WWE Extreme Rules 2021: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True

Quick! Somebody tell Vince McMahon that this is Extreme Rules, not WWE TLC!

Vince McMahon WWE Extreme Rules 2021
WWE

D...d...did WWE forget what this pay-per-view is called?

A worrying apathy towards Extreme Rules, and the fact that mega-matches like Brock Lesnar vs. Roman Reigns are already being promoted for Crown Jewel after it, show that this weekend isn't the priority. WWE want to get into Columbus, Ohio ASAP, then jet out as quickly as they arrived.

The latest money-spinning Saudi supershow looms on the horizon, then attention will turn to the usual Raw vs. SmackDown festivities come Survivor Series. That, rather annoyingly, is the way this non-stop WWE machine churns - things are booked to a strict calendar, not because they make sense as part of an overarching narrative.

That's why, on Sunday, a few things could go badly wrong for everyone on the card. Oh yes. Abandon hope all ye who enter here, because this is a 'Negative Nancy's' paradise. There's scant little positivity - the clue in the title. This is 100% about those nasty "nightmares" that could have people watching through cracks in fingers come bell time.

Anything that can go wrong will go wrong on this list. So, here's every horrific outcome that could feasibly happen...

10. Dolls Take Centre Stage

Charlotte Flair Alexa Bliss Lilly Charlie
WWE.com

Correction: WWE's "stupid" dolls.

Charlotte Flair vs. Alexa Bliss would be a solid Raw Women's Title match without the stressful thought that it'll be some pseudo-tag match with Lilly and Charlie. OK, so Flair ripped the latter apart on Monday night, but would anybody be super-shocked if WWE resurrected the toy for some Extreme Rules capers?

It'd be a horror show to rival last year's pay-per-view of the same name if Charlotte vs. Alexa was sullied by a f*cking doll run in. Seriously, read that back then start getting worried. Nobody tell creative what was said here! Nobody! They might just borrow the idea - they did book zombies on pay-per-view earlier this year, after all.

One gets the feeling that this title bout will be totally ruined by Bliss' supernatural stuff, the dolls and something else few are expecting. In fairness, some folks on Twitter did guess that the story was going this way last year...


9. Alexa Bliss Possesses Shayna Baszler

Shayna Baszler Alexa Bliss
WWE

...and it could happen now.

It perhaps says everything that this fan tempered his excitement for havoc-wreaking bad ass Shayna Baszler from Raw with a creeping sense of dread that she might become Alexa's plaything. Last year, Bliss was hypnotising Nia Jax and Reggie during her whistle-stop tour of barminess with Shayna, and Baszler could be next.

What if Shayna is about to revealed as Alexa's tool of destruction? What if her annihilation of Nia Jax was Bliss' twisted way of eradicating a title rival (Nia had been feuding with Flair too, don't forget) and controlling another enemy (Baszler) by preying upon her mind?

Sounds horrific, doesn't it? The story could be fun if WWE's recent track record with Bliss, dolls and all that other mayhem wasn't so spotty, but Baszler needs a title push. She definitely doesn't need to become someone else's puppet as part of some sub-Goosebumps level story.


8. Fans Are Silent For Carmella & Liv Morgan

Carmella Zelina Vega
WWE.com

Liv Morgan looked like she was about to be WWE's next breakout female star...back in late-2019. That's a lifetime ago now, and she's done next-to-nothing since beyond reunite with AEW runaway Ruby Soho and then become a default babyface who's rarely featured on SmackDown.

The worry here is that Liv's match with perennial push (whenever WWE need to plug a gap in the title scene) Carmella will be short and unsatisfying for everyone, including the live crowd. Zelina Vega and Toni Storm may get involved for some outside interference, and it's likely that one of them will set up a roll-up finish.

Ohio could sh*t all over that.

WWE only have themselves to blame if the Nationwide Arena is silent. The fact that Liv and Carmella have been arguing over their bloody ring attire and who looks the best says it all. This is not the way to get fans onside for a women's wrestling match in 2021.


7. Damian Priest Gets Cut Short

Sheamus Damian Priest
WWE.com

Jeff Hardy has either been added to the United States Title picture on Sunday to take the fall or win the belt himself. Those are the only logical reasons for why WWE would bother to shake up Damian Priest vs. Sheamus when they had an easy rematch on their hands and Jeff had been farting about with Karrion Kross anyway.

Either way sucks for Priest.

If Hardy is eating the pin at Extreme Rules, then it's likely Sheamus beating him. That means Damian's brief US Title reign would come to an end just like that, and he'd be stone cold (not that 'Stone Cold') on Mondays going forwards. The problem is that this guy can see Priest moving to SmackDown in the upcoming Draft.

Creative would probs want to get the belt off of him before then. In other words, Damian Priest fans should start getting paranoid about Hardy's involvement at the weekend. Sheamus might be getting that title back pronto.


6. WWE Cram In Unnecessary Matches

Rhea Ripley Nikki A.S.H.
WWE.com

This article will be published before Friday's episode of SmackDown. There, 'King' Nakamura will defend his Intercontinental Title against Apollo Crews. Yeah, you can totally see where this point is going; if that pair go to a screwy finish, then WWE will probably book another rematch at Extreme Rules.

It'd be foolish to cram in too many unwanted or boring matches though. Nakamura vs. Crews doesn't seem good enough for pay-per-view (especially given the lack of proper build), and it'd be one that'd play before silence in Columbus. They'd pop for the Rick Boogs-led intro, but that's about it.

Other duffers could happen too.

Doudrop vs. Eva #1,236 is possible, and so is a Women's Title repeat pitting Nikki A.S.H and Rhea Ripley vs. deposed champs Natalya and Tamina. Exactly none of the matches from that trio listed above sound like they'd be must-see on Sunday night.

Quality > quantity.


5. The Usos Drop Their Belts

The Usos Roman Reigns Paul Heyman Bloodline
WWE.com

There's something awesome about seeing heel stables holding multiple championships. It worked for DX, it worked for the nWo, it worked for The Shield and it works for today's Bloodline. Roman Reigns is Universal Champion, and The Usos are dominating SmackDown Tag-Team Champs.

That's just the way it is - until it isn't.

The Street Profits haven't held tag gold since losing the belts to Dolph Ziggler and Robert Roode this past January. Since then, Ford and Dawkins have nipped in and out of the title picture with varying success, but they've found great dance partners in Jimmy and Jey. That could prompt WWE to make a switch they shouldn't.

It'd be a poor decision to take those SmackDown Tag straps away from The Usos right now. They'd lose so much momentum, and they'd instantly look weaker next to Roman. Plus, well, SmackDown has seen enough of comedic babyface content from The Profits. They need a change of scenery.


4. SmackDown’s Women Are Gimmick Free

Becky Lynch Bianca Belair
WWE.com

Can't wait for WWE to present TLC without one TLC match on the card later this year. Also, who's buzzed for a Royal Rumble show in early-2022 that doesn't have a 30-wrestler brawl?! That'll be fun. Seriously though, these things won't happen, so why does it feel like Extreme Rules is borderline gimmick free?

Roman Reigns vs. 'Demon' Finn Bálor is the only bout at time of writing that has a gimmick attached to it, and that's...unexpected from a company that adores these themed specials. It's also slightly concerning that Becky Lynch vs. Bianca Belair, which is one of the bigger rivalries on the card, looks like being a straight-up singles battle.

It's one of the only feuds with enough spice to merit a stip.

Lynch has been rubbing SummerSlam in Bianca's face for a solid month now, and 'The Man' even left Belair laying in her hometown on SmackDown. Those two plot points alone mean there has to be some sort of violent stipulation for their rematch.


3. Finn Bálor’s ‘Demon’ Is Ruined Forever

Finn Balor Demon Roman Reigns
WWE.com

Finn Bálor's 'Demon' alter ego could best be described as a useful tool that's handily dusted off no more than twice per year. His menacing crawl and dramatic body paints up the ante for upcoming matches, and this tussle with Roman Reigns on Sunday night is no different.

The unfortunate truth though, whether WWE wants to admit it or not, is that they're gonna have to sacrifice the 'Demon' to their 'Tribal Chief'. Bálor cannot be the guy who beats Roman, especially not before Reigns tangles with Brock Lesnar in Saudi Arabia and then possibly/hopefully The Rock come WrestleMania 38 season.

They have to be very careful with this, because one wrong step could destroy Finn's 'Demon' forever. He's supposed to be this levelled-up extension of Bálor, so he can't go down with a whimper to Reigns. Extreme Rules has to be the fight of Roman's life, otherwise the 'Demon' is cooked.

Remember that point if Roman squishes him flat then WWE try to sell Finn as a threat next year.


2. A F*cking Chairs Match

Bobby Lashley Steel Chair
WWE.com

Eek!

Some fans on social media believe that an announcement is incoming - one so horrible that it'll cause eyes to bleed from reading it. Yes, there are folks out there who think WWE are about to book a 'Chairs Match' between Bobby Lashley and Big E at Extreme Rules.

Take a time out to go and be sick in the sink.

This fear is born from Lashley's chair-filled attack towards the end of Monday's Raw broadcast. Could it happen? Well, yeah. Should it? No. The 'Chair Match' gimmick has been one of the poorest things about the TLC pay-per-view for years now, and it's so bad that even WWE only use it sparingly.

E vs. Bobby would be fun if they were allowed to brawl. Yes, it'd also be cool for them to use chairs as part of that melee. This overhyped in-house pretence that a 'Chairs Match' is on par with ladders, tables or an Extreme Rules-style bout needs to p*ss off though.


1. It All Feels…Less Than Extreme

WWE Extreme Rules 2020
WWE.com

That's a worry with Extreme Rules generally.

This pay-per-view already looks like it could be one of the most sanitised "Extreme" showings of all time. As silly as it was, even last year's event had somebody kinda/sorta/not really losing an eye, a table-laden bout and some lads fighting in a swamp as part of wrestling's obsession with cinematic stuff.

What does the 2021 version have to shout about? Reigns vs. Bálor getting the titular gimmick treatment despite already being an afterthought and playing support band for Brock Lesnar? Literally no other stipulations have been announced, and that's shameful considering Raw was 'go home' for some of the matches.

It's an ancient joke by now, but this pay-per-view could easily be titled WWE: Singles Matches or WWE: Exhibition Card. Or, how about WWE: Crown Jewel 2021 Kickoff? Come on now, give people a reason to care about it.

What other nightmare scenarios could come true at WWE Extreme Rules 2021? For more like this, check out WWE SummerSlam 2021: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True and WWE Extreme Rules 2021: 10 Things That Must Happen!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.