite last year, you could feel the anticipation emanating from the crowd. Which big name was about to become #AllElite?

Advertisement

Then the lights went back on and, to borrow a phrase from Todd Grisham, "It's...it's Satnam Singh".

Now, before anyone accuses us of hypocrisy for echoing the same phrase we lambasted Grisham for earlier, allow us to explain. Christian is a well-known and hugely respected figure in the world of wrestling, whose arrival merited genuine excitement. (Or at least a level of interest above "My Starbucks bill was 10¢ cheaper than I thought it'd be"). Satnam Singh, on the other hand, is a former NBA player with almost zero name-value as a wrestler.

Seriously, when the hardcore AEW fanbase finds themselves scratching their heads over a wrestler's identity, you can be sure you're looking at a true unknown.

7. Road Warrior Animal Main Events Sin 2001

The last months of WCW were a sad, sad sight for wrestling fans.

Advertisement

Only three years removed from its status as wrestling's number one production, WCW's fall from grace was as swift as it was painful. A series of inept creative and business decisions culminated in the company closing doors for good on March 26, 2001, and Sin 2001's main event proved emblematic of the company's struggles.

The match itself was promoted as Scott Steiner defending the WCW Championship against Sid Vicious, Jeff Jarrett and a "mystery opponent". Going back to watch the PPV, you can hear the audience's disappointment when that man of mystery turned out to be Road Warrior Animal.

For context, this would be like WWE headlining a PPV with a surprise appearance from D-Von Dudley. D-Von and Animal were both important parts of legendary tag teams back in the day, but that day passed a long time ago. A visibly out-of-shape tag wrestler was not going to turn WCW's fortunes around, and Animal's reveal was just another reason for the company's dwindling fanbase to see what the competition was up to.

To quote wrestling's greatest mathematician - "Change the channel to the WWF and watch Stone Cold...because WCW sucks!"

6. Savio Vega Replaces Shawn Michaels (In Texas)

Shawn Michaels may have been a notorious diva, but there's no denying that he was every bit the mega-star he thought he was. As such, when he had to bow out of 1998's No Way Out of Texas PPV it was a crushing blow for WWE fans - especially as it was to be held in Michaels' home state.

Advertisement

As you likely guessed, WWE opted to soften the blow by promising a worthy replacement. And - yep, you guessed again - that replacement's reveal dampened fan enthusiasm faster than a King Charles cameo in a porn movie. ("Lie down and think of England while I get my upper lip stiff").

For context, fans had no idea Michaels wouldn't be appearing until the day of the PPV. This meant they were already disgruntled when the show started, and when Savio Vega - a decent worker, but a perennial midcarder - walked through the door, the unfortunate wrestler was showered with boos.

One of wrestling's many maxims is to under-promise and over-deliver, and its safe to say that swapping the Heartbreak Kid for a man best known as the runner-up to the worst ever King of the Ring did exactly the opposite.

5. Paul Roma Joins The Four Horsemen

Speaking of over-promising and under-delivering...

Advertisement

When Ric Flair and Arn Anderson promised to reform the iconic Four Horsemen in 1993, the wrestling world took notice. The Four Horsemen were an integral part of the '80s wrestling landscape, and WCW fans were ecstatic at the thought of Flair, the Anderson brothers and Tully Blanchard once again wreaking havoc on the rest of the WCW roster.

What they got was Flair, the Anderson brothers... and Paul Roma.

In this case, three out of four didn't make a passing grade. Paul Roma - who had spent the majority of his career being jobbed out in the WWE - would later admit he had never watched the Four Horsemen prior to joining the group, but anyone who saw his clueless attempts to fit in could have guessed that.

Fans immediately turned on Roma, and he failed to win them back as he consistently failed to display the style, attitude, charisma and workrate that had defined the Four Horsemen when Blanchard was part of the group.

The above picture says it all - you've got the stylin' and proflin' Ric Flair; the Enforcer Arn Anderson; and Paul Roma, who looks like he's desperately trying to figure out how to do the Horsemen's signature taunt as he gives what appears to be a reversed Vulcan salute.

Beam him up, Scotty - nobody wants him here.

4. DDP Stalks His Way Into WWE

In Mick Foley's seminal first autobiography, wrestling's cuddliest icon lamented that of all the ways WCW could have brought him back into the fold after injury - either as a retribution-seeking babyface or a sadistic, unchained monster - WCW lumbered him with an utterly nonsensical, Z-level soap opera storyline. To the surprise of no-one, it failed utterly and left Mick falling down the ladder of relevancy.

Advertisement

Years later, WWE took a page out of their vanquished rivals' playbook when introducing Diamond Dallas Page to their audience, with similar results.

We'll give this to the WWE - when fans were speculating how DDP would make his entrance in WWE, few predicted that it would be as a deranged stalker tormenting the Undertaker's then-wife Sara. Fewer still would have guessed the former WCW man's motivation - that he thought a match with the Undertaker would "Make (him) famous!".

It's safe to say that WWE fans were on different wavelengths/drugs to WWE Creative, as the idea bombed horribly - especially as DDP ended up getting annihilated by the Undertaker, as well as Sara herself. Even the most stalwart WWE fan knew who Page was (as seen by the huge pop on his reveal), and that he deserved better than being a whipping post for Undertaker to work out his insecurities on.

3. No Monè, Mo' Problems

The garishly-dressed audience member in the above photo is correct - the Saraya/Baker/Mystery Partner angle was, indeed, baka.

Advertisement

AEW really only have themselves to blame here. Weeks of nudge-nudge, wink-wink promos ("I'm The BOSS") fuelled fan specualtion that WWE's Sasha Banks - now going by Mercedes Monè - would be Saraya's tag partner against the duo of Britt Baker and Jamie Hayter. Indeed, fans were so expectant of this result that when Toni Storm announced herself as Saraya's partner the week before the bout, many thought it was just another ruse from the company to hide Mercedes' arrival.

It wasn't. Toni walked out to what we can best describe as "polite displeasure" - the audience knew Toni had been put in a bad spot, so didn't turn on her as vociferously as you might think, but they clearly weren't happy.

What really sent them over the edge was when the arena went dark after the match and AEW - having apparently learned nothing from the Satnam Singh debacle - left the audience with... the AEW Rampage logo playing on the tron.

Fool us once, AEW...

2. Ric Flair Is The Black Scorpion

To end this article, we'll take a look at a brace of wrestling reveals that are classics of their kind, in the same sense that Plan 9 From Outer Space is a classic of cinema. (For younger fans, Plan 9 was essentially The Room of its day).

Advertisement

We previously mentioned WCW's love for convoluted plots, and the Black Scorpion was the company at its best-worst self. For months, WCW's Sting had been tormented by a nefarious figure known as the Black Scorpion who, like the best cartoon villains, would always escape the hero's clutches just before being unmasked.

The problem with the angle was that nobody - not even the writers - knew who the Black Scorpion was. WCW being what it was, when the time came to end the angle they landed on the most nonsensical option available - Ric Flair.

When the Black Scorpion faced Sting at Starrcade 1990, the audience immediately smelled a rat. Not only did the Scorpion look substantially different to his prior appearances, it was obvious that it was Ric Flair under the mask (that's what happens when you put one of wrestling's biggest stars in a mask that only covers half his face).

If you're wondering why Flair was such a bad choice, read the previous sentence - he was one of the biggest stars in wrestling! Not only that, he and Sting had a long and storied history to work with. If WCW had wanted to drum up PPV buys, all they needed to do was have Flair tell Sting, "You. Me. Starrcade".

Not for nothing did this once stand as the worst reveal in wrestling history...

1. Vince McMahon Is The Higher Power

...until WWE stole the crown on one of RAW's most infamous episodes.

Advertisement

To explain the much-maligned Higher Power storyline in a nutshell - Vince McMahon spent much of 1999 being terrorised by the Ministry of Darkness who, among other things, kidnapped his daughter and attempted to sacrifice her to a "Higher Power" in a quasi-Satanic ritual. The twist? Vince McMahon was the Higher Power, and he did it all to... *sigh*...mess with Steve Austin.

If that was painful to read, it was even worse experiencing it live. Even as a callow 12 year old, this writer felt cheated to have sat through months of Buffy-lite stupidity for that pay-off. McMahon was the CEO of the company! He'd been feuding with Austin for over a year! On what planet was Vince kidnapping his daughter and mentally scarring her for life the logical escalation of his beef with Stone Cold?

Oh well. The one consolation was that WWE learned their lesson, and Vince never again declared himself to be the the unassailable mastermind of an infamously malicious organization.

Advertisement