The WORST Moment From Every WWE WrestleMania

41 iterations of WrestleMania and 41 moments WWE would rather you forgot.

WWE WrestleMania 40 Jimmy Jey Uso
WWE.com

There's something about the name WrestleMania that just feels good. It's like a cosy pair of slippers or a hug in pro wrestling form. In WWE circles, you'll see workers stare off into the distance like they're about to go on a movie monologue as they talk about 'Mania being important to their formative years as a fan and the ultimate destination for anyone pulling on a pair of boots.

Binge-watching every show to date is an experience. You'll see some of the best matches in industry history, and there's a truckload of fabulous moments waiting for those who boot up the archives and get stuck in. Despite all of those greatest hits memories WrestleMania has thrown up, there's a flip side.

Welcome to that flip side.

To date, WWE has produced no less than 41 editions of its most famous event. The series began in 1985 with a make or break evening for the McMahon family, and it has blossomed into an international stadium show special that even draws lapsed fans back for another round annually.

All of that gooey positivity surrounding 'Mania? Leave it at the door, then come on in to experience the worst that Vince McMahon's vision (now guided by Triple H and those money-grabbing folks at TKO) has had to offer across 5 different decades.

We're running chronologically here, so things will kick off with the original WrestleMania at Madison Square Garden in the mid-1980s then finish with the latest supershow from April 2025.

Enjoy the ride!

41. Lord Alfred Hayes Looks…Scared?! (WrestleMania I)

WWE WrestleMania I Lord Alfred Hayes
WWE

The first WrestleMania is rough to revisit.

There, it's been said. Obviously, anyone interested in the history of WWE or pro wrestling as a whole should endeavour to sit down and give it a watch, but don't go in expecting much. Most of the matches will bore you senseless unless you're content to bask in the retro atmosphere or enjoy how crowds reacted differently in 1985 before they'd seen practically everything the medium has to offer.

Rewatch 'Mania I and you'll almost certainly wonder if Lord Alfred Hayes had been shoved in front of the camera to conduct promos at the eleventh hour. Pretty much all of Alfred's interviews were rushed, poorly-produced and oddly formatted, which is shocking to think about given how much was riding on this show for Vince McMahon.

Throughout the night, Hayes looked for all the world like he was fearing for his life whenever the cams were on him. Worse, he welcomed in one wrestler to scream about their opponent, then immediately brought in said foe to retort. What? So, they'd just been standing idly by watching a rival talk smack about them? Literally a few feet away?!

None of this gave a great first impression for what'd become WWE's calendar focal point. Granted, wrestling didn't quite know how to soup up the TV presentation in '85, but the whole affair was clunky and disjointed. Lord Alfred takes the cake for his frankly bizarre, detached and 'there's a gun to my head' skits too.

Surely there was somebody better for this role than him? A potted plant might've sufficed.


40. Susan St. James On Commentary (WrestleMania 2)

WWE WrestleMania Vince McMahon Susan St James
WWE

One of the first things McMahon wanted to do with 'Mania was make each entry unique. That'd give way to general pageantry eventually, but having a direct USP wasn't his worst idea. In 1986, Vince beamed the second supershow from 3 different locations: Los Angeles, Chicago and New York. A trio of major markets all served up to the viewer.

In lieu of producing commentary from a remote location, the WWF posted announce teams to each venue, and there was a celebrity calling the action everywhere you looked. Elvira was in LA, Cathy Lee Crosby was in Chicago, and sitcom actress Susan St. James joined McMahon on the call in New York.

That was their first mistake.

The 4 bouts St. James watched in Uniondale? Paul Orndorff vs. Don Muraco, Randy Savage vs. George Steele, Jake Roberts vs. George Wells, and a boxing bout pitting Mr. T vs. Roddy Piper. Throughout, Susan was totally annoying, out of her element and just overall atrocious.

Her cries of: "UH OH" veered into meme territory before that was even a thing. Being fair, St. James wasn't up to speed on the federation's product, but that should've instantly told the company that drafting her in was a terrible plan. No, Elvira and Crosby didn't prove to be the next coming of Jim Ross, but they were offset by the likes of Jesse Ventura and Gorilla Monsoon.

McMahon couldn’t guide Susan through things, so the New York portion was unbearable on the ears. There are only so many "UH OH" or, "WHAT A MANOEUVRE" moments one can take.


39. King Kong Bundy’s Fall From Grace (WrestleMania III)

WWE WrestleMania III King Kong Bundy Hillbilly Jim
WWE.com

Imagine Cody Rhodes went from headlining 'Mania one year to working on the undercard in a comedy spot the next. It isn't inconceivable that somebody could have a seismic fall from grace, but it's less likely in the modern era. Triple H and WWE as a whole tend to protect the main event stars they're painstakingly pushing as featured workers fans should care about.

Vince was usually the same, but he forgot about protecting his roster back in 1987. Andre The Giant had turned heel for a showdown with top boy Hulk Hogan, and that caused 'Mania 2's main villain King Kong Bundy to slip and slide down the pecking order like he was Titus O'Neil entering a so-called Greatest Royal Rumble.

In 12 months, Bundy went from headlining opposite Hulk inside the old blue barred steel cage to mixing it with Hillbilly Jim, Haiti Kid and Little Beaver the following year. Bundy also warred with his partners Little Tokyo and Lord Littlebrook during the match/segment, and the whole thing was blatantly played for laughs.

'Mania III was starting to up the ante for the event by delivering more production bang for your pay-per-view bucks, but the concept was still in its infancy. Even so, this was the biggest wrestling card ever, and 1986's main heel was reduced to a going-nowhere undercard scrap by 1987.

No wonder Bundy decided to go and sell computing equipment instead. The WWF even had the cheek to try and heat him back up for Hogan after this. Yeah, the bloom was off the rose there.


38. Top Stars Bore Everyone Senseless (WrestleMania IV)

RICK RUDE JAKE ROBERTS WRESTLEMANIA
WWE

Rick Rude vs. Jake Roberts looked like one of the better matches in the 14-man WWF Title tournament at 'Mania IV on paper, but it was rubbish. Despite having an issue going into the pay-per-view (Rude was ribbing Roberts about how much his wife actually fancied 'Ravishing'), they somehow conspired to have one of the most boring bouts in existence.

Together, Rick and the 'Snake' went to a humdrum 15 minute draw. It was abundantly clear within minutes that they were stalling for time and that this would go all the way, which didn't help. Thus, the match played before silence in front of a bored live crowd who ranged from disappointed hardcore fans to Donald Trump's high-rollers.

What a waste.

Those aforementioned Trump pals looked on in bemusement at most of the action anyway, but even they must've known that Rude and Roberts were stinking up the joint. It says everything that this collision earned the 'worst of' (dubious) distinction on a card that also included matches like Don Muraco vs. Dino Bravo and Bam Bam Bigelow vs. One Man Gang.

Anyone hoping that a workhorse duo like Rick and Jake could pull the nose up on those ended up Oliver Humperdinked. Even Bam Bam's flashy manager would've smacked both with his trusty cane for delivering a performance so uninspired and bland!

Overall, the WrestleMania IV tournament was a washout only hardcores will glean something from, but nobody had Roberts vs. Rude down as stinker of the night going into the show. Not a chance.


37. Piper’s Pit Goes Loooooooong (WrestleMania V)

WWE WrestleMania V Roddy Piper Morton Downey Jr Piper's Pit
WWE.com

Looking back, although Roddy Piper was definitely one of the better talkers in the biz, the 'Hot Scot' didn't half prattle some amount of nonsense during his promos. He was engaging, energetic and knew how to work the cameras to maximum effect during interviews, but Piper existed in an era where what you said was less important than how you said it.

When focused on a specific wrestler or occasion, Roddy could nail it, but he was a meandering mess at WrestleMania V mid-Piper's Pit with Brother Love and actor Morton Downey Jr. The WWF drafted Morton in as a celeb guest, and had him blow smoke in Roddy's face towards the conclusion of the piece.

It was supposed to be edgy and fun-filled, but the skit was actually kinda flat. Piper spent most of the time arguing with Love, so this was a celeb cameo spot that just didn't land. Downey Jr, for his part, appeared totally confused as what was even going on, and it's hardly like he was gonna return to fed screens for a blowoff match or anything.

WWE have spotlighted the scene several times, but the skit was far, far, far too long. Even Bruce Prichard/Love has said via his podcast that Piper refused to wrap things up and went a tad overboard with the bickering. That would've been understandable if there was anything riding on the segment, but...there wasn't.

It didn't really lead to anything worthwhile. They gave Curt Hennig and Owen Hart just over 5 minutes for this?!


36. Roddy Piper’s Racist Commentary Misses The Mark (WrestleMania VI)

Roddy Piper
WWE

ARGH!

When looking back at Piper painting half of his body with black paint for WrestleMania VI's match vs. Bad News Brown, you might hear some folks say: 'Ah, but it was a different time'. OK, but even if one stretches to allow for that, then it still doesn't make the idea a good one that should've happened! This was an appalling call from 'Hot Rod', to be honest.

It seems that painting half of his frame was supposed to be some 'it doesn't matter what colour you are - I'll still beat you up' stand from Piper, hence the Michael Jackson glove. Or, at least, that's what people think was going on. At first glance, and when analysing who Roddy was working that night, the whole scheme was bizarre and frankly rather racist. Again, shouldn't have been slapped with a green light.

WWE avoid drawing attention to this in the modern era for a reason. They know it's not a great look for a legend like Piper or for 'Mania history. Brown was reportedly pretty miffed at Roddy anyway, and so going with make up/paint to partially change his skin tone was only going to anger the heel further; not kayfabe anger either.

Side note; Andre The Giant poured out a solution bought in to remove the paint, so Roddy had to walk around half and half for days. He once recalled during an interview clutching a giant Mickey Mouse for his daughter as he strolled through the airport still half-painted.

That had to be alarming for folks in Toronto airport.


35. An Infamous Blindfold Battle (WrestleMania VII)

jake roberts rick martel wrestlemania 7
WWE.com

Being fair right off the bat, both Jake Roberts and Rick Martel did the best they could with the blindfold gimmick at ‘Mania VII; fans were into some of the action, but the match went just a few minutes too long and left both workers with no chance. They were up against it from the off, and everyone knew it.

It perhaps says everything about how solid/forgettable WrestleMania VII was (depending on your point of view) that something this bang average ranks as the worst moment from the show. Hulk Hogan winning the WWF Title from Sgt. Slaughter in the main event wasn't an in-ring classic, but it was Hulk headlining and people still gobbled that up in 1991.

So, the blindfolded match wasn't outright terrible, but it was defo the biggest clanger of the night.

At first, it was tempting to shoe-horn something about Slaughter's anti-American turncoat gimmick in or the mediocre British Bulldog vs. Wardlord midcard match and call it a day, but nah - Martel and Roberts pretending they couldn't see one another for nearly 10 minutes gets the nod whether it's especially fair or not.

Vince McMahon arguably set the scene for how middle of the road 'Mania VII would be ahead of time when he and his WWF crew relocated indoors to the LA Memorial Sports Arena. Originally, the event was supposed to take place at the Memorial Coliseum, but the show just didn't shift enough tickets for that.

One half-hearted claim they feared snipers might take Sarge out and 'Mania retreated inside. Blind leading the blind.


34. Papa Shango Misses His Cue (WrestleMania VIII)

WrestleMania VIII Papa Shango Botch
WWE

You've got to feel for Papa Shango here. He'd only debuted a new witch doctor heel gimmick a few months before WrestleMania VIII, then heard that he'd be running in on the Hulk Hogan vs. Sid Justice main event. That was a huge show of faith in Shango from management, and it'd surely lead to matches between Papa and Hogan.

Or not.

Someone either misjudged the length of the aisle way or sent Shango out for his spot too late, because he didn't reach the ring in time to thump Hogan as the big red and yellow babyface pinned Sid post-leg drop. It was Hulk's worst nightmare that Justice had to power out of his finisher without help. Stop the presses, brother. That hostility won't stand, dude.

Of course, The Ultimate Warrior's own comeback distracted everybody, but Papa had to be mortified. His bold new character's WWF career was never the same after this botch, but he'd eventually find success as The Godfather after playing Kama Mustafa as well. At least he bounced back.

It had to be chaos behind the curtain in Indianapolis though. Vince McMahon and other WWF chiefs must've been fuming that the headliner's finish had been ruined. However, they were the ones who wanted to book a crummy disqualification result in the first place, so perhaps they deserved those plans to fly out the window.

The flubbed spot proved to be a disaster for Shango regardless. He took the blame, and his persona faded to the point he was eliminated in seconds by the following year's Royal Rumble.


33. Giant Gonzalez Stinks Up The Place (WrestleMania IX)

WWE WrestleMania IX The Undertaker Giant Gonzalez
WWE.com

Next time you watch a wrestling match and think it sucked, fire up WrestleMania IX (or 'WrestleMania Niiiiii-yaaaaaaan' if you're Randy Savage) and gaze in awe at Giant Gonzalez. If anyone tells you that size didn't still capture the WWF's imagination after the steroid investigations started spooking everybody, then point to the big Argentinian as proof they're talking utter rubbish.

Gonzalez couldn't work a lick. He couldn't deliver painful-looking strikes, he couldn't move around the ring easily, and he sold every one of The Undertaker's punches like he was performing some in-ring parody protest of wrestling. It was pitiful, and this match is one 'Taker used as a means to browbeat management for years afterwards.

He knew it was rotten, and wasn't even going to try and defend the decision to put him in the ring with Gonzalez. According to Bruce Prichard on his podcast, Undertaker wanted an apology for this booking. Rightly so. He was a slow moving zombie gimmick in 1993, so he needed someone to create movement around him. Giant Gonzalez was not that guy.

Yes, this bout is even worse than Mr. Fuji's nonsensical challenge to Hulk Hogan on behalf of 'his Yokozuna' later on at the end of the night. That hurt for Bret Hart and his fans, but Hulk's blushes were spared by what Gonzalez and 'Taker produced earlier on.

Also, what was up with that outfit the federation put on Gonzalez? Airbrushed muscles?! Pubic hair?! A butt crack so big it could've been the 'Mania entrance?! Horrible.


32. WWE Gets ‘Falls Count Anywhere’ Wrong (WrestleMania X)

Randy Savage Crush WrestleMania X
WWE.com

Like the 'Mania IV snoozer pitting Rick Rude vs. Jake Roberts from earlier, a 'Falls Count Anywhere' bout involving Randy Savage should've been classic, but it wasn't. Firstly, the WWF didn't seem to understand the rules. Here, at WrestleMania X, they told fans that 'Macho Man' or Crush had 60 seconds to make it back into the ring once defeated.

It was a messy addendum to the classic stipulation that simply didn't need to happen. Worse, Randy and Crush decided to use some sort of pulley system for the finish, and that didn't work either. Crush had to barely (just barely) hang upside down and play pretend that he was stuck and couldn't reach his feet to unhook them.

Looking back, it's regrettable that this proved to be Savage's last 'Mania moment. He was likely thrilled at the thought of working with one of his real life friends on such a big show, but Crush was never capable of giving Randy the kind of bout he needed in 1994, and the 60 second thing confused the hell out of everybody in attendance as well as those watching back home.

It speaks volumes that the Randy vs. Crush finish beats out Bam Bam Bigelow and Luna Vachon vs. Doink The Clown and Dink, or Earthquake besting Adam Bomb in 35 seconds for worst moment. The mixed tag proved to be a bit of a laugh, at least. Nobody was satisfied with Savage's send off - even if fans didn't know this would be the last hurrah for 'Mach' on the WWF's biggest pay-per-view of the year.

The situation would've been infinitely better without that unnecessary 60 second bit.


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.