5 Ways AEW Is More Effective With Their Roster Than WWE
AEW exemplifies how to build many storylines by using their roster more effectively than WWE.
All Elite Wrestling rang in 2019 with ambitions of changing the world. While AEW has not achieved that lofty goal, they have succeeded in breathing new life into the industry, offering wrestling fans an energetic and creative product in the form of AEW Dynamite.
Despite, arguably, the best roster it's ever assembled, WWE's creative has stagnated, relying on part-time talent to play integral roles, bringing back Hall of Famers to try and pop a rating, or simply being unable to write stories that don't involve a championship. This has left Monday Night RAW and Friday Night SmackDown with lacklustre mid-cards and under-utilized talent. AEW has far less depth on its roster, yet has managed to be vastly more effective, creating a superior product than either of WWE's main roster shows.
AEW has created a promotion where wrestlers are both protected and given the opportunity to flourish, with the freedom to develop their own characters and promos. There have been blunders along the way - here's looking at you Dark Order - but on the whole, AEW has delivered a more consistent product. There is certainly an argument to be made that NXT has been more than enough competition for AEW on Wednesday nights. However, this article is only comparing AEW and WWE's main roster.
With so many jaw-dropping performers, it's never been a better time to be a wrestling fan, but not necessarily a WWE one. Maybe they could take some tips from AEW on how to use their talent.
5. A Lack Of Over Exposure
To close out 2019, Erick Rowan spent eight consecutive Monday nights walking down to the ring and squashing, either a local competitor or No Way Jose. The Law of Diminishing Returns has rendered this weekly segment as nothing more than a chance to remember how great Jim Carrey is whenever Vic Joseph yells about "The Claw".
In that same time span, Darby Allin has made four appearances on AEW Dynamite, wrestling in three matches, only one of which was a singles match. It would be a challenging task to find a wrestling fan who would argue that Rowan is a more intriguing or exciting performer than Allin.
WWE has the unenviable task of trying to fill seven hours of televised wrestling a week, but surely creative can come up with something better than having Rowan wrestle the same match, every RAW, for two months. How about crafting a women's feud not centred around romance or a title? Both the men's and women's tag- team divisions could use some focused storytelling to get back on track. The point is, when wrestlers have nothing to do and no story to tell, it can be beneficial to keep them off television.
While the women's division could still use some fleshing out, between Dynamite and Dark, AEW has been diligent about when to have its wrestlers appear on TV. AEW has shown patience and restraint, ensuring talent only appear on TV to develop a character and/or further a storyline.
4. Good Use Of Part Time Performers
Despite having a main roster loaded with top tier talent, WWE have not prioritized developing main event stars. Instead, WWE have relied on bringing back part time talent- often legends- to headline the year's biggest shows. Remember how much time Batista and Triple H were given, both in the build-up to WrestleMania 35 and on 'The Grandest Stage Of Them All'? Did we really need Kane and Shawn Michaels to return for that disastrous tag team match at Crown Jewel?
AEW has been far more effective with its part-time talent. Instead of trying to get a ten minute match out of a legend to pop a rating, AEW have their veterans backstage, helping with production and storylines. AEW has refrained from making part-time wrestlers a focal point, opting to develop and put over younger talent instead. Think about how beneficial TV matches with Chris Jericho were for the development of Darby Allin, Scorpio Sky, and Jungle Boy.
So how has AEW been using its part-timers? Exactly as part-timers should be used: not as centrepieces, but as thoughtful additions that enhance segments or matches. Arn Anderson's spinebuster on Shawn Spears was an excellent spot during the latter's match with Cody at All Out. Diamond Dallas Page carrying Brandi Rhodes to the back after she was ejected from ringside during Cody and Dustin's bout at Double Or Nothing was a wonderful touch.
AEW has prioritized developing a young, athletic roster, while being meticulous and thoughtful about the use of its part-time talent.
3. Tony Khan Knows His Role Better Than Vince McMahon
One of the biggest reasons AEW has been more successful than WWE at presenting wrestlers and telling stories is Tony Khan's understanding of his role as AEW CEO. While Khan has stated he does have the final say in creative and production, the AEW President knows that he has some of the industry's most prolific storytellers in his writing room. How many times have stories broke about Vince McMahon arriving at the venue for a live taping and shredding the script before re-writing it by himself?
For the most part, Khan has stayed in the background, using his propensity for analytics to help shape the men's and women's title picture. It would have been easy enough for Khan to insert himself onto AEW Dynamite, as some sort of authority figure, but it seems he has resisted any impulse he might have for the spotlight, restricting himself to interviews after pay-per-view events and whatever you want to call this.
While McMahon maintains an autocracy when it comes to decisions about WWE creative, Khan has trusted that his writing team will be able to work with AEW wrestlers to help get them over. Khan has demonstrated a willingness to defer to his Executive Vice-Presidents and a commitment to allowing talent to script their own promos.
While we're on the subject...
2. Unscripted Promos
Take a minute to reflect on the promos that wrestling fans have been spoiled with since AEW Dynamite kicked off last October: Chris Jericho's introduction of The Inner Circle, Cody's babyface masterpiece in the build up to his title fight at Full Gear, Jericho telling Marko Stunt he is short for any age, anything MJF has touched, and, did I mention, Chris Jericho?
Following Jon Moxley's blistering interview on Talk Is Jericho this past May, it became evident that WWE wrestlers have little to no input in their promos. Frankly, scripting is evident by simply watching WWE promos; from Ricochet's desire to prove superheroes exist, to Braun Strowman's nonsensical inclusion of "get these hands" in every other sentence, it is incredibly difficult to suspend your disbelief and buy into a wrestler's motivations.
In contrast, the freedom AEW has given its performers has been a breath of fresh air. It is easy to believe what a wrestler is saying when they are using their own words and developing their own character. It is easy to believe the level of disdain Le Champion has for the rest of the locker-room. The ire and hatred was palpable in every segment during the Moxley-Omega feud. Need I mention the very real tears shed by both the wrestlers and audience in the aftermath of Cody vs. Dustin, at Double Or Nothing?
Unscripted promos have been the catalyst for bringing believable wrestling characters back to television for the first time in a while.
1. AEW's Creative Is... Well, More Creative
Before Aleister Black stepped out of his dark room to, twice, pick a fight with Buddy Murphy - in two excellent matches - what was the last WWE storyline that did not involve romance, a title, or a controversial pay-per-view in Saudi Arabia? For a promotion that is more sports-entertainment than wrestling, WWE has proven themselves incapable of producing captivating storylines.
AEW has not been perfect, but their creative team delivered stories throughout 2019 that were compelling. The Omega-Moxley rivalry steadily grew in brutality before reaching a crescendo in an ultra-violent unsanctioned match at Full Gear. The Rhodes brothers five-star, generation vs. generation, clash at Double Or Nothing was nothing short of a classic. Both Shawn Spears and Maxwell Jacob Friedman turned heel at Cody's expense last year.
Even when AEW has resorted to prop-wrestling it has outdone WWE. When AEW had their Dynamite Dozen Battle Royal - for the beautiful AEW Diamond Ring - they ensured that the eventual victor, MJF, was both a rising star and an insufferable winner. What has the OC done since winning the title of "best tag team in the world"? What ever became of Braun Strowman's green belt he earned by winning The Greatest Royal Rumble?
Yes, so far The Dark Order has been underwhelming, but at least it has been in an attempt to try something different. The writers in any promotion will occasionally miss the mark, but AEW consistently produces more creative and believable storylines than WWE.