Though the term “box office bomb” is synonymous with failure and essentially indicates a terrible film, you might be surprised to know that sometimes great films flop hard. It appears that, indeed, quality doesn’t always equal success – at least in terms of financials – as the below ten films suggest. It’s frustrating because this happening only helps make studios more cynical and more confident in generic, production-line mulch rather than taking chances on creatively risky endeavours such as some of these. Here are ten great films that dive-bombed at the box office.
1. Heathers
Despite costing a measly $2m, Heathers still only pulled in about half that in revenues, all the more surprising given that it was one of the most intelligent and brilliantly provocative teen films of its time, and today, it remains a high benchmark that has rarely been met. With its risky storylines about teen suicide and murder, Heathers eviscerated the high school experience with a razor-sharp edge, daring to go to the dark, unsavoury places that was just so uncommon in Hollywood at the time. Post-Columbine, this sort of subject matter would prove extremely prickly, and pretty much every studio would surely pass on it, even though a sequel of some kind is in fact in the works (though you can bet it’ll shift the focus considerably).
It’s staggering to think that a film starring two young, popular actors – Winona Ryder and Christian Slater – along with such an incisive premise didn’t get butts on seats; there’s no accounting for taste, I guess.
We are currently seeking Film contributors on WhatCulture. To find out more about the perks of being a Film contributor, click here.










13 Comments
I offiially love you for including The Fountain on this great list. Also, special love for Iron Giant, Donnie Darko, Scott Pilgrim, Office Space, and of course Fight Club and The ‘Shank.
I too really liked The Fountain and wished Aronofsky could have shown us his original vision.
The reason Scott Pilgrim Bombed at least in the US market is because of Michael Cera. I couldnt get any of my buddies to see this movie with me because of him. If you seen one of his movies you have essentially seen the character he will be playing.
The whole movie was fun but it was too ironic to the point its slapping us in the face.
We get it your Emo!
I wouldn’t call a lot of these films great; Scott Pilgrim, Shawsahnk, Gremlins, Fight Club etc. they were alright and good films – but not great.
The King of Comedy needs to be on here, too.
Really, no Blade Runner?
J’accuse!!!
I haven’t done any analysis on this subject, but it seems to me that most of these movies bombed due to lack of timing, poor advertising, or boring trailers. I’ve seen them all and I love most of them, but I waited until they came on movie channels or DVD before watching them. Scott Pilgrim is a good example for me. I love Michael Cera, but the price of a movie ticket wasn’t worth what I saw in the trailers (I thought).
Three words, A Christmas Story.
This article sums up why I hate when people say “The film is better is made more money”, the box office is totally bs when it comes to how good the film is
How many of these movies that failed at the box office succeeded in DVD / Blue ray?
I wouldn’t call any of those films great. One is quite good. Most are underrated. The Shawshank Redemption is exceptionally overrated. The Fountain is flat-out awful.
Hats off to the person who noticed the exclusion of Blade Runner.
How about John Carpenter’s The Thing?
What about Almost Famous? That movie had a 60 million dollar budget and only grossed 47 million worldwide. I was really surprised that that was essentially a bomb, considering it’s my favorite movie of all time, was nominated for a bunch of awards and has one of the greatest scenes in cinema history (not to mention an amazing soundtrack). Although it did subject everybody to more Kate Hudson, so there’s that.
Now do an article “10 Terrible Movies that succeeded at the box office”,
I’ll start you off:
Twilight Breaking Dawn Part 1 -
Budget: $110 million
Gross: $705 million
RT Score: 25%
Great article, although a little stuck in modern times (but at least your title doesn’t state “of all time” in there, so it’s a suitable list). Scott Pilgrim, The Fountain & Shawshank are some of my all time favorite films.
I like this post, enjoyed this one thankyou for posting . Charm Bracelets and Charms pandora style beads http://frontierscme.theimegroup.org/node/37#comment-15116