10 Stupidest X-Men Mutants Of All Time

Be warned Channing Tatum, you are about to play the stupidest X-Men character of all time.

Besides being one of Marvel's mandatory biannual "events", the House of M crossover had the more prosaic aim of clearing up the mammoth supporting cast that had slowly been amassing in X-Men comics over the past fifty years. When Scarlet Witch used her reality-warping powers to take away the abilities of around ninety percent of the world's mutants, she also took away the constant headaches of X-editors and the need for new readers to be aware of the names, powers and affiliations of literally thousands of fictional characters. Which some of us can manage, but we understand it's not as easy for everyone. For the world of the X-Men to become bloated to the degree that such extreme action had to be taken speaks volumes. Where the series began with just the core group of Cyclops, Beast, Jean Grey, Angel, Iceman and Professor X vs Magneto - actually, writing that out, that seems like a lot to even start off - each successive creative team was insistent on leaving their mark on the mutant population, flexing their brains to come up with ever more bizarre abilities. In the course of five decades those new mutants (not the New Mutants, FYI) really started to add up. And not all of those mutants were created equal, as for every Wolverine there were two dozen poor unfortunates who were cursed with some truly awful excuses for superpowers. There were mutants who couldn't control when their powers manifested, mutants who had what you'd only derisively refer to as "abilities", and mutants whose skills weren't helpful in the slightest. As we all climb aboard the hype train for the Days of Future Past film adaptation, which introduces even more mutants in the movie universe, we figured it'd be apt to have a look at ten of the comic book X-Men who should never, ever appear on the silver screen. Or in any of the comics, to be honest. If there's anybody you think we forgot, or you disagree with our choices, please feed your Cerebro data into the comments below!

10. Slipstream

In theory, Slipstream should be one of the most useful young members of the X-Men. Young Davis Cameron's latent mutant powers allow him to generate a "warp wave" which lets him teleport himself and others anywhere in the world. He's like Nightcrawler without the stinky purple clouds, or Cloak from Cloak and Dagger without the emotional hang-ups! The image above and the whole "warp wave" thing may have tipped you off as to why Slipstream is part of this list, however. He can teleport anywhere in the world, that's true, that's pretty baller. But in order to do so he rides the warp waves using a metal board. Slipstream is a super-powered surfboarder. Let that sink in for a moment. What was the best bit of the film Point Break? If you say "the surfing" rather than "that one chase through suburbia" or "Dr Cox off of Scrubs", then please take the rest of the day off. If you are a sane person, meanwhile, you will most likely agree that a surf bro X-Man is pretty darn stupid. Add in the fact that he can't teleport without posing like a tool, and if he wants to take others with him they need to squeeze onto his little boogie board, and you've got a pretty terrible excuse for a mutant.

9. Callisto

Admittedly, the leader of the underground mutant settlement the Morlocks began as a pretty cool character. Her skill set was a little ill-defined, but she had a wicked eyepatch and androgynous look, and the cover of Uncanny X-Men #170 - of her and Storm engaged in a knife fight over who should continue to be the Morlock's head mutie - was pretty badass. Everything started to go wrong for Callisto a little later, but boy did it go wrong. Because she got her arms replaced by tentacles by fellow Morlock (and jerk) Masque. From that point on, Callisto lost all of her former badassery. Because she had tentacle arms. What good are tentacle arms? No good at all, which is why the character languished in obscurity since gaining them, appearing only in a handful of X-related comics and the fever dreams of the most depraved hentai addicts. The tentacle-arm thing reduced a cool character to a one-note joke. Thankfully she was put out her misery when she was one of the mutants who had their powers (in her case, stupid arms) stripped by the Scarlet Witch, a blessing in disguise.

8. Stacy X

The post-Grant Morrison period was a weird one for the X-Men. Subsequent creative teams struggled with whether to continue on in earnest, following the weirder and more mature bent the Scottish writer had taken to the characters, or to return to the status quo and just keep introducing weird and wacky characters. Some decided to do both, as was the case with Joe Casey's dubious crowning achievement, Stacy X. There is something to be said for the character, a mutant sex worker who uses her powers of pheromone control to entice her customers and give them the best, ahem, happy ending of their lives. That's actually pretty interesting, and something that hasn't been explored in the X-Men before. Sadly, once it got past the ideas stage and she was drafted into the team, Stacy didn't have much to offer outside of trying to sleep with every male member (steady) of the team, then quitting when she got turned down by everyone. Like Callisto, Stacy X also lost her powers on M Day, the ultimate fate for characters nobody knows what to do with.

7. Cypher

Doug Ramsey actually ended up becoming one of the most interesting characters in the New Mutants, but not by virtue of anything the young superhero codenamed Cypher brought to the table. When he was "resurrected" in a merged form with fellow deceased alien friend Warlock - making the imaginatively-named Douglock - that was pretty cool, and his recent, more legit reanimation has come with a secondary mutation which makes Cypher a powerful telepath with super-synathesia which lets him interpret the world purely as language. All of this is really just overcompensating for the fact that Doug was originally saddled with a pretty useless superpower, especially amongst his New Mutant kin. To begin with, Cypher's mutant ability was that he could understand any language. He was the living embodiment of Google Translate, the C-3PO of the X-Men, and when it came to battling the world's more malevolent mutant menaces, that was about as useful as it sounds. And to make matters worse, even Doug knew it.

6. Ink

Considering the growing propensity people have to getting tattoos, in a way it makes sense that there would be an X-Man whose powers came from getting inked. In another way that is the stupidest thing we've ever heard, but too late, it already happened: even worse, despite being part of the Young X-Men, Eric Gitter wasn't even technically a mutant. He'd just been given tattoos by one. So perhaps the real stupidest mutant in this position should be Leon Nunez, the tattoo artist in question. Leon's powers allow him to bestow superpowers on people by inking certain symbols upon them, and Eric - who chose the codename Ink after presumably five seconds of thinking about it - got a whole bunch of them. The biohazard symbol on his palm made people ill when he touched them, Colossus-based branding on his other hand made it super strong, lighting bolts on either side of his head made his really good at brainstorming...or was it telepathy? Then he had wings on his back so he could fly, a Caduceus symbol that let him heal, and even tried to tap into the Phoenix force with the iconic bird tattooed above his eye. Not only is that a moronic set of abilities, but Nunez recently went into a coma and apparently if he wakes up, Ink will lose all his powers. So then he'll just be another doofus with some bad tats.

5. Dust

There's a lot to recommend Sooraya Qadir, one of the first progressive depictions of a Muslim character in the Marvel Universe, who chose to keep her niqab rather than suit up in the traditional Xavier school yellow spandex. Discovered by the X-Men in Afghanistan, Dust first unleashed her powers when she was kidnapped by mutant slave traders who removed her headdress. Enraged, she turned into...a cloud of sand. That's right, a cloud. Dust can turn into sand, but not in the cool way that Spider-Man villain Sandman can, allowing her to transform her body into all sorts of cool configurations and become near-omnipotent when on a beach. Nope, Qadir just sort of collapses into an amorphous sandstorm, which means she's easily defeated by just blinking your eyes a lot or wearing sunglasses. Also her weakness is water. That one's not a joke.

4. Toad

You have to feel sorry for Toad. An original member of Magneto's Brotherhood of Evil Mutants (Erik was always better with the world domination than the PR), Mortimer Toynbee - see, Toad isn't the worst name in existence after all! - was slavishly devoted to his leader, despite the fact he was treated as nothing more than cannon fodder. Eventually he was demoted out of the Brotherhood and started his own splinter faction who spent less time fighting for mutant dominance and more time committing petty crimes. Which was more suited to his particular set of skills, which...aren't that impressive. He was the requisite increased speed, strength and endurance most superheroes have as a default, but he's also hunchbacked! And has a really long tongue! And recently went through a secondary mutation that made him green and slimy, like a real toad! Those are good powers, right? So good that Toad has been relegated to a bit-part in the X-Men comics, as the long-suffering janitor at the Jean Grey School for Higher Learning. It's really all he's good for.

3. Jubilee

Jubilation Lee is fondly remembered by those who were weaned into geekdom by the nineties X-Men cartoon. She was the audience identification character in the place of the comics' Kitty Pryde, a young new recruit to the team who was introduced to the mutant way of life at the same time viewers were. And, much like the viewers, Jubilee was surplus to requirements. Just as we watching at home would have added absolutely nothing to the core X-Men team, neither did she. Even in the stripped-down team in the cartoon, Jubilee wasn't able to do anything that helped the rest of them. She just spoke like a mallrat, wore a garish yellow trenchcoat and asked questions to trigger exposition. Her role in the comics has been much the same, since a mutant whose power is that she can shoot fireworks from her hands isn't good for much else. Recently she has gained a baby and become a vampire, because she wasn't stupid enough as it is.

2. Adam X The X-Treme

Rumour has it that Adam X was created as part of a bet to create the most obnoxiously X-Man possible, a character who embodied everything that was wrong with nineties comics, who nobody could ever be taken seriously. And if that rumour is true, then he would have easily won that bet. The rumour isn't true, because we just made it up, but we can't think of any other circumstances under which Adam X The X-Treme was created that wouldn't just make us sad. At least he never became the third Summers brother, as was originally planned. That was just a step too far. With his backwards baseball cap and oodles of braided rat tails in his peroxide hair, Adam X had the novel power of making people's blood boil. Not because he was such a stupid character, that was his literal mutant ability: setting fire to people's blood, so long as it was oxygenated, which meant he had to carry a bunch of ridiculous knives around so he could cut people up, make them bleed, and then set them alight from the inside. Of course he could have just killed people with the knives, but whatever. Also his own blood was acid, because why not?

1. Gambit

Remy LeBeau lies at the eye of perfect storm of stupidity in X-Men. His costume - a weird sorta half-mask, trenchcoat, and bright purple breastplate - looked immediately dated, and he's never changed it. He talks like Pepé Le Pew. He gives off a creepier vibe than even Starfox, the Avenger whose superpower is tricking people into sleeping with him. In theory, his mutant powers are pretty neat, as he's able to control pure kinetic energy to his will. But he uses it in the stupidest way possible, by throwing playing cards at people which explode with all the consequence of a party popper. Did we mention the accent? And the creepiness? And the fact that he may very well be a pick-up artist, with all the sleaziness that entails? Not content with hitting all those key crappiness requirements, Gambit is involved in one of the most tedious sorts of ongoing subplots: his on-again, off-again relationship with Rogue. Does anybody care at this point? Rogue's cool, with her tragic powers and Southern belle demeanour. In fact she's the exact opposite of Gambit, which is why they really shouldn't end up together. Gambit and Rogue are the Ross and Rachel of the X-Men. And nobody's favourite Friend is Ross.

In this post: 
X-Men
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/