10 Reasons Why Damian: Son Of Batman Was An Absolute Mess

In just four issues, writer/artist Andy Kubert managed to make us all wish DC had never bothered with the series in the first place.

Damian Wayne was Bruce Wayne's only biological son by way of Talia Al-Ghul, the daughter of Ra's Al-Ghul (the Demon's Head of the League of Shadows and one of Batman's greatest foes). Created by Grant Morrison, Damian made his first appearance in 2006 when Talia introduced him to Batman who took over care of the pre-teen Damian. Among his first acts, Damian nearly beat Tim Drake to death, wounded Alfred, and went on to murder a minor Batman villain. And yet when he was killed in 2013, in the final Batman arc of Morrison's 7 year run, everyone loved him - readers and characters. We'd seen him go from being the bratty sociopath to a still arrogant but vastly changed vigilante who respected his new Bat family and had become a key member in the group. His and Bruce's relationship became one of the highlights of the series, which continued on into Peter Tomasi's well-received New 52 Batman and Robin series. When Damian died, there was shock, anger and a lot of sadness from Batman readers who couldn't believe DC would allow such a popular character to be killed off. So there was some consolation when it was announced that later on in 2013, a four-issue Damian mini-series would be published written and drawn by Andy Kubert (one of the artists who worked with Morrison during his Batman run), focusing on the alternate timeline glimpsed in Batman #666 and Batman Incorporated #5 where Damian becomes the new Batman of Gotham City. More Damian €“ what could be better? Then we got the series. Oh... In just four issues, writer/artist Andy Kubert managed to make us all wish DC had never bothered with the series in the first place. The warning signs were there in Joker #1, the Villain's Month one-shot, but maybe the mini-series would be better... somehow... but no, it wasn't! Before I get into it, I will say that I quite liked the art €“ Andy Kubert is, if not a good writer, still a good artist and his work here is alright. Plus the logo design where the Bat symbol splice with the word "Damian" in the title so that the bat-ears make up the "M" and the wings cross the "A"s is very cool. Those are the only pluses I'll give the series - everything else was garbage! So just how awful was this series? Read on...

10. Damian's Appearance #1: The Robin Outfit

Robin Outfit The mini-series takes place before the Morrison-scripted Batman #666 and Batman Incorporated #5 so it's all about how Damian goes from being Robin to becoming Batman, in both appearance and ethos. When the series begins, he's still Robin but he's definitely older than when we saw him last €“ he's no longer a 12-year old and looks more like a 17-18 year old. But why is a young adult still wearing the Robin outfit? Why is (supposedly) the most badass of the Robins still wearing a kiddie outfit? When Dick Grayson (the first Robin) entered his late teens, he discarded his old outfit and became Nightwing. Why hasn't Damian established his own vigilante persona €“ why is he still wearing kiddie clothes as a young man? I would have thought his own ego would've forced him to assert his own personality on a new design and a new persona rather than be content to continue wearing something that instantly marks him out to be second fiddle. Grant Morrison showed Damian's creativeness in Batman Incorporated #4 when Damian became Redbird when Batman told him Robin was grounded. In a more relaxed situation where he's not the target of global assassins, why wouldn't he do something different with his costume? Was he just going to be Robin forever while Dick was Batman? No, he wouldn't, but if he created his own persona, he'd be less likely to become Batman when Dick died because he'd prefer to be his own person. Keeping him in the Robin outfit long after he's outgrown it is just a massive plot contrivance.

9. Damian's Appearance #2: The New Batman Outfit

Batmanoutfit With both Dick and Bruce out of the picture, Damian decides that he's going to be Batman. He looks at the glass case with the Batman outfit €“ and then chooses to wear a different one. This ties in to the point about Damian not asserting his own personality enough when accepting to wear the Robin outfit because he is doing just that with the new Batman duds. But why? Dick didn't change the Batman suit because it's perfectly designed for all situations AND it looks awesome and scary, which is part of its purpose. Why does Damian mess with the formula and come up with a high collar? The reasons behind the design choices for the new costume should've been explored in this mini-series but aren't. He's simply wearing it because that's what he wore in Batman #666 and Batman Incorporated #7. One minute he's Robin and the next he's Batman with a new look, fully formed. Has he had the costume ready beforehand? So was he planning on replacing Dick as the Batman of Gotham City or work alongside him? How was he able to put together such a professional-looking and practical costume almost instantly? When did he make the costume and why the changes? Yet another plot contrivance - he just does, ok? Very disappointing.

8. Damian's Appearance #3: Boy To Man Instantly

Boytoman Though he's a young man, Damian still looks childlike in stature, at least in the first issue and he's noticeably shorter than Dick. By the second issue, Kubert's made him more muscly, (maybe Damian's been on the 'roids since Dick died?) perhaps realising Damian's Batman is taller and stronger than Damian's Robin and he's got to make up the difference somehow. It's not convincing. Look at the way he's drawn in the first issue and then in the second. Damian goes from a lean young man as Robin to a taller, beefier, more grown-up looking man in his thirties when he puts on his Batman outfit. Is that what the Batman suit does €“ makes whoever puts it on instantly look like THE alpha male, like Shazam/Billy Batson? It's incompetent work from Kubert, made all the more damning when you realise this is a 4-issue mini-series where he couldn't even be consistent for that long.

7. Everyone's Out Of Character #1: Bruce

Brucecharacter Andy Kubert has written Bruce completely out of character in this book. So the twist in issue #1 is that "Batman" dies but it turns out that it's not actually Bruce wearing the cowl, it's Dick, and Bruce has been retired for years. Damian sets out to avenge his friend's passing and winds up killing some of Batman's minor rogues. Bruce's response? To try to kill Damian, his own son?! He launches himself at Damian at the start of issue #2 saying things like "I'm finishing this €“ right now!" and "I'm going to make damn sure it doesn't happen again". Apparently, Batman's rogues mean more to Bruce than his own son! That's not how the Bruce/Damian relationship has been written AT ALL. Like I said at the start, one of the reasons readers embraced Damian so much was his developing relationship with his father, whom he came to love wholeheartedly - seeing Bruce try to kill Damian over some nothing rogues when Dick died is an utterly moronic response from Bruce and totally out of character.

6. Everyone's Out Of Character #2: Damian

Damiancharacter Right away from the first page I could tell things were wrong: Damian recoils in fear at the sight of a pile of dead bodies and fish in Gotham Harbour €“ why? Damian has been written since the beginning as a cold-blooded killer who isn't fazed by anything. He's been trained by the League of Shadows since birth to become the perfect assassin. He has no problem with death, both seeing it and dishing it out, because he's been around it for his entire ife, so why would he be shocked at the sight of some dead nobodies and a pile of fish? He wouldn't. It's just bad characterisation from Andy Kubert. Everything about Damian is a bit off in this story. He's supposed to be a tactical genius but he loses at chess; he's an amazing fighter but keeps getting beat up by ordinary henchmen; he's unsure of himself constantly despite years of being written as an arrogant know-it-all; he's always believed he was destined to be Batman but he doesn't want it when the position's available; he's suddenly Catholic because he goes to confession throughout this book; he has to re-learn not to kill as Batman, even though that's a lesson he's already learned €“ it's clear Kubert simply doesn't understand the character and should've had a writer who does to write the script for him.

5. The Pointless Priest

Pointless Priest Kubert makes Damian Catholic for this book just so Damian can talk through his problems without it seeming like the cheesy old Batman comics where entire pages were taken up with exposition-filled thought bubbles. But the priest Damian confesses to seems very familiar €“ so who is he? From his appearance alone, and because of his noticeable absence in the rest of the story, many readers speculated that it was Jim Gordon. It looks like Jim because of the classic glasses and moustache combo - but it's not Gordon. The hints are there when he says "I have known and respected your family for a long time. I have cared for all of you" and "Your methods run counter to your father's strongest code of ethics" €“ Gordon was close to Batman but these comments sound a bit too overly familiar. Then in a scene when the priest goes around to the confessor's side of the box, Damian's gone €“ the classic Batman disappearing act. Later on in the story, we get the reverse when the priest tells Damian about the Joker and Damian goes to the priest's side of the confession box only to find the priest gone. The whole situation was a contrived visual representation of the famous phrase "Like father, like son" €“ the priest is Bruce in disguise. We never see the priest again but we see Bruce shortly afterwards kidnapped by the fake Joker. But why did Bruce dress up as a priest? Wasn't he in a coma? Actually it seems that he was pretending - in one panel in issue #2 he opens his eyes after Damian announces he's going to be the new Batman and leaves. So why pretend? I have no idea. Trying to make sense of this book is impossible! Also, why couldn't Bruce simply talk to Damian and advise him that way? Because Kubert's a terrible writer and the whole priest thing was an idiotic waste of time.

4. Joker's Wild!

Jokerswild The Joker is the best Batman villain so having him in the story should instantly make it better. I think that's what Kubert was thinking and decided to go even further: "Hey, if 1 Joker is exciting, how about 2 Jokers? Or 3!?!" (starts frothing at the mouth). Yeah, there are 3 Jokers in this story. The first Joker we see is some short, fat nurse man/woman talking in an abhorrent facsimile of a Southern accent, cooing over Bruce who's unattended (for some reason) and on life support (but still semi-conscious and, if you buy my priest theory, then it's unclear why he's not doing anything about the Joker hovering over him). It's a painfully written scene that has no relevance to the story and we never see this Joker again. The second Joker is another fake who's replaced the real Joker because the real one's disappeared for some reason (we never find out why) and he wants to make a name for himself by being the Joker who kills all the Batmen. He's done in Dick (presumably because he's a Joker and Dick was killed by a Jokerfish, though he never admits to the murder), and now he wants Bruce and Damian's scalps too. Not because Bruce was Batman but because Bruce Wayne is Bruce Wayne. Apparently in this story Joker is like Batman €“ a title. And the third Joker is the real Joker who shows up, shooting the second fake Joker, appearing from wherever he's been, but not going after Bruce and Damian after they've defeated the second fake Joker, despite them being vulnerable to an attack. And he hasn't aged either but Bruce is an old man. Why did we need 3 Jokers in this 4-issue story? We didn't. 1 would've been fine but Kubert bungled it by throwing in 2 insipid, useless clones, completely losing control of the story in the process.

3. Dumb Detective, Stupider Villains

Dumbdetective Batman is supposed to be the World's Greatest Detective, and he was when Bruce was Batman. Damian? Based on this "story", he's a terrible detective.. The "story" in this book is that Damian is hunting down Dick Grayson's killer, who is the Joker. For some reason he decides to go after Professor Pyg and his dollotrons who're mixed up with Jackanapes and his gang. I think this was put here because Kubert had so little "story" that he needed something to pad it out so this fit the bill (the Dollotrons were in Batman #666 after all). It's so irrelevant that the pointless priest wraps it up in a single panel in issue #3 and the storyline is never mentioned again. It was all useless filler. So even though Damian avenges Dick by taking out the fake Joker and Dick's death was due to Jokerfish bomb, Damian is certain €“ for no reason, based on no evidence to the contrary €“ that "Grayson's killer is still out there. I'm not convinced that the Joker imposter was the only one involved. I'll find whoever's responsible! No matter how long it takes!". What an idiot. Oh and Mr Freeze and Killer Croc apparently both have blogs where they boast about their crimes. That is beyond stupid.

2. Reincarnation Is Real?!

Reincarnationisreal Alfred Pennyworth happens to be at the very location in the Gotham River where an unconscious Damian appears after losing his fight with Professor Pyg. He takes him back to Batcave and, after dutifully stitching up Damian, dies. Damian's had a cat called Alfred since the last Batman Incorporated story and that cat's still around. The cat's wandering about while Alfred dies and then all of a sudden, the spirit of Alfred the Butler is inside Alfred the Cat! We know this because when Damian comes to, Alfred the Cat is talking to him in the voice of Alfred Pennyworth!? How do we know for sure that it's actually Alfred Pennyworth and not anyone else? He helpfully informs Damian "After the battle with the dollotrons, young sir, I brought you back to the Batcave for treatment". So apparently reincarnation is real and in some weird Tim Burton-esque way and Alfred Pennyworth's spirit has gone into Alfred the Cat's. I liked it better when Alfred the cat was just an ordinary cat €“ it just made more sense and grounded Damian in a relatable way, showing an empathetic side to the brutality. He came to have a fondness for his father's butler and named his fearsome feline pet in honour of him, showing him to have a sentimental side too. Having a supernatural talking cat is just dumb and too literal an interpretation of Damian's pet name. Another stunningly bad choice by Kubert!

1. A Huge Wasted Opportunity

Wastedopportunity When I first heard of this mini-series and that it was a precursor to Damian becoming the new Batman of Gotham, I was excited because I really liked what Grant Morrison had done with this particular Damian story. Consider what Morrison put into Batman #666 and Batman Incorporated #5: the world's climate has risen to nearly fatal levels; there is constant war; Damian has sold his soul to the Devil to become Batman and is seemingly invincible; Commissioner Barbara Gordon €“ in a combat reinforced wheelchair! €“ is Batman's enemy, believing him responsible for the death of a loved one; Damian is even more prepared for anything than his father, booby-trapping the entirety of Gotham City; Jackanapes is an ape-like version of Hank McCoy. Look at all that potential! Kubert could've shown the world descending into chaos, we could've had a scene where Damian sells his soul to the Devil, we could've seen the death that turns Barbara against Damian €“ we saw none of that. Instead we got the most uninspired story of Dick Grayson being killed by a Jokerfish and Damian ineptly fighting a fake Joker with numerous scenes of a dull priest reciting mundane platitudes. We don't get a hint of Damian's obsession with traps and even Jackanapes is written to be a one-note goon rather than a super-intelligent ape. The diseased Joker who unleashes the Joker virus that leads to Gotham City being wiped out by an atomic bomb isn't here, and we get one panel of Barbara Gordon in the background without any lines. On the one hand it's not fair to compare Andy Kubert's writing ability to Grant Morrison's as the gap between the two is enormous €“ I didn't expect Kubert to write as cleverly or imaginatively as Morrison and he met that expectation. But Morrison left behind a lot of ideas to be explored that even a half-decent writer could've made something much more entertaining out of. It's one thing to pick apart the different elements that went into making Damian: Son of Batman the disaster it was, but the biggest problem by far was the wasted potential. It could've been an AMAZING mini-series (or even a series unto itself) but instead it wound up being one of the most forgettable and poorly put-together Batman books in years. If there's one takeaway from all of this, it's that Andy Kubert should never be allowed to write Batman ever again and stick to drawing him instead! * What did you think of Damian: Son of Batman? Were you disappointed or did you enjoy it? Let me know in the comments below!

In this post: 
Batman
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I reads and watches thems picture stories. Wordy words follow. My blog is http://samquixote.blogspot.co.uk , and if you want to see all the various places I contribute to, or want to send me a message, you can find links to everything here: http://about.me/noelthorne/#