10 Wrestling Stories That Blurred Reality
That stuff is scripted, but this is real. Honest...
Despite being a worked business that relies on carefully-orchestrated stories, larger-than-life characters and more drama than your average season of Friends to lure fans in and rip cash from their wallets, pro wrestling is obsessed with reality.
It's not hard to see why. Television as a whole has become increasingly dominated by "real life stories" - reality TV's rise in the late-1990s bled over into the wrestling sphere, creating an atmosphere that bizarrely takes elements of truth and mixes them up in a bowl with some good, old-fashion wrasslin' histrionics.
It sells, or at least should sell.
The phrase 'worked shoot' is well-known now, and WWE are still trying to convince everyone that some of their angles are more real than others. This, as you might expect, creates a schism between what's presented in one segment compared to the next; if that story is real, but this one isn't, then what's the point in the fake one?
That's a question wrestling likes to ignore, because it gets in the way of occasionally blurring lines between fiction and reality. As these examples prove, the biz loves to blur...
10. Jeff Hardy's Redemption (2020)
Jeff Hardy f*cked up with drugs and alcohol, knows it and craves one final chance to make things right and end his wrestling career on the best possible terms. That's the story WWE are telling in 2020 with their very own 'Charismatic Enigma', and it marries gritty realism with personal strife.
At the same time, Hardy is fighting off bullies like Sheamus and working his balls off to become Intercontinental Champion. That's where the blurred lines come in; Jeff's first singles title was the IC belt, and he's told WWE cameras he'd love nothing more than to win it again and redeem himself.
Have some pro wrestling razzle dazzle with your scoop of reality.
The truth is that Jeff did make an arse of things, and he has done several times throughout his otherwise glittering career. WWE's decision to use real-life controversy and personal demons won't sit well with everyone on social media, but it has given Hardy quite the comeback story.
9. Vince Russo Fires Hulk Hogan (2000)
Vince Russo wasted approx 10 minutes of pay-per-view time roasting Hulk Hogan at WCW's Bash At The Bash 2000 show. That shouldn't come as much of a surprise to anyone who lived through the promotion's output that year - WCW wasted pay-per-view time constantly.
This was just the latest example.
In Daytona Beach, Russo concocted a story that'd see Jeff Jarrett lay down for that "big, bald son of a bitch" Hulk Hogan. After "bullsh*t like this", Hogan left the arena with Eric Bischoff and the pair celebrated a worked shoot angle done well by downing champagne in their limo. Then, Russo went to work and the wheels came off.
Russo, power mad and apparently deciding that he was Vince McMahon 2.0, blasted Hulk on the mic, decreed that he was a selfish piece of crap and basically fired him in front of the live audience. This didn't sit well with Hogan despite the obvious acting from Vinnie Ru, and it led to endless courtroom battles for real.
8. Maria Kanellis' Pregnancy (2019)
This is another modern-day WWE example.
In the summer of 2019, Maria Kanellis announced mid-match that she was pregnant. The audience sort of/almost/kinda' gasped, with some likely believing that Maria was ribbing so that Becky Lynch wouldn't remodel her face. In reality, Kanellis was actually carrying child.
Her very real pregnancy started the ball rolling on a topsy-turvy angle in which she shamed husband Mike for being a worthless d*ck (almost literally; Maria also teased Mikey boy that he might not be the father of her baby after all, because he "couldn't get the job done at home") and acted like an insufferable gal who believed the world revolved around her.
WWE mixed in some cuckold fun for good measure by having Mike willingly agree to anything that'd make Maria stop berating him if it kept the peace. It was every bit as weird as it sounds, and outright failed to get Mike over at all.
7. The Undertaker Gets Frustrated (1998)
In his stunning 'Last Ride' documentary series on the Network, The Undertaker claimed that he's kept fans in the dark on his character for the last 30 years. That, dear readers, isn't exactly the truth. On the 1 June 1998 episode of Raw, 'Taker cut quite the quasi-shoot promo on Vince McMahon's ass.
Nothing was sacred during 'Attitude', not even 'The Deadman's' aura.
'Taker appeared in regular street clothes and said he'd done everything to placate McMahon's lust for gold over the past eight years. He'd destroyed "all the monsters" Vince put before him, and made sure to protect his kingdom for "handpicked champions". What's more, he was loyal when everyone else bolted to "greener pastures".
It was jarring at the time to hear The Undertaker speak so freely about topics like WCW, Shawn Michaels ("I never lost my smile") and the boss of the company. Then, he blurred the lines by pretending that Kane was his real brother and McMahon was profiting from his family feud.
6. John Cena's Disrespect For The Rock (2008-2013)
One 2008 interview with The Sun revealed how John Cena really felt about The Rock. Holding nothing back, Cena said it p*ssed him off that Dwayne Johnson professed to "love" WWE and called it "home" when he "wants to be an actor". JC then said, "Explain to me why he can't come back for a 15th Anniversary show or make an appearance at WrestleMania".
Yeah, Dwayne. Stop bringing it via Skype!
Vince McMahon probably loved this, if only 'cause he knew Rocky would retort somewhere down the line and he'd be able to squeeze some box office hits out of the feud himself. That was how things panned out - The Rock was guest host at 'Mania XXVII, attacked Cena and then set up a match at the following year's show 24 hours later on Raw.
Throughout their rivalry, Cena and Rock took shots at one another's presentation, love of WWE and business ventures. They'd eventually become friends, and Cena apologised to Johnson, but not before they scorched one another for years and WWE capitalised on real-life animosity.
5. Ric Flair Hates Eric Bischoff (1998)
Speaking of real-life animosity.
WCW royalty Ric Flair was taken to task by Eric Bischoff in April 1998 for ditching an episode of Thunder in favour of some family time. Lawsuits happened, and the bad blood between Ric and Eric bubbled over to the point that Flair genuinely hated Bischoff's guts.
The pair would mend fences enough to make a storyline out of it later that year. They worked at Starrcade (with Flair even putting Bischoff over in a short seven-minute brawl) and used their actual hostility as fuel for shoot-style promos on TV beforehand. The feud was WCW's bold attempt to piggy-back the WWF's wildly successful Austin vs. McMahon saga.
It worked too. Fans got a kick out of Ric's OTT antics, wanted to see Bischoff put in his place and could sense that both guys weren't exactly exchanging Christmas cards at the time. Today, Eric and Ric are great friends with mutual respect. That wasn't the case back in '98, but at least they made some cash out of it.
4. Bret Hart Goes Anti-American (1997)
Obviously, Bret Hart didn't actually despite the good old USA or think that the country was a toilet he was ashamed to work in. The Canadian hero had earned millions of dollars off the back of entertaining American fans, and he'd grown fond of the place despite his heritage further north.
Even so, Hart was sour on the way pro wrestling fans at large were changing, and he knew that the United States (as the WWF's hub) was at the centre of that evolution. So, jumping at the chance to revitalise his character and turn heel for the first time in years, Bret told the US to cram it and embarked on a wonderful run as villain to Americans and babyface everywhere else.
The gimmick let Hart vent his frustrations about how fans were increasingly becoming bloodthirsty brats but massaged his ego by allowing him to play Superman internationally and at home in Canada. If you've never seen much of Hart pre-'Montreal Screwjob' in '97, then you're missing out.
It was some of the best work his career, and that's down to splashes of reality.
3. CM Punk's Pipebomb (2011)
"Do I have your attention now?".
Nobody has been more frustrated with WWE's corporate structure than CM Punk. The former indy darling defied the odds to become an important star in Vince McMahon's company, but he still wasn't the top guy some thought he should be. Then, he cut his famous 'Pipebomb Promo' and became a legend.
Admittedly, it was slightly hilarious to see fans at the time claim that Punk went rogue and said things that hadn't been vetted by WWE beforehand. You do not get to speak that freely on McMahon programming without it being part of the act - anybody who thought different was fooling themselves.
However, Punk did have some leeway to be controversial on the 27 June 2011 episode of Raw, and it's true that he was sick and tired of WWE's suit and tie, yes man style. Seeing him lambaste Vince, Stephanie, Triple H and John Cena, then namedrop ROH and New Japan, felt like groundbreaking stuff.
If only WWE had stuck to their guns after he won the title at MITB. If only.
2. Bret Hart's Return (2010)
Originally, the 'Montreal Screwjob' was on this list for obvious reasons. That drama, depending who you believe, was 100% real though, and so it doesn't quite fit the "wrestling stories" part of the title. The events of 2010 however? They definitely qualify.
It was possible to see a lot of ill will escape Bret Hart's body when he returned to WWE and hugged Shawn Michaels on the 4 January episode of Raw. The 'Hitman' had carried around so much negativity for so many years, and it must've felt good to finally let go of his emotional baggage. Then, Vince McMahon booted him in the stones.
WWE weren't about to let drama so chronicled escape without making some more money.
Hart vs. McMahon was set for WrestleMania XXVI. It ended up being a total disaster, but it probs gave Bret some more closure on a bitter chapter from his history. The build relied on Vince maintaining that "Bret screwed Bret", and the fact the boss then let his old enemy kick lumps out him was physical catharsis for old transgressions.
1. Matt Hardy's Heartbreak (2005)
The wrestling community was left slack-jawed when news crept out that Lita had cheated on Matt Hardy with Edge. Things got even more shocking when WWE released Matt from contract because he wouldn't stop bashing both in the media or talking about something the company just wanted to go away.
Eventually, they realised that hey, there was cash to be made. Imagine that.
Hardy was rehired exclusively so he could ambush Edge and kick off a blood feud against his former friend on TV. As with most angles that WWE try to sell as totally real, the announcers feigned horror that Matt was invading Raw, and the rent-a-cops had their moment by hauling Hardy away like some sort of love-scorned psychopath.
WWE, Matt, Edge and Lita concocted a plan that'd exploit real-life heartache. It cannot have been an easy ride for anyone involved, and yet they somehow worked professionally. Arguably the biggest shocker here is that Hardy didn't just use this as an excuse to get close to Edge so he could beat him up for real.
What other wrestling stories blurred fiction with reality? For more like this, check out 10 Times Triple H Actually Made Legit WWE Stars and 10 Times WWE Tried The Same Failure TWICE!