10 Things DC Wants You To Forget About The Riddler
Riddle us this...what's with that name?
More than anything - or perhaps along with everything else - Batman is known for boasting perhaps the best rogue's gallery of villains in comic books, or really any other medium. Where Superman always just ends up scrapping with Lex Luthor or Brainiac, or the Fantastic Four spend most of their time foiling the evil plans of Doctor Doom, The Dark Knight has a cavalcade of colourful criminals with which to engage in BIFF, POW fisticuffs
The Joker remains the most beloved, but he's got plenty more besides the clown prince of crime: The Penguin, Catwoman, King Tut...perhaps the second most infamous villain to come a cropper of the Caped Crusader, however, is one Edward Nigma. That is, The Riddler. He tends to be better known by his alter ego, which is good, because his real name's pretty silly.
Besides The Joker, the Riddler has one of the most clearly defined motivations, approach and costumes amongst Batman villains. He's been a big part of every adaptation of the Dark Knight into other media and remains a pretty important part of the comics, too, making a big fuss in the pages of Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo's Zero Year prequel.
So that makes old E. Nigma (get it now?) a pretty big deal. His history stretches back pretty far, in the comics and elsewhere, which have paved the way to becoming such a big fish amongst the on-and-off inmates of Arkham Asylum - it's also littered with weird turns in character, off-centre portrayals, and mistakes that DC Comics have tried desperately to cover up.
The Riddler has a pretty interesting history, and a lot of its been expunged from the books. Good thing we've got good memories, huh? Here are just ten things DC wants you to forget about the Riddler.
10. He's Kinda Similar To The Joker
Not that Batman's greatest villain is all that original himself, but you gotta admit he's memorable. So memorable, in fact, that it makes the similarities between him and The Riddler obvious to anybody with half a brain. All of Gotham's greatest threats have their own weird gimmicks, from The Penguin's...resemblance to a penguin to Clayface's...clay face. Man, they really do have some literal names, huh?
The conceit of both The Joker and The Riddler is pretty similar, however, and we're not just talking about the green-and-purple colour scheme. Well, we are sort of talking about that. They're pretty similar. Both characters have a weird history, as each was introduced as a one-off bad guy in the Golden Age (thirties/forties) incarnation of the Batman title, and rarely seen after until they were brought back properly in the silver age (fifties onwards). So at the time the fact that they're almost identical wasn't so egregious - they were a couple of wackos who happened to have a similar obsession with both the Caped Crusader and carrying out crimes with a particular linguistic bent.
The similarities haven't stopped there, though. There's the punning "real" names for both villains - Edward Nigma and Jack Napier - and both turned to a life of crime simply because they were super-intelligent men who were bored. Their intelligence and knack for manipulation has also alienated both from the rest of Gotham's bad guys. They're both bonkers - which isn't that unique amongst Batman's enemies - but each has their specific form of madness, a fixation on the Dark Knight and with constructing elaborate crimes.
Look they're basically the same except one has never had an Oscar-worthy portrayal on film, m'kay?
9. The Marilyn Manson Makeover
The nineties animated Batman series remains the gold standard against which all future superhero cartoons have been held to - to some it's even the definitive portrayal of the Dark Knight, on screen or otherwise. Which set the bar pretty high for any future shows that followed, and which...well, they've had mixed success in reaching.
Whilst the Brave And The Bold series was a heck of a lot of fun, the most recent CGI-based outing Beware The Batman sank and, before those two, we got the frankly bizarre The Batman back in 2004.
At first following the classic depiction of the character to a tee, The Batman diverged wildly as it started to reach back into the Caped Crusader's history. Initially Commissioner Gordon was nowhere to be found, his daughter Barbara became a much younger Batgirl, and many of his most infamous villains went through some pretty radical redesigns. The Joker wore a straightjacket-cum-nu metal outfit and green dreads, Bane abandoned his luchador outfit for a Red Hulk look, and The Riddler got his most...shall we say interesting makeover to date.
Since his first appearance on the shower people were comparing The Batman's Riddler to gangly goth rocker (and surprisingly eloquent star of Bowling For Columbine) Marilyn Manson. Which isn't an unfair comparison, what with the similarly pale and androgynous look, flowing jet black locks and urban legend surrounding removal of some of his rib bones. Well, maybe not the last one, but it was a pretty weird redesign, and even with Robert Englund - yes, Freddie Krueger himself - on vocal duties, we're not likely to see this Riddler ever again.
8. Everything That Happened In Hush
There's a lot to recommend Jeph Loeb and Jim Lee's Hush storyline, but it's not perfect. We mean, what is? Amongst all the other shenanigans going on with dead sidekicks seemingly coming back to life, it's easy to forget that the Riddler went through his own massive changes during this Batman crossover, too.
For starters, it turned out that Nigma had been diagnosed with cancer,and that he was using one of Ra's al Ghul's resurrecting Lazarus Pits to try and cure himself of the disease. During his time in the pit he also figures out that Batman is Bruce Wayne - about seventy years after the rest of us, c'mon mate, catch up - and thus enacts the whole sordid plan that makes up the majority of Hush.
Teaming up with Dr Thomas Elliot, Bruce Wayne's childhood friend, Riddler sics Killer Croc, Poison Ivy, Harley Quinn, Joker, Clayface and Scarecrow on the Dark Knight. It doesn't work out, as these things tend not to, and the newly-rejuvenated but much more insane Riddler has to keep the revelation about his arch enemy's secret identity to himself, lest Ra's al Ghul and the League Of Assassins hunt him down for using a Lazarus Pit without asking. It's just impolite.
After things go sour for our villain, he gets beaten to a pulp by Elliot - aka the titular bandaged bad guy Hush - and is stripped of his deductive powers, left to live the rest of his existence as a member of Gotham's homeless population. Eventually he manages to get himself out of this mess, thanks to an ex-NSA employee and some extensive plastic surgery, but it was a weird time in the Riddler's life in general, and not one that seems to have affected any of his later appearances.
7. Riddler Reformed
Of course the biggest change to happen - and then be totally undone - in the storied life of Edward Nigma is when he abandoned his superciminal activities altogether, and even ended up helping Batman for a while. It didn't work out in the end, as it hadn't for Two-Face, but you've got to give the guy credit for trying, at least. It's more than most of the Gotham rogues gallery ever manages.
In a story written by Paul Dini, one of the masterminds behind the nineties animated series, the Riddler Reformed story arc came not long after the culmination of Hush and is violent aftermath. After having been in a coma for nigh on a year, the former villain awakens to find himself cured of the insanity that saw him compulsively committing crimes. Whilst he does lose his madness, he also manages to hold onto his immense intellect - specifically, his genius-level capacity for solving puzzles. Which makes him not only a pretty good asset in the fight against crime but not a bad partner for Batman, the self-proclaimed World's Greatest Detective (we assume it's self-proclaimed, anyway, because we don't think we've actually seen anyone call him that).
It probably helped that during the time he spent unconscious he totally forgot that he knew Bruce Wayne's secret identity, which was pretty handy. At first Riddler acted as a private consultant, hired to figure out crimes and mysteries that nobody else could fathom. Inevitably this leads to him having encounters with both Batman and the extended Bat-Family, slowly earning their trust and eventually becoming a valued ally in their fight against the scum and villainy of Gotham City.
It was a neat twist on an underused character, and made a lot of sense...right up until the point somebody decided they were bored of the reformed Riddler and sent him back into being a bad guy for no real reason, and without much explanation.
6. His Dad Abused Him
Oh yeah, one of the other big developments in the Riddler's character during the Hush storyline was the revelation that he was abused as child. During his time recuperating after having seven shades of shinola kicked out of him, he somehow recovers the repressed memories of his upbringing: with his mother out of the picture he was raised by his single father, who was not exactly a model parent by any stretch of the imagination.
This origin story for Edward Nigma dovetailed with the existing history he had in the comics as a brilliant child who committed his first crime in order to ensure he won a school contest that involved solving a puzzle in the fastest time. The prize? A book of riddles. Like, duh. So that was always the accepted explanation of why the Riddler was so into, well, riddles and puzzles, and why that obsession was intrinsically tied to his criminal activities.
It wasn't until this induced flashback to his childhood that we got the full picture, however: because not only was the young Edward a whip smart kid, but his deadbeat dad was incredibly jealous his son's academic achievements in school. He also couldn't understand where the intelligence was coming from, since he clearly didn't have much himself. This line of thinking lead the elder Nigma to assume that his son wasn't some sort wunderkind but a big fat cheater - which, to be fair, he was at least half-right about - and so subjected him to regular beatings.
From this sudden revelation The Riddler realises why he has such a compunction to leave behind clues as to his crimes - he has a deeply held need to prove his innocence, to absolve himself of any wrong doing or deception. At least that was the explanation before the New 52 reboot threw all that character development out the window.
5. Some Of His Riddles Are Really, Really Terrible

Even allowing for that one there - which isn't a real riddle, to be fair - The Riddler has told a lot of crummy riddles in his time. Which is pretty bad when you consider it's what his entire personality is based around. That would be like if The Joker wasn't very funny. And even when his one liners fall flat you basically have to laugh, either because you've got a gun to your head or you've been dosed with Joker toxin.
We suppose you could argue that it's down to that deep seated need to get caught, but...shut up. Honestly though, his crimes are all based on making riddles. So if he can't manage that even, what hope does he have for anything else? If they're not totally awful puns that a child could figure out, let alone the World's Greatest Detective - eg "What people are always in a hurry? Russians" - then they're absolutely impossible to figure out and make no logical sense, like some of the more taxing questions he poses the players in the Arkham games - "Zsasz is counting on you finding his work" was totally nonsensical to anybody not familiar with Batman lore - neither of which are great for...well, The Riddler.
There are only so many riddles in the world, and both writers and Edward Nigma probably get bored of trying to fit crimes to word games. Still, that's a bit lazy for a guy who loves riddles so much that he named himself after them. That Russian one's still bothering us. That would be like us calling ourselves The Amazing Chef and committing crimes based on beans on toast. Actually, that's quite good, let's just write that down...
4. Jim Carrey
The Batman films took a weird turn somewhere. At first they were dark but still pretty noticeably comic book-like, as Tim Burton turned his twisted and hyperreal filmmaking style to the Caped Crusader with brilliant results. Then Joel Schumacher took over the franchise with Batman Forever and, well...there's a reason people were so thankful when Christopher Nolan took over the movie Dark Knight and made them less of a sugar-fuelled pop art nightmare that nobody asked for.
As rightfully reviled as Batman & Robin is, things went way of course before that, thanks principally to Tommy Lee Jones's scenery-chewing turn as Two-Face but perhaps worse, Jim Carrey's OTT rendition of The Riddler. In the comics The Riddler is a bit Joker-like. There's the similar gimmicks, dress sense and the like, but when it comes to how they act they're pretty different. The Riddler is a lot more grounded in his insanity, spending last time running around giggling like a maniac and more time being quietly confident in his fiendish deathtraps.
Apparently Jim Carrey didn't get the memo, or got the two characters confused as so many have before and since, and when playing Edward Nigma in Schumacher's film decided to go full Ace Ventura on the character. We can blame the costume designer for his bizarre ginger bonce and skin-tight green suit covered in question marks, but we're pretty sure the rest is totally Carrey's fault.
His Riddler is a gurning, manic lunatic who leaps around the art deco sets and seems to have no control over the volume of his voice - but not in a fun Ron Burgundy way - and it's terrible. And really annoying.
Thankfully this version of The Riddler was never seen anywhere else ever again. Of that we should be thankful. And some of Arnold Schwarzenegger's Mr Freeze jokes in the next film were kinda funny in a "dad joke" way.
3. That Edward Nygma Is A Stupid Name
Look, Jack Napier isn't great either, but it's still a bit of a stretch to "jackanape". The short, single step from Edward Nigma to "enigma", though? That is just lazy. That is almost insulting to our intelligence, DC. With a name like that he was almost destined to a puzzle-based crime lifestyle, if you believe in nominative determinism. Which you should, if Batman's rogues gallery is anything to go by. You've got flippin' Harleen Quinzel in there, too. None of them are worse than Edward Nigma in our minds, however, and even the Zero Year change to spell it Nygma won't get us away from that.
Originally, he didn't have such a ridiculous name. Upon his debut The Riddler's alter ego was the much more ordinary and believable Edward Nashton, which so far as we can tell isn't anything approaching a pun. Unless Enashton is some old-timey version of a riddle that we haven't heard of because we're not a hundred years old.
Anyway, it wasn't long after that he got changed to Edward Nigma (because they played fast and loose with continuity back in the Golden Age), and it's the sort of goofiness that usually gets left behind in the silly olden days of comics. The days when there were Superbabies and Batbabies teaming up to defeat toddler Lex Luthor.
Except that is so much fun, and a dude called Edward Nigma is just stupid. Especially when you take him from that more fancy free days of superhero comics, when that sort of nonsense flew, and place him into the more grim and gritty world of the modern Batman comic. Modern Batman is supposed to be relatively grounded, to be less comic book-y, to have "realistic" heroes and villains. And whilst there are people called Bruce Wayne in the real world, we'd put good money on us flipping through the phonebook and not finding a single Edward Nigma. Nygma. Whatever.
2. He's Better As A Green Arrow Villain...
Unlike the Dark Knight, the Green Arrow doesn't have much in the way of classic villains. Batman sort of hogged all of them the way that entitled orphans probably would, so rather than try and invent any original ongoing nemeses for Oliver Queen in the comic books, in the early noughties DC editorial decided simply to export one of the Caped Crusader's enemies from Gotham to Star City. And, well, it actually worked pretty well. Maybe too well.
For a little while Edward Nigma (did we mention that was a stupid name, btw?) was laying pretty low in the comic books, never quite regaining his place as one of the top dogs in the former Arkham crew until the whole Hush debacle. Having all but failed to conquer Gotham City he decides to sack it off all together because, as the saying goes, if at first you don't succeed, travel to the other side of the country and try wrestling control of a major metropolitan area from a masked vigilante who's fabulously wealthy. That's a saying, right?
Coming up against both Green Arrow and the Black Canary, partly in retaliation for the pair of them handing his butt to him during the big old No Man's Land event where Gotham was decimated by a series of earthquakes. In the aftermath of Hush he orchestrated a series of assaults that almost killed Arrow and his old sidekick Arsenal, and has plagued Star City on and off since then. He actually sort of worked better as a Green Arrow enemy, since he had the personal vendetta and The Joker comparisons weren't as obvious.
Again, though, the New 52 reboot has left the canonical status of these stories in peril.
1. ...Or Just As A Supporting Character
Perhaps that's the key thing we can take away from all this. The Riddler is a pretty good character, despite everything - like the crummy real name, the similarities to The Joker and the often terrible riddles - but he might be better in a supporting role rather than as a fully-fledged bad guy. One of the best depictions we've seen of the character has been in the Arkham series of Batman video games, where he's rarely (if ever) seen as an on screen enemy, unlike...basically every other member of the rogues gallery who crops up in those games. Instead he provides the bulk of the optional missions, things that aren't essential to the plot but are plenty fun.
We think that might be the best way to use The Riddler, not as an instigator or major player in big storyline, but as a small piece of a larger puzzle. That's the role he plays in Jeph Loeb and Tim Sale's classic Batman graphic novels The Long Halloween and Dark Victory, where his intelligence and puzzling skills are utilised by more forward thinking and straight up violent bad guys.
It makes more sense, honestly. It's why he worked so well as a reformed villain, he seems more like a guy who can lend his brain to people who need it rather than someone who comes up with dastardly schemes on his own. It's also why he worked well as a Green Arrow villain. He tended to be overshadowed by the other, more unique Batman villains, whileas in Star City he really stood out.
Amongst the denizens of Gotham he is unfortunately a lot less special, which is why we reckon he would fit in much better as part of a whole - that's certainly the way he started off in Zero Year, before becoming the main antagonist once again. So whilst he would probably work better as a supporting character, it's not gonna happen any time soon.