5 Ups & 7 Downs From WWE WrestleMania 34

Blood & Guts.

By Michael Hamflett /

WWE

As long as WWE insist on allowing shows to spiral beyond a reasonable runtime or refuse to split the 'Show Of Shows' over two days in an arena rsther than an empty gym, there'll perhaps never be a WrestleMania fans can unanimously agree on again.

Advertisement

There were loathsome moments on this card. Spells of moribund misery that would be mourned to this day if they'd taken place during the height of the Attitude Era. Segments so sh*tty that they simply didn't belong on the 'Grandest Stage'.

It also featured one of the greatest Sports Entertainment showpieces in company history.

Advertisement

Such is life on the 'Grandaddy Of Em All'. WWE want people watching every last minute for those valuable Network statistics, so the carrot/stick philosophy underpins the entire card. 12 matches made up the main card with two shunted to the kickoff, but this may look quaint by the time WrestleMania 40 takes up an entire week.

All bets are off now and forever more. They were a year before this show. Back then, they were doing mad sh*te like putting a major singles title on Jinder Mahal.

Advertisement

(Want more WrestleMania Ups & Downs? We got 'em: I, 2, III, IV, V, VI, VII, VIII, IX, X, XI, XII, 13, XIV, XV, 2000, X-Seven, X8, XIX, XX, 21, 22, 23, XXIV, 25, XXVI, XXVII, XXVIII, 29, XXX, 31, 32)

Downs...

7. United State

WWE.com

Jinder Mahal: United States Champion was a Plan B following one of the worst Plan A's in contemporary company history.

Advertisement

Jinder Mahal had been one of the most talked-about wrestlers in the world in 2017 thanks to a divisive and transparent WWe Championship run, but at no point had he remotely levelled up to the responsibility of the role.

By comparison, his 'Show Of Shows' victory didn't carry half the heft, even if sentimental favourite Rusev was again bantered off at the height of his 2018 popularity. 'The Bulgarian Brute' taking the pin felt intended as a bullet in the heart of the 'Rusev Day' movement, but burned fans were already moving on from yet another failed pet project.

Advertisement

6. Bludgeoned

WWE.com

The New Day's absurd entrance (a cavalcade of little people dressed as stacks of pancakes) was an unfortunate return to a stifled part of WrestleMania history in which Vince McMahon p*ssed himself at the mere sight of those shorter than him, but it proved to be the only memorable moment from a match emotionally ignored by the huge New Orleans crowd.

Advertisement

Much had rightfully been made of The Usos making their overdue 'Grandest Stage' debut in the build, but following Ronda Rousey's iconic debut wasn't in the first draft of the script.

Playing out to shattered silence, the crowd sat on their hands for awesome New Day/Jimmy and Jey exchanges waiting for the predictable Bludgeon Brothers victory.

Advertisement

5. Drunk In Love

WWE

Bizarre, brilliant and yet so, so bad, the long-fantasised-about Undertaker/John Cena 'Show Of Shows' scrap was a lot like Eric Bischoff officiating a gay wedding - WWE confronted a number of inconvenient truths in just three minutes.

Advertisement

'The Deadman' squashed 'Big Match John', give both men a p*ss-easy shift on the 'Grandest Stage' without care or concern for the legacies of two company icons. It

Compared to Undertaker's post-2014 efforts, this was a joy - he could repeat this feat with a different figure every year and go for another couple of decades at this rate - but there'll perhaps never again be a legitimate company dream match so carelessly tossed away as this. WWE should use spectacles like this to sell tickets. In giving one to John Cena, one of the best in the house went for free.

Advertisement

4. All About The Shame, And How You Play It

WWE.com

Nia Jax beating the sh*t out of Mickie James before repeating the feat on Raw Women's Champion Alexa Bliss was a vital bit of storytelling needed to get around any lazy reason to have Nia struggle against the overmatched 'Goddess'.

Advertisement

Despite failing to promote Jax as having the talent or knowhow to pull off the spot, WWE still booked a 50/50 battle that serviced neither the Champion or Challenger. Bliss got more offence than she should have, and while Alexa's shortcuts were admirable, the result could have wrapped in two minutes instead of the ten the pair received.

The Samoan babyface win was welcome enough on a night that needed another in the main event, but the quality of the match highlighted just how much misused talent were left marooned in a pre-show Battle Royal.

Advertisement

3. KnackerMura

WWE.com

Even New Japan Pro Wrestling purists were placing their cards on the table whilst the match was in progress - AJ Styles and Shinsuke Nakamura didn't realise the dream their clash was promoted as, and a post-match heel turn for the 'King Of Strong Style' kicked off a creative decline many predicted for him since he first left NXT.

Advertisement

AJ had suffered similar fate against Chris Jericho two years earlier, but neither man here offered any kind of violence to break the crowd from their silence. Obvious and unfair comparisons to their Wrestle Kingdom 10 classic were unnecessary - this was objectively poor in contrast to other matches on this card.

Champion and Challenger did better against one another later that year, but like every targeted assault by Shinsuke going forward, the bar was extremely low.

Advertisement

2. Kid 'N Play

WWE.com

As evidenced by certain supershows away from the 'Grandest Stage', modern-era WWE will do anything for money, and will go almost as far just to generate buzz, numbers and hype. Hoying a kid in the ring to win a title on the biggest show of the year was a moment to be ranked not with stars or in reviews such as these, but by the thousands of likes, shares and retweets images such as the one above generated on their various social media feeds.

Advertisement

To this end, it could broadly be considered a success. But watched out of context, the entire ordeal is an artless, humourless contravention of character development.

Braun Strowman battered The Bar with ease, but the entire match was undermined by the preposterous visual created by poor Nicholas' over-awed expression. There are times and places to do this mad sh*te, but WrestleMania and WWE in general were neither of those things.

Advertisement

1. Bloody Hell

WWE.com

Brock Lesnar's WrestleMania 34 victory over Roman Reigns was perhaps the most depressing in the history of the event, not least because there wasn't any winner that would have sent the angry crowd home happy.

Advertisement

Booing what they assumed was a 'Big Dog' win from the opening bell, the fans didn't bite on six F5s, nor Roman losing a few pints of blood as the pair desperately tried to create drama with a grisly and unnecessary finish. Lesnar wailed has he delivered the final blow, as if to instruct the audience to do the same instead of leaving early or lob another beachball around.

Red had once equalled green, but Stone Cold Steve Austin gutting his way through the Sharpshooter against Bret Hart, this was not. This wasn't even a near-dead Stone Cold Steve Austin retiring against The Rock. Ahead of a personal battle that would transform every perception about the beleaguered 'Big Dog', the 'Roman Empire' yet again looked in a state of ruin.

Advertisement

Ups...

5. Triple Header

WWE.com

Dressed as wrestling's 'Night King' from Game Of Thrones for 2018's overblown WrestleMania aesthetic this year, 'Monday Night Rollins' proved as indestructible as the devastating force from the HBO show by throwing himself in to combat with far less trepidation than normal.

Advertisement

It brought the best out in all three men - The Miz and Finn Bálor were two of several that probably could have argued a higher place on that year's card, but the trio were at least giving the honour of opening the show instead of the potential poisoned chalice of closing it.

'The Architect' was entrenched in his Triple H rivalry one year earlier - this win gave him agency over his career for the first time in a long time, and kickstarted a year-long run to the opposite end of the 'Show Of Shows'.

Advertisement

4. The Streak Isn't Over...

WWE.com

...not to Vince McMahon, anyway.

Advertisement

Charlotte wept buckets at the end of this match - in keeping with Flair WrestleMania tradition - due in-part to the response the result received. Asuka witnessed her near 1000-day undefeated streak burned to a cinder, just as 'The Queen's had a month before WrestleMania the prior year.

To her credit, 'The Empress Of Tomorrow' entered in to her uncertain future without an obvious boo-boo face. The pair worked a match-of-the-night contender early doors, with the prestige of the title and Asuka's unbeaten record well serviced by such an outstanding encounter.

Advertisement

3. Rousey

WWE.com

The greatest celebrity match in company history? Without question. The greatest debut match in company history? Almost definitely. The greatest match, outright, in company history? No, but staggeringly high up the table.

Advertisement

This was special.

An immaculately booked masterpiece, Triple H and Stephanie McMahon's sh*tkicking at the hands of Kurt Angle and (mainly) his 'Baddest Woman On The Planet' partner was the type of star-making display 'The Game' hadn't brought out bag of tricks since his year 2000 prime.

Advertisement

It marked the first time he'd sprinkled some of his NXT dust on his own work. Grabbing his wife's hand to stop a certain submission in tribute to The Revival's futile effort in a TakeOver Title defence two years earlier, Hunter deftly employed desperation elsewhere in the bout too. Offering callbacks to countless past exchanges with both Kurt and Ronda as well has his collision course with Stephanie last year, Hunter was in rare form against the debutant and her semi-able accomplice.

Kurt Angle was used sparingly to sublime effect, whilst Stephanie performed her one job (dodging a submission hold quite literally as if her arm depended on it) with exquisite aplomb. Capturing the excitement of a split-second UFC scorcher, the quartet somehow stretched that same emotion over 20:40 and left everybody gasping for more with their final shortened breaths.

Advertisement

2. Elias

WWE

The show's most spectacular banter-merchant brought the biggest slab of banter at 2018's 'Show Of Shows' when Elias emerged from the darkness originally designed for 'The Deadman'.

Advertisement

It was a glorious subversion of the usual gag. Elias' interruptions were designed to get under the skin of the former 'Drifter' - turn months of frustration on the crowd was far more effective than Jason Jordan's veg-lobbing strategy.

An acoustic strum in place an iconic dong worked those in the arena and watching at home into a furied frenzy, and heel Elias absorbed immediate comeuppance from John Cena for daring to troll 'The Champ' and the fans still awaiting the The Undertaker's supposed return from retirement. In show more about moments than the matches that made them, this was one of the very best.

Advertisement

1. Bryan Shane

WWE.com

Daniel Bryan's SmackDown Live return weeks before the 'Show Of Shows' was masterfully handled by WWE and the 'YES! Man' himself. Neither party could top it on 'The Grandest Stage', but the above-average tag battle pitting Bryan and fellow blue brand boss Shane McMahon against Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn just about stayed the right side of scintillating,

Advertisement

Suffering an early assault from the heels, Bryan's return from stretchered-out oblivion mirrored his last evocative display in the very same building, and his match-winning onslaught was a cathartic reminder of all the audience had lost in the years hence.

There was a touch too much Shane McMahon, but that's been a complaint just about every single time he's hauled on one of those themed baseball jerseys. Bryan told the world to fight for their dreams - battling for less McMahon would be wasted effort on a flagrant fantasy.

Advertisement