10 Wrestlers WWE Only Signed Because Of AEW
If it wasn't for AEW, would WWE have even signed these wrestlers?
Competition is never a bad thing.
And when it comes to the pro wrestling sphere, a number of high-profile companies all vying for your attention tends to lead to a noticeable increase in the quality of in-ring action and compelling storylines being forged for your entertainment.
That most definitely has been the case when it comes to the two biggest wrestling forces in the industry at this current moment in time, with both WWE and AEW continually pushing each other to produce the most eye-catching television possible in a bid to outdo their biggest rival.
But ratings numbers and social media interactions aren't the only things The Land of All Elite and The World of Sports Entertainment have been fighting over.
Both promotions have also been doing everything in their power to get their hands on the brightest and biggest talents the business has to offer... or just keep their number #1 adversary from adding to their already star-studded ensemble.
In fact, had it not been for their newest All Elite challenger, there's a solid chance WWE in particular wouldn't have even been interested in signing the following names to their roster, it must be said.
Yet, AEW is most definitely a thing, and their existence has unintentionally paved the way for a whole host of talented folks becoming (or remaining) All WWE since they arrived on the scene in 2019.
10. Cole Karter
While it'd be fair to admit that the likes of AEW Dark and Dark: Elevation haven't exactly been appointment viewing since their creation in October 2019 and March 2021, respectively, it's clear that Tony Khan's biggest rival has still been keeping an eye on the largely developmental shows over the last few years.
Look no further than the snapping up of one Cole Karter back in March 2022 on the back of the eventual Troy 'Two Times' Donovan appearing on both shows in bouts against All Elite stars such as Lance Archer and even former WWE legend Paul Wight (a.k.a. Big Show) as a sign of the attention WWE were clearly paying to this AEW content.
And while the young Karter's impressive work on the independent scene no doubt also played into WWE's decision to hand him a deal, the rising star being highlighted on AEW's YouTube shows whilst not under All Elite contract was likely the biggest reason the prodigy ended up on the Sports Entertainment radar.
Karter's time in WWE ultimately came to an end (for now) just a few months on, however, with the NXT talent being let go due to a failed drug test before eventually returning to The Land of All Elite and aligning himself with The Factory later in the year.
9. Rey Mysterio
It's rather easy to forget that one of the biggest stars ever to captivate a WWE audience was actually a part of the PPV that kick-started all things All Elite.
Teaming with eventual AEW talents Bandido and Rey Fenix in a trios match against The Golden Elite's Kota Ibushi and The Young Bucks in the main event of All In, Rey Mysterio's association with the eventual new big wrestling promotion in town very nearly didn't end with that glorious night back in September 2018.
The masked icon would eventually go on to officially return home to WWE later that month. But it was evident that AEW were interested in continuing their relationship with the most famous luchador ever to fly through the air.
As reported by Dave Meltzer around the time Mysterio was negotiating a new deal with WWE in 2020, after spending a few months working without a deal, AEW were said to have offered the former WWE Champion a deal that equaled WWE's per-match offer.
However, the Sports Entertainment giant being able to boast more dates helped make the concept of sticking with WWE more lucrative for Rey. But had AEW not been sniffing around the legend, would Vince McMahon and co. have been in as much of a rush to tie him down for a further three years?
Either way, Mysterio remained with WWE despite All Elite Wrestling very much keeping the door open for him.
8. Lita
Lita's unexpected return to WWE television in the early stages of 2022 coming not too long after turning down the chance to work for AEW was likely no coincidence.
As the WWE icon would admit later down the road, Tony Khan and his team did very much reach out to Lita before she made her crowd-popping Royal Rumble return earlier this year, with it being reported by Fightful Select that said programme could've involved Britt Baker going one-on-one with the influential veteran.
But as Lita would also make known around the time of that Rumble appearance, despite "potential opportunities floating around", as soon as the chance to appear in said over-the-top-rope spectacle landed on her doorstep, "(she) was like, 'Yes, I’m in.'"
WWE would proceed to take full advantage of having Lita back onboard for a spell, too, throwing her into a dream match of sorts opposite Becky Lynch at Elimination Chamber in February. Yet, the timing of her in-ring comeback, four years on from her last WWE in-ring appearance, definitely smelt like an attempt to keep AEW from capitalising on one of the most notable women ever to step in-between the ropes.
That being said, it doesn't appear that Lita has entirely shut down the idea of one day showing up in TK's company should the right opportunity arise...
7. Edge
Though the idea of Edge ever even being able to hit another spear felt like little more than a fantasy for an age, the visual of him safely doing exactly that back at SummerSlam 2019 soon set the stage for the most unexpected of bidding wars.
According to The Rated R Superstar himself during his WWE 24 special, hot on the heels of nailing Elias with his finisher in Toronto, another "company within the industry" got in contact with the WWE Hall of Famer and told him they were interested in signing him, asking whether Edge knew if he could wrestle again.
Dave Meltzer would later report (via Fightful) that Tony Khan offered Edge a whopping $3 million-per-year to become All Elite, with the returning legend being in line to begin working with the company when AEW debuted on TV in October 2019.
In the wake of being offered this potential AEW debut, though, Edge insisted that he had to speak to his long-time employer Vince McMahon first. And the second the former WWE Chairman discovered both AEW's interest and the fact Edge was looking to make an in-ring comeback, McMahon told him it had to be with WWE.
6. Emma
With Tenille Dashwood's deal with Impact Wrestling coming to an end in August, questions over where the Australian star would end up next soon began to do the rounds online, with many understandably assuming that becoming All Elite was a very real possibility for the former Knockouts World Tag Team Champion.
After all, Dashwood's former tag partner Madison Rayne recently arrived on the All Elite scene as both a performer and coach. And the concept of a dream and one-time seemingly impossible showdown with old NXT rival Paige/Saraya would've likely been too tantalising an opportunity for the AEW President to pass up on, surely?
Despite once appearing on AEW programming during the All Out 2019 Buy-In women's Casino Battle Royal, however, one of the stars who helped spark the Women's Revolution into existence was ultimately snatched up by Triple H in the wake of her time with Impact ending in 2022.
And on top of being an undoubted reliable hand in-between the ropes and one of the most experienced, high-profile workers on the free agency market, the fact Dashwood would've definitely helped seriously bolster AEW's hit and miss women's division also probably played into WWE's decision to bring Emma back after not having any contact with the star for five years.
5. Mia Yim
As will be highlighted a few more times before this list reaches its conclusion, the fight to boast the most talented and impressive collection of women wrestlers in the business has very much intensified in the wake of Triple H becoming the new king of WWE creative.
So much so, that whenever a gifted worker now suddenly finds themselves having a stretch in the free agency market for a second, both The Game and TK waste very little time making a case for why a chosen performer should quickly step into the new WWE regime or become All Elite, respectively.
Mia Yim was one of the more recent stars to likely earn the attention of both top-tier companies on the back of her deal with Impact expiring in October. And with Yim being unceremoniously let go by WWE in November 2021, the idea of perhaps reuniting with her husband Keith Lee in AEW towards the end of the year was one that the former NXT performer and AEW themselves probably considered.
But just a few weeks on from her final showing in Impact, Yim was very much a part of Triple H's main roster, aiding The O.C. in their fight against The Judgment Day.
And just like that, WWE were once again able to reunite The Game with one of his one-time NXT darlings whilst simultaneously denying AEW the chance of acquiring another tried-and-tested, popular addition to their women's division.
4. Roxanne Perez
Following on from eventually signing on the dotted line and becoming a part of a pre-Tony Khan Ring of Honor roster, Rok-C would eventually reveal to Fightful that AEW actually contacted the youngster after she'd already committed herself to ROH.
And at just 19-years-old around the time of this interest, it's not too hard to see why Khan's promotion were keeping an eye on the rising star, with Rok-C eventually going on to win a tournament to crown the first-ever ROH Women's World Champion before her 20th birthday.
Unfortunately for TK, though, AEW being keen on potentially bringing Rok-C into the All Elite mix down the line likely acted as one of the driving forces behind many in WWE pushing for the young sensation to be handed an NXT deal after her time in ROH ended due to the company's hiatus at the end of 2021.
Said push ultimately led to Rok-C signing with WWE in March, and one of the hottest prospects in the industry eventually going on to lift the NXT Women's Championship before the end of 2022; meaning the now-Roxanne Perez reigned as both ROH and NXT Women's Champion in the same calendar year.
A reminder that she's still just 21-years-old. And that Tony Khan is likely kicking himself that he didn't hand the Booker T-trained talent a contract before her ROH debut in 2021.
3. Dakota Kai
Another one-time NXT darling Triple H was evidently a little frustrated to see let go last year came in the form of Dakota Kai.
Throughout her time on the black and gold/2.0 brand, The Captain of Team Kick became one of The Game's most reliable performers, stepping up as an NXT Women's Championship challenger and eventually holding the NXT Women's Tag Team Championships on two occasions.
So, it wasn't that much of a surprise to hear of AEW reportedly starting up talks with Kai upon being released from WWE. Yet, despite a number of other promotions being interested in booking the talented free agent and talents within AEW in particular pushing for Kai to get a deal with the company, Tony Khan and his team didn't progress past a short introduction with the one-time NXT performer.
Sensing that he likely couldn't risk TK and the gang rethinking their passing up on a wrestler that was clearly respected and admired by all corners of the business, Triple H soon made the now-Damage CTRL member a priority signing the second he was handed the keys to the creative kingdom.
2. Dragon Lee
It was no secret that WWE were massively interested in signing recent AEW debutant Bandido in the wake of realising that he'd put in one hell of display opposite Chris Jericho on September 28's Dynamite without being under contract.
However, in the end, it was Tony Khan's promotion who were able to convince the former ROH star to sign on the dotted line. But the same could not be said of fellow masked sensation Dragon Lee.
Instead, after rocking up alongside Andrade El Idolo and brother RUSH in a Dynamite AEW Trios World Tag Championship tournament match against The Elite in August, WWE succeeded where they failed with Bandido and quickly set about signing the impressive high-flying performer to an NXT deal.
As it goes, AEW were said to also be interested in making Lee All Elite. Yet, upon offering him a deal, Lee soon decided that he would likely get "lost in the mix" on AEW programming at this current moment in time, according to the Wrestling Observer Newsletter (via WrestlingInc).
So, the 27-year-old made his move to WWE official on the night of his AAA Tag Team title victory over FTR alongside Dralistico at Noche de Campeones in late December. Though said move would've likely never gone down had it not been for his Dynamite debut...
1. Cody Rhodes
Cody Rhodes' return to WWE at WrestleMania 38 felt like a significant moment in time.
Not only was this The American Nightmare's first appearance on WWE programming since departing due to creative frustrations in 2016 and eventually going on to help create The Land of All Elite, but his re-emergence also acted as the first real AEW-to-WWE defection.
And make no mistake, WWE clearly saw the acquiring of Dusty Rhodes' son as a huge opportunity going forward in more ways than one.
In Rhodes as a performer, WWE brought back a star who could clearly add something exciting to the top of their card. But it's what the former AEW EVP could represent in the long-term that was also of serious value to Vince McMahon and now Triple H and the gang.
If WWE are able to keep Rhodes looking strong and make him feel like even more of a star than he did in Tony Khan's company, then you have to imagine it'll only be a matter of time before other top All Elite talents decide to run down their own deals and give the new WWE regime a try.
Simply put, Rhodes' move to WWE was a shrewd call for all involved. And it's one that could have catastrophic consequences for TK's world by the time a certain bidding war of 2024 comes around...