How Good Was Brock Lesnar Actually?

Is 'The Beast' one of WWE's best or completely overrated? Time to rank it.

By Terry Bezer /

WWE.com

The sun is finally setting on the nearly 25-year pro wrestling career of Brock Lesnar.

Advertisement

He's a former amateur wrestling champion, an ex-UFC Heavyweight Champ and was once the youngest WWE Champion of all time, but just how revered is Brock in the history of this company and pro wrestling at large? 

This is a man who has had run-ins vs. everyone from Hulk Hogan to Cody Rhodes. He's stood across the ring from The Rock at his absolute zenith, and is currently paving the way for future great Oba Femi. On the surface, it feels as though there are no holes in Lesnar's armour, but is that really true? Is there something lacking from the skillset of one of the most decorated combat sports athletes of all-time?

That's what we are going to examine today as we go deep into the belly of 'The Beast'. The mayor of 'Suplex City' and "the 1 in 21-1" has had a glittering wrestling career, but this is an in-depth exposé which asks the burning question: Just how good was Brock Lesnar...actually?!

10. Presence/Look/Presentation

The craziest thing about Brock Lesnar? His presence is the dictionary definition of “undeniable”. The word “aura” is thrown around to describe any old nonsense in the modern era, but Lesnar exudes an intimidation factor that is almost entirely unique to him. When he first arrived, he looked like a monster, but WWE (and Paul Heyman in particular) wanted you to know that he was a legit badass away from the world of pro wrestling.

Advertisement

This was an NCAA Division 1 heavyweight wrestling champion. Pro wrestling matches are all about how much you can convince the audience to buy into what you’re selling. When Brock Lesnar is annihilating men who looked like they were chiseled from stone, you believe that he could actually do that. This only magnified when he went to the UFC and became their Heavyweight Champion, then returned to WWE wearing fight gloves in his matches; WWE has purposefully accentuated the public knowledge that Lesnar is a certified bad, bad man to its advantage.

As for Lesnar’s theme music, the opening noise is perfect for his arrival. It sounds like a death knell from hell, and gives an instant feeling that everyone’s safety is in imminent danger. The brute force of the music itself pairs perfectly with the way Lesnar bounces on the spot before his intimidating walk to the ring.

It’s as explosive as the man in question.

Heyman also has a very specific walk when he’s leading his 'Beast' to the ring too. When he was the 'Special Council' to the 'Tribal Chief' Roman Reigns, Heyman walked with humility and reverence for his client. When he leads Brock Lesnar into battle or a promo segment, he walks with a swagger, a street strut, and like his balls are 10lbs too heavy for his body. Heyman is a vital part of Lesnar’s entire presentation. He's his biggest cheerleader on every level, in real life and on screen.

As for Brock’s looks over the years, there’s been a justifiable approach of “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it”. Lesnar is arguably the toughest man to ever enter a wrestling ring. His bulging eyes, immense physique and legitimized toughness make Lesnar a walking main attraction, matched only by Andre The Giant and potentially Oba Femi in the future. The “techno viking”, cowboy hat-wearing look of his current (and perhaps final) run doesn’t quite have the intimidation factor of old, but that feels like a relative irrelevance to the bigger picture.

8.5/10

9. Promos

This is a strange bridge to cross with Brock, as Paul Heyman has operated as Brock Lesnar’s mouthpiece for much of his WWE career.

Advertisement

Heyman is one of the best public speakers of all time, and he does a magnificent job of selling Lesnar’s toughness and why he is such a unique talent in the pantheons of wrestling history. Hell, you can’t even read Brock Lesnar’s name without hearing Heyman’s signature way of saying it. Heyman is the originator of the term ‘Suplex City’, which defined one of the most dominant spells of Lesnar’s career. The advocate was majestic in goading the still reeling New Orleans audience on Raw the night after WrestleMania XXX, referring to Lesnar as “the 1 in 21-1” after Brock conquered The Undertaker’s undefeated streak.

This isn’t to suggest Lesnar can’t speak. To take us out of pro wrestling for a second, his intense hatred of mediocre fighter Frank Mir had him spitting one of the best promos in the history of the UFC, including telling the world that he’d pulled out the horseshoe Mir had up his ass and then beat him over the head with it, seconds after smashing him into the next realm. His steely-eyed words in the run-up to fights also made people want to pay to see him in the Octagon.

Nevertheless, in WWE, Lesnar feels like a more menacing presence when he stands grimacing in the background as his advocate does the talking for him.

5/10

8. In-Ring Ability

Lesnar’s transition to pro wrestling is nothing short of magnificent.

Advertisement

His natural explosiveness for a man of his size is breathtaking. The role of the big man is usually to work slower because of their hoss size, but Brock turned that idea on its head from the minute he arrived in WWE, blowing people away like a hurricane in 2002. To witness someone work with such speed and velocity whilst also being built like a tank is quite simply one of wrestling’s greatest in-ring sights.

Watching Brock put an opponent in a Kimura Lock feels more impactful because we’ve seen him submit a monster like Shane Carwin in UFC. His German and belly-to-belly suplexes are performed with maximum devastation because he is a world-class amateur wrestler who is built like a barbarian. When he puts an opponent in the corner and charges his shoulder into their gut, it looks so spectacular because he’s enormous and he connects with such celerity.

The F5 is literally perfect as a finisher: Whether it’s hoisting an opponent up and spinning them like they’re pizza dough, or straining to pick up a heavier adversary before devastating them to the ground, the F5 has all of the drama and impact necessary to signal the end of a match. His monstrous facial expressions after lofting an opponent onto his shoulders are also pitch-perfect.

Something that is often overlooked about Brock is his ability to sell for his opponent. The reason Brock has so many memorable in-ring epics is that he is always willing to make the offence of the man standing opposite him look great. He is an unselfish worker, and that only adds to his brilliance in the ring.

9/10

7. Time’s Test

Something that’s great about Brock is that you can only ever imagine him as a main event talent, and he’d have been that in any promotion at any point in wrestling history. This may sound like hyperbole, but let’s examine the evidence.

Advertisement

So few men in the history of wrestling would have been dangerous and credible enough for the savage crowd in ECW, big enough to compete with Hogan, Nash, and Goldberg in WCW, and have the natural star appeal to hang with the heavyweights of the 'Attitude Era'. He would have been perfect as a WrestleMania opponent in the era of Hulk and 'Hulkamania', and had the chops to put on clinics with Bret and Shawn as he did with Angle and Benoit. Lesnar made magic with Guerrero and CM Punk too. No matter what you might think of accusations that exist against Lesnar away from the ring, Brock is bulletproof inside the squared circle and as a box office attraction in wrestling.

He would’ve been an attraction in the days of the territories because of his size and willingness to bleed for his art, and he spent the majority of his career thriving in the PG-era of WWE. He blew away The Rock at his height, and he is currently being used by the TKO-era of WWE to legitimize wrestling’s next bonafide superstar in Oba Femi.

Maybe there’s a question about his ability to sell feuds at the elite level without Paul Heyman as his advocate, but even that feels speculative. There is simply no world or era in which Lesnar doesn’t rank among the best members of any roster ever assembled by anyone anywhere. He’s a freak of nature and has an undeniable presence that is almost entirely unique to 'The Beast Incarnate'.

9/10

6. Cultural Significance

This is a tricky subject matter with regard to Brock.

Advertisement

For all the immense accolades we’ve spoken about thus far, pro wrestling has always felt like it’s a job for Brock Lesnar more than a passion. He cares immensely about anything he puts his name on, and it never feels like Lesnar is half-baked in anything he does, but to connect with WWE’s audience at the highest level, you have to feel like the performer loves the art of it, and that’s rarely the case with 'The Beast'.

This is where it gets difficult. Lesnar is essential to the 'Ruthless Aggression' era and was one of the few superstars Vince McMahon knew how to book well and maintain as a box-office draw in his woeful last decade as a promoter. He has held WWE’s main championship 10 times in 3 different eras and no other title in the company, because even the Intercontinental Title feels too small for the waist of Brock. He brings legit sports cred to WWE from his time in the UFC, and is a definitive character in WWE's modern history.

When he hangs up his boots (and actually remains retired), he will go down as one of the best big men in wrestling history. Why is it, then, that WWE fans don’t feel all misty-eyed about him in the way that they do about the other men and women who have enjoyed his level of success? The only real answer to that is around the speculation that Brock is in it for the money.

7/10

5. Rivalries

Brock has had something of a mixed bag when it comes to rivalries.

Advertisement

He arrived in WWE like a bulldozer, destroying anyone who stood in his way, and his first real rivalry was one for the ages with Kurt Angle. Both men have legitimate amateur wrestling pedigrees at the highest level, and both made transitioning to Vince McMahon’s universe look like a piece of cake. They created magic together that headlined WrestleMania and justified their position in commanding that spot, and had great chemistry in the ring and in the buildup to this showcase. Throw in their 2003 'Iron Man' classic on SmackDown and this is one of Brock's best feuds to date.

In contrast, Lesnar has headlined multiple 'Manias with Roman Reigns, and it’s never felt particularly compelling. Maybe that’s because Brock was working with an underdeveloped version of Reigns, or maybe it’s because they don’t have the chemistry required to hook audiences in. Whatever the case, Reigns and Lesnar never felt like the all-time feud that it could (and perhaps should) have been.

This is again contrasted by his brilliant feuds with John Cena. John is the most wholesome babyface in wrestling history, and Lesnar is the ultimate playground bully. Cena and Lesnar both have undeniable star appeal, and they always matched up perfectly. If styles make fights and feuds, then John and Brock’s “Captain America meets Thanos” schtick fit together like peanut butter and jelly in timeless fashion for multiple runs.

The Undertaker’s respect for Brock Lesnar translated into great TV time and matches together. Even beyond their unforgettable WrestleMania XXX moment, the 2 legendary big men had great feuds together in the aftermath of their moment that will last forever. Lesnar is also the only man to wrestle any quality out of Goldberg in WWE, reiterating his ability to sell his opponent’s offence.

Watching Jon Moxley in AEW, it's wild to think about how badly he and Lesnar fit together on the road to WrestleMania 32. Their 'No Holds Barred' match at AT&T Stadium in Dallas was one of the biggest misfires in the history of 'Mania. Even now, it’s mind-boggling to consider how guys who seemed perfect for one another on paper created such an unconvincing mess of a feud and pay-off.

There are great but short feuds between Lesnar and CM Punk, Seth Rollins and The Rock too, but these feuds generally are not as undeniable as other weapons in his arsenal.

7/10

4. Moments

Brock has some all-time great moments in his cannon, but one stands out above all else: WrestleMania XXX started with Steve Austin, Hogan and The Rock, followed by Daniel Bryan beating Triple H to reach the main event of the evening. The crowd was white hot from this opening combo and didn't remotely cool until they were stunned into a silence that usually only accompanies an accident - Lesnar pinning The Undertaker at 'Mania and snapping his streak, laughing with his tongue out afterwards as the stunned guy in his 'Just Say Yes' shirt looked on with an expression of sheer disbelief in the front row became the stuff of legend.

Advertisement

Lesnar's victory became mainstream global sports and entertainment news for days afterwards. It is in the top 5 biggest moments in WrestleMania history, and it belongs to Brock.

He became the youngest WWE Champion in history by pinning Rock at SummerSlam 2002. Revisit that match and listen to how red hot the crowd is. They explode as Lesnar stops a People’s Elbow attempt with a decapitation-worthy clothesline, and roar as Brock hoists the 'People’s Champ' up onto his shoulders for the winning F5. The night 'The Next Big Thing' became the face of the company was magical.

It was also at SummerSlam in 2014 that he manhandled John Cena in another of WWE’s most shocking nights. The stunned reaction inside LA's Staples Center and amongst a watching global audience was palpable, as Lesnar landed 16 German suplexes to take Cena apart in a one-sided battering. Cena deserves applause for going with a plan that the likes of Hogan and Hunter would never have succumbed to, but it’s just another reason Lesnar is a one-of-one. It was believable because even ‘Super Cena’ couldn’t stop a former UFC champion from having his way with him in whatever fashion he pleased.

WWE had never seen a ring explode and be reduced to rubble until Lesnar and Big Show literally tore the thing apart on SmackDown in 2003, and he even took a ring apart with a forklift truck during his SummerSlam 2022 match with Roman Reigns. His 'No Disqualification' war with CM Punk at SummerSlam 2013 was perfection. Kicking John Cena’s cap after F5'ing him on his WWE return was amazingly “school bully”, and he was even able to get a good WrestleMania match out of an aged and empty Bill Goldberg.

There is also a catalogue of meme-worthy moments in his repertoire, such as his sitting-up stand off with The Undertaker, dancing while using the Money In The Bank briefcase as a boombox while Heyman played air guitar behind him, and also falling on his butt on a 2026 episode of Raw.

It’d be remiss not to mention the flubbed Shooting Star Press at the end of his 'Mania XIX match with Angle, but the bout itself between the duo was still a breathtaking spectacle. There’s also being booed out of the building after one of the worst matches in WrestleMania history vs. Goldberg at WrestleMania XX, with the crowd raining jeers down on both men mercilessly as they were leaving WWE that evening.

Nevertheless, Lesnar has a highlight reel that is the envy of any big man to ever enter WWE, or wrestling as a whole.

9/10

3. Range

Brock Lesnar is a cyborg-like killing machine. To extend the range of that ethos would be to dilute its impact. If you’re looking for a diverse range of approaches to pro wrestling, then Lesnar is not 'The Beast' you're looking for.

Advertisement

One of Brock's best-selling t-shirts says: ‘Eat. Sleep. Conquer. Repeat.’ It’s fitting, because whether he is a face or a heel that is Brock’s MO. He's here to kick ass and chew bubblegum, and you ain’t ever seen Brock Lesnar chewing on some Hubba Bubba.

One of the things that works when analysing Heyman in Brock's corner is that Lesnar is tailor-made to feel like a monster being led out of his pit on a leash to destroy WWE’s next leading contender. He’s a man of actions and not words, and that limits him when it comes to range.

There isn’t a litany of different character changes and looks when it comes to Brock. He's simply a walking spectacle and has been used in pretty much the same way from his time as 'The Next Big Thing' in 2002 to what appears to be his current farewell run in 2026.

4/10

2. Drawing Power

'The Beast' has headlined WrestleMania 5 times. For the record, that’s more than Bret Hart, Randy Orton, Seth Rollins and Randy Savage, and as many times as The Undertaker.

Advertisement

In the doldrums of the 2010s, Brock was one of the only true box office draws that WWE could rely on. The whole argument for Brock being the man to beat 'Taker’s streak was that it would make him WWE’s “end of level” boss for the foreseeable future, something that worked relatively successfully. Not only did Brock draw major money during this difficult period, but he also gave WWE an enormous boost in credibility that they sorely lacked in their product during that time.

This street cred is worth mentioning when it comes to Brock’s relevance as a box office draw, as he was a huge star for the UFC too. His UFC 100 fight with Frank Mir drew a massive 1.6 million buys, and still boasts the biggest UFC PPV buy rate not to include Conor McGregor.  

When WWE inked their $1 billion deal with FOX to take SmackDown to the US broadcasting giant, Brock Lesnar winning the WWE Title in an incredibly galling fashion from Kofi Kingston was what Vince McMahon chose to lead with as his headline attraction.

7/10

1. Conclusion

If we're talking about the Mount Rushmore of wrestling monsters, then Brock is surely guaranteed his place on that landmark. He's a phenom in the ring, responsible for some of the biggest WWE moments of the 21st century, and someone who could hang at the elite level of any roster ever assembled. He doesn’t have a broad range of contributions across a nearly 25-year run, but there’s no need to deviate from a formula that has proven itself to be truly timeless.

Advertisement

Lesnar isn't the best at promos, but his career has involved arguably the best talker in wrestling history flapping his gums on behalf of "Brrrroooooock Lesnar". There’s a suspicion amongst fans that he enjoys the size of wrestling’s payoffs more than he’s in love with the squared circle, and that can stop some from embracing Brock's legacy in the way that they could and probably should. The counterargument to that is that he’s a consummate professional in the ring and does a magnificent job of unselfishly selling for his opponent at all times.

There may also be an immovable stain to come in Brock’s legacy due to his name being heavily attached to the Janel Grant case. For now though, fans are embracing perhaps the final run from a giant of the game, and celebrating the career of a true WWE legend into the bargain.

8/10

Advertisement