6 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE WrestleMania 31

He'll Be Back...

WWE.com

Brand new commercial and critical acclaim had finally started to creep into 2015's WWE ahead of that year's 'Show Of Shows', thanks respectively to eye-watering new television rights opportunities and the tangible growth of Triple H's rebooted developmental system. Between USA (future monies) and NXT (future megastars), the company finally appeared to refocus their eyes on the future in sync with their attempts to remain prosperous.

WrestleMania 31 was an advert for both...and also Terminator Genisys.

A year into the WWE Network era, the company was firmly rebadged and ever-willing to accept massive pots of cash for ostensibly innocuous gestures. Such as donating the entire stage to a film tie-in, or Triple H's ostentatious entrance to a film tie-in, or a 2K trailer to a film tie-in. Indeed, WWE's doors were wide open, so much so that longtime stay-away Sting finally even strolled through them to relive his best years as a vigilante on the 'Grandest Stage'.

Or so he thought...

(Want more WrestleMania Ups & Downs? We got 'em: I, 2, III, IV, V, VI, VII, VIII, IX, X, XI, XII, 13, XIV, XV, 2000, X-Seven, X8, XIX, XX, 21, 22, 23, XXIV, 25, XXVI, XXVII, XXVIII, 29, XXX)


Downs...

4. The Monday Night Whaa?

WWE Network

WWE were determined to present the Sting vs Triple H match at WrestleMania 31 as a final battle between WWE and WCW some fourteen years after it was sewn up by Vince McMahon’s famous purchase of the opposition. It wasn't ideal, but it would at least have been nice to get storyline notice first.

The tale going into the show was based around evergreen babyface Sting doing whatever he could to stop power-mad Hunter destroying a company he'd come to respect. The tale on the night was that 'The Game' and his buddies had to win the Monday Night War all over again.

D-Generation X and The New World Order all ran in to bolster the sides in what was an otherwise-enjoyable angle masquerading as a match, but the inevitable Triple H victory resulted in a nonsensical handshake between the supposed bitter rivals. Staying the right side of daft b*llocks was ultimately for the best, in spite of the infuriating company propaganda infecting the entire ordeal.


3. Girlbye

WWE.com

WrestleMania's last ever "Divas" match between The Bella Twins and the Paige/AJ Lee duo was a fitting farewell to the darkest days of the female league. Nikki and Brie's conformity served as the avatars for the unrealistic expectations of women for an entire generation - the babyface victory was scored as much with an eye on the brighter days ahead.

Lee's retirement came one night later, but she'd at long last pushed through an agenda she was for a while the only advocate of - women were finally given an actual wrestling match based on talent alone, without the distraction of every other member of the roster surrounding the ring in condescending cheerleader roles or as part demeaning stipulation there strictly to titillate.

The match didn't have a great deal to it - the main roster 'Women's Revolution' moved glacially in comparison to the action on NXT - but the tearful babyface celebration spoke to the changes in the air.


2. The (United States) Champ Is Here

WWE.com

Back once again with his ill behaviour, John Cena had a far better time of it against Rusev than he had Bray Wyatt a year earlier, but the start of his hugely popular 2015 United States Championship run had all the problems his eventual defences wouldn't.

Still sloppy in the super-worker role (despite one of the only successful deployments of the controversial springboard stunner), Cena's victory at the 'Show Of Shows' undermined the glancing blow the 'Bulgarian Brute' had landed on him one month earlier.

It was the best and worst of times for Rusev. His entrance on a tank remains one of the most popular in recent WrestleMania history, but he was all show and no go when the bell rang. Outthought and outfought by 'The Champ', Rusev joined the long list of those that ended up worse off than before from their interaction with the organisation's golden goose.


1. Cards Marked

WWE.com

Bray Wyatt always had a problem commanding respect from audiences when in there against somebody with demonstrably more star power, but he deserved more than he received from The Undertaker at WrestleMania 31.

It was only half the match it could have been already, thanks to virtual silence from 'The Deadman' in the 12 months since his undefeated streak melted away through his own concussed gaze. Wyatt admirably attempted to build it by himself as optimistic fans frothed themselves into a frenzy over the prospect of a broken 'Phenom' passing the torch to Bray, too.

Or a protracted 15 minute squash in the sunshine. Whatever.

Undertaker no-sold not just weeks of aggro but most of his moveset too. The Bay Area's light night didn't suit either of the darkness dwellers, but even low evening glow couldn't have hidden the hugely unsatisfying horrors.


Ups...

6. New Day Sucks!

WWE.com

This retrospective look at WrestleMania has otherwise avoided pre-shows, but 2015's WrestleMania Kickoff offered something entirely different. And it had to start somewhere. It had to start sometime. What better place than there. What better place than then?

"We about to get so filthy, we need to take a shower. And you got to feel the power!" was Big E's only opening salvo as the trio entered third to minimal response as the commentators literally talked about the weather instead. The New Day gimmick was barely six months old at this point, bu the only reaction they were experiencing was one of irritated negativity.

It wasn't by accident.

Kofi Kingston, Big E and Xavier Woods had gone so full on with the "Power Of Positivity" patter that the audience grew to loath it. "New Day Sucks!" chants grew more pronounced as the match fell apart, but the trio had already achieved their stated aim - it was better to finally be over, than good.


5. Ladder Match

WWE.com

Daniel Bryan's bruising Intercontinental Title victory didn't deserve the banter build-up it received, not least considering the damage Dean Ambrose seemed willing to inflict on himself to get the whole thing over.

An underrated multi-man from a period in WrestleMania history where the market had become flooded, this played like a greatest hits package of the performers within it. In the aftermath of such a spectacular 'Show Of Shows' scuffle, only the 'Lunatic Fringe' continued upwards.

Luke Harper went continually unpushed, Daniel Bryan went quietly into a brief early retirement, R-Truth and Dolph Ziggler went back to the treadmill whilst Cody Rhodes and Wade Barrett began contemplating an entirely different future. Time was running out for WWE to make the most of many of these talents, and with so many on the way up, it's little wonder notable names eventually sought pastures new...


4. Stomped Out

www.wwe.com

When Edge cashed in the first ever Money In The Bank contract in 2006, he'd tossed aside an undercard match against Ric Flair in order to remain rested and ready for his assault on John Cena later that night.

Seth Rollins took no such shortcut. 'The Architect' engaged in an outstanding battle with former Authority colleague Randy Orton that cemented 'The Viper's return to the babyface fold thanks to yet another creative deployment of an "outta nowhere" RKO.

Orton even bought new trunks for the occasion - a lesser-spotted joy for wrestling gear aficionados, not least when there's actually a good match to toast as well.


3. 'The Baddest Woman On The Planet' Enters A New Universe

WWE

Like everything else about her interactions with professional wrestling, Ronda Rousey's special guest spot at 2015's 'Show Of Shows' was an unqualified success.

Tying in The Rock and Triple H's legendary rivalry as well as foreshadowing Ronda's spectacular feud with Stephanie McMahon that followed a few years later, Rousey was at this point the undefeated and unflappable top star in UFC and arguably the biggest female star in world sports.

Her interactions with The Authority here were mere teases of her incredible aptitude for Sports Entertainment, but her positioning next to The Rock enhanced and enlarged the entire spectacle of the scene. All four were mammoth stars in what was then still something of a barren sky, and whilst Ronda arrived for real in 2018, her maiden moment spoke volumes about her untapped potential away from the Octagon.


2. Suplex City

WWE

Brock Lesnar's dominant destruction of Roman Reigns was an elegant solution to an obvious problem after the 'Big Dog' became the confirmed figure of fan loathing at January's Royal Rumble.

A rub from The Rock, a win over Daniel Bryan and months of television talk of him being a perfectly nice guy after all hadn't done anything to bring the audience around on the former Shield member, and Lesnar's destructive domination steered into the crowd's bloodlust. Smiling through the sh*tkicking, Reigns role was far from that of a pasted passenger - he was a gutsy and confident hero to himself, if not a fanbase that fundamentally refused to support him.

WWE had another ace up their sleeve too. A match this powerful needed an equally enjoyable finish, and the company weren't about to bodge the biggest bit...


1. Money Player

WWE.com

The shock and awe around Seth Rollins’ insertion into an unpredictable Brock Lesnar/Roman Reigns main event at WrestleMania 31 was palpable, and produced the most successful show-closing heel victory in the event’s history.

Sprinting down the enormous runway as both Lesnar and Reigns lay prone, ‘The Architect’ used his since-banned curb stomp on his former ‘Shield’ partner to score his first WWE World Title and cannily leave a conclusive finish between ‘The Beast’ and ‘The Big Dog’ for another day.

Patiently waiting for the right moment rather than the quickest and easiest one in the months prior to the 'Show Of Shows', WWE deployed their biggest surprise on the biggest possible stage for the first time ever. Rollins, as beneficiary was forever made in its aftermath.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.