7 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (10 Jan - Results & Review)

WWE produces a tight wrestling show and Triple H gets the 3 hour SmackDown format right.

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE.com

If SmackDown is going to stick to the three hour format, then it's important Triple H finds some better balance than he did on last week's show. Don't get it wrong: Last week wasn't a terrible TV show. In fact, it was notable for Tiffany Stratton's cash in and title win, some Drew McIntyre-led storytelling, and more. Ironing out some wrinkles was always going to be necessary though.

Advertisement

Now for the good news.

This week's show was a much improved watch from beginning to end. Sure, familiar WWE tropes like stretching out entrances (those entrance > ad break > recap package > entrance sequences are a little painful when watching live) remain, but several lengthy matches and increased emphasis on some of the midcard pack definitely helped soothe that. At times, SmackDown was the show Raw's Netflix debut should've been.

Advertisement

Jacob Fatu looked every bit a WWE headliner in the making, Tiffany found out who her first title challenger is, Kevin Owens continued being the bane of Cody Rhodes' life, and a pair of surprisingly slick tag-team bouts added loads to the night. When was the last time anyone could say that about Los Garza or A-Town Down Under?!

Elsewhere, Paul Heyman declared Roman Reigns for the 2025 Royal Rumble, LA Knight battled Shinsuke Nakamura for the United States Title, and Chelsea Green...badly needs to move on. There were negatives, yes, but some of them are paper thin when stacked up next to the glowing praise this week's blue brand deserves.

Advertisement

Here's all the good and bad.

Advertisement

Downs...

3. Heel? Babyface? Tiffy Tweener?

WWE.com

It kinda sucks to admit this, but Tiffany Stratton’s celebratory promo after winning the Women’s Title was a little all over the place. Her actual delivery was fine, but WWE must thrash out an alignment for Tiffy and stick to it. If she’s going to be a tweener, then she needs to work that out and have better material. Here, Stratton went the heel 101 route and came across more as a straight up bitch, and that really clashes with the reactions she’s been getting from crowds.

Advertisement

Creative shouldn’t swim against the tide Vince McMahon style with this.

Meh, maybe they'll get it right next time. Something else is lurking around the next corner and has this writer worried though; it'll be interesting to see how audiences react to Bayley now she’s Tiffany’s first challenger. Fans in arenas might reopen old wounds by booing Bayley in favour of someone else like they did many moons ago. Don't forget, that led to Bayley's heel turn back in 2019.

Advertisement

She doesn't want to relive the nightmare of standing mid-ring and floundering just because things aren't going to plan, but there's a real chance of that happening. WWE crowds have been swept up in Tiffy fever, so it's certainly brave to think Bayley will change that after the second half of 2024 she had.

If Stratton is staying heel, cool. If not, then she'll need to be a little less full on heel on the mic than she was this past Friday. This sort of thing could be a bit awkward in front of different fans.

Advertisement

2. The Downside

WWE.com

One of the best things about WWE programming since 2022-ish is that some of the 'Downs' seem like nitpicking. That's definitely the case for this one, and it'd be stupid to try and deny it. In fact, you might not actually share the same opinion as the dude writing this or think it's that big a deal at all. Being fair, it isn't a big deal, but here's an explanation.

Advertisement

You just knew Jacob Fatu would come back to haunt LA Knight as soon as the babyface chucked Solo Sikoa’s monster out of the building on behalf of security and Nick Aldis. Fatu and Tama Tonga cost Knight the chance to become US Champ again by ruining his match vs. Shinsuke Nakamura, and that was a tad too obvious. Look, obvious isn’t always the worst thing in the world, but it meant everyone was just sitting around waiting for that run-in throughout an otherwise-fine battle between Knight and Shin.

There’s an upside to all of this, so stay tuned for that.

Advertisement

However, yeah, it was a given that Fatu and Tonga would interfere as soon as LA took matters into his own hands backstage. It might've been better had WWE booked a Knight run in to even the odds during their wild opening segment. Then, they'd have cast a wider net for Jacob and Tama. As it was, Fatu was right out for revenge after being embarrassed by the popular loudmouth backstage.

Again, the most minor of minor grumbles, but one worth mentioning.

Advertisement

1. It’s Time To Move On

WWE.com

Lord only knows what WWE's writers think they're achieving by prolonging Chelsea Green's beef with Michin, but they seem intent on running it back time and time again. The finish to Friday's match dropped a heavy hint that at least one more scrap is coming (presumably on the next Saturday Night's Main Event). Green retained her Women's US Title by rolling through a crossbody and hooking the tights.

Advertisement

What a dirty cheater. She cheated! Good, Chelsea should be doing that sort of thing. Seeing her move on to fresh challenges would also be great. The match wasn't terrible by any stretch of the imagination, but...why does it just feel like all of this is droning on and on and on without any actual purpose? Green sorely needs someone new to work with.

Whilst Michin is accomplished in-ring, she hasn’t connected with the fans at all. Please just move on for everyone’s sake. Mia Yim can always return as a challenger in 6-9 months once she's been fleshed out as a character rather than the half-baked hardcore queen stuff WWE tried before losing interest. Her lack of direction collides awkwardly with the clear path Chelsea 'Champ Of The United States Populace' gimmick has.

Advertisement

There are only so many times fans can sit through matches between this duo. They've done everything to death - there's nothing new to say. Green's title reign (and the brand new belt WWE shouted long and hard about) deserves so much more than to dwindle. Keep this sort of fare up and it'll be renamed the Women's European Title before long.

Ups...

7. The Upside

WWE.com

So, the Jacob Fatu and Tama Tonga run in was telegraphed as soon as LA Knight stepped on toes backstage, but what was the actual match between Knight and Nakamura like? Pretty good, as it turned out. This fan could watch LA and Shin do their thing all day. Yep, those boys have some real chemistry together in-ring, so the upside is they're going to have at least one more match.

Advertisement

Stick that on SNME instead of Green vs. Michin, please. Or, failing that, let them tear it up at the Rumble and produce a great moment or two.

The super-obvious Bloodline black cloud hanging over LA's head didn't help either man here, but it's hard to get too mad that Knight vs. Fatu is incoming sooner rather than later. There's typically an upside to even the 'Downs', dear readers. That's the beauty of pro wrestling - creative can always rescue matters by putting on a show later on.

Advertisement

This was a really, really tidy match. There was enough bad blood between Knight and Naka after everything that's gone on between them in the past, so they had the live crowd proper invested near the end pre-interference. Go back and watch SmackDown to find ringsiders who defo thought they were going to see a title change in their hometown. The place was hanging on every movement once Nakamura's Kinshasa hit the exposed steel buckle in the corner.

LA's finish was cut short by the invading heels, which was a minor pity. Knight and Shinsuke can be proud of the shift they put in though.

Advertisement

6. Los Garza Show Babyface Chops

WWE.com

There was a time when the thought of Los Garza getting a progressive, career-enhancing 10 minute match on TV seemed impossible. Honestly, who really has a clue if Angel and Berto will be babyfaces longer term, but they certainly did a bang up job filling that role vs. Pretty Deadly on SmackDown. Here's hoping Triple H gave both a big thumbs up once they came back through the curtain.

Advertisement

Garza vs. PD moved along at a good pace, and it actually had some context due to all of the ‘who attacked The Street Profits?’ stuff that’s been happening behind the scenes recently. Also, what a finish Los Garza have. It looks sensational. Of course, none of this will matter if creative don’t keep spotlighting these teams. Hopefully they do and reports of Hunter shining a bright light on overlooked talent with these three hour SmackDowns ring true.

Legado del Fantasma could use a break from the folks penning this stuff, to be honest. Elektra Lopez looked good during her Women's US Title tourney match before, and Santos Escobar is one hell of a worker bell to bell himself. Go the spitfire babyface road with the stable and WWE might find they should've been the real LWO all along.

Advertisement

Maybe that's harsh on Rey Mysterio, Zelina Vega and pals. Anyway, Los Garza needed a win like this. Pretty Deadly will be absolutely fine too. They're the human punching bags of the tag division, and that's a role Kit and Elton play well. If nothing else, it's refreshing to see more tag-team issues play out on mainline TV.

5. Motor City = One Step Closer

WWE.com

Speaking of which, this.

Advertisement

Motor City Machine Guns tandem Chris Sabin and Alex Shelley beat A-Town Down Under to move one step closer to a number one contenders berth for DIY’s belts. Motor City will need to beat Los Garza first, but that looks likely. Put another tick next to tag-team wrestling on SmackDown, because there was a lot to like about this match, and it’s been enjoyable to see some other often overlooked teams become involved in this story.

The Street Profits ‘whodunit’ has been fun, and it’s clearly helping Pretty Deadly and Los Garza (as aforementioned). Austin Theory and Grayson Waller definitely need to split, but they’re handy for matches like this. Good work from everyone all round, including SmackDown's new commentary team Joe Tessitore and Wade Barrett; Joe hasn't called an endless string of matches like this, so his excitement is infectious and leaps through the screen.

Advertisement

Those keeping a close eye on proceedings might've spotted Waller laying into Theory outside the ring post-match, so perhaps WWE does fancy bringing that split story back to boil after all. Fingers crossed, 'cause they've got little left to offer as a permanent team beyond staring at the lights like they did on Friday night.

Side note: WWE live crowds are warming up to Sabin and Shelley's style. It helps that they raced to the top, were shot down by Johnny Gargano's antics and now have to claw their way back up. People can get behind that sort of sympathetic babyface redemption story.

Advertisement

4. All Four Women Bring It

WWE.com

Tiffany Stratton's occasionally decent/occasionally confusing celebration promo did feed into an unexpected delight set up by man with the plan Nick Aldis. Yes, it's always amusing that wrestling authority figures seemingly march headfirst into every show without a concrete lineup of matches to fill time like it's their first day on the job, but that's just something viewers have learned to roll with over the years.

Advertisement

Aldis announced Bayley vs. Nia Jax vs. Naomi vs. Bianca Belair would be happening "right now", and sprinkled on that the winner would be getting a title shot vs. Stratton. Later in the show, it was revealed that Stratton vs. Bayley will be happening on next week's episode. All going well, that can main event the program so they get bags of time. Not that short bouts will be a worry for now!

Again, Bayley winning does throw up questions about whether or not some boos are headed her way now Tiffany is a fresh star people like, but that’s the future. In the present, go out of your way to check this four-way out. All involved put on a show without throwing in too many cheap tricks like weapon shots or loads of run-ins, and there was a nice dynamic between Naomi and Belair.

Advertisement

Candice LeRae, who did run in, grabbed Bianca’s braid, which led to Belair accidentally whipping her tag partner. That spot led into Naomi eating the pin and the loss. There’s way more to come on that for sure. It was pleasing to see WWE use this match as an excuse to add some tension between the new Women's Tag-Team Champs.

Really good showing from all four.

Advertisement

3. A Wild Start & A Lot To Unpack!

WWE.com

Where to start with this?! Paul Heyman announced that Roman Reigns is entering the Royal Rumble. He told Cody Rhodes that Roman plans to win it then challenge for “his” title at WrestleMania 41. That took care of that, and means Roman might not be on TV much before 1 February. Then, Kevin Owens walked through the stands to point out more of Cody’s hypocrisy with The Bloodline.

Advertisement

They brawled, then Jacob Fatu and Tama Tonga cornered Heyman before Jimmy Uso saved his skin. That led to Cody coming back to fend off Fatu and Tonga. Phew! This was a really hot start to the night, which is something Triple H has become adept at when he feels like the show needs that. Being honest, this segment felt way slicker and more exciting than many on Raw’s Netflix debut.

For example, the fact there was actually some aggression to everyone put it above The Rock’s weird 'Final Boss but not really' promo from Monday, but at least KO referenced that to give it some purpose. Social media won't want to acknowledge this, but there's always a chance WWE knows exactly what they're doing by formatting things this way. Giving Owens something else to bitch about is never a bad thing, 'cause he'll run with it.

Advertisement

Smartly, WWE avoided the usual promo train trope by having everyone appear organically. Heyman asked Cody to come out, Kev showed up in the people, Fatu and Tonga sprinted in out of nowhere, and Jimmy was there to have Rhodes' back.

Got to love the way this was laid out.

Advertisement

2. Jacob Fatu Shines In A Big Spot

WWE.com

What a night Jacob Fatu had.

Advertisement

WWE put a lot of focus on the bulldozer throughout all three hours, and seeing him shine without sharing the stage with Solo Sikoa felt like a big deal. Fatu wrecked shop and generally took the lead in Solo's absence. Dare one say he...came across as a better 'Tribal Chief'/leader than the man he professes to love? Now that's tasty, and it's something the writing team can use going forwards.

Jacob also found time to cut a powerful promo as he and Tama walked backstage towards Gorilla for their main event tag vs. Cody and Jimmy Uso. Then, as if that wasn't enough, Fatu proved to be the difference maker for his team. Next week, Jacob will either re-pledge his allegiance to Sikoa or decide he’s a weak link after failing to beat Roman Reigns.

Advertisement

Being brutally honest, this guy still thinks Fatu needs to come up with a new finish (he’s still using Tiffany Stratton’s moonsault), but that’s a minor gripe. One of many, as you've probably noticed. Right, enough of that. Back to the good stuff.

Jacob and Tama make a better team than Tama and Tonga Loa ever did, but it's clear to anyone watching that Fatu is about to break out and become a singles megastar around these parts. 2025 is going to be his year. It's practically guaranteed if he manages to stay injury free and keep his nose out of trouble.

Advertisement

Triple H gave Fatu centre stage on SmackDown, and the boss will be damn proud of the results.

1. KO & Cody Crash!

WWE.com

The show's finish wasn't just a double table bump for the sake of it. No, it was a key piece of storytelling that shows how far Cody Rhodes is willing to go when confronted by arch nemesis Kevin Owens. Also, and this is similarly important, Cody sees red whenever KO is around these days. He's grown to hate the man for what he did to Randy Orton and what he continues to do to him.

Advertisement

Sweet and sour emotion rules.

Rhodes and Owens resumed their brawling during the main event, then eventually found themselves trading punches atop production crates. That's when Cody launched himself at Kev and they both tumbled through some nearby tables as fans roared their approval. That was a mini-preview of the mayhem to come during the pair's ladder bout at Royal Rumble, and everyone knows it.

Advertisement

In an unintentionally hilarious add-on, KO reached out to try and hit Cody again right at the end of the show before security and company officials stopped the fight. It took Owens a split second or two to regain his bearings. Then, when he did and saw Rhodes to the side of him, he tried one last cheeky pot shot. Outstanding heel work there.

Cody being busy with Kevin meant Jimmy Uso was left to the wolves. Fatu and Tonga picked up the tag-team win whilst two main eventers hammered home the fractured friendship they'll use as fuel heading into the Rumble. Christ, what a well-formatted show-long story this was from WWE.

Advertisement

Love it.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 5 New Directions After WWE Raw's Netflix Debut and 5 Things WWE Raw’s Netflix Debut Told Us About WrestleMania 41 Season!

Advertisement