10 Wrestlers WWE Has Given Up On

Has Vince McMahon mentally written off ex-WWE Champions and fan favourites?

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE burns through a ton of pro wrestlers, but this isn't a new thing. What feels fresh and exciting in Vince McMahon's company suddenly becomes old overnight, at least internally - it's a constant pursuit for the shiny new toy. Who, after all, is going to be the "next Hulk Hogan/Steve Austin/John Cena"?

Advertisement

McMahon is obsessed with this.

Of course, creating money-drawing superstars isn't a bad thing. There's a sense that WWE has forgotten how to do this though, especially on the babyface side. Wrestlers are met with unrealistic expectations, handed page after page of scripted promos that prioritise verbatim over organic performances and more.

Sink once, or fail to do what the boss demands, and the road to relevance becomes even harder. Christ only knows what's actually been said about the workers on this list backstage, but their TV output and downward slides as characters show that they're not exactly Vince's favourites.

Is there a way back? For some, possibly. For others, as McMahon's entrance theme barks, there's just "no chance in hell". WWE has already given up on them, and the booking proves it.

10. Mustafa Ali

An obvious starting point.

Advertisement

Mustafa Ali is currently locked in a stand-off with WWE. He's had enough and wants out, but they don't seem super-keen to cut him loose despite releasing everybody and their dog throughout 2021. It's a weird situation, and one that probably won't end with a Raw or SmackDown comeback.

Truthfully, the creative team had seemed to give up on Ali before he started shouting from the rooftops about his desire to leave WWE. That Retribution nonsense was horrible, and his tag-team with Mansoor went absolutely nowhere too. The dude was pretty directionless as a character, which is a real shame for someone so clearly talented.

That superhero-like gimmick Mustafa was playing before he took charge of the world's worst faction was promising to fair, and yet that seems like it happened a lifetime ago. There's only one solution here: Ali leaving WWE behind and going on to pastures new.

9. Cedric Alexander

Poor Cedric Alexander might have to follow suit, because his opportunities are more limited than ever under Vinnie Mac's watch. The former Cruiserweight has gone from flying high as part of The Hurt Business to jobbing on episodes of Main Event that nobody really pays attention to.

Advertisement

That's quite the tumble.

Most recently, Alexander did the honours for NXT 2.0's LA Knight on the 'C' show. That, more than anything, should let him know that he's someone WWE don't see as a prospect. The company might as well send Cedric a Twitter DM that says, "we're not pushing you lol". At least then he'd know once and for all.

The side issue Alexander worked with Shelton Benjamin, during which he ridiculed Shelty B for being old (how dare he) failed to reap any rewards either. In fact, it was so nondescript that WWE forgot about it when they reunited the pair as a tag-team shortly thereafter.

8. Mansoor

Mansoor's positional switch from 'designated local hero on Saudi Arabian stadium shows' to full-time Raw/SmackDown man hasn't really worked. It was never going to once WWE established their grand plan for the man's character; the bright-eyed and bushy-tailed Mansoor was treated like this was his first day on the job.

Advertisement

Backstage skits with The Viking Raiders and Mustafa Ali painted him like a total moron who could barely find the building without a step-by-step guide from his peers. It was a weird choice to portray someone you're already calling a "WWE Superstar" as a lowly scrub who barely knew where the locker rooms were.

That pattern has continued since May 2021, and it shows no signs of stopping. Mansoor's only story to date has been falling for Mustafa's tricks, which also made him look like WWE's resident thick babyface. Now, the promotion's top brass don't even seem interested in developing that persona.

He's in no man's land.

7. Los Lotharios

Individually, Angel Garza and Humberto Carrillo were floundering. WWE's...unique decision to have Angel shove roses down everyone's pants was odd, and so was Jerry Lawler once describing Carrillo as a "Mexican Justin Bieber". Oooooooh boy, who knows what the 'King' was on about there?!

Advertisement

Angel and Humberto eventually came together as 'Los Lotharios'. The handsome pair handsome'd much harder than most men could handsome, but that has become their only identifiable trait. At first, it seemed like this might be enough to steal some success on SmackDown as a heel duo, but no.

These Lotharios have been squashed flat and turned into a loser tag-team.

WWE's booking has been seriously counterproductive too. Angel and Humberto targeted Shinsuke Nakamura and Rick Boogs (who aren't even a full-time tag) at first, then got creamed whenever they stepped in there against proper units. A two-minute loss to The Viking Raiders on the most recent SmackDown says it all.

6. Ricochet

Shoots of recovery followed by crashing lows.

Advertisement

That could summarise Ricochet's main roster WWE run. This is a guy who has wrestled Brock Lesnar (well, been hammered by Brock) and put on some dazzling displays, but is also seemingly overlooked because he isn't The Rock when holding a mic in his hands.

Look at the high-flyer's recent fortunes for proof of his topsy turvy WWE career. One week, Rico was working a solid match with the ever-dependable Sheamus. He lost, but got a nice response from the live crowd and it seemed to be something he could build on. Exactly one week later, Ricochet was squashed by the same opponent and looked every bit like some local enhancement talent who'd been drafted in for a one-off shot.

This useless approach reeks, and it's hardly giving Ricochet a fighting chance to get over. Although the writers know he's someone who will give them a good match, they point blank refuse to go further with things.

5. Apollo Crews

Apollo Crews embraced the potentially-calamitous decision to work a Nigerian accent last year. He put his all into the character from the off, and has tried his best to overcome the familiar 'hot or cold but no in between' WWE booking. Did that dedication get him anywhere? Nah, not really.

Advertisement

You could probs chuck Commander Azeez into this story too, but sheer physical size will land him at least one more gig in WWE once he eventually splits from Crews. Meanwhile, Apollo will either denounce his "Nigerian royalty" gimmick as a temporary blip and seek babyface approval again or continue faltering as an under-utilised heel.

That's a crap position to be in.

His Intercontinental Title reign was a miserable flop too. Nobody's blaming Crews for this - WWE seemed to feature him less after bagging the belt, which is astounding, and there wasn't much he could do about that. The promotion gave up on Apollo whilst he was still champ.

4. Shinsuke Nakamura

What is it with the IC Title and WWE disinterest?

Advertisement

Shinsuke Nakamura has defended the prize once since winning it in August 2021. ONCE! That sole title defence came on the 24 September SmackDown against former champ Apollo Crews, and that's just sad. At time of writing, it's been 124 days since Naka put that thing up for grabs on television. Wow.

He has worked IC Title bouts on house shows, but let's get real here - WWE don't give a toss about the secondary strap, and they haven't done since Big E dropped it to Apollo at WrestleMania 37 in that humdrum 'Nigerian Drum Fight'. If they did, then Shin wouldn't be carting it around like a fan fresh from the WWE Shop sales.

Nakamura's Intercontinental reign is a disgrace to that title, but it's symptomatic of where he is in WWE circles nowadays. Rick Boogs' pal is on the periphery for sure, and that ain't about to change. His next stop is surely losing the belt to Sami Zayn, then falling further into the mire.

3. Shayna Baszler

One well-known McMahon test is for wrestlers to prove that they have personality. Sure, they might be able to put on solid matches, but can they sports entertain? That's what Vince what's to know, and it's presumably why he had ex-MMA hard nut Shayna Baszler sh*t bricks over Alexa Bliss' little dolly over on Raw last year.

Advertisement

Remarkably, that didn't kill off Baszler's interest in wrestling. Even more amazingly, Shayna actually defended the creative process and said she enjoyed being pulled from her comfort zone in those mega-cheesy skits. This is a guess, but Baszler probably isn't enjoying doing sod all on SmackDown.

She's criminally overlooked.

Since moving brands, Shayna has become on/off involved in Sonya Deville's issues with Naomi. That hasn't been a consistent spot though, and Baszler has vanished into thin air. She's gone AWOL. One of the best women WWE has on tap hasn't wrestled a TV match since mid-December.

2. Jinder Mahal

2017: Jinder Mahal shocks everyone by becoming WWE Champion and embarking on a 170-day reign that nobody could've predicted. His push came out of nowhere like a Randy Orton RKO, which is fitting - Randy was the man Jinder beat to win the big one.

Advertisement

2022: Jinder teams with his big mate Shanky and the pair occasionally rap like a pair of goofs for no real reason whatsoever. Also, this comes hot on the heels of Mahal looking second-rate next to old 3MB buddy Drew McIntyre back at SummerSlam 2021.

What a contrast, one that proves how far Jinder has fallen down the importance scale since receiving the biggest push of his entire career. Injuries have plagued him, no doubt, but WWE don't seem to view Mahal as anything other than a lower-card act these days anyway.

They've given up on presenting him as a serious threat to...well, anybody. He raps, he loses and he rants. That's it.

1. Cesaro

It was 2015 when Vince McMahon sat down with Steve Austin on WWE Network and outright said that he didn't view Cesaro as a draw. Seven years on, the Swiss wrasslin' machine is still on company books and still working tremendous matches when he's given time to.

Advertisement

That's really key, 'cause Cesaro is wasted when he's teaming with Mansoor in short efforts (like he did on SmackDown recently) or expected to be some promo king. Speaking isn't his key strength, so it's maddening that WWE keep trying to force that side of things; Cesaro isn't awful on the mic either, by the way, but he's never going to be John Cena.

It does suck, however, that Cesaro has gone from working opposite Seth Rollins and Roman Reigns in hot matches to teaming with Mansoor as a tossed-together tag. What's that all about, and what was the point in him excelling like he did vs. Reigns if this was gonna be his fate?

Which other wrestlers has WWE given up on? For more like this, check out 10 Wrestlers AEW Has Given Up On and WWE Royal Rumble 2022: 10 Things That Must Happen!

Advertisement