5 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Rampage (Sep 24)
CM Punk shakes off ring rust; Adam Cole scores another win; AEW debut an ex-TNA star.
AEW served up a bonus hour of telly this week.
Rampage joined Dynamite as part of the midweek 'Grand Slam' festivities. That meant this week's Friday night offering was pre-taped, and that can sometimes work against a show. The good news is that All Elite have their format down to a fine art, and they know exactly what kind of matches hardcore fans want to see.
Arguably, Rampage was a little tag-heavy. Four of the six bouts taped for the broadcast were multi-mans, and that meant the card had a bit of a 'squeeze everyone on and see what happens' feel. One angle also failed to land at all with the New York audience, and there was some questionable psychology surrounding wrestling's latest debut moment.
It'd take a major wobble for Rampage to outright suck though. AEW are already doing a nice job of presenting the show as an add-on to Dynamite rather than some 2021 version of 2003 Sunday Night Heat. It's above average, and that didn't change even with that extra 60 minutes.
Tony Khan shouldn't make this two-hour gig a regular thing however. It's important that Rampage whizzes past every week rather than becoming a chore.
Downs...
4. Hair vs. Hair
Urgh.
Look, Matt Hardy is doing everything in his power to make the feud with Orange Cassidy worthwhile. It's just...well, is this actually going to help take Cassidy to the next level? That strategy would make sense if Orange hadn't already rivalled the likes of Chris Jericho in major matches.
What is walloping 'Big Money Matt' gonna do for him? Worse, AEW want to drag this thing out by dreaming up a 'Hair vs. Hair' match between Cassidy and Jack Evans. Nothing about this is coming across as must-see; the hair gimmick is unspectacular because Evans isn't over and Orange has short hair, and beating Jack to get to Matt feels bland.
Worries were expressed when All Elite thought that Hardy vs. Christian Cage was the way to go over a decade after that was relevant. Now, those same fears are cropping up with a younger guy (Cassidy). This is a skippable story.
3. The Dark Order
Also, can everybody please stop pretending that The Dark Order are awesome?
OK, few genuinely do, but there's this sense in AEW circles that The Order must linger around like a bad smell like it's 2019 and this company doesn't have better ideas. The stable's original menace is gone, and they're pointless after an admittedly heartfelt run paying homage to Brodie Lee.
That was sentimental and lovely, but this 2021 version of the group is painful to watch. They didn't need to run in for a big brawl after the women's match - that added nothing to Rampage, and came out looking like Vince Russo was backstage having a few cocktails and pulling names out of a hat.
Face it, Anna Jay has outgrown The Dark Order. She needs to leave Evil Uno, Colt Cabana and cronies behind before they start appearing less like stablemates and more like leeches who hurt her chances to succeed more than help them.
2. Skewed Psychology
Some viewers may see this as harsh, and this writer does love him some brawling, but the 'Lights Out' match did nothing for yours truly. In fact, it kinda made Jon Moxley and Eddie Kingston look weaker than Minoru Suzuki and Lance Archer, which cannot have been the intention.
Those hard nuts needed Homicide to save them.
The ex-TNA tag star (and Kingston's old ROH pal) ran out to cut tape off Mox's wrists and free him so the faces could win. Psychologically, this was all over the place. In wrestling, isn't it more important that the baddies have the numbers advantage? Doesn't Homicide rushing out to make it three-on-two put some sympathy on Suzuki and Archer?
Maybe most don't feel that way, or care about that sort of stuff, but it's important. Also, this was a meandering brawl along the lines of overrated ECW "classics" involving New Jack more than anything else. It wasn't as pulsating as some more recent Moxley fights.
1. Fans Didn't Care About The MMA Crew
Crossover angles can work in wrestling.
Bad Bunny's work in WWE during WrestleMania season was tolerable, and AEW's business with both Mike Tyson and Shaq has ranged from decent-to-fun at times. This UFC invasion though? Nah, New York's hardcore wrasslin' fanbase wasn't interested in it. Not even slightly.
Jorge Masvidal, Andrei Arlovski and Paige VanZant joined Scorpio Sky, Ethan Page and others in putting the boots to Chris Jericho and Jake Hager. Meanwhile, Arthur Ashe Stadium's residents sat on their hands and wondered if MMA fighters kicking lumps out of Inner Circle members was really the way to go.
AEW deserve the chance to make this work, but this wasn't a hot start. Names like Masvidal and Arlovski don't have the kind of mainstream appeal that makes them household names to wrestling-centric folks, so the angle loses any easy brownie points it'd have there.
Ups...
5. Pulling The Nose Up
Last week, this article was rather hard on Anna Jay's match with The Bunny. The psychology of Bunny hammering Jay's previously-injured shoulder got praise, but that was about it. Thankfully, Anna vs. Penelope Ford was much better. Or, at least, much slicker.
This was much more like it.
Women like Jay and Tay Conti (who performed a run-in at the end) will be relied upon to start motoring up the card so they can eventually challenge Britt Baker. Granted, they're a wee while off doing that, but they're getting some decent ring time during matches to show what they can do and hone their skills.
This is what Rampage should be about - it should be a place where those just outside the title scenes can get some valuable minutes in. All four women (Jay, Conti, Ford and Bunny) should be relishing their upcoming tag encounter and looking to turn some heads.
4. Miro Takes No Sh*t
Miro has been turning heads for a while now.
The reigning TNT Champ has put that 'Best Man' sh*te in the rear view mirror to become a titan of AEW's product. Last week, a game Sammy Guevara was installed as Miro's next challenger, and there's deserved anticipation for that one-on-one. These guys could do awesome things together on pay-per-view, for example.
Here, Sammy and Fuego Del Sol came out for Guevara's cue card bit. Instead of just letting that play out as a 60-second distraction though, AEW's bookers had Miro roll through the curtain to toss Fuego off the stage and then stretch Sammy in his 'Game Over' submission as the announcers screamed blue murder.
Honestly, this fan can't get enough of Miro being a brute. This is exactly how WWE should've used him. His promos are simple and to-the-point, his matches are well-structured so that he always looks physically-imposing, and he just comes across as such a bad ass all the time.
3. Hometown Heroes
Remember that gentle whine about Rampage possibly having one too many tag matches? Yeah, ignore it when booting up the show to watch Santana, Ortiz and Lucha Bros vs. The Butcher, Blade and Private Party. This was all-action, and it never once threatened to overstay its welcome.
10 minutes was the perfect length.
Fans in New York also popped big style for Santana and Ortiz. It's pretty amazing how they've gone from Inner Circle hoodlums to proud babyfaces who don't tolerate heel sh*t. Seeing them team up with Penta and Rey Fenix was another one of Rampage's minor thrills.
Butcher and Blade followed on from their one-off challenge for the AEW Tag Titles on last week's show with another fine showing here too. They themselves have gone from an uneven act struggling for house room to a neat addition to the tag ranks.
2. CM Punk Works Off Rust
CM Punk's in-ring debut at All Out vs. Darby Allin must've been nerve-racking for the man. He got through it though, and now fans wonder what's next. In the short-term, the answer is: Team Taz. Punk worked a solid match with Powerhouse Hobbs on this week's Rampage.
It was another bid to shake off remaining ring rust.
AEW fans are going to have to be patient with Punk. Anyone hoping that he'd burst onto the scene and start wrestling in World Title matches instantly must've known that was unlikely; Punk himself knows he has a few more gears to rediscover. He hasn't been wrestling top-tier scorchers like Bryan Danielson elsewhere, after all.
Punk vs. Hobbs was the best way imaginable that AEW could've opened this special two-hour Rampage. There's surely a bout between Punk and Ricky Starks incoming, and the veteran might want to play a part in Hook's development too.
1. Superkliq Party
Adam Cole is visibly having the time of his life in AEW.
Cole joined The Young Bucks in six-man tag work against Christian Cage, Luchasaurus and Jungle Boy during the first hour of Rampage. Throughout, the former NXT man lapped up the fiery New York atmosphere and showed what's coming once he properly beds in.
Let this be a lesson to Tony Khan - AEW fans want to see wrestlers, not MMA fighters. The difference in reaction towards this quarter hour and the one involving the UFC lot later on was night and day. Cole also set about the task of readying singles bouts with Cage and Jungle Boy in the future.
Both of those are sure to be stunning. The way Cole chewed out a disappointed JB post-match was especially good. This, being honest, was very Shawn Michaels. AEW's new boy was setting up his next segment before the prior one had even ended. He's learned from the best.
What did you think of this week's AEW Rampage? For more like this, check out WWE Extreme Rules 2021: 10 Things That Must Happen and WWE Extreme Rules 2021: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True!