9 Ups & 2 Downs From NXT TakeOver: In Your House

A literally smashing night of pro wrestling...

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE.com

Did WWE just produce the best In Your House card ever?

Advertisement

It's an interesting debate, because the NXT crew's efforts far exceeded many previous cards in the pay-per-view series' 25-year old history. If you were looking for the best possible blend of nostalgic fuzziness and zippy, modern pro wrestling, then TakeOver had you covered, and it was glorious.

There's no point in ignoring the obvious - everyone reading this can see from the number of 'Ups' compared to 'Downs' that NXT's latest was a lot of fun. Maybe it didn't reach the heights of Canadian Stampede back in 1997, but that's perhaps an unfair comparison because WWE couldn't lean on a red hot crowd at Full Sail in 2020.

Advertisement

The various extras behind plexiglass at ringside - and the quite brilliant trio of Mauro Ranallo, Beth Phoenix and Tom Phillips on commentary - created enough atmosphere, and the show (at under two and a half hours) never threatened to overstay its welcome.

Between new champions, stipulations that didn't quite click, retro flavour and more, here are all the good points and bad from another memorable TakeOver...

Advertisement

Downs...

2. “Must End In The Ring”

WWE.com

Hmm.

Advertisement

That was the overriding feeling when WWE made it clear that Adam Cole vs. Velveteen Dream in a 'Backlot Brawl' had to end inside a wrestling ring. It kinda' ruins the point of an outside scrap if there's a proper ring present and the match "must" end between those ropes.

Dream and Cole worked wonders with that frankly mystifying stipulation though. If you enjoyed the mayhem of MITB (which, in fairness, put a ring on top of WWE HQ, so it might be a bit cheap to whine about what happened at TakeOver) and AEW's 'Stadium Stampede', then you'd have liked this one too.

Advertisement

Nice touches of comedy like an Uber driver showing up and stopping both men in their tracks, the inclusion of Cole's Undisputed Era cronies, Dexter Lumis and more made this a run romp through big spots and cinematic carnage despite the glaring presence of a ring.

1. Io Shirai Pins Rhea Ripley (Not Charlotte)

WWE.com

Hmm x2.

Advertisement

It always slightly cheapens things whenever a title changes hands during a Triple Threat match and the reigning champ going in isn't the one taking the fall. Of course, this is a neat way to protect someone and still switch a belt, but it wouldn't have hurt Charlotte Flair too badly to lose to Io Shirai.

Worse, Rhea Ripley is (yet again) the proverbial ugly duckling of the situation. The super-talented future of WWE's female ranks has been beaten in back-to-back major matches on pay-per-view, and that really sucks; it's hard to see why she'd take the fall here. Rhea vs. Io is surely next up for NXT now Flair is gone.

Advertisement

One cannot shake the feeling that Shirai could've hit her moonsault on Flair and pinned her instead as Ripley rolled around in agony from the Figure Eight. That, actually, would've made more sense - what was stopping Charlotte from reaching over and breaking up Shirai's pin on Rhea?

Ups...

9. That Retro Intro

WWE
“NXT, for over five and a half years, the revolutionary force in sports entertainment”.

What an intro line that was. It instantly fostered feelings of nostalgia for ye olde WWF programming, and that was furthered by the presence of the one, the only Todd Pettengill. The 'Toddster' looked like he hadn't lost a step. His cheesy banter worked, and the guy could probs still do a job for WWE today.

Advertisement

They should seriously think about bringing him back - Pettengill was flawless here, and he'd fit in nicely as a backstage interviewer on Raw, SmackDown or NXT in 2020. His joke about giving away a house (something the company did on the very first In Your House show back in 1995) was a nice touch too.

The whole intro was just nostalgia overload. Better yet, it was totally inoffensive for any younger viewers who might not have grasped what WWE were going for with the retro flavour. It's not like they went too far with it. Code Orange still provided that modern metal atmosphere.

Advertisement

8. The Set Design

WWE

Also, that set design.

Advertisement

It brought childhood memories flooding back to see the old house set, one that was a nice change of pace from WWE's typically video screen heavy sets today. Most of the promotion's designs are too similar to stand out, but that really helped In Your House stand alone.

The fact these were actual, tangible set pieces instead of graphics on a screen helped as well. Seeing the old screen panel work on the left was awesome, and so was the addition of a garage (which almost everyone not-named Johnny Gargano strolled out of) and the actual house door (which Gargano lurked behind before his match).

Advertisement

WWE should honestly ponder revitalising some other old props for NXT. This worked, and there's a market for classic gems from the archives like No Mercy, Armageddon and the timeless Backlash swinging spikes set if they really put their minds to it.

7. Opening With That Six-Woman Tag

WWE.com

Snagging the opening slot on the show was the six-woman tag's best shot at relevancy, so it was nice to see WWE recognise that they needed freshness on their side. Refreshingly, this was the kind of opener that the company would never have booked back when In Your House was a bi-monthly series.

Advertisement

Everyone involved got their chance to shine.

Raquel Gonzales channelled the spirit of Chyna with her look, Shotzi Blackheart was all energy, Candice LeRae played the bitch, Dakota Kai cowardly tried to avoid her rivals, Mia Yim was the composed veteran and Tegan Nox got a win she can point to in the future. Yep, this was good stuff.

Advertisement

Some of the best pay-per-views in history have opened with hot tag matches. This was reminiscent of the classics without stealing the best spots from more important bouts on the card. These women nailed everything they were going for.

6. Making The Most Of Things

WWE.com

Even Finn Bálor vs. Damian Priest was a winner.

Advertisement

That might sound slightly harsh, but this fan was 100% worried that this match would be the night's stinker - a popcorn break, if you like. Instead, it was way more exciting than it perhaps had any right to be. These guys made the most of what they had, and they also avoided stealing from later matches.

Priest's back bump on the steel ring steps was brutal, Bálor's hard work enhanced Damian's profile and Finn even got to set a new NXT record by bagging his 11th TakeOver win. That, according to motormouthed play-by-play man Mauro Ranallo, is the most in brand history to date.

Advertisement

This was the kind of match Priest needed. He doesn't always shine this brightly, but he benefitted big time from having someone like Bálor to glue his workmanlike bits and pieces together. Rather surprisingly, this would-be dud is well worth checking out.

5. Johnny Smarts

WWE.com

This writer has to admit when he's wrong, and he was totally wrong about what should headline TakeOver. Rather than go with the predicted Keith Lee vs. Johnny Gargano closer, WWE ended the night with the women's Triple Threat. That was absolutely the right call, because Lee vs. Gargano was more of a slow burner.

Advertisement

A slow burner with some epic storytelling.

Gargano's TakeOver matches always have some logical thread running through them, and this one was no different. He constantly focused on his opponent's injured hand whenever Lee looked to be on top, and he also aimed a few choice spots at big Keith's kayfabe scratched cornea. Fighting through all of this made Lee look tough as nails.

Advertisement

Credit to Tom Phillips for pointing out that Gargano targeted Lee's "good eye" (as in, the one Johnny hadn't previously injured) when he keyed it on the ring apron too. That defended a possible botch and eliminated any complaints from eagle-eyed fans.

4. Karrion Kross Dominates

WWE.com

Tommaso Ciampa got his licks in, but Karrion Kross knocked his lights out and dominated by way of his 'Kross Jacket' submission. This, in months to come, will be looked back on as a banner night for Kross and his woman Scarlett; Ciampa is still NXT royalty, and being booked to beat on a TakeOver card is nothing to sniff at.

Advertisement

The fact Kross did it by choking the life from Tommaso is even better.

Their match was exactly what it needed to be. Kross and Ciampa couldn't go epic because of Cole vs. Dream's 'Backlot Brawl', and they couldn't rely on some sort of developing injury storyline because of Lee vs. Gargano's hand and eye business. So, the duo kept things simple, and their bout was better for it.

Advertisement

WWE clearly think Kross is a future player on NXT. This smacked of a light 'passing the torch' moment from Ciampa, which is fine. The best match results come when the loser isn't negatively affected (which Tommaso isn't), but the winner looks like a killer.

3. Adam Cole Retains

WWE.com

Rumours are flying around right now about Adam Cole's WWE contract. It does look like he's keen on an extension though, and that should come as sweet news for any NXT hardcores. Nobody is a better choice as NXT Champion than Cole - therefore, WWE made the right choice by keeping that belt on him at In Your House.

Advertisement

It's maybe time for Velveteen Dream to try his luck on Raw or SmackDown anyway. No, he's never been NXT Champ, but Dream has been part of the brand's furniture for years now, and he doesn't want to drop down the pecking order when he's so talented. The only way he should be heading is up towards top titles on other shows.

The prematch stip said Dream couldn't challenge Cole again if he lost. He did, and that means this angle has to stop dead ASAP. The only logical move is for Velveteen to pull a Matt Riddle and seek pastures new. Then, Cole can join him when WWE finally supplant him as champion.

Advertisement

2. Io Shirai’s Big Dive

WWE.com

Well, someone had to do it.

Advertisement

It might as well have been the 'Genius Of The Sky', Io Shirai. Her spectacular leap from atop the house set onto Charlotte Flair and Rhea Ripley was one of the best moments from TakeOver. It was a nice, rather sneaky nod towards her fellow Japanese star Asuka's MITB antics too.

Somehow, the commentary trio managed to avoid making a Mick Foley reference (he famously jumped off his house in a home video as a teenager before becoming a world famous star), but at least they put Shirai's daredevil behaviour over big time. Ranallo said she'd do anything to become NXT Women's Champion.

Advertisement

There are too many through the ropes dive spots in wrestling generally, and it was nice to see something over the top like this replace one of those tired leaps of faith. Plus, it fits Io's character to take chances, and nobody got hurt. That's a win-win.

1. Switching The NXT Women’s Title

WWE.com

As annoying as it was to see Shirai pin Ripley and not Flair, it was the right call to switch that NXT Women's Title to her at TakeOver. Io will be a fine champ, and Charlotte is arguably needed more elsewhere now that Becky Lynch is on maternity leave.

Advertisement

WWE didn't waste time. They announced that Flair would be having a rematch on Raw against Asuka shortly after In Your House.

That plugs a gap in star power on one brand, and leaves the likes of Io Shirai, Rhea Ripley and others to continue their business over on NXT. The opening six-woman tag match at TakeOver proved how much talent this company has on the female side of things - the future is oh-so-bright.

Advertisement

Tegan Nox, Candice LeRae, Dakota Kai, Raquel Gonzalez, Shotzi Blackheart, Mia Yim, Rhea and Io makes quite the women's division. Flair isn't really needed on NXT at the moment. She's better off on Raw where she can taunt Asuka about WrestleMania 34 and claim she'll take a belt Asuka "never earned" away from her.

What did you think of NXT TakeOver: In Your House? For more like this, check out Ranking Every WWE In Your House From Worst To Best and 10 WWE Legends Embarrassed By Their Own Matches!

Advertisement