Ranking Every WWE In Your House From Worst To Best

Some absolute stinkers mixed with some stunning hidden gems...

WWE
"What is this, dad?"

Those were the honest words of an otherwise cheery young boy in 2018 when yours truly and a good friend fired up the WWE Network and chucked on an old In Your House pay-per-view. Said lad was allowed to stay up well past his bedtime, and had hoped for some wrasslin'-related hijinks. Instead, two old farts "treated him" to a night of retro action that clearly didn't go down well.

Maybe he'll change his tune now NXT has dipped into WWE's archives, reached for a mid-to-late-90s pay-per-view 'B' series and modernised it for the 2020s (which is absolutely terrifying to say). Oh yes, NXT's roster are guaranteed to produce some worthwhile fare, and they might even create the best In Your House show ever.

You'd be forgiven for thinking that wouldn't be a stretch - of the 27 events slapped with the In Your House branding, only a handful are truly essential. Others range from one-match wonders to atrociously-poor wastes of cash that people actually had to pay to watch.

This list ranks every single one from worst to best, and it refuses to pull any punches...


27. In Your House 4: Great White North

Diesel British Bulldog
WWE.com

Vince McMahon probably wanted to punch someone as he tossed his commentary headset angrily to the ground after In Your House 4's Diesel vs. British Bulldog main event. The pay-per-view, for lack of a better or more fitting word, had been absolutely sh*te.

Nobody needs to see 'King' Mabel and Yokozuna wrestle again.


26. D-Generation X: In Your House

Shawn Michaels Ken Shamrock
WWE.com

Less than one month after the controversy of Survivor Series (Montreal, and all that), the WWF put on a craptacular pay-per-view featuring no less than four DQ finishes on an eight match card. As if that wasn't bad enough, they also booked past-his-prime Sgt. Slaughter to go 17 minutes with Triple H, and cast Sarge as the babyface despite D-Generation X's connection with the rebellious audience.

Swing and a miss.


25. In Your House 1

Bret Hart Jerry Lawler
WWE.com

The inaugural In Your House event had a fine Bret Hart vs. Hakushi match and a decent handicap effort pitting Razor Ramon against Jeff Jarrett and The Roadie. So, why it is so far down this list? Try to sit through the interminable Diesel vs. Sid main event and Mabel vs. Adam Bomb to see why.

Bret's brilliance was all the federation had here.


24. In Your House 8: Beware Of Dog

Steve Austin Savio Vega Strap Match
WWE.com

Who turned out the lights?

In Your House 8 has become famous for the fact that power failed inside the building on 26 May. Two nights later, the WWF scrambled together a redo of matches that fans watching on pay-per-view had missed completely. The whole thing was a mess, although you should go out of your way to see Steve Austin and Savio Vega in a 'Strap Match'.


23. In Your House 12: It's Time

Bret Hart Sycho Sid
WWE.com

This was an event named after Vader that didn't have Vader on it, and that perhaps says it all. Instead of a proposed Shawn Michaels vs. Vader rematch, the WWF put Sycho Sid in there with Bret Hart and kept the "It's Time" tagline for...some reason. That wasn't the only problem the show had.

Every match, possibly barring a fine Flash Funk vs. Leif Cassidy opener, felt lacking.


22. Rock Bottom: In Your House

Undertaker Steve Austin Buried Alive
WWE.com

The Undertaker and Steve Austin never shared much chemistry together despite their combined star power, and that showed at Rock Bottom: In Your House in December 1998. The Rock's very own pay-per-view came across as a house show with cameras more than anything, and there were just too many TV-esque matches.

It was a three hour Raw with a 'Buried Alive' bout, basically.


21. In Your House 2

Jeff Jarrett Shawn Michaels
WWE

Tune into In Your House 2 and you'll get a kick out of seeing future DX buddies The Roadie (Road Dogg) and 1-2-3 Kid (X-Pac) lapping up the spotlight in the opener. You're also likely to enjoy Shawn Michaels vs. Jeff Jarrett for the IC belt. Then, Diesel and Sid ruin things by putting on another stinker of a headliner.

The WWF was totally directionless in mid-1995, and it shows here.


20. In Your House 5: Seasons Beatings

Bret Bulldog In Your House 5
WWE

Bloody matches weren't exactly common place in 1995 WWF. That's why In Your House 5 feels weightier than IYH 2; Bret Hart vs. British Bulldog for the title ends up being a claret-soaked war that, whilst inferior to their SummerSlam '92 effort, is still worth watching.

A one match show, perhaps, but that could be said for a lot of these cards.


19. In Your House 9: International Incident

Sycho Sid Owen Hart
WWE.com

Case in point.

'International Incident' turned out a totally respectable and riotously fun six-man tag main event. Shawn Michaels teamed with Sycho Sid and Ahmed Johnson to face Vader, The British Bulldog and Owen Hart, and there's enough superb talent in there to make those 24 minutes race by. Even big Sid pulled his weight.


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.