10 Times Batman Has "Died"

Shot to the head! But who's to blame?

If it looks like a superhero, acts like a superhero, and is resistant to death as a superhero? It's probably a superhero. People like to argue that Batman isn't technically a superhero, because of his lack of powers (they're totally wrong about that, by the way). But seriously, outside of soap operas, what other stripe of fictional character comes back from the dead as often as superheroes? Apart from zombies. Death is a particularly relative concept in superhero comics, with almost every major death that's ever occurred in the genre eventually reversed. People used to joke that the only people who would ever stay dead in comics are Uncle Ben, Gwen Stacy and Bucky; currently we're sort of at two out of three, and Peter Parker's kindly relative is almost certainly due a gritty, mature readers reboot. But death is also a concept which defines a lot of characters: Spider-Man has Uncle Ben, Superman has his entire planet, and Batman has his parents. The murder of Bruce Wayne's mum and dad in a random mugging is what inspired his life as a crimefighter, and it's a life that's been defined by even more death - Jason Todd, every girlfriend he's ever had, etc. Plus there's all the times he's died himself. How do you define a superhero? How about someone who is literally indestructible? The Caped Crusader met his maker once again in a recent comic, but it's far from the first time. Eventually he comes back - through hook or by crook or by Lazarus Pit - but it's usually pretty spectacular when he goes. Here are ten times Batman has "died".

10. Bleeding Out In A Cave With The Joker

The most recent €“ and so far, most permanent (in the sense that it's been a month since it happened and he hasn't immediately come back to life) €“ demise that the Dark Knight has suffered came in the pages of Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo's €œEndgame€. The storyline in the main Batman title saw the hero facing off against his arch nemesis for what seemed like the final time. Riffing on their brutal confrontation in Fran Miller's The Dark Knight Returns €“ which turned fatal for one of them €“ the climax of €œEndgame€ saw the Clown Prince Of Crime and Caped Crusader fighting in a series of underground caves which housed a hidden pool of life elixir stuff that previously brought The Joker back to life. Not particularly wanting the most dangerous man in Gotham to be essentially immortal, Batman pulled out all the stops to first cease a city-wide dosing of Joker venom and then to off the bad guy himself, once and for all. There was eye-gouging, back-stabbing, and finally the two of them collapsed in a heap of limbs and blood, with the cave then caving in on the both of them.

9. Exploded In A Helicopter Crash

Grant Morrison had some grand ideas when he took over writing the main Batman title. The Scottish writer is adept at folding in his own interests in occult mysticism, weird sex and the grand history of superhero comics into his work, and managed to do all of that in the €œBatman RIP€ storyline which sought to square the varied history of the Dark Knight into one concise character. That meant returning to concepts and characters that had been long since forgotten by multiple DC universal reboots, with a Batwoman that hadn't appeared since the fifties and other themes that hadn't been touched upon by Batman writers in decades. Of course, he also had to go one further and kill the Caped Crusader off whilst revitalising him. The €œRIP€ storyline came to an end with a criminal organisation called the Black Glove gaining access to the Batcave, incapacitating all the Bat-Family and smearing the Wayne family name. The fact that the group were apparently lead by Bruce's long-dead father Thomas didn't help matters. Their final move was to have Batman die in a helicopter crash...or so it seemed.

8. Shocked By The Electrocutioner

Go ahead. Try and guess what The Electrocutioner's power set involved. Go on, guess. Try and guess what his costume gimmick was as well. For a supervillain so lacking in subtlety or invention, the title of The Electrocutioner has somehow been passed down to three separate people. It was the second €“ the brother of the original €“ that came closest to besting his rival, though. Lester Buchinsky was introduced by Chuck Dixon in Detective Comics #644, which kicked off the €œElectric City€ arc where he adopted the guise of The Electrocutioner and headed out on Batman's trail, blasting electricity from his gloves and able to draw power from other energy sources he happened upon along the way. Eventually he did manage to catch up with the Dark Knight and, well, there's only so much electricity a man can take. Even when that man has had a lot of special training and wears a funky rodent suit. Batman's heart stopped, and he was only saved by Robin resuscitating him, before refusing his sidekick's pleas that he rest and heal with €œI was technically dead. Not clinically.€

7. Heart Stopped (On Purpose)

If the likes of €œEndgame€ and €œBatman RIP€ seem a little out-there to modern tastes, the early days were surely beyond the pale. The Golden and Silver Age adventures of Batman were so bonkers it made Adam West's sixties TV series look Christian Bale-dark by comparison, with the Caped Crusader fighting suicide bomber gorillas and the like. Yes, that happened. Still, they found moments of grim fatalism in places, like the story where Robin kept dying in hilarious ways, like Kenny from South Park. Or the time that Batman finally met his maker, but it all turned out to be an elaborate ploy so that he could go undercover in an exclusive criminal organisation. Whaaaaaaa. Yeah, in €œThe Death-Cheaters Of Gotham City€ had his heart artificially stopped and was technically dead for several minutes, before Robin had to revive him. Nothing like faking your death to freak out your already-orphaned surrogate son. The whole thing was a ruse so he could join the Death-Cheaters Club, with having been dead for a bit being the main entry criteria.

6. Killed Three Times In Countdown Arena

Countdown was one of the lesser crossover events DC has published in their history, supposedly building up (or is that down?) to an even bigger event called Final Crisis. It was also supposed to function as a sequel to the incredibly successful €“ and really damn good €“ series 52, a weekly book that preceded it and explored stories with a lot of B-list characters. It was a lot of fun. Not only was Countdown a semi-lead-in to Final Crisis, but it got its own spin-offs, too. One of which was the extricable Countdown: Arena, wherein the supervillain Monarch orchestrates a Roman-style gladiatorial battle between heroes from loads of different universes, in order to build an army that will fight the multiverse-destroying Monitors. It was a goofy concept from the start, and it ended up being as needlessly bloodthirsty, vicious and inhumane as the gladiatorial arenas that inspired it. Mainly in the single issue that killed off multiple alternate-reality Batmen in one fell swoop, with the one from Gotham By Gaslight knocked out, WWII hero The Bat killed by vampire Batman, the latter of whom is summarily obliterated.

5. Zapped With A Time-Bullet By Darkseid

Final Crisis is even more difficult to describe that the Grant Morrison epic that lead into it, the aforementioned Batman RIP. When that title turned out to be something of a misnomer the Scottish writer nevertheless orchestrated a demise for the Dark Knight. It's so hard to describe because whilst the former series involved the Bat-Family, Final Crisis starred the entire DC Universe. That's not an exaggeration, this was a crossover event that involved literally the whole universe, as cosmic villain Darkseid unleashed his €œAnti-Life Equation€ which tipped the scales so evil would finally win in a comic book world where good was always supposed to triumph. It was pretty meta. As was the death Batman faced right at the end. Having broken his one rule and smuggled a gun into Darkseid's lair, Batman gets the drop on the big bad and shoots him with a cosmic bullet that travels through time. It does the deed, but the phenomenally powerful Darkseid makes sure that it bounces back and removes the Dark Knight from the equation. Actually it just sent him back to the Stone Age, but still. Good as dead.

4. Blew Himself Up Before Communist Superman Got Him

€œRed Son€ is a weird story. Part of DC's Elseworlds line of alternate-reality stories that don't have any bearing on the mainstream continuity, writer Mark Millar took that as a carte blanche excuse to come up with the most high-concept alternate history he could. Namely one where Kal-El landed in the USSR as a baby, rather than America, raised a well-mannered Communist superpower. Instead of becoming the defender of Truth, Justice, and the American Way, he's €œthe Champion of the common worker who fights a never-ending battle for Stalin, socialism, and the international expansion of the Warsaw Pact.€ A weapon for the Communist state, the United States are eager to toppled their enemy's secret weapon. The Cold War goes a little differently in €œRed Son€, with Batman being a kid whose dissident parents were shot by a member of the KGB, who dedicates his life to stopping Superman with the help of Lex Luthor. He's just like regular Batman, only he wears a furry hat. Oh and that he doesn't stand a chance against Superman, so he blows himself up like a suicide bomber before the Man Of Steel can.

3. Stabbed In The Chest With A Shovel

Exploring the origins of the immortal (literally and figuratively) Batman villain Ra's al Ghul, Dennis O'Neil and Norm Breyfogle's €œBirth Of The Demon€ flits back and forth between a modern-day duel between the bad guy and the Dark Knight, and the early days of the man who would be Ra's. Turns out a man who's been alive for 600 years has some pretty good stories to tell. Go figure. €œBirth Of The Demon€ mainly exists to show the differences and similarities between Batman and Ra's: both are equally driven, blessed with divine purpose, but Ra's doesn't have the whole moral crusade thing of the Caped Crusader. He's just kind of a nutter, but one who's really committed to killing absolutely everyone. In pursuit of that goal he goes toe-to-toe with Batman, who has bested him a few times prior to this battle. Unwilling to accept another defeat, Ra's gets especially brutal and, once he has the upper hand on his opponent, grabs a shovel and sticks into right into Batman's chest. actually stabs him with it. Bruce technically dies, his last bit of strength dragging him and Ra's into a Lazarus Pit...

2. Electrocuted, Then Used As A Puppet By The Atom

€œThe Corpse That Wouldn€™t Die!€ is straight up one of the strangest stories ever told in comic book history. Not just Batman comics, or superhero comics, but all comic books ever published. After all, what other story have you read €“ in any medium, come to think of it €“ that involves somebody dying, only to be brought back to life by a tiny person jumping around in their brain? A little backstory, not that it will make it sound any more sane: Brave and the Bold #115 opens with Batman being shocked as he enters an electrified window, the voltage being enough to stop his heart. And this time, there's no Robin around to resuscitate him and then being rudely patronised! Instead The Atom, who can shrink himself down to minuscule sizes, is on hand to watch Batman's demise. And instead of getting a doctor or something, Ray Palmer instead makes himself small enough so that he can enter the Dark Knight's cerebral cortex and control him like a puppet, in order to track down the killer. And somehow, Batman's organs start working again at the end. Yay!

1. Tortured For Eternity By The Joker

€œEmperor Joker€ is the first time the Clown Prince Of Crime has ever really gotten one-up on his arch enemy/beloved. The mostly-forgotten crossover event saw The Joker steal reality-altering powers from Superman villain Mister Mxyzptlk, which allows him to literally change the world as he sees fit. Which, it turns out, mainly involves subjugating every single superhero in the DCU. Technically a Superman crossover event, rather than a Batman one, €œEmperor Joker€ saw the bad guy rewriting reality so that the Man Of Steel was in Arkham Asylum for killing Lex Luthor, the Justice League was lead by his evil doppelgänger Bizarro, and Huntress, Nightwing, and Robin are dead too. Oh, and Aquaman has an actual fish head. The Joker's sense of humour and psychopathy are both on show in the fate he commits Batman to: torturing to death day in, day out, before resurrecting him the next morning and starting it all over again. In fact that's the way the story would have ended, were it not for The Joker himself realising the error of his ways €“ despite all his attempts, Superman didn't save the day. It was Emperor Joker realising that his sense of self was so tied up in Batman, that if the Dark Knight were to die for good, he wouldn't have a reason to live either. So it kinda makes sense €œEndgame€ ended that way too €“ FULL CIRCLE!

Watch Next


In this post: 
Batman
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/