10 Genius Ways Wrestlers Proved The Critics Wrong

Galaxy-brained responses to basic-level criticism.

By Iain Taylor /

It's safe to say that if you want to become a professional wrestler, you need to develop a thick skin towards criticism. This is especially true for today's wrestlers who, after every match/TV appearance/sighting at a local supermarket, can look forward to a barrage of critiques on social media about their ring-work, promo skills or purchasing habits ("They bought normal Coke instead of Diet? IT'S LIKE THEY'RE NOT EVEN TRYING ANYMORE!")

Advertisement

Having said that, criticism of wrestlers isn't exactly the sole domain of bored internet trolls. Way before Facebook was a gleam in Zuckerberg's cold, lifeless eyes, wrestling audiences were chanting "DIE ROCKY DIE" at the seemingly hopeless Rocky Maivia, and Bret Hart was seen by Vince McMahon himself as not a big enough name to wrestle in Madison Square Garden.

Naturally, both those wrestlers proved their critics wrong. And, in the decades since, many other wrestlers have joined Bret and Rocky in forcing their critics to eat a big helping of humble pie. (Although The Rock is the only one who made the critics turn the pie sideways and... well, you know the rest).

So, let's kick off the list in style by taking a look at how one of the biggest names in wrestling shut down one of the sport's longest-serving chants...

10. John Cena's Open Match Challenge

"YOU CAN'T WRESTLE!" *clap-clap-clapclapclap* "YOU CAN'T WRESTLE!" *clap-clap-clapclapclap*

Advertisement

This chant dogged John Cena for ?????. After becoming the face of the company by dethroning JBL at WrestleMania 21, wrestling audiences rebelled against the former fan-favourite in vicious fashion. Like a Manchester United board member, John essentially spent ten years being told by the fans that he sucked at his job. The difference being, John Cena actually quelled fan dissatisfaction through his seminal US Open Challenge series.

After taking the US Title off Rusev at WrestleMania 31, Cena became a fighting champion and spent months on RAW defending the belt against any and all challengers. To the surprise of many, the results were spectacular. As well as putting in surprisingly enjoyable matches against midcard no-hopers like Zack Ryder and Stardust, Cena put on genuine Match of The Year contenders against Sami Zayn and Cesaro. The challenge also ignited his superlative feud against Kevin Owens, which helped cement KO as a genuine main-event level talent.

Cena followed his stellar 2015 with a cracking feud against AJ Styles the following year, finally putting a conclusive end to the chant that had followed him since his first World Championship win.

9. The Kabuki Warriors - No English, No Problem

It's safe to say the Asuka and Kairi Sane didn't have the best of starts to their life as a tag team.

Advertisement

Everything about the Kabuki Warriors - losing their first title match, being off TV for months and being given the laziest theme music in wrestling history (it was literally Asuka and Kairi's themes flipping back and forth every 15 seconds) - suggested that the team weren't exactly priority no.1 for WWE's booking committee.

The notoriously promo-centric WWE obviously thought a non-English speaking duo would struggle to get over, yet something miraculous happened. After turning heel the Kabukis began speaking exclusively in Japanese and, to the surprise of many, began getting cheered by crowds who had no idea what they were saying.

Turns out, if you have sufficient charisma (and Asuka and Kairi have it in spades), what you say isn't as important as how you say it. Wrestling fans respond to passion, and the Kabukis sheer delight in delivering promos in their native tongue allowed them to engage with the audience despite the language barrier.

8. Randy Orton Bleeds For His Art

With Randy Orton making wrestling fans' hearts grow fonder through his lengthy absence, it's fitting to go back to the time he began winning the WWE audience over.

Advertisement

When a young Randy burst onto the scene in the early noughties, he didn't immediately endear himself to the public. An obviously talented worker, Orton nonetheless suffered from the perception that he was coasting by on his family name and favouritism (joining a stable led by the notoriously over-pushed Triple H didn't help in that regard).

Mick Foley, as was his wont, took it upon himself to improve the fans' perception of Randy. And, as was Mick's other wont, he did so through violence.

Orton and Foley's hardcore match at Backlash 2004 acted as a coming of age party for the younger superstar. Brilliantly, Orton allowed himself to look like a total putz at the start of the match - his barbed wire 2x4 unravelled almost instantly, and he looked like a terrified extra in a slasher movie. However, as the match progressed Orton grew into it, taking some hellacious bumps (including a particularly nasty thumbtack spot) and transforming from a generic horror movie victim into the heroic Final Girl (or Guy, in this case).

By the end of the match, Orton had not only slain his dragon but shown that he was willing - and capable - of putting his body on the line to create magic. As star-making performances go, there have been few better.

7. Xavier Woods Risks It All For New Day

Give how universally beloved New Day are now, newer wrestling fans would be stunned to learn just how loathed the stable was for the first year of its existence.

Advertisement

Initially conceived as a happy-clappy cheerleader group, New Day's Power of Positivity schtick was inch-deep, one-dimensional and about as well-received as a skin fungus. Xavier Woods knew the group were dying a death, and that's when he audaciously put his career on the line in a conversation with Vince McMahon.

Per ComicBook, Xavier told Vince that if he couldn't get the fans to boo Kofi Kingston - who'd spent five years as the quintessential WWE babyface - then there were "60 dudes in developmental that deserve this spot more than I do". A bold claim, but fortunately for us (less fortunately for those 60 hopefuls), Xavier accomplished his mission by being his best/worst self.

Xavier worked a masterclass in becoming a Jimmy Hart-style irritating loudmouth whose incessant crowing about his buddies caused the fans to turn on them by default. Not only that, but his addition of playing a trumpet - badly - during matches turned the New Day into WWE's most entertainingly obnoxious heels, paving the way for their face turn and the "New Day Rocks!" chants that continue to this day.

Wrestling is notorious for the cliques (or Kliqs) it develops, but few wrestlers have ever gone to bat as hard as Xavier did for his friends.

6. Chris Jericho Makes The List

Frankly, the number of times Chris Jericho has counfounded the critics could be a list in and of itself. But for now, let's take a look at one of his finest rebuttals to the claim that the former Y2J was a spent force.

Advertisement

When Jericho made one of his semi-regular returns to the WWE at the start of 2016, he brought with him some serious "dad at the school disco" energy. Awkward skits alongside the now-popular New Day, and his cringeworthy attempts at getting "Rooty, Tooty Booty" over as a catchphrase, made Jericho seem like a washed-up rocker trying to show the cool kids he's still got it.

And then he made The List. (Granted, there was some other stuff in between - his misguided feud against AJ Styles and short-lived rivalry with Dean Ambrose - but The List was when the Jericho magic of old returned).

The List was such a simple concept - of ?????? someone as petty and vindictive as Jericho would keep a physical reminder of those who'd wronged him - but it worked beautifully. Chris and his clipboard became the highlight of every show they were on, and fans embraced "You just made The List!" every bit as fervently as they had rejected "Rooty, Tooty Booty".

5. Matt Hardy Breaks Out Of His Brother's Shadow

It's tough living in your sibling's shadow.

Advertisement

For years, popular perception of the Hardy Boys was that younger brother Jeff was the cool, maverick daredevil people paid to see, and Matt was... Jeff's brother. (Hell, it's a view still held by some of wrestling's more controversial podcasters).

However, in 2016 Matt did the impossible. Not only did he become a bigger name than his brother, he became the most-talked about man in professional wrestling when he popularized Cinematic Wrestling with The Final Deletion.

An absolutely bonkers "match" involving fireworks, drones and the world's most conveniently placed boat, The Final Deletion should have become the biggest joke in the industry. Instead, thanks to Matt's total commitment to the bit it became the biggest thing in wrestling when it dropped, and kickstarted a resurgence in Matt's career that culminated in him and Jeff Hardy making one of the WWE's most electric returns.

Cinematic Wrestling itself seems to have been quietly retired after 2020 overdosed fans on the format, but The Final Deletion deserves to be remembered. Not only was it a highlight in the long history of professional wrestling, it showed that Matt Hardy has always been more than his brother's keeper.

4. Eddie Kingston Takes His Shot

Sometimes, a person can be their own worst critic.

Advertisement

Such was the case with Eddie Kingston who, in a shockingly raw self-penned article, described his struggles with mental health and depression. Watching former colleagues like CM Punk and Kevin Owens hit the big time in the WWE made Eddie feel inadequate about his own standing as a professional wrestler and, like many people in his profession before him, he attempted to numb his feelings through alcohol.

Fortunately, Eddie had good people in his corner who carried him through the worst days of his life until he came across the opportunity he needed.

After cutting a typically passionate promo during an independent show in Jersey, footage of Eddie shooting his mouth off made it all the way to Cody Rhodes (back in the latter's AEW days). Cody invited Eddie to AEW for a promo and a match (the pro wrestling equivalent to dinner and a date) and, after some encouragement from the late, great Brodie Lee, Eddie tore the house down with Dusty's progeny on national television.

The match and promo formed a one-two combo that ultimately led to Eddie getting signed by AEW, and since then Eddie has excelled as the promotion's ultimate every-man hero - the guy who's taken all life can throw at him but refuses to back down because of it.

3. The Young Bucks Sell Like Michael Scott

Where would wrestling be today without the Young Bucks?

Advertisement

It's an intriguing question, as Matt and Nick Jackson have already crafted a legacy in the business few other tag teams can compete with. As well as playing key roles in the founding of AEW, the Bucks' chaotic everything-everywhere-all at once style of wrestling - where they wrestle each match like their loved ones will explode if they don't fit in every single idea that pops into their heads - has led to some of the most wildly entertaining matches in wrestling history.

It's also encouraged the idea that Matt and Nick can't sell for toffee which is - respectfully - utter nonsense. Matt Jackson in particular has been selling the same back injury he picked up in NJPW for ???? ?????. A career spent being thrown about like an unwanted toy in a pram has led to Matt's spine being a more obvious weak spot than a glowing red button in a video-game boss fight, and Matt sells that peril to perfection in every big match he's in.

The Young Bucks may not be to everyone's tastes, but they didn't get to where they are through good luck and colourful tassels. They're damn good wrestlers first and foremost, and that includes the ability to sell like a weed dealer at Woodstock.

2. Tetsuya Naito Becomes Ingobernable

Does anyone else remember Kane's "Embrace The Hate" campaign? No, not the noxious nonsense the current Mayor of Knoxville spews on Twitter, but his attempt back in 2012 to do the impossible and turn John Cena heel. Kane failed, of course, but somewhere in Japan a young Tetsuya Naito took heed of his advice and earmarked it for future use should his own babyface run hit the skids. (???????? ??????)

Advertisement

And hit the skids it most certainly did. When NJPW tried to turn Naito into the promotion's next babyface hero, the company's famously respectful fans made a rare show of open dissent. Naito was showered with boos wherever he went and, unlike Cena, Naito decided to fully embrace the hate.

Naito's transformation into the leader of Los Ingobernables de Japon (still one of the best stable names in wrestling) revitalized his flagging career. Espousing the virtues of being "Tranquilo" - a.k.a. not giving a single, solitary toss about what other people thought of him - Naito became NJPW's resident bad boy. And, like many a bad boy before him, Naito's heinous acts couldn't hide the fact that his newfound attitude had turned him into the coolest man in the building. This, ironically, lead to the same fans who booed him as a babyface to cheer him as a heel.

A state of affairs which might seem familiar to those who've been following WWE for the past few years...

1. Roman Reigns Becomes The Heel He Was Born To Be

ACKNOWLEDGE HIM!

Advertisement

*Ahem*. Sorry about that. This writer seldom marks out for anyone these days, but will always make an exception for the WWE's resident Tribal Chief, Roman Reigns.

Roman's story is similar to that of Naito's - an over-pushed babyface finally hits his stride after a much-needed heel turn - but there are some differences. Most notable is that while Naito specifically blamed the fans for making him break bad, Roman's turn to the dark side had very little to do with the WWE audience, and everything to do with embracing who he truly is.

Truthfully, Roman never worked as the babyface WWE pushed him as. This writer has said it before, but WWE's "Big Dog" nickname for Roman never made sense when the company was dead set on pushing him as the underdog in every major feud he was in. And Roman being the underdog never made sense because he's an extremely talented, genetically gifted, broodingly charismatic hunk of a man.

It was impossible to ever view Roman as an every-man hero, because he isn't every man. He is a megastar, through and through - the kind of man who knows every eye is on him whenever he enters the room, and revels in the fact. It's what makes him the biggest star in the WWE, a fact that Roman is fully aware of and exploits to his full advantage in his storyline role as the Tribal Chief.

Some people are born to be stars in this business, and Roman Reigns became his best self when WWE let him - and us - acknowledge this simple fact.

Advertisement