5 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (April 16)
Cesaro becomes Roman Reigns' next challenger on WWE SmackDown. Or does he?

Cesaro will never be the guy in WWE.
That's no disgrace. The 'Swiss Cyborg' (as Michael Cole likes to call him) is one hell of an in-ring worker, and it does look like he'll get to briefly flirt with the main event scene as Roman Reigns' next Universal Title challenger. That is, of course, if WWE don't get ye olde proverbial cold feet and decide to scrap his push - there's always a threat of that.
Vince McMahon is well-known for his whims. What seemed like the best idea one week might not be his plan the next; SmackDown's conclusion kinda' spoke to that haphazardness on Friday night. Cesaro wasn't even allowed a dominating win over Roman's "Right Hand Man" that would've prepped him for a title tilt.
Instead, it looks like Seth Rollins vs. Cesaro II is destined to happen come WrestleMania Backlash. That's not a huge problem, because they work well together, but it does make one question Cesaro's long-term prospects as a headliner.
Here are all the 'Ups' and the 'Downs' from WWE's latest slice of blue brand action inside the ThunderDome.
Downs...
4. Nothing New Here

Neither Natalya nor Shayna Baszler got an entrance before their singles match on SmackDown. That, dear reader, pretty much says it all. They, their partners Tamina and Nia Jax, and this feud are as low as they come on WWE's creative pecking order.
The problem is this: WWE's disinterest comes across. They can't expect anybody to give a sh*t about a WrestleMania 37 rematch between these two teams if they don't, but that won't stop it from happening. Nattie picked up the win over Shayna here, then Tamina blasted Nia with a big boot. Another Women's Title shot is all-but-guaranteed.
This is lazy.
The women's tag division is a total mess. Anybody hoping that Baszler and Jax would have someone new to war with would've been disappointed by SmackDown's booking. Also, what the hell happened to Reginald? Has he been discarded?
3. A Pointless WrestleMania Rematch

Speaking of pointless.
It's a bit crap to report that any match between Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn sucked, but this one did. Zayn challenged KO to a 'Mania rematch, then lost by count out and took another Stunner for his troubles. There was nothing new here to keep the story ticking along.
Both lads literally just worked this bit in Tampa, so it's unclear what WWE were hoping to achieve by repeating the same old stuff on Smackers. Maybe the rivalry isn't quite over (WrestleMania Backlash needs some 'Mania flavour, after all), but yes - this was hardly necessary and didn't progress the feud anyway.
The onus is on WWE's writers to come up with fresh scenarios. When they don't, and press the recycle button on matches that happened at Wrestle-f*cking-Mania, then they're letting the fans and roster down. KO and Sami deserve better than going through the motions.
2. Cesaro’s Push Gets Muddied

Cesaro should've beaten Jey Uso in that main event and then been attacked by Seth Rollins afterwards. Instead, WWE booked some lame disqualification finish - yours truly doesn't mind non-finishes on TV (or even pay-per-view if they have a clear purpose), but this one did next-to-nothing for Cesaro.
If he's going to eventually challenge Roman Reigns, then he has to beat Uso. Jey is like a sub-boss for the 'Head Of The Table', so it's not a good sign that WWE wouldn't let Cesaro plough through him. Plus, Seth's involvement in what is effectively a Roman mini-feud could be bizarre.
Both are alpha male-style characters, and it'd probs be for the best if WWE kept them apart for as long as possible. Perhaps they reason that another Cesaro win over Rollins at Backlash will make him look like a million bucks, but meh - that still doesn't excuse the decision-making here.
Again, Cesaro needed to win, and do so definitively.
1. No Edge Or Daniel Bryan Fallout

Where were these guys?
Edge and Daniel Bryan were completely absent from SmackDown, which was a disappointment. The pair were two-thirds of 'Mania 37's main event last Sunday night, but WWE couldn't find anything for them to do on the next fallout episode of TV? Come on.
There's no excuse for failing to line up some pre-recorded "on location" comments from Edge, at least. His obsession with becoming Universal Champion had been a weekly highlight since he won the Royal Rumble in January. Now 'Mania is out the way, that journey apparently doesn't matter anymore.
Bryan's absence is less egregious. He's more of a utility player than Edge is these days anyway, and he will slot neatly into another story more easily. Fingers crossed these guys were only off telly because WWE are readying a spin off feud between them.
Ups...
5. A Fine Big Man/Little Man Match

Short, zippy pace. Check. Smart finish with a crucifix roll up. Check. Heel outrage post-match. Check. Nice big man vs. little man dynamic. Check. Yep, Otis vs. Rey Mysterio ticked a lot of boxes on this week's SmackDown. They made the most of the time they were given and produced a tight little TV match.
More of that, please.
Otis' alliance with Chad Gable has more meat on the bone than WWE are likely willing to admit, but nobody should be salty about them coming up short here; Rey and Dominik should be next in line for a crack at the SmackDown Tag-Team Titles, and this gives them some momentum.
It'd actually be cool to see WWE program two concurrent tag feuds on Fridays. Rey and Dom can challenge Dirty Dawgs for the gold, and Alpha Academy can battle it out with The Street Profits. Or, perhaps they could, y'know, introduce a new face team to add more weight to the division?
4. That’s Why They’re The Dirty Dawgs

There was a slight worry that WWE would book a title change here for the sake of it. The Street Profits had been celebrating Bianca Belair's WrestleMania success, after all, and typical babyface booking would've resulted in a follow-up title win after Bianca said Montez Ford needed gold.
Thank God they didn't do that.
Dolph Ziggler and Robert Roode are one of the finest tags in pro wrestling right now. They've got swagger, they've got that 1980s vibe, and they're workhorses inside the ring. The fact they were written to use The Profits' own quick tag tactic against them is great - 'dem Dawgs looked strong here.
OK sure, The Profits hardly deserved a title match after losing in that four-way on "WrestleMania SmackDown" last week, but a solid match is still a solid match. This, for what it was, worked. The finish made Dolph look like a genius too.
3. Bayley Steps Up

"Ding Dong, Hello!"
Bayley will be Bianca Belair's next long-term challenger. She might have to wait on that surefire rematch between Belair and Sasha Banks (WrestleMania Backlash, and all that jazz), but it's a fine pairing. Also, Bayley vs. Bianca has another major plus: WWE can't run a 'frenemies' angle again.
They just burned through that approach with Sasha. It didn't work then, and it wouldn't work with Bayley, but the company are unlikely to book exactly the same dynamic so soon anyway. Breathe a sigh of relief, people, because the writers will need to go a different route with Bayley. It might even make her more serious again.
The unofficial 'Mania 37 hostess is at her best when she ditches the goofy comedy and gets gritty. Hopefully, and if SmackDown's promo is anything to go by, that's the road WWE want to take with this feud. This was a fine first step.
2. Roman Reigns Walks Away

If Bayley is at her best when she's serious, then Roman Reigns is at his finest when he's a dismissive, arrogant piece of sh*t. SmackDown opened with a straightforward victory speech for the Universal Champ, then Roman dissed Cesaro by walking away as soon as he spotted the Swiss star going for a microphone.
Why would Reigns wait to hear what he had to say?
This was spot on characterisation. Roman just pinned Edge and Daniel Bryan (one man a Hall Of Famer and the other a future HOF'er) at the same time in Tampa last weekend, so he should feel like his crap doesn't stink right now. Such hubris will be his downfall eventually.
Cesaro's reaction to this disrespect was also awesome. He took Roman's slap in the face to heart, and looked like he was ready to kick some ass. This segment was a winner from beginning to end, and it set the tone for what should b a fun mini-feud (if WWE go through with it).
1. Pat McAfee’s Commentary

Yes, Pat McAfee gets the number one 'Up'.
Commentary isn't easy, especially when the windows to get info across are as tight as they are in WWE, but Pat nailed it on Friday night. He was a snug fit next to Michael Cole, provided enough colour to offset Cole's strait-laced style and was a pleasure to listen to.
It's early days, but McAfee is actually a more entertaining partner for Cole than Corey Graves was. Anyone who reads this article regularly will know how high this writer is on Corey's blend of smart-assed heel defensiveness and Bobby Heenan-ish silliness, so that's meant as a compliment. Pat might have Corey licked.
McAfee even found the time to add insight from his NFL days when Sami Zayn punted Kevin Owens ("he should've followed through!"). Another joke, about WWE potentially adding timeouts so heels can take a breather, was one of his better lines too.
Well played, sir.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more, check out 3 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE SmackDown (April 9) and 10 Things We Learned From Stone Cold Steve Austin On Talk Is Jericho!