4 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (April 23)
Cesaro gets bumped; Aleister Black's "new" gimmick; SmackDown goes heavy on wrestling.
Well, that didn't last very long.
Cesaro was bumped from the Universal Title challenger slot on this week's SmackDown, at least for now. Instead, it's his good pal Daniel Bryan who will meet Roman Reigns for the belt on the next episode - WWE also added the stipulation that Bryan must leave Smackers for good if he comes up short.
Hmm.
It feels churlish to whine about Reigns vs. Bryan, because everyone knows they'll deliver, but why have WWE decided to make Cesaro look second rate again? Sadly, that wasn't the only problem with Roman's challenge to DB. These niggling issues conspired to sully some of the good that happened on Friday night, and that made SmackDown a mixed bag.
The overall emphasis on solid wrestling was nice, but missed opportunities and the injection of unwanted comedy into what should be a serious title feud elsewhere didn't work. Although SmackDown is rarely outright bad, WWE should be mindful not to make too many false promises week-to-week.
Here are all the 'Ups' and the 'Downs' from the latest wrinkles on the road to WrestleMania Backlash...
Downs...
4. Still A Struggle
The drama WWE are trying to layer on top of Nia Jax and Shayna Baszler is rather flimsy. Reginald doesn't feel relevant without Carmella either; this is Reggie's third alliance on SmackDown. He was with 'Mella, chased Sasha Banks and is now with Jax. Jesus, WWE - do you think that's enough?!
Reggie and Shayna cost Jax a match with Tamina on this week's show, but...yeah, Tam and Natalya just feel like yesterday's news as challengers for the Women's Tag-Team Titles. This entire division needs a rethink. It's blatantly not a priority, but surely creative can come up with something better than this.
Jax and Baszler have run their course as a duo.
It doesn't help that the champs seemingly have multiple feuds going on at the same time. They're at loggerheads with Mandy Rose and Dana Brooke over on Raw, and have some veterans to contend with on SmackDown. Both angles are dull.
3. A Missed Opportunity
Why is Kevin Owens being used for one-off title shots?
KO vs. Apollo Crews could've been a full-blown feud instead of this throwaway stuff. The meat of the match, whilst fine, didn't do Owens any favours. He dominated 70% of it, got distracted by Sami Zayn and then lost via roll-up. Big whoop. Then, there's the Sami issue.
Here's another 'why'. Why is Kevin's feud with Zayn still going on after Owens beat him at WrestleMania? They're always entertaining together, but that should've been the end of it. WWE's intentions were clearly pure on SmackDown (they wanted to give Crews a title defence and make Commander Azeez look useful), and yet this felt like a waste.
Apollo maybe should've pasted a lower-card guy like Murphy or Slapjack, then built up his inevitable rematch with Big E for next week. Sacrificing Owens, distraction-based finish or not, was totally unnecessary. It was also avoidable.
2. Comedy When It Should Be Serious
Yuck.
Memo to WWE: Bayley pretending to congratulate Bianca Belair on her 'Mania success and then laughing her ass off is not the way to go with this rivalry. This was a worry yours truly expressed last week when Bayley made it obvious she was next in line, and it's already coming true.
Nobody looks good when they book this sort of sh*t. Bianca came across as a fool for buying into Bayley's lies, and the challenger herself is still doing this goofy comedy nonsense that's rotten to the core. Honestly, nobody will care about this title feud if WWE don't get their arses in gear and sprinkle it with seriousness.
They've got three more weeks to put things right, have Bayley attack Belair with a steel chair (or something) and turn this into something worthwhile. What next? Are they gonna' become best mates and challenge for the Women's Tag Titles?
1. Illogical Behaviour
Roman Reigns side-stepped Cesaro's Universal Title challenge and fired out one of his own to Daniel Bryan. Erm...hello? Roman's character has told the world that he only defends the belt when he's contractually obligated to. Also, why would he feel like he has anything to prove to Bryan anyway?
The reigning champ pinned both DB and Edge at WrestleMania. If anything, he should be telling Cesaro and Bryan that they're both fighting to be at the back of the line. This made zero sense, and the stipulation tagged onto Reigns vs. Dan was rushed beyond belief - Bryan "must leave" SmackDown if he loses next week.
He will, which is a bit of a bummer for Friday nights.
A Daniel-less SmackDown is a lesser product. Someone needs to explain why making Roman look like a panic merchant and potentially taking away one of the brand's biggest babyfaces is best for business right now. This better be leading to something good.
Ups...
4. Aleister Black’s New Vignettes
The jury is out on this one, admittedly.
WWE scripted endless "pick a fight with meeeee" vignettes for Aleister Black a few years ago. They started off well, then got samey and never went anywhere. These new "Tales Of The Dark Father" skits best result in a meaningful push for someone who is, let's be honest, criminally overlooked.
Black is far too talented to rot away on the sidelines doing nothing. On the plus side, this opening salvo was well-done (as you'd expect) and didn't shy away from the more Satanic aspects of Aleister's character. As hilarious as it is to see WWE kid on that this is a "new" gimmick, at least they're trying.
They just need to keep on trying, then mix these promos with some killer matches. Black could become a top star on Fridays if the writers show some patience and consistency here. There's absolutely no reason why he couldn't be in the main event picture by the end of the year.
3. New Number One Contenders
Rey and Dominik Mysterio vs. Alpha Academy was a great little tag-team match that ticked every box it needed to. Dominating heel beatdown section? Check. Spirited babyface comeback? Check. Clean babyface win that sets up new SmackDown Tag Title contenders? Check.
Good stuff.
Chad Gable and Otis have developed into a team you should keep your eye on. Their time will probably come if they continue this standard of work, but they were never going to win this one; Dolph Ziggler and Robert Roode needed babyface challengers for their belts. Therefore, Rey and Dom winning made sense.
Michael Cole might've given the game away by saying there has "never been father and son tag champs in WWE". Don't be shocked if Rey and Dom are the first. They're coming for 'dem Dirty Dawgs, and that match will presumably happen at 'Mania Backlash.
2. Seth Rollins’ Excuses
Seth Rollins carried that opening promo segment with Cesaro (at least until Daniel Bryan came out). His poise on the mic is plain for all to see, and he must be loving the chance to ham it up by making wild statements that never quite justify coming up short.
If only that damn weather hadn't interrupted his pre-match WrestleMania ritual, Seth said.
That was tremendous heel banter. Seth claimed that the rain delay in Tampa threw him off his game and is the "only reason" why Cesaro came out on top in their match. This, you won't be surprised to learn, is leading to a rematch on the next pay-per-view. Unlike KO vs. Sami Zayn, that's fine.
Rollins should want another crack at Cesaro. Meanwhile, "Zezarooo" (Seth's way of saying his name) should be ready to crack some skulls after being shunted out of the Universal Title mix so suddenly. This, hopefully, will prep Cesaro for an eventual title shot he richly deserves.
1. An Excellent Opener
Two or three segment matches aren't always stunners.
Sometimes, it's really forced when WWE stretch out a match across multiple commercial breaks. This wasn't that - Cesaro and Daniel Bryan vs. Seth Rollins and Jey Uso was so well-worked from beginning to end, and it never threatened to overstay its welcome the longer it raged on.
There was a lot to like here. Cesaro shone again, he and Bryan clicked (there's a future Tag-Team Title run in those guys), Rollins left Uso high and dry like a cowardly heel should, and the announcers were organically sucked into the action. Take a bow, Cole and Pat McAfee - that was really, really good wrestling commentary.
Their soundtrack complemented the quartet working their butts off in-ring. Cole kept things ticking, and Pat added in some nice energy and comedic flourishes when he could. Go out of your way to see this match, and enjoy it.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out 5 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (April 16) and WWE 2K22: 10 Rumours You Need To Know!