5 Most Disastrous Comic-Con Panels In Recent Memory

Nerd gatherings aren't always pleasant.

Conventions can be a wonderful affirmation for comics enthusiasts of all types and stripes, from the hardcore reader who can list 500 DC Comics characters from memory to the casual fan who'd like a few drawing tips or a chance to meet their favorite cartoonist. Panels (not the picture frames of comics, but the gatherings of people to discuss them) are likewise an opportunity to learn all kinds of fascinating things about the business, and sometimes as exciting in their own way as an Apple product launch or a campaign speech by a candidate you actually believe in. Most reports on comic conventions have a "having a wonderful time, wish you were here" feeling to them. They focus on the good. But we've seen plenty of the bad: self-indulgent bloviating by movie stars or comics writers or artists who just aren't as important as they think. Some discussion panels have taken twenty minutes just to introduce all their participants and another ten minutes to clear out between talks, leaving only thirty minutes out of the hour to do what they allegedly came there to do. Conventions are events planned by people, and sometimes plans go awry. Sometimes planners aren't that good at planning. Also, remember how we said "enthusiasts of all types?" All types means all types, and not everyone is worth spending time with. A few convention panels this decade haven't just been bad. They've gotten ugly.

5. Women In Comics--Characters And Creators, Denver ComicCon, 2015

Not all comic-con panels are so troubling, though. Some are merely mortifying. An all-male panel isn't necessarily a crime against diversity, especially when there are only three participants. Sometimes the available pool of potential panelists is too small for gender balance to even be a problem. But if you're doing a "women in comics" panel without women on it, and if you've advertised your convention as the only comics convention with a "diversity mission," you'd better have good excuses. Denver ComicCon's excuses were as lame as they come. Its spokesperson, Jason Jansky, claimed this was a "historical" panel, not one that covered the contemporary scene, as if women would have nothing of interest to say about female creators or characters unless they were contemporary. Kevin Robinette, who dominated the panel itself, claimed it was a last-minute addition to the schedule and he didn't know any women to invite-- but earlier in the panel, he had mentioned comic-book writer, artist, and historian Trina Robbins' work and her presence at the convention, and as authorities on women in comics go, Robbins is about as good as one gets. Even the "last-minute" claim is odd, since the year before, Denver ComicCon had featured 10-12 women in a similar panel. The content wasn't much better, including such nuggets of old-fashioned "conventional wisdom" as "boys don't want to read about girls" and "girls get bored easily with comics," claims which don't align very well with current sales numbers or reader demographics. The silver lining that makes this only #5 on the list is that it led to a much improved "Women in Comics" panel at that very same convention, organized and led by Robbins, with Crystal Skillman, Hannah Means-Shannon, Amanda Conner, Marguerite Bennett, Meghan Hetrick, Joƫlle Jones, and Emily Singer. With such a turnaround, Denver has the chance to put this incident behind them. #4 on our list will have no such opportunity.

4. Almost Any Panel - DashCon, 2014

DashCon may not have strictly been a comics convention, but then it wasn't strictly much of anything. It appears to have been an abbreviation for "dashed hopes at the convention." The real trouble began when an alleged funding crisis led organizers to ask attendees and Tumblr fans for $17,000 in crowdfunding as the convention began, a goal that DashCon fandom met on Friday. By Sunday, DashCon "fandom" had effectively ceased to exist. Today, the convention has abandoned plans to return in 2015, liquidated its remaining assets and sold its URL. Some attendees continue to suspect that the funding crisis was a scam or else proof of mismanagement. These claims wouldn't have nearly as much traction if everything else about the con had gone well, but events and panels were poorly planned and sparsely attended. Panels labeled "18+" also reportedly accepted minors. Noelle Stevenson, the biggest comics guest, soldiered through her panel, although DashCon never provided her a moderator or paid for her hotel room, despite previously promising both. Similar broken promises obliged the cast of the Welcome to Night Vale podcast, the show's single biggest draw, to cancel its appearance. The organizers promised disappointed attendees "an extra hour in the ball pit"-- once they finally announced the cancellation, more than an hour after the Vale panel was to begin. You won't find a better summary of the DashCon experience than this footage from the WTNV panel floor. Or just stare at that lonely, empty ball pit for another few minutes. That'll give you the same general idea.

3. Women Who Kick Ass - San Diego Comic-Con, 2013

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gkX1yte5u74 Comic-Con's "Women Who Kick Ass" panel of 2013 is definitely an example of the ugly. Yet most of the panel was not only fine, but quite well-composed and uplifting for those who cared to see it. When you gather Katee Sackhoff (Kara "Starbuck" Thrace from Battlestar Galactica), Tatiana Maslany (the endlessly cloned star of Orphan Black), Danai Gurira (Michonne from The Walking Dead), Maggie Q (TV's Nikita); and Michelle Rodriguez (from the Fast & Furious and Resident Evil movies, Avatar, and Lost), you're going to end up with some interesting stories. But as the panel ran into overtime as most panels did that day, certain members of the audience, generally male, started murmuring, louder and louder. If you're wondering why they didn't just get up and leave, the reason is simple: and 20th Century Fox and Marvel were slated to introduce footage from their film projects afterward. Because Hall H is so difficult to get into, many of the fans would have sat through a panel about model ducks rather than miss the chance to see the first public screening of Guardians of the Galaxy footage anywhere. And yet, in the end, there's no excuse for the vocal unrest in the face of an important issue, let alone the one attendee who greeted the end of "Women Who Kick Ass" by shouting "Women who talk too much!" Todd Vanderwerff's eyewitness account has a lot more to say about the battle-of-the-sexes tension in the air. It was not a proud moment to be a fan.

2. Prism Comics - Long Beach Comic-Con 2013

Harassment is one thing when it comes from the rows of attendees. It's another thing entirely when it comes from a fellow panelist. MariNaomi certainly didn't have any warning. The panel should have been a safe space: it was about queer comics and included only one straight guy. However, that straight guy did about every sexually inappropriate thing we could imagine short of sending her a dick pic onstage: questioning her bisexuality, announcing he was "distracted" by his sexual attraction to her, touching her arm repeatedly, and making a crude sex joke about her microphone. He also told her, when it was time for them to pose for pictures, that her Asian features made it look like she was always smiling. She felt trapped by the professional obligation to finish the panel, and by the social pressures that always make harassed women feel trapped. Only realizing the presence of MariNaomi's husband made him apologize... to the husband. The guy in question was Scott Lobdell, still one of the highest-profile writers in comic books. Lobdell did come forward after MariNaomi had given an account that left him anonymous and issued a better apology, characterizing the whole act as a misguided attempt at humor. But whatever you think of that action, the panel itself was one of the most disgraceful single hours in comics' recent history, if only because no one else said a word to discourage Lobdell. So why isn't it #1? What could be worse? Well, how about an incident of actual violence?

1. Resident Evil: Afterlife - San Diego Comic-Con, 2010

This panel (held in Hall H and featuring Michelle Rodriguez, just like the "Women Who Kick Ass" panel) showed every sign of being a snoozefest. That's its own genre of disaster, especially at San Diego, where the stakes and expectations are so high. Director/writer/producer Paul W.S. Anderson kicked things off with a 3-D version of a trailer already seen in 2-D which didn't look that different, prompting Cinema Blend and SlashFilm to ask why the 3-D conversion was necessary or desirable. After that, the team didn't have a whole lot of new or interesting information to share-- did you know that the same creative team had worked on all four films in the franchise to date? Did you know the cast are happy with their lead actress and director? Did you care? Still, there were worse things in the world than boredom, and the stability of the franchise (this was the fourth of six movies) means that at least some of the attendees of the panel were having a good time. It was possible to take comfort in such philosophy as the panel went on. And then at the end of the panel, people were filing in and out to get ready for the next promo, for the movies Paul and Cowboys and Aliens. And someone got stabbed near the eye with a pen. For maybe sitting too close. Neither the attacker nor the victim's name was released to the press, and no lasting injury was done, but still. Still. We're sure there's a joke to be made here about "eye-popping 3-D," but ultimately, we can't show a better sense of humor about this one than the convention itself-- the cosplayers organized a quick response.
Those are the biggest con horror stories we could find, but we're sure you have some others! Hit us up in the comments.

Contributor
Contributor

T Campbell has written quite a few online comics series and selected work for Marvel, Archie and Tokyopop. His longest-running works are Fans, Penny and Aggie-- and his current project with co-writer Phil Kahn, Guilded Age.