6 Best Broadway Musicals by Decade

Phantom Of The Opera It's Broadway week where I live in New York, so I thought it might be a good time to list what I consider the greatest Broadway musicals by decade. I realize this list might make someone question my sexuality, but yes, I'm a straight man, and yes, I love Broadway musicals. (As Jerry Seinfeld might say though, "Not that there's anything wrong with that.") Broadway is actually a fairly recent love of mine. I didn't really get into Broadway shows until college, and even then I was watching way-off Broadway shows in Baltimore. But to me, enjoying musical theater is a natural, mature transition from enjoying concept albums. I went from loving "The Wall" to "West Side Story." Both have characters, both tell stories, and both are set to music to help you remember those characters and stories in the first place. Here then, in chronological order, are my favorite musicals of all time. Similar to my article on the Best Worst Movies, I picked one from each decade, starting from the '50s on up:

Best 50s Musical - "West Side Story"

West Side Story Considered by many theater critics to be "the perfect musical" (sorry "A Chorus Line"), "West Side Story" has it all. Taking a page from Shakespeare by updating his "Romeo and Juliet" and setting it to music, you can't really find a better€”or more tragic€”love story than this. Of course, the dialogue isn't very realistic. Tony, a.k.a. Romeo, meets Maria, a.k.a. Juliet, at a dance, and when they first make eye contact, he walks across the floor, grabs her hand, and says, "Is this actually happening??" She swoons. Back in my swingin' singles heyday, if I was to go up to some girl at a club, take her hand, and ask, "Is this actually happening??" the least that would happen is she'd throw her drink in my face. But screw the dialogue; the song list is a litany of theater's greatest hits: "The Jet Song," "Something's Coming," "I Feel Pretty," "America," "Maria," "Cool," and, my personal favorite, the beautiful, ethereal "Somewhere," which was covered by Phil Collins and Aretha Franklin (on the same album!), among countless others.

Best 60s Musical - "Hair"

Hair No other musical defined its decade better than "Hair," despite the fact that it lost the Best Musical Tony that year to "1776," but which show is remembered more? Features such classic tracks as "Good Morning Starshine," the title tune, and "The Age of Aquarius/Let the Sunshine In," which was even covered by the cast of "The 40-Year-Old Virgin" during the movie's climatic musical number. Pop legends The Cowsills covered "Hair," and the other songs were also on regular rotation on the radio, a rarity for Broadway shows. And, of course, let's not forget about that infamous nude scene!

Best 70s Musical - "Jesus Christ Superstar"

Jesus Considered the first (or at least first successful) rock opera ever staged, though it would take the great "Rent" to make the genre ubiquitous, this was Andrew Lloyd Webber's masterpiece. "Superstar" is one of his first€”and still best€”shows, and that's saying something considering this man's prolific run. (See the next musical on this list, as well as "Evita," "Sunset Boulevard," and Webber's other Bible-centric production, "Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat," but, by all means, skip "Cats.") Told from the perspective of Judas, Jesus' betrayer, this show finally gave him something to say ("I've been your right-hand man all along" and "Have you forgotten how put down we are?"), and you almost sympathize with his plight, despite the fact we all know what he does in the end.

Best 80s Musical - "The Phantom Of The Opera"

Phantom Yes, that's two Andrew Lloyd Webber shows in a row, but he deserves it. There's a reason this is currently the longest running show in Broadway history. I was actually dragged to it three times (by three different girls), but each trip was well worth it. Many people believe this is a love story, but it's actually a bittersweet and poignant unrequited love story€”between the Phantom and Christine, his soprano-singing muse. My favorite part is towards the end when the Phantom rages about how much he'll love her and take care of her and punish anyone who gets in his way, and, instead of reacting in fear or anger, Christine sweetly, sympathetically sings, "Pitiful creature of darkness, what kind of life have you known?" "All I Ask of You" has become a romantic classic and has one of the best opening lines of any Broadway tune: "No more talk of darkness...." Even if you don't know anything about this show and just heard that line, you'd know exactly what's been going on up until that point. The title song and "The Music of the Night," which are performed concurrently in the show, have both become standards, but my favorite is "Wishing You Were Somehow Here Again," when Christine serenades her dead father's grave. If you're not moved by that scene, you should pinch yourself because you're probably dead. The sequel, "Love Never Dies," received extremely harsh reviews (one critic called it "Paint Never Dries"), but how can you follow up one of the greatest musicals of all time?

Best 90s Musical - "Rent"

Rent This is probably my favorite show on the list; it made me fall in love with Broadway in the first place, though, at the time, it sounded nothing like Broadway. Jonathan Larson's Pulitzer Prize-winning masterpiece really did change the face of the Great White Way forever. Now, we have rock-filled shows like "Spring Awakening" and Green Day's "American Idiot" opening on Broadway as a regular occurrence. The show's philosophy, "No day but today," is still something I try to live by every day, and it's fitting and unbelievably heartrending that Larson died the very day his show opened off-Broadway. (It moved to Broadway shortly afterwards.) My favorite song is the spare, haunting "One Song Glory," which, ironically enough, is about a character trying to write a great song, not realizing he's doing it in the process. Unfortunately, the song he comes up with in the end, "Your Eyes," is hackneyed and uninspiring, but that didn't deter my love of the show, which also features the rockin' title track and too many amazing ballads to list here, the most popular of which is "Seasons of Love." Once in a while, you see something that not only exceeds your expectations, which were already pumped high from all the praise you hear beforehand, but it opens your eyes to the wonderful beauty and mystery of life itself. Now, over a decade later, I'm perhaps too old and bitter to relate to the struggling, starving-artists story of Mark and Roger, but these guys, and this show, will always have a special place in my heart. Just make sure you ignore the movie version.

Best 00s Musical: "Avenue Q"

Ave Q A perfect blend of "Rent" and "Sesame Street" (with a dash of "South Park"), "Avenue Q" tells the story of trying to bridge the life-gap between college and the Real World€”with puppets. The moment the fuzzy, orange Princeton stepped onto stage with his cap and gown and sang, "What do you do with a B.A. in English?" I knew I was in love. As if the hilarious puppets€”and performers€”weren't enough, the show also throws in a screaming, indecipherable Asian woman, who's inexplicably named Christmas Eve, and, of course, the late, great Gary Coleman as the characters' superintendent (yes, that Gary Coleman)€”played by a woman. The original Gary was actually asked to be in the show, and it's too bad he passed; playing himself would've been the best role of his career. Just reading the list of song titles in the show is enough to prompt more than a few immature giggles: "It Sucks to Be Me," "If You Were Gay," "I'm Not Wearing Underwear Today," "The Internet Is for Porn," "Everyone's a Little Bit Racist," and, of course, "You Can Be As Loud As the Hell You Want (When You're Makin' Love)." But it's not all fun and games. The cute "Mix Tape," when Kate Monster realizes Princeton likes her, is heartwarming, and the breakup ballad, "There's a Fine, Fine Line" is surprisingly moving, considering it's delivered by a torso-less, inanimate object. But the song that really got me, which almost brought a tear to my eye, was "I Wish I Could Go Back to College," especially the line, "I wish I had taken more pictures." Luckily, through the power of Facebook friends, I've discovered a few photos of myself during those days. (You mean I actually used to have hair??) This Little Musical That Could actually beat the big-budget, overhyped "Wicked" for Best Musical Tony that year. I was originally disappointed in the ending, since there's no happy resolution of the various plot threads, but as years have passed since I first saw the show (I saw it again later), I've learned to respect that choice. After all, life is messy too€”even for a bunch of puppets.

Honorable Mention: "Godspell"

Godspell This musical literally changed my life. It forced me to reevaluate my Christianity as a way of life and not just a once-in-awhile hobby. The central message of the show is best illustrated by the very beginning of the first act, when God essentially asks the world, "What are you people doing??" and then Jesus comes to the rescue like Superman (only he's wearing a clown outfit, for some reason). It's not quite as powerful as its fellow '70s predecessor, "Jesus Christ Superstar," but the message is still important: Life is a gift from God that shouldn't be squandered. And I got all that from a Jesus wearing a giant, red clown nose.

 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Michael Perone has written for The Baltimore Sun, Baltimore City Paper, The Island Ear (now titled Long Island Press), and The Long Island Voice, a short-lived spinoff of The Village Voice. He currently works as an Editor in Manhattan. And he still thinks Michael Keaton was the best Batman.