13 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE SmackDown On FOX (Oct 4)

Cain Velasquez & Tyson Fury debut, Brock Lesnar becomes WWE Champion, and more!

The Rock Becky Lynch
WWE.com

Last night's SmackDown needed to be huge.

It was the biggest show of this crazy week in wrestling, edging out AEW's explosive Dynamite debut and Sunday's neglected Hell In A Cell pay-per-view. It was also night one of the biggest television contract in the sport's history. This is FOX. This is big time. Even with things like The Rock, Kofi Kingston vs. Brock Lesnar, and the promise of change on deck, it needed to deliver.

And it did.

This was WWE television at its biggest, loudest, and most bombastic. Hitting the airwaves with a fresh soundtrack, set, and presentation style, the new A-show raced through two hours of all-action programming crammed with newsworthy events. Combat sports athletes invaded the Staples Center to confront two of WWE's biggest and baddest, a new WWE Champion was crowned in a controversial main event, and WWE's most marketable modern star rubbed shoulders with The Rock. Elsewhere, NXT's old Four Horsewomen locked horns in tag action, Kevin Owens and Shane McMahon battled for their careers, and The Fiend tormented Seth Rollins once more.

Let's dive into it...

(Author's note: so it turns out the previous week's "last column ever spiel" was a tad premature. Sorry about that. This is the last one, though. I promise.)


Downs...

2. Big Lads, Big Snoozefest

Roman Reigns dive
WWE.com

While putting a couple of big lads in the ring to theoretically knock lumps out of each other could've been a smart, legitimacy-building move from WWE on this FOX debut, said big lads didn't knock lumps out of each other. Instead, Erick Rowan and Rowan Reigns elected to work a mundane run-of-the-mill midcard bout that was as plodding as Rowan's new entrance theme.

The lumberjack stipulation gave it a shot of extra flavour, but not much. For the most part, this was a routine bout worked at a house show pace, though Reigns did hit an awesome-looking dive to the outside. The one big spot wasn't enough to save it, though.

These two brutes kicking the absolute sh*t out of each other for nine minutes would have been a great look considering all the new eyes on the product last night. Alas, it wasn't to be. This was boring.


1. Kofi Deserved Better

Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

The complete non-pop Kofi Kingston received when his entrance music hit for last night's main event shows, once again, the hordes of WWE have zoned out from his title reign. This column has argued several times that a change was due. KofiMania was incredible, the Daniel Bryan match ruled, and Kingston has been presented as a fighting champion throughout these past six months, but the WWE Championship reign wasn't half as compelling as the chase. He should have lost to Brock Lesnar last night.

But not like this.

Kingston lasted just nine seconds against 'The Beast Incarnate,' with a single F5 all it took to finish him off. This stinks. Surely WWE could have granted their champion at least a slither on his offence on his way out? Surely they could have let him go out as he reigned? Instead, they squashed him. They snuffed him out with a move that Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins have kicked out of dozens of times between them.

The Samoa Joe/Great Balls of Fire format would've resonated a lot better, with Kofi taking a quick advantage with a lightning-fast flurry of offence before eventually falling to the unstoppable force. Instead, WWE did him dirty.


Ups...

13. Ready For A Good Time

Last night's SmackDown kicked off with the briefest of introductions from Stephanie and Vince McMahon rolling into a brand new opening video, and it ruled.

A big, slick production with all kinds of jazzy effects, it highlighted major stars like Randy Orton, Becky Lynch, and Roman Reigns, perhaps teasing how next week's draft might pan out. Regardless, it looked and felt big time. This was as critical as hooking up with AC/DC, whose "Are You Ready" provides the new soundtrack - a welcome break from the rancid butt-rock wrestling promotions usually go for.

Making a strong first impression is always critical. WWE did that here, setting off on their maiden FOX voyage in style.


12. A Fresh Lick Of Paint

Brock Lesnar new SmackDown set
WWE.com

Holy sh*t, that new set design is awesome.

While Raw's Tony Hawk Pro Wrestler aesthetic feels similar to the previous wall-of-videos design, SmackDown's new layout is totally different. Yes, there are a lot of new video panels, but the four brackets at either side of the stage, new entrance tunnel, and illuminated ramp look great, as does the new lighting rig. These things combined to give SD a bold, cinematic feel every time the camera caught them, giving WWE's new A-show an A+ look.

The way a wresting show looks is important. In doing away with the old screen, WWE have erased much of the staleness that had crept into SmackDown's presentation.


11. Spotlight Dodgers

Mark Henry Goldberg
WWE.com

It was refreshing to see WWE not go all-in on old-timers last night, with the majority of SmackDown's guest stars appearing only as faces in the crowd.

The likes of Ric Flair, Hulk Hogan, Kurt Angle, and Mick Foley all made quiet ring entrances while SD was on commercials, before waving and smiling for the camera as it cut to them for four/five seconds at a time. Mark Henry and Goldberg lended their shocked reactions to Brock Lesnar's win over Kofi Kingston. Lita and Trish Stratus where there too, and again, they didn't hog the spotlight.

Not only were the legends not used to detract from full-time performers. but their minimal usage helped prevent a major cram on an already packed show. Kudos to WWE. Here's hoping they use this approach more often in the future.

Pretty weird that the pre-advertised Sting, Undertaker, and Steve Austin didn't appear on the main show though...


10. Hire Erin Andrews

FS1's Erin Andrews appeared early in the broadcast, interviewing The New Day ahead of Kofi Kingston's match with Brock Lesnar. She was a total breath of fresh air. While the segment's point wasn't to get her over, she's a slick, professional broadcaster with a bit of personality, and meshed well with Kingston, Woods, and Big E to elevate a relatively routine segment. Contrast with some of the more robotic speakers WWE have thrown into this role over the past few years.

The New Day had a little fun with the interview. They gyrated into the scene before Kingston put himself over as the big-time underdog he is, promising to leave Woods and E behind so that he could "climb the mountain alone." That didn't exactly work out for him in the end, but it followed Kofi's general presentation as champion.


9. The Two-Man Booth

Corey Graves Michael Cole
WWE

What a joy to see WWE return to a two-man booth on last night's SmackDown, with Renee Young moved away from the announce team to focus on other tasks, leaving Corey Graves and Michael Cole to handle the show.

The result was a smoother viewing experience largely devoid of the usual commentary complications. WWE's third announcer too often feels like a third wheel, no matter who it is, with the likes of Young and Byron Saxton bringing little to the table other than a handful of excited yelps. In removing them, WWE have hit the sweet spot.

The commentary still wasn't perfect (and never will be with Vince McMahon's overproduction), but this was a definite improvement, and it was good to see Cole and Graves going out of there way to make the show more accessible to new fans as well. They went into much greater detail than usual with their descriptions of what was going on, contextualising everything with FOX's bigger viewership. A smart, smart move, though they'll need to remove the kid gloves as the new audience's familiarity with the product increases.


8. Hell In A Fun House

Firefly Fun House Seth ROllins
WWE.com

Last night's Firefly Fun House saw Bray Wyatt's fancy jingle interrupt Seth Rollins before his match with Intercontinental Champion Shinsuke Nakamura.

Bray was looking all intense and creepy and that, before flipping his personality and going full-on happy-clappy. He then ran through the Fun House's cast, perhaps for new viewers, before providing a preview of what was going to happen to Seth when he meets The Fiend inside Hell in a Cell. This saw Ramblin' Rabbit pitted against the much larger Mercy the Buzzard in a little red cage, and Mercy savaged the little puke, tearing far too much stuffing out of the poor, beaten toy, which means Sunday's pay-per-view is definitely closing with Rollins' entrails splattered across the arena.

A relatively routine Fun House here, though a routine Fun House is still good content, even though Seth does look like a bit of a goober selling these things. Somebody get that man some extra acting lessons.


7. The Fiend Ravages Rollins

The Fiend Seth Rollins
WWE.com

There was no need for Seth Rollins vs. Shinsuke Nakamura to go any longer than it did. Having the Intercontinental or Universal Champion eat a pin or submission wouldn't have been ideal at the moment, and the whole thing was only booked to facilitate The Fiend's ambush of 'The Beastslayer.' Besides, doesn't it make sense that Bray Wyatt would choose to maul Seth early on rather than sitting around backstage, twiddling his thumbs, just letting the former Shield man wrestle?

A predictable but effective go-home angle saw Rollins retreated to the stage when Wyatt's gimmicks started hitting. A swell in crowd noise told the viewer that The Fiend had emerged behind him, and Bray struck, downing the Universal Champion with a Mandible Claw.

It's something we've seen several times before in recent weeks, but screw it. This worked. It was designed to show that Rollins is in deep, deep trouble at Hell In A Cell, and accomplished that effectively.


6. Reaching For The Stars

Tyson Fury
WWE.com

There was talk a few months ago that WWE had been reaching out to a number of celebrities and FOX TV personalities to ensure that SmackDown would look big-time on launch night, recruiting an all-star cast to present Vince McMahon's promotion as the major leagues, and everything else as small fry. They succeeded in doing so.

While the use of celebrities wasn't anywhere near as gratuitous as many had speculated, the inclusion of several WWE legends, two legit combat sports killers in Cain Velasquez and Tyson Fury, and FS1's Erin Andrews elevated the old B-show to a different level. These guests, coupled with the new stage and general presentation tweaks, sold SmackDown as a big-time, attention-grabbing Hollywood wrestling show.

It'll be interesting to see if WWE can maintain this going forward, but SD looked and felt like the top tier last night. Even WWE's other shows felt a lot smaller by comparison.


5. Four Horsewomen Lead The Way

Charlotte Flair Sasha Banks
WWE.com

Using NXT's old Four Horsewomen as a reintroduction to SmackDown's in-ring product was a sharp move that demonstrates just how much WWE value these performers and what they bring to the table.

It would've been easy for the company to throw a Seth Rollins, Roman Reigns, or Brock Lesnar into this spot, but no: they went with Charlotte Flair and Becky Lynch vs. Bayley and Sasha Banks. New viewers would have immediately known that these people and their ongoing issues are big deals.

It helps that the match was a little firecracker, too. While not quite on par with the banger they worked in Madison Square Garden a few weeks ago, it was short, snappy, and full of life. These four have worked together so often that they could've just coasted on chemistry. Instead, they performed with real urgency, crafting a complimentary layout that kept the crowd on the edge of their seats, with Flair eventually tapping Bayley out with the Figure Eight.

A tasty teaser for the weekend's two Women's Title matches, this tagger hit the mark.


4. The 'Strow & The Fury

Braun Strowman Tyson Fury
WWE.com

Last night's Braun Strowman/Tyson Fury confrontation made major waves in the United Kingdom, with outlets that wouldn't normally touch professional wrestling with a barge pole (The Guardian, Independent, etc.) covering the story. The angle is already an objective success. It has created levels of buzz and generated exposure that wouldn't normally be possible, so no matter what awaits when WWE hand Fury a live microphone on Raw, the programme has already done its job.

The angle almost felt hotter than the Cain Velasquez/Brock Lesnar segment that closed the show, too.

It began during Braun's arbitrary eight-man tag against AJ Styles, Robert Roode, Dolph Ziggler, and Randy Orton. That bout quickly broke down into a daft big move buffet, and Strowman first crossed paths with the heavyweight boxer after charging around the ring, knocking everyone down with shoulder charges. The squared up, teasing conflict. Seconds later, Braun knocked Tyson down by throwing Ziggler towards him, then hit the ring, scored the 1-2-3, and celebrated.

Cue: Fury hoping the barricade as an army of security guards surged around him, keeping him from planting a fist on Strowman's chin. An everything angle born of a nothing match, this was totally worth it.


3. Kill The King

The Rock
WWE.com

Complaining about those very WWE segments in which someone from the past shows up to batter a full-time roster member is common, but context is key. The participants matter. Not every legend's beatdown is a burial, as was demonstrated last night, with The Rock and Becky Lynch joining forces to take Baron Corbin out.

This was bloody marvellous. It began with the King of the Ring interrupting 'The Man' and her show-opening promo, before The Rock's theme music blasted around the building to a massive form. 'The Brahma Bull' was in classic form thereafter, ripping into Corbin, his costume, and everything else, with Becky claiming that if she had testicles, they'd be bigger than Baron's.

Corbin tried to blast back by insulting LeBron James, but nah. That didn't work. Rather than getting the better of the babyfaces, Corbin got whooped, eating a People's Elbow, a Lynch leg drop, and the Rock Bottom before rolling out of the ring, leaving Dwayne and Becky reigning supreme.

Lynch got a decent rub by standing with Rocky and Corbin's character is calibrated for moments like this. He's a guy who lives to eat sh*t, and there's nothing wrong with said sh*t being served by 'The Man' and WWE's biggest mainstream crossover star.


2. That's Gotta Be Cain!

Cain Velasquez Rey Mysterio
WWE.com

A couple of caveats with this one:-

1. Cain Velasquez vs. Brock Lesnar is informed by their MMA history. Cain TKO'd Brock to become UFC Heavyweight Champion at UFC 121 back in 2010. If you didn't know this beforehand, there's a chance you got nothing out of last night's show-closer.

2. Velasquez probably should've kept that t-shirt on. He's a stone-cold killer, but he looks less than impressive when stood next to Brock.

Regardless, this was a suitably shocking end to a night of major thrills and spills. Brock and Paul Heyman were celebrating in the ring when Rey Mysterio's music hit, and out stepped the lucha legend with Cain by his side. A brief staredown ensued. Then, Velasquez took Lesnar to the mat and bludgeoned him with ground and pound, forcing the new WWE Champion to flee up the ramp.

A big, impactful debut to close a big, impactful show, let's see if the duo's worked bout is as compelling as their shoot fight was.


1. See Ya, Shane

Shane McMahon Kevin Owens
WWE.com

It's hard to invest too much into WWE's "loser leaves town" stipulations. People get "fired" from the company only to return days later all the time, which makes you really feel stupid when you take these things at face value, so perhaps this entry is a set-up for a fall.

Screw it, though. Shane McMahon vs. Kevin Owens was an awesome plunder match with absolutely the right result.

'The Best In The World' is at his most compelling in scraps like this, where he can be a crash test dummy for 10-15 minutes without trying to present himself as a serious, credible wrestler. He played his role well, as he has done throughout this feud, eating major bumps while throwing his own body around the ring with trademark recklessness, showing that when the situation calls for it, the former SmackDown Commissioner will do business.

Owens ended the bout after bouncing Shane's body off a ladder in the corner, then scaling the steps to score the legal papers. McMahon is gone, apparently. He's done. Here's hoping that this isn't the usual ruse and that those reports that FOX wanted less involvement from non-wrestling figures were accurate.

The best part of all of this is that KO can finally move on. Let's hope a brighter future awaits him regardless of where he lands in the upcoming daft.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.