10 Best Daredevil vs. Kingpin Storylines

These guys seriously just can't get along.

Daredevil has been a mainstay in the Marvel Universe for 50 years, but it took nearly two decades for this iconic superhero to get a legitimate arch nemesis to call his own. When Frank Miller and Klaus Janson first incorporated Wilson Fisk, aka the Kingpin of crime €“ a villain previously associated with Spider-Man €“ into Daredevil in 1979, it dramatically changed the course of the series. Fisk was unquestionably the missing piece of the puzzle €“ bringing a physically and intellectually imposing villain into a world that was getting darker and grittier thanks to Miller and Janson€™s film noir-inspired sensibilities. In the years that followed, Daredevil and Kingpin evolved into one of comics€™ very best hero/villain pairings. The two have engaged in a long-term game of cat and mouse that has featured brutal beat downs, cerebral mind games, heartbreak, betrayals and unlikely alliances. And these storylines have been crafted by a who€™s who of award-winning and critically acclaimed creators, including Miller, Janson, Brian Michael Bendis, Alex Maleex, Ann Nocenti, John Romita Jr., and Ed Brubaker. To celebrate Daredevil€™s 50th anniversary this month, here are 10 of the very best Daredevil/Kingpin storylines. These are the arcs that have helped make this hero and villain dynamic such a highlight of the Marvel Universe €“ even if it took Marvel 15 years to get them together.

10. The Man Without Fear

This 1993-94 five-part miniseries from Frank Miller and John Romita Jr. looks back at Daredevil€™s roots, and explores how a young boy who is blinded by radioactive waste could eventually become the €œMan Without Fear.€ While the mini primarily functions as an origin retelling and re-imagining, Miller and JRJR also manage to introduce the rise of Wilson Fisk as an early antagonist for Daredevil. The creative team is careful to never allow Matt Murdock and Fisk to physically interact at any point during the storyline, as the two wouldn€™t actually meet for the first time until Daredevil #170 (years after this mini takes place). But The Man Without Fear is still a worthwhile examination of how the two characters are inextricably linked. Plus, readers are treated to some of Kingpin€™s trademark ruthlessness, as Fisk assumes his leadership position in the mob after assassinating the boss by crushing his skull with his bare hands.

9. The Typhoid Mary Saga (Daredevil #254-263)

During her long-term run as writer on Daredevil, Ann Nocenti (along with John Romita Jr.) managed to create one of the great female antagonists in Typhoid Mary, who suffered from schizophrenia and possessed potent telekinetic and psychic powers. In this storyline, the Kingpin immediately hires Mary for a very special assignment. Fresh off his embarrassment at the hands of Daredevil in the €œBorn Again€ arc, Kingpin concocts a new way to strike at Matt Murdock: through his heart. He sends Mary after Matt, but demands that she make Daredevil fall in love with her before unleashing the psychotic €œTyphoid€ personality to physically punish him. Matt is immediately smitten with Mary, and even cheats on his longtime love Karen Page with the woman. Demonstrating his own animal magnitude, Kingpin also gets some action from Mary. Kingpin manages to make a huge mess of his rival€™s life thanks to Mary. But, when Mary goes too far and presumably kills Daredevil (he would return after an issue away), Kingpin is conflicted by his victory, demonstrating the criminal€™s complicated relationship with the hero.

8. The Return Of The King (Daredevil vol. 2 #116-119, 500)

It€™s difficult to sympathize with a man who has caused as much misery and despair in the Marvel Universe as Wilson Fisk, but Ed Brubaker and Michael Lark manage to pull it off in one of the most epic opening chapters to a storyline in Daredevil comics€™ history. In the €œReturn of the King€ prologue, Kingpin is overseas and madly in love with a woman and her two young children. Kingpin€™s happiness is snatched away from him by the Hand€™s hired assassin, Lady Bullseye, who murders the woman and her children in cold blood in order to lure Fisk back to New York. €œThe Return of the King€ marks the second time in the Brubaker/Lark run where Kingpin and Daredevil unite against a common foe (more on that shortly). Kingpin convinces Daredevil to join his side in an effort to take down the Hand. But, once that union is formed, that€™s when the double-crossing begins. Kingpin attempts to stab Daredevil in the back during the final confrontation with the Hand, but Murdock one-ups him, convincing the ninja gang to join his side and kick Fisk to the curb. It€™s a stunning reveal that demonstrates that Daredevil has certainly learned a few things from his time going toe-to-toe with the Kingpin.

7. The Murdock Papers (Daredevil vol. 2 #76-81)

Brian Michael Bendis and Alex Maleev finished their Eisner Award-winning run on Daredevil in extraordinary fashion when Wilson Fisk and Matt Murdock both end up behind bars. In this arc, Kingpin finally decides to use the information he has long held over Murdock€™s head €“he knows his secret identity as Daredevil €“ to his legal advantage by bargaining for his immunity and offering the FBI evidence that proves the attorney has obstructed justice. The FBI takes the bait, but not before Kingpin concocts a way to get Daredevil to set himself up. In a call back to the very first Daredevil/Kingpin storyline in Daredevil #170-172, Kingpin keeps referring to mysterious €œfiles€ that will prove Murdock/Daredevil€™s guilt called the €œMurdock Papers.€ The mere hypothetical existence of these files sends everyone into a frenzy. But the €œMurdock Papers€ were all a ruse designed by Kingpin to lure Daredevil out and expose his identity to the feds. Of course, Kingpin€™s brilliance backfires on him, as he ends up in prison too. It€™s a unique ending and is one of the few times where both Matt and Fisk hit rock bottom simultaneously.

6. The Devil In Cell Block D (Daredevil vol. 2 #82-87)

The Ed Brubaker/Ed Lark era on Daredevil starts off with a bang as the duo craft a story that puts Matt Murdock and Wilson Fisk on the same side within the close and dangerous confines of Rikers Island prison. After Murdock is sent to jail (thanks to Fisk€™s chicanery in the €œMurdock Papers€ arc), he instantly becomes a marked man for all of the vengeful criminals he ever defeated as Daredevil. When Matt€™s best friend and law partner Foggy Nelson is apparently murdered, Murdock assumes it€™s the work of the Kingpin. Little does he realize that the conspiracy goes much further than Fisk and, instead, it€™s just an elaborate plan to get Daredevil and Kingpin to kill each other, thereby eliminating both alpha males from the prison. The Daredevil/Kingpin alliance is one wrought with obvious tension and reluctance. When the Kingpin employs another one of Daredevil€™s most nefarious enemies, Bullseye, to help break the duo out of prison, Matt realizes he€™s in over his head. That forces Matt to form another uneasy alliance with Frank Castle, aka, the Punisher. The arc ends with Daredevil and Kingpin as sworn enemies again. But, by having them join forces, Brubaker and Lark set the stage for additional reluctant partnerships in the future. And there€™s nothing more fun than a superhero/supervillain odd couple.

5. Love And War

This surreal original graphic novel from 1986 pairs off Frank Miller with artist Bill Sienkiewicz. In terms of its visual and narrative style, Love and War is unquestionably Miller€™s most unique Daredevil story. But it also features some top-notch character moments involving Kingpin and Daredevil, despite the fact that the two never physically cross paths in the story. The graphic novel shows the Kingpin at his most desperate. He kidnaps the blind wife of a famous doctor and forces the man to €œcure€ his amnesiac, mentally unstable wife, Vanessa. And, since Kingpin is a bad man who (admittedly) gets everything he wants, he expects his underworld tactics to produce a happy ending for he and Vanessa. Despite his corrupt efforts, Kingpin cannot connect with Vanessa. And, after Daredevil rescues the doctor€™s wife from Fisk€™s goons, Kingpin no longer has any leverage to continue the arrangement. The graphic novel is one of those rare instances where the Kingpin is left sad and alone, while Daredevil€™s life continues without crisis.

4. The Elektra Saga (Daredevil #174-181)

While most comic book fans identify Elektra€™s inaugural arc in Daredevil with her iconic death €“ murdered with her own sai by the lunatic Bullseye €“ the bulk of the story focuses on the femme fatale€™s experience working as Kingpin€™s chief assassin. The fact that Kingpin, still relatively new to the world of Daredevil comics at the time this storyline was published, would choose Matt Murdock€™s college sweetheart, Elektra Natchios, as his hired gun only managed to further elevate the Kingpin/Daredevil feud. Watching Daredevil confront his former love, who had turned cold and calloused, created riveting, character-driven drama during the acclaimed Frank Miller/Klaus Janson run on the series. And, even with Elektra€™s looming presence over Matt€™s life, the storyline ultimately came down to Daredevil vs. Kingpin. During this arc, Elektra threatens the life of Daily Bugle reporter Ben Urich, who is investigating the link between Kingpin and New York City mayoral candidate Randolph Cherryh. When Ben backs off the story in order to protect himself, Daredevil looks at some of the reporter€™s photos and notices one of Kingpin€™s thought-to-be-dead wife Vanessa, wandering the sewers as a vagabond. Daredevil uses this information to convince Kingpin to withdraw Cherryh from the mayoral race. This game of one-upmanship and €œcan you top this€ would become a trademark for the Daredevil/Kingpin relationship. Meanwhile, Elektra€™s failure to assassinate Matt€™s law partner, Foggy Nelson (per Kingpin€™s request), directly leads to Bullseye killing her in order to prove his worth to the boss. Elektra€™s death has a profound effect on Matt for years. So, €œThe Elektra Saga€ is another in a long line of instances where Daredevil might have won the battle, but Kingpin won the war.

3. €œHardcore€ (Daredevil vol. 2 #46-50)

Ever since Frank Miller first incorporated Wilson Fisk into the Daredevil universe, he and the €œMan Without Fear€ engaged in a cyclical game of cat and mouse that would always end with Kingpin on top as the boss of New York City€™s criminal underworld. This cycle came to an abrupt halt during the Brian Michael Bendis/Alex Maleex run on the title, as Daredevil decided once and for all to cross a line he previously never crossed in order to assert his dominance over Fisk. In €œHardcore,€ Fisk returns from a brief hiatus looking to aggressively take back his crown as the Kingpin. Fisk destroys his underworld rivals without mercy, and sics some classic villains on Matt Murdock, such as Bullseye and Typhoid Mary, all in an effort to let the world know that the €œking€ is back. But, rather than try and outsmart him, Daredevil shows up at the Kingpin€™s home base and beats him within an inch of his life, claiming Hell€™s Kitchen as the his own turf. The scene that depicts Daredevil standing defiantly over a battered and bloody Kingpin in Daredevil #50, is still shocking to read years later. Yet, with all the history these two characters have, Matt€™s aggression is unquestionably justified.

2. €œGang War€ (Daredevil #170-172)

Frank Miller€™s impact on the world of Daredevil is immeasurable, but arguably his greatest contribution was the introduction of Wilson Fisk, the €œKingpin€ of crime, as Matt Murdock€™s chief adversary and antagonist. The €œGang War€ arc marked the very first time Daredevil and Kingpin locked horns. The storyline established a number of themes and dynamics that would go on to play key roles in future Daredevil/Kingpin confrontations, such as the cat and mouse game the two characters would endlessly play. €œGang War€ depicts a reluctant Kingpin enjoying the fruits of his €œretirement.€ But, as any mob boss can tell you, every time Fisk thinks he€™s out, somebody pulls him back in. In this instance, a number of rival gangs make a play to obtain Fisk€™s secret €œfiles.€ At one point, Murdock dons a disguise and tries out for Kingpin€™s gang to get the files for himself, only to be discovered and beaten senseless (and dumped into a sewer pipe) by the rotund crime boss. During one of the gang battles, Kingpin€™s wife, Vanessa, is presumed dead. By the end of the storyline, Kingpin just hands his files over to Daredevil, and tells him to do what he wants with them €“ that he€™ll just regroup and come back stronger and meaner than ever before. And thus, a rivalry that has endured for more than 30 years, is born. Meanwhile, Miller€™s decision to cast Kingpin as Daredevil€™s nemesis was a stroke a genius. It only makes sense for a superhero that spends his civilian life as an attorney defending the integrity of the law to be paired off with a villain who works the legal system and corrupts it to his benefit.

1. Born Again (Daredevil #227-231)

Not just the greatest Daredevil/Kingpin storyline of all-time, but arguably one of the best Marvel arcs ever published, €œBorn Again,€ is Frank Miller€™s magnum opus on €˜Ol Hornhead with equally inspiring pencils from David Mazzucchelli. As the title indicates, the storyline focuses on the spiritual fall and resurrection of Matt Murdock, as his ex-girlfriend Karen Page sells out his secret identity in exchange for a shot of heroin. Kingpin naturally catches wind of his enemy€™s secret, and uses that information to systematically destroy Murdock from stem to sternum. Thanks to the Kingpin€™s influence, Matt€™s accounts are frozen by the IRS, the bank forecloses on his apartment, and a crooked police lieutenant testifies that he saw Murdock pay a witness to perjure himself. When a broken Matt confronts Kingpin, the boss makes quick work of him, leaving him for dead. But, as Kingpin realizes, €œthere is no corpse.€ Kingpin€™s path of vengeance doesn€™t stop with Daredevil. He also uses his subordinates to attack Daily Bugle reporter Ben Urich, a personal friend of Matt€™s, who is investigating the conspiracy. Kingpin hires €œNurse Lois€ as an enforcer to stalk and intimidate Urich, including breaking his hand. But Urich is emboldened by the assault, and moves forward with his investigation. Matt works his way back from the abyss, and even reconciles with Karen along the way. Kingpin, still obsessed with Daredevil, contracts with a rogue Super Soldier named Nuke to lay waste to Murdock€™s Hell€™s Kitchen neighborhood. Daredevil, with assistance from Captain America, is able to publicly link Kingpin with Nuke, exposing his nemesis once and for all as a criminal. After being outed, Kingpin loses all of his support and, even more damning, is no longer considered a €œlegitimate businessman€ in the eyes of the public. €œBorn Again€ is a pitch perfect example of what the comic book medium can offer readers. There€™s action, suspense, love, and redemption. Despite how clearly the storyline delineates good from evil, €œBorn Again€ also manages to paint Daredevil and Kingpin as complex characters. Its placement at the top of this list is without question.

In this post: 
Daredevil
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Mark is a professional writer living in Brooklyn and is the founder of the Chasing Amazing Blog, which documents his quest to collect every issue of Amazing Spider-Man, and the Superior Spider-Talk podcast. He also pens the "Gimmick or Good?" column at Comics Should Be Good blog.