7 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (3 Jan - Results & Review)
WWE SmackDown's three hour era begins with a huge title change and "Transfer Window' carnage.

Understandably, most of WWE's focus has gone on hyping up Monday's Netflix debut as much as humanly possible. You couldn't move for the Netflix chat on this week's SmackDown, but it's puzzling how much of an issue that seems to be for some on social media. Why is anyone pointing fingers at the company for promoting their own products? What's the alternative? That they...don't? That wouldn't make much sense.
Ceaseless Netflix hype wasn't one of the show's problems anyway. Being honest, the blue brand didn't have too many on Friday (some of the 'Downs' featured here are fairly minor and could be one fan jumping the gun by looking into things waaaay too much). It was a solid episode with one huge moment that'll get everyone talking. The future of women's wrestling arrived in style on Friday, put it that way.
WWE waved goodbye to the two hour format on last week's broadcast, so there's a bit more to highlight from this three hour special. On that, it's keeping things "special" that'll be one of Triple H's objectives in coming weeks and months. Nothing is certain there, but WrestleMania season should help a lot.
Star power wasn't threadbare. Cody Rhodes, Kevin Owens, Drew McIntyre, Sami Zayn, The Usos and Solo Sikoa's Bloodline all worked various segments and matches for the live crowd. Further, a big title change and a few other bells and whistles made SmackDown more than watchable.
Here's all the good and bad from a show that'll have to be content with 'B' tier status behind Raw for a while. Yes, again!
Downs...
4. Nothing New

Paul Heyman’s hype promo for ’Tribal Combat’ was standard Heyman stuff. That’s not meant as criticism, but it’s just chewing up time at this point, and there’s only so much WWE can do without Roman Reigns actually being there. Solo Sikoa then coming out to confront Paul led to nothing new either. Hmm, one didn’t expect the lack of energy here considering what’s coming on Raw, but something just felt a little off.
WWE’s writers stretched thin material as far as they possibly could, and that was obvious as soon as they sent Heyman out with a stick to do his usual story recap. Put it this way: Did anyone actually need Paul talking about how Solo recruited Tama Tonga, Tonga Loa and Jacob Fatu? That was a little too basic for a story everybody has been glued to anyway.
Heyman crapping his pants when Sikoa marched out to get in his face was cool, but it wasn't nearly enough to make this segment worth anyone's time. There was nothing new on offer. Solo simply said that he wanted Paul to put the ula fala around his neck and acknowledge him as 'Tribal Chief' "when" he beats Roman Reigns.
Again, did they need a 15 minute promo skit to put that across?
The announcers tried their best to add some spice by presenting the breakup between these dudes as heartbreaking last summer. It really wasn't. In fact, everybody wanted it to happen. Yeah, this was a rare miss for WWE when it comes to The Bloodline. Things will pick up again on Monday.
3. MCMGs Needed To Be Angry

There's a clear upside to this match that'll be explored in the 'Ups', but something else is worth saying before getting to that: Chris Sabin and Alex Shelley really needed to have a bit more bite to them from the off. The Motor City Machine Guns lost their belts and learned not to trust old pal Johnny Gargano in the process. Then, they were attacked backstage. Here, both were content to work their usual zippy style.
Nah, screw that. Context is everything. The Guns should've come out spitting venom. Sometimes, story and characterisation should override the need to hit flashy moves and all that sort of stuff, especially when it'd fit the direction WWE has been running with anyway. This was not the time for babyface tag goodness - it was the time for anger, and should be viewed as a real missed opportunity for the Guns to show a different side to their game.
It's kinda surprising an agent on WWE's watch didn't make sure they were emotional and out for revenge. This didn't ruin the match or anything, but it did stick out a trifle odd during the first few minutes. Sometimes, wrestlers are guilty of ignoring the story they've been working so they can do familiar entrance routines and 'get their stuff in'. That was the case here, unfortunately.
Again, not a deal breaker, but MCMGs should've been all over Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa from the opening bell. A little warning from the ref wouldn't have gone amiss too. Tell your story, gentlemen.
2. This Still Isn’t All That Interesting

Going in, this fan hoped Michin would get some mic time to explain why she dislikes Chelsea Green so much and why she wants to wipe her Women's United States Title win from memory. Instead, WWE served up a decent match between Michin and Piper Niven that badly exposed the fundamental flaw with the former's presentation right now. In other words, it's difficult for people to care.
By all accounts, Michin is a positive person who's well-liked and a credit to the promotion behind the scenes, but there's something missing when she's in front of fans. Things rarely click the way everyone wishes they would. Being brutally honest about it, she and Chelsea have a job on their hands to justify this upcoming US Title rematch. Their whole feud peaked a while back and feels unnecessary going into the new year.
Creative has to take some of the blame for that. Michin's character hasn't been fleshed out very well, and most would agree Green deserved something bigger for her first title feud. Will they have a solid match once the bell sounds on the next Saturday Night's Main Event special or on TV? Absolutely, but then what? WWE don't even lean on the 'she's hardcore' persona they had going for a while.
That has vanished.
The biggest problem with Michin is that no part of her act sticks out as extraordinary right now. She's OK on the mic, excels in-ring without being as good as others in the division, and audiences don't really react whenever they see her. Either fix this by actually giving her some meaningful depth, or find someone else who'd click with Chelsea.
1. 3 Hours Could Be A Problem

This week's SmackDown wasn't a bad show at all, but...is anyone else slightly worried about weekly three hour SmackDowns that piggy back on weekly three hour Raws? WWE's television output feels better without that extra hour (two hour episodes of Raw were the slickest in years towards the end of 2024), because that enables creative to avoid awkward sags here or there. Or, y'know, the need to pad everything out with video packages and recaps.
There were a few too many of those on Friday.
This might be jumping the gun, but three hours could prove to be too much for the blue brand. Raw will be WWE's focus, at least for a while, and asking the fanbase to sit there watching eight hours (including NXT) of core TV each week a ambitious at best and silly at worst. Suddenly, WWE's entire library of programming will feel like a big commitment unless you’re watching on catch up and can skip through some of the fluff. That won't bother hardcore fans, but the more casual market? Yikes.
Friday's effort was largely fine 'cause it was the first edition and there's a bit of buzz surrounding the Netflix jump/WrestleMania season starting. WWE also 100% defo deserve the chance to make this work, but it was noticeable how stretched some segments felt throughout SmackDown. The Usos and Sami Zayn took so long over their entrance it was nearly time to lift the curtain on Royal Rumble by the time they'd finished yeeting.
Just be careful, Hunter. There are only so many superstar vignettes, recaps and visible filler people can stomach.
Ups...
7. Getting Everyone Involved!

Sure, the Machine Guns needed to show more fire than they did during the first half of their title showdown vs. DIY, but that was already moaned about in the 'Downs' section. Moving on, the rest of the match and segment worked a treat. Pretty Deadly and Los Garza got involved, which led to the referee throwing the match out. It'd be easy to shake your head at that kind of finish, but stick with it.
All of it makes sense within the framework of the story being told.
Deadly are stirring the pot backstage by telling lies aplenty, Garza called them out on it, and now both teams are in the mix for tag title shots of their own someday. Why? Well, DIY vow to make PD number one contenders if they keep helping them beat MCMGs, and Los Garza will be thrust into the mix by Nick Aldis if they keep popping up. That's cool - this gives these squads something meaningful to do every week.
Recent scuttlebutt suggests WWE plan to give some overlooked acts more time to develop on SmackDown in coming weeks and months so they don't end up on lists looking at the roster's biggest losers. If so, then that's laying down the gauntlet to under-utilised teams like Deadly and Garza. Now, it's up to them to meet management halfway and deliver the goods. They're off to a decent start on that front.
The second half of DIY vs. Guns banged, and writers laid foundations for some PD and Los Garza-inspired interference earlier during a backstage skit. No complaints with any of this. It's a fine use of the tag division.
6. A Match That Played To Their Strengths

One of the best things about Triple H's WWE since he claimed control from Vince McMahon is his general propensity to highlight strengths more than weaknesses. That isn't always true across the board, but it certainly is for workers like Shinsuke Nakamura and Andrade. They've been doing some of their best company work ever recently, and Friday night was the latest slice of positivity for both.
Naka vs. Andrade was really, really good. It's fair to say that neither guy is particularly strong on the mic, but they're both fabulous inside the ring. Again, Trips has done a good job of shrouding Shinsuke in mystery lately by tweaking his character to become some quasi-Mortal Kombat villain who carries an edge. Meanwhile, Andrade is a known workhorse who's been chasing the United States belt for a while.
Their exchanges were lively, but crucially made sure Nakamura remained menacing and calculated in his approach. His match-winning Kinshasa looked awesome, for example. Shin's facial expressions before hitting the knee strike sold it perfectly, and so did Andrade's 'out of it' eyes. There was a lot to like here from first minute to last, and that includes LA Knight's attack afterwards.
The ex-US Champ then promised he'd win the title back. Being fair, it's a little strange he's claiming Nakamura "stole" the championship, but everyone's looking forward to their main event title rematch on next week's show regardless.
Straightforward and classy pro wrestling with a definitive finish and then some lead in to what's next? You've got to love it.
5. Drew McIntyre’s Distraction

Speaking of workers who recently worked their best WWE match yet - it's Drew McIntyre.
The Scot interrupted Cody Rhodes then said he was there to help not hurt him, but that set the table for a Kevin Owens ambush. Technically, Drew didn’t lay a finger on Rhodes, so he was true to his word. However, deep down, it’s clear he understands why KO resents Cody teaming with Roman Reigns back at Bad Blood. That, dear readers, is consistent characterisation everyone can get behind. McIntyre comes across as a real human being who remembers the past.
OK, so nothing earth shattering happened between Cody's entrance and Owens sneaking up from behind like a crafty little git, but it was a star-strong opening to the show that sold one PLE match (Rhodes vs KO at Royal Rumble) whilst teasing another (Rhodes vs. Drew for the title) to come. That's a win for the creative team as far as this WWE lifer is concerned!
It'll be interesting to have a killer, cerebral heel like McIntyre on SmackDown going forwards, and it looks like that’s the plan during this transfer window gimmick. He seemed to forget the name of that, but didn't lose track of his promo. Cody was there to play John Cena to Jeremy Piven by bailing him out. Christ, hope we don't have to wait until Summerfest to see them going at it.
Seriously though, get used to this sort of segment on three hour shows. That won't be a problem if each is laced with the kind of forthright direction this one was.
4. The Subtle Strength Of This Segment

Not every must see segment needs to happen in front of a live crowd or even contain any violence at all. For proof, check out Cody Rhodes and Nick Aldis having a polite but firm conversation towards the end of Friday's episode. Not to harp too much on this, but both joined Drew in the 'acting like a real person' category. This was a rare beast for pro wrestling. It was the kind of chat that could've believably happened without cameras.
Aldis pointed out that Cody talked him into making the Royal Rumble ladder match, but “seems hell bent on not making it” there to actually wrestle Kevin Owens. Rhodes then said Aldis is a good boss and has the right to question him, but this is personal with Kevin so he’ll call his shot and “drop him on sight”. He also brought Drew McIntyre back into things too, which was smart.
Both stayed true to their characters and made sure they each looked strong without the need for unnecessary/overboard confrontation, and it presented Rhodes as someone KO has successfully wobbled with his antics. Good work. It's worth saying that Aldis continues to be one of the best GM characters WWE has had for a while. He's survived a rocky early start to stand tall as an important authority figure who actually contributes to the product each week.
His stature also makes it nigh-on impossible for workers to physically intimidate him easily one on one. That adds credibility. This might be forgotten as a throwaway face to face in the grand scheme of things, but it did a lot to push each guy's respective personas.
3. Serious Time (And The Right Winners)

Lengthy matches are another thing regular SmackDown viewers will need to get used to again. You'll be seeing a ton of those over the piece. WWE gave The Usos and Sami Zayn vs. Solo Sikoa, Jacob Fatu and Tama Tonga approx 22 minutes to close the show. Honestly, they could’ve shaved a few minutes and made the match tidier, but the important thing was always gonna be Solo standing tall before ’Tribal Combat’ on Raw.
A few weeks back, it looked like Hunter might drop the ball there by booking Sikoa to suffer a dramatic loss of confidence before meeting Roman Reigns in a destiny-shaping epic on Netflix. Thankfully, he's gone the other way and made Solo look dominant in the right moments. It's rather telling from a character standpoint that he only felt comfortable confronting someone like Paul Heyman on his own.
Had Paul been a wrestler, Sikoa would've brought Jacob Fatu and Tama Tonga out with him as backup.
Back to the match. Everybody except maybe Tama got to show their wares throughout, and Drew even walked out with more chaos on his mind before Jey cut him short with a dive spot. That added some last minute hype to their Raw match on Monday, and it's sweet that WWE kept that clash in mind even when Uso was doing the tag thing here.
Yes, the six man could've benefitted from a little less time, but the extra minutes meant nobody had to rush. Telling stories has been a Bloodline hallmark. It's nice to see that continue in the interim no matter what's coming on Netflix.
2. Naomi & Nia Worked HARD!

There's obviously one distinct moment fans will remember from the Women's Title match on this week's show. More on that to come, but Naomi and Nia Jax deserve some plaudits first. Pre-cash in, they put in one hell of a shift out there. The match had several excellent near falls for Naomi, and there were a few sweet bumps from Jax peppering the second half.
Go out of your way to see this match even if you've read results and know the outcome. Sometimes, it's just nice to enjoy the process. Being upfront, this writer has been rough on Naomi since she returned to the promotion, so it's important to celebrate the good times and give praise when merited. Not everything needs to be doom and gloom, and this fan kinda gets a kick out of being proven wrong. Is that weird?!
Fingers crossed Naomi can carry this sort of form over to her seemingly inevitable heel turn. She's being outed as the woman who attacked Jade Cargill, right? It's either her or Bianca Belair. Either fits, but it'd be class to see Naomi over on the WWE heel side for the first time in a long time. She could do some refreshing work as a villain.
These women worked their butts off to put a bow on Nia's title reign properly. The match was Naomi's best singles effort in a while, and all of the extras around ringside (Belair, Candice LeRae and eventually Tiffany Stratton) added fuel to the fire that was blazing brightly inside.
This can't be said enough: Go watch and enjoy.
1. Tiffy Time Arrives

It's a lovely feeling to get totally fooled when you've watched countless hours of wrestling and think you've seen everything. WWE tricked an entire audience when Tiffany Stratton helped Nia Jax retain the Women's Title vs. Naomi. Then, Stratton pounced to seize her moment and cash in Money In The Bank. Fans popped huge for all of this, and there's no denying how well-worked the setup was; Tiffany feigned cashing in at first then shoved the ref over the barricade so she could thump Naomi with the case.
Nia smiled, LeRae let her guard down, Stratton celebrated, then...her devious plot hatched. That evil genius play charmed ringsiders, and it's clear Triple H has a real star on his hands. Yep, following up will be make or break for any title reign, but this was some start to 'Tiffy Time' on SmackDown. It's good to have the briefcase stuff in WWE's rearview mirror too.
That was beginning to drag on a bit. The beaten up case had to go, and it has. Stratton has replaced it with a shiny title belt, and now she can be the female tweener/babyface of everyone's dreams. People will be talking about and replaying this moment for years to come. It might even be one of the most satisfying MITB cash-ins ever.
Side note: Someone tell Jacob Fatu to stop using Tiffany’s finisher as a highspot. He used the 'Prettiest Moonsault Ever' move to get a near fall in the main event six man, which sucked when Stratton had used it to score a World Title earlier in the evening. Have a word, agents. This sort of stuff shouldn't be happening.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 50 Things You Learn Binge-Watching Every WWE Royal Rumble and 50 Things You Learn Binge-Watching Every WWE WrestleMania!