10 Most Shocking WWE Transformations Since 2020

Who changed the most during four years of Roman Reigns-led WWE dominance?

By Jamie Kennedy /

Roman Reigns was the name on everyone's lips between 2020-2024. He was WWE's main star despite working a part-time schedule, and his value went through the roof thanks to unmatched performances as the heel 'Tribal Chief'. 2020 feels like it happened 10 minutes ago, but a lot more has changed in those four years than you might expect.

Advertisement

A collection of key wrestlers totally transformed in that timeframe, for example.

There were some ground rules here. Firstly, anyone included had to be on WWE's books at time of writing. That means no place for current AEW names like Adam Copeland or Toni Storm. Yes, they've both changed a lot, but they're on Tony Khan's roster not Triple H's.

Second, there is scope for those going the other way. One standalone champion went from AEW > WWE during Roman's sensational title saga, and you might be surprised by how different things were for him back in 2020. Let's just say he made an aesthetic decision that All Elite fans didn't necessarily get!

Right, who's changed the most since Reigns was returning to action in the summer of 2020?

10. JD McDonagh

NXT UK was the then-Jordan Devlin's home brand in 2020. Back then, most fans who did watch the Brit-based show probably thought that was JD's ceiling in the company. Nope. He'd move to NXT proper in 2022, then started hanging around Judgment Day on Raw in 2023. Since then, he's been in one of the best spots possible on weekly WWE TV.

Advertisement

McDonagh was an unwanted nuisance to other stable members like Damian Priest and Rhea Ripley at first, but he'd eventually become a fully-fledged part of the team. Currently, he's part of the revamped Judgment Day alongside Finn Bálor, Dominik Mysterio, Liv Morgan and Carlito.

The good times keep rolling.

During Roman's time on top, McDonagh went through a name change, several brand switches, and totally rocked up his look to fit in with Judgment Day. He's also gone on to enjoy a World Tag-Team Title run alongside mentor Bálor. Life is good for someone who once seemed an unlikely fit for WWE's main roster.

9. Karrion Kross

Karrion Kross must've hated his first stab at Raw in 2021.

Advertisement

It was miserable, and involved Kross dressing up like a knock-off mix between Shredder from TMNT and Demolition. If that sounds cool in theory, then just know that...it wasn't. Karrion had been a top star on NXT, but then Vince McMahon got his creative mitts on the guy and ruined all that potential.

Karrion's career has been all about recovery ever since. Thankfully, there are signs that he'll get back to his best and make something of this second go-around on the flagship. Triple H certainly seems to get Kross more than his father-in-law did. The shaven-headed Killer Kross look is gone too - it's been replaced by long hair and an almost Sean O'Haire circa 2003 aesthetic.

What a journey Karrion has been on since 2020. He's been NXT Champ several times, a laughing stock on the main roster, released, brought back, on/off pushed again and a stable leader. Finding his groove on the midcard is working out too.

8. Seth Rollins

Pictured on the left: Miserable 'Monday Night Messiah' Seth Rollins. That late-2019 rebrand was Seth's bid to find himself again after an initially-great babyface run turned into a nightmare. He can blame Hell In A Cell 2019 and other crappy booking for that. Things got so bad that Rollins simply had to turn heel.

Advertisement

He couldn't be anymore different in 2024.

Today, Seth is prone to wearing outfits so garish they'd make Randy Savage or Liberace heave if they were around to see them. He's turned the silly dial all the way up to rock everything from huge devil horns and see through mesh to elaborate gowns and a pumped up referees outfit.

Seth blatantly borrowed from Becky Lynch's wardrobe for some of this. It can't be a coincidence that 'Big Time Becks' was wearing some outlandish gear then her hubby literally followed suit. The gruff and down-tuned ring attires of 2020 are a thing of the past for a dude who officially made "Freakin" part of his name.

7. Cody Rhodes

OK, so admittedly Cody Rhodes didn't sport the brown/black hairdo for too long. He was actually trying to mimic Clark Kent in 'The Return Of Superman', but it fell flat with AEW's audience and the bleach blonde was back before anyone knew it. Still, things were rather different for Cody in 2020.

Advertisement

He was in All Elite for a start.

Nobody could've known that Rhodes would bolt from a promotion he helped start by 2022 and rejoin the WWE machine. To that point, few could've guessed that Cody would be the man to end Roman Reigns' peerless title run after back to back WrestleMania main events. That's quite the turnaround from wrestling Angelico and Warhorse on Dynamite.

Forget the obvious hair colour thing for a second. Something else is true: Rhodes is much happier riding high on top of WWE than he ever looked in AEW at any point post-2020. He was already hearing scattered boos from fans in 2021, but only hears booming cheers today.

6. Nikki Cross

From coffee dates with Alexa Bliss to tortured screams in the Wyatt Sicks.

Advertisement

That's the sweeping change Nikki Cross has experienced over the past four years, and she's even found time to be an almost superhero too. Yes, apologies for reminding everybody about Nikki A.S.H. It was a bold idea, but it was never going to reinvent the wheel; WWE were always going to get bored of something so saccharine.

Cross was totally lost on the roster before signing on as part of the Uncle Howdy-led Bray Wyatt tribute faction. She plays the role of Abby The Witch/Sister Abigail, but hasn't actually wrestled under the guise quite yet. Nikki's last match came in November 2023 - it was a Battle Royal, if you're wondering.

She's gone from beaming smiles and energetic, Duracell-bunny performances that entertained Michael Cole to donning a mask and appearing largely expressionless. A gig's a gig, although Cross will have to do some wrestling again at some stage.

5. Dexter Lumis

Dexter Lumis was a curious face on NXT befo...BLOODY HELL! That can't be considered a glow up, but it's some change in look if nothing else. Dex had slicked back hair and a moustache on the third brand, and carried that look over to Raw following a release and return in 2022.

Advertisement

The Lumis gimmick didn't really go anywhere on the main roster, and big Dexter faded into the background off TV. Triple H made the call to bring him back into the mix as Mercy The Buzzard in Uncle Howdy's Wyatt Sicks faction. He's a bodyguard at best, but will presumably work some matches again in the future.

Again, you've got to take what you can get sometimes.

Lumis has grown his hair and beard out, and managed to trim down some size. He's still jacked, but he's definitely leaner than he was before. On TV, Dexter typically wears the Mercy mask, but he has been spotted more often without it in recent weeks.

Quite the change.

4. Bo Dallas

Final Wyatt Sicks entry here, and a good one.

Advertisement

Bo Dallas was still on WWE's books as calendars turned to 2020, but he wasn't really being used. The promotion eventually let him go in 2021, and it looked like that was curtains on any Bo-lieving fans were hoping to do. Or not. Dallas returned to the fold when his brother Bray re-signed in 2022.

His new character was the mysterious Uncle Howdy, but that wouldn't go anywhere serious before Wyatt's untimely death in August 2023. Nowadays, Bo's apparent main motivation for being in WWE is to pay tribute to his sibling by continuing the Howdy gimmick and splicing in little splashes of Bray's 'Fiend' for good measure.

The guise requires a radical overhaul of Bo's look. He appears as normal in backstage promos, but then takes on the long blonde-haired and masked look of Howdy in front of crowds. It's dramatic. It's also unclear how long a shelf life all of this has, but seeing Dallas change things up and pay homage to Bray is good for the soul.

3. Rhea Ripley

Rhea Ripley has always been open and honest about feeling the need to fit into WWE's preconceived notions of what female wrestlers should look like. The Diva days hangover was still lingering when she signed in 2017. Things had changed, but Rhea believed she'd have a better chance of making it if she had long blonde hair.

Advertisement

In short, she didn't feel comfortable being herself and experimenting with a look.

That'd change. By 2020, Ripley was NXT Women's Champ and had more confidence. Her short-haired rocker look grabbed attention, but that was only the beginning. Over the next four years, Rhea dabbled with a few other hairstyles and outfits, but doubled down on the goth vibes when creating the 'Mami' character for Judgment Day.

Today, Ripley knows she's in control of her image. Her striking appearance is one of wrestling's best, and it's helped turn Rhea into a 'Terror Twin' (alongside Damian Priest) who draws favourable comparisons to Chyna. Rhea will probably change again, but she's struck gold with her current look.

2. GUNTHER

Now there's a glow up.

Advertisement

WALTER (he likes the all caps thing) was a record-setting NXT UK Champion back in 2020. However, there were rumblings behind the scenes that the big Austrian didn't want to commit to working for other WWE brands. Privately, WALTER didn't want to move to the United States full-time either. He'd have to if he wanted to shoot up the ladder.

Things eventually changed, and dramatically so. WALTER landed on NXT proper, changed his name to GUNTHER and remarkably never looked back.

Even reports that Vince McMahon wasn't keen couldn't stop him from eventually hitting the main roster and working a historic, lengthy Intercontinental Title reign that not-so-coincidentally took place almost entirely after the former Chairman resigned in disgrace for the first time.

Physically, GUNTHER worked hard to change his physique. He dropped weight, added lean muscle, and managed to maintain his aura into the bargain. 

1. Dominik Mysterio

It's an age old tale. Boy starts to resent dad > boy meets Rhea Ripley > boy gets corrupted by her influence > boy joins Judgment Day > boy becomes one of the hottest heat-seekers in the biz > boy completes transition into Eddie Guerrero. Did anyone see that coming for Dominik Mysterio when he was teaming with Rey in 2020?!

Advertisement

You won't be booed out of the building if you try to speak. Go on.

Seriously though, what a ride this has been for 'Dirty' Dom over the past four years. He's gone from string bean with the boyish good looks to one of WWE's best heels and a key member in Judgment Day. The Guerrero nod is fantastic, and so is Mysterio moving on from Rhea to current girlfriend Liv Morgan.

There's a reason workers like Cody Rhodes are full of praise for Dom Dom. He's grown into his skin as a WWE star. Being honest, there were signs that he'd do so when he was working bangers vs. Seth Rollins back in 2020. Man's a natural, and there's so much more to come from him.

Which other WWE stars transformed between 2020-2024? For more wrestling, check out 10 Unlikely Wrestling Faction Members That Totally Worked and 10 Things You Didn't Know About The WWE Title! 

Advertisement